A Post-GWAS Functional Analysis Confirming Effects of Three BTA13 Genes CACNB2, SLC39A12, and ZEB1 on Dairy Cattle Reproduction

In our previous GWAS of Chinese and Nordic dairy cattle, genes CACNB2, SLC39A12, and ZEB1 locating on BTA 13 were suggested as candidate genes for reproduction. In this study, validation of these associations was performed in an independent population with records of nine reproductive traits. More importantly, functions of these genes in the reproductive process were verified by employing the expression data of ovarian follicles. The potential variants within the three genes were firstly detected in 68 Chinese Holstein bulls, and then screened in 1,588 Chinese Holstein cows using the KASP (Kompetitive allele-specific PCR) method. There were nine variants with polymorphisms in CACNB2, five in SLC39A12, and four in ZEB1, respectively, of which one SNP was in the upstream regulatory region, two in exon region, four in downstream regulatory region, and 11 SNPs in intronic regions. Amongst the 18 variants, g.33267056T/G in CACNB2 explained the largest phenotypic variance for age at first calving (0.011%), interval from first to last insemination (0.004%), and calving ease (0.002%), while g.32751518G/A in SLC39A12 contributed the most to stillbirth in heifers (0.038%). Two haplotype blocks were constructed for CACNB2 while one each for SLC39A12 and ZEB1, which were significantly associated with five reproductive traits, including age at the first service, age at the first calving, calving ease in heifers and cows, and the interval from calving to the first insemination. We then studied the profile of gene expression in granulosa cells isolated from four developmental stages of ovarian follicles from eight dairy cows. All three genes were differentially expressed between ovarian follicles with different sizes (p < 0.05), indicating their potential roles in the reproductive process of dairy cows. This study successfully demonstrated the associations of three BTA 13 genes CACNB2, SLC39A12, and ZEB1 with reproduction and further examined their expression levels in ovarian follicles directly. These findings can be beneficial for the ongoing genomic selection program for reproductive traits which have long been considered as traits that are difficult to achieve genetic improvement due to the lack of efficient genetic markers.