Cargando…

Rapidly adapting primary care sentinel surveillance across seven countries in Europe for COVID-19 in the first half of 2020: strengths, challenges, and lessons learned

As the COVID-19 pandemic began in early 2020, primary care influenza sentinel surveillance networks within the Influenza - Monitoring Vaccine Effectiveness in Europe (I-MOVE) consortium rapidly adapted to COVID-19 surveillance. This study maps system adaptations and lessons learned about aligning in...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Bagaria, Jayshree, Jansen, Tessa, Marques, Diogo FP, Hooiveld, Mariette, McMenamin, Jim, de Lusignan, Simon, Vilcu, Ana-Maria, Meijer, Adam, Rodrigues, Ana-Paula, Brytting, Mia, Mazagatos, Clara, Cogdale, Jade, van der Werf, Sylvie, Dijkstra, Frederika, Guiomar, Raquel, Enkirch, Theresa, Valenciano, Marta, Kissling, Esther, Domegan, Lisa, O’Donnell, Joan, Murray, Josephine, Martín, Virginia Sandonis, Martínez-Baz, Iván, Machado, Ausenda, Casado, Itziar, Behillil, Sylvie, Larrauri, Amparo, Tsang, Ruby, de Lange, Marit, Riess, Maximilian, Castilla, Jesús, Hamilton, Mark, Falchi, Alessandra, Pozo, Francisco, Dunford, Linda, Burgui, Cristina, Sigerson, Debbie, Blanchon, Thierry, Martínez Ochoa, Eva María, Connell, Jeff, Ellis, Joanna, van Gageldonk-Lafeber, Rianne, Kislaya, Irina, Rose, Angela MC, Bernal, Jamie Lopez, Andrews, Nick, Flecha, Inmaculada Casas, Thoulass, Janine, Nunes, Baltazar, Gomez, Verónica, Sa Machado, Rita, Enouf, Vincent, Pinto Leite, Pedro Licinio, Molesworth, Anna, McKenna, Adele
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control (ECDC) 2022
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9248262/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35775429
http://dx.doi.org/10.2807/1560-7917.ES.2022.27.26.2100864
_version_ 1784739335899185152
author Bagaria, Jayshree
Jansen, Tessa
Marques, Diogo FP
Hooiveld, Mariette
McMenamin, Jim
de Lusignan, Simon
Vilcu, Ana-Maria
Meijer, Adam
Rodrigues, Ana-Paula
Brytting, Mia
Mazagatos, Clara
Cogdale, Jade
van der Werf, Sylvie
Dijkstra, Frederika
Guiomar, Raquel
Enkirch, Theresa
Valenciano, Marta
Kissling, Esther
Domegan, Lisa
O’Donnell, Joan
Murray, Josephine
Martín, Virginia Sandonis
Martínez-Baz, Iván
Machado, Ausenda
Casado, Itziar
Behillil, Sylvie
Larrauri, Amparo
Tsang, Ruby
de Lange, Marit
Riess, Maximilian
Castilla, Jesús
Hamilton, Mark
Falchi, Alessandra
Pozo, Francisco
Dunford, Linda
Burgui, Cristina
Sigerson, Debbie
Blanchon, Thierry
Martínez Ochoa, Eva María
Connell, Jeff
Ellis, Joanna
van Gageldonk-Lafeber, Rianne
Kislaya, Irina
Rose, Angela MC
Bernal, Jamie Lopez
Andrews, Nick
Flecha, Inmaculada Casas
Thoulass, Janine
Nunes, Baltazar
Gomez, Verónica
Sa Machado, Rita
Enouf, Vincent
Pinto Leite, Pedro Licinio
Molesworth, Anna
McKenna, Adele
Thoulass, Janine
author_facet Bagaria, Jayshree
Jansen, Tessa
Marques, Diogo FP
Hooiveld, Mariette
McMenamin, Jim
de Lusignan, Simon
Vilcu, Ana-Maria
Meijer, Adam
Rodrigues, Ana-Paula
Brytting, Mia
Mazagatos, Clara
Cogdale, Jade
van der Werf, Sylvie
Dijkstra, Frederika
Guiomar, Raquel
Enkirch, Theresa
Valenciano, Marta
Kissling, Esther
Domegan, Lisa
O’Donnell, Joan
Murray, Josephine
Martín, Virginia Sandonis
Martínez-Baz, Iván
Machado, Ausenda
Casado, Itziar
Behillil, Sylvie
Larrauri, Amparo
Tsang, Ruby
de Lange, Marit
Riess, Maximilian
Castilla, Jesús
Hamilton, Mark
Falchi, Alessandra
Pozo, Francisco
Dunford, Linda
Burgui, Cristina
Sigerson, Debbie
Blanchon, Thierry
Martínez Ochoa, Eva María
Connell, Jeff
Ellis, Joanna
van Gageldonk-Lafeber, Rianne
Kislaya, Irina
Rose, Angela MC
Bernal, Jamie Lopez
Andrews, Nick
Flecha, Inmaculada Casas
Thoulass, Janine
Nunes, Baltazar
Gomez, Verónica
Sa Machado, Rita
Enouf, Vincent
Pinto Leite, Pedro Licinio
Molesworth, Anna
McKenna, Adele
Thoulass, Janine
author_sort Bagaria, Jayshree
collection PubMed
description As the COVID-19 pandemic began in early 2020, primary care influenza sentinel surveillance networks within the Influenza - Monitoring Vaccine Effectiveness in Europe (I-MOVE) consortium rapidly adapted to COVID-19 surveillance. This study maps system adaptations and lessons learned about aligning influenza and COVID-19 surveillance following ECDC / WHO/Europe recommendations and preparing for other diseases possibly emerging in the future. Using a qualitative approach, we describe the adaptations of seven sentinel sites in five European Union countries and the United Kingdom during the first pandemic phase (March–September 2020). Adaptations to sentinel systems were substantial (2/7 sites), moderate (2/7) or minor (3/7 sites). Most adaptations encompassed patient referral and sample collection pathways, laboratory testing and data collection. Strengths included established networks of primary care providers, highly qualified testing laboratories and stakeholder commitments. One challenge was the decreasing number of samples due to altered patient pathways. Lessons learned included flexibility establishing new routines and new laboratory testing. To enable simultaneous sentinel surveillance of influenza and COVID-19, experiences of the sentinel sites and testing infrastructure should be considered. The contradicting aims of rapid case finding and contact tracing, which are needed for control during a pandemic and regular surveillance, should be carefully balanced.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-9248262
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2022
publisher European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control (ECDC)
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-92482622022-07-07 Rapidly adapting primary care sentinel surveillance across seven countries in Europe for COVID-19 in the first half of 2020: strengths, challenges, and lessons learned Bagaria, Jayshree Jansen, Tessa Marques, Diogo FP Hooiveld, Mariette McMenamin, Jim de Lusignan, Simon Vilcu, Ana-Maria Meijer, Adam Rodrigues, Ana-Paula Brytting, Mia Mazagatos, Clara Cogdale, Jade van der Werf, Sylvie Dijkstra, Frederika Guiomar, Raquel Enkirch, Theresa Valenciano, Marta Kissling, Esther Domegan, Lisa O’Donnell, Joan Murray, Josephine Martín, Virginia Sandonis Martínez-Baz, Iván Machado, Ausenda Casado, Itziar Behillil, Sylvie Larrauri, Amparo Tsang, Ruby de Lange, Marit Riess, Maximilian Castilla, Jesús Hamilton, Mark Falchi, Alessandra Pozo, Francisco Dunford, Linda Burgui, Cristina Sigerson, Debbie Blanchon, Thierry Martínez Ochoa, Eva María Connell, Jeff Ellis, Joanna van Gageldonk-Lafeber, Rianne Kislaya, Irina Rose, Angela MC Bernal, Jamie Lopez Andrews, Nick Flecha, Inmaculada Casas Thoulass, Janine Nunes, Baltazar Gomez, Verónica Sa Machado, Rita Enouf, Vincent Pinto Leite, Pedro Licinio Molesworth, Anna McKenna, Adele Thoulass, Janine Euro Surveill Euroroundup As the COVID-19 pandemic began in early 2020, primary care influenza sentinel surveillance networks within the Influenza - Monitoring Vaccine Effectiveness in Europe (I-MOVE) consortium rapidly adapted to COVID-19 surveillance. This study maps system adaptations and lessons learned about aligning influenza and COVID-19 surveillance following ECDC / WHO/Europe recommendations and preparing for other diseases possibly emerging in the future. Using a qualitative approach, we describe the adaptations of seven sentinel sites in five European Union countries and the United Kingdom during the first pandemic phase (March–September 2020). Adaptations to sentinel systems were substantial (2/7 sites), moderate (2/7) or minor (3/7 sites). Most adaptations encompassed patient referral and sample collection pathways, laboratory testing and data collection. Strengths included established networks of primary care providers, highly qualified testing laboratories and stakeholder commitments. One challenge was the decreasing number of samples due to altered patient pathways. Lessons learned included flexibility establishing new routines and new laboratory testing. To enable simultaneous sentinel surveillance of influenza and COVID-19, experiences of the sentinel sites and testing infrastructure should be considered. The contradicting aims of rapid case finding and contact tracing, which are needed for control during a pandemic and regular surveillance, should be carefully balanced. European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control (ECDC) 2022-06-30 /pmc/articles/PMC9248262/ /pubmed/35775429 http://dx.doi.org/10.2807/1560-7917.ES.2022.27.26.2100864 Text en This article is copyright of the authors or their affiliated institutions, 2022. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY 4.0) Licence. You may share and adapt the material, but must give appropriate credit to the source, provide a link to the licence, and indicate if changes were made.
spellingShingle Euroroundup
Bagaria, Jayshree
Jansen, Tessa
Marques, Diogo FP
Hooiveld, Mariette
McMenamin, Jim
de Lusignan, Simon
Vilcu, Ana-Maria
Meijer, Adam
Rodrigues, Ana-Paula
Brytting, Mia
Mazagatos, Clara
Cogdale, Jade
van der Werf, Sylvie
Dijkstra, Frederika
Guiomar, Raquel
Enkirch, Theresa
Valenciano, Marta
Kissling, Esther
Domegan, Lisa
O’Donnell, Joan
Murray, Josephine
Martín, Virginia Sandonis
Martínez-Baz, Iván
Machado, Ausenda
Casado, Itziar
Behillil, Sylvie
Larrauri, Amparo
Tsang, Ruby
de Lange, Marit
Riess, Maximilian
Castilla, Jesús
Hamilton, Mark
Falchi, Alessandra
Pozo, Francisco
Dunford, Linda
Burgui, Cristina
Sigerson, Debbie
Blanchon, Thierry
Martínez Ochoa, Eva María
Connell, Jeff
Ellis, Joanna
van Gageldonk-Lafeber, Rianne
Kislaya, Irina
Rose, Angela MC
Bernal, Jamie Lopez
Andrews, Nick
Flecha, Inmaculada Casas
Thoulass, Janine
Nunes, Baltazar
Gomez, Verónica
Sa Machado, Rita
Enouf, Vincent
Pinto Leite, Pedro Licinio
Molesworth, Anna
McKenna, Adele
Thoulass, Janine
Rapidly adapting primary care sentinel surveillance across seven countries in Europe for COVID-19 in the first half of 2020: strengths, challenges, and lessons learned
title Rapidly adapting primary care sentinel surveillance across seven countries in Europe for COVID-19 in the first half of 2020: strengths, challenges, and lessons learned
title_full Rapidly adapting primary care sentinel surveillance across seven countries in Europe for COVID-19 in the first half of 2020: strengths, challenges, and lessons learned
title_fullStr Rapidly adapting primary care sentinel surveillance across seven countries in Europe for COVID-19 in the first half of 2020: strengths, challenges, and lessons learned
title_full_unstemmed Rapidly adapting primary care sentinel surveillance across seven countries in Europe for COVID-19 in the first half of 2020: strengths, challenges, and lessons learned
title_short Rapidly adapting primary care sentinel surveillance across seven countries in Europe for COVID-19 in the first half of 2020: strengths, challenges, and lessons learned
title_sort rapidly adapting primary care sentinel surveillance across seven countries in europe for covid-19 in the first half of 2020: strengths, challenges, and lessons learned
topic Euroroundup
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9248262/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35775429
http://dx.doi.org/10.2807/1560-7917.ES.2022.27.26.2100864
work_keys_str_mv AT bagariajayshree rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT jansentessa rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT marquesdiogofp rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT hooiveldmariette rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT mcmenaminjim rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT delusignansimon rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT vilcuanamaria rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT meijeradam rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT rodriguesanapaula rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT bryttingmia rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT mazagatosclara rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT cogdalejade rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT vanderwerfsylvie rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT dijkstrafrederika rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT guiomarraquel rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT enkirchtheresa rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT valencianomarta rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT kisslingesther rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT domeganlisa rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT odonnelljoan rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT murrayjosephine rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT martinvirginiasandonis rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT martinezbazivan rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT machadoausenda rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT casadoitziar rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT behillilsylvie rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT larrauriamparo rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT tsangruby rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT delangemarit rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT riessmaximilian rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT castillajesus rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT hamiltonmark rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT falchialessandra rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT pozofrancisco rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT dunfordlinda rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT burguicristina rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT sigersondebbie rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT blanchonthierry rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT martinezochoaevamaria rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT connelljeff rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT ellisjoanna rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT vangageldonklafeberrianne rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT kislayairina rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT roseangelamc rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT bernaljamielopez rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT andrewsnick rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT flechainmaculadacasas rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT thoulassjanine rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT nunesbaltazar rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT gomezveronica rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT samachadorita rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT enoufvincent rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT pintoleitepedrolicinio rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT molesworthanna rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT mckennaadele rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned
AT thoulassjanine rapidlyadaptingprimarycaresentinelsurveillanceacrosssevencountriesineuropeforcovid19inthefirsthalfof2020strengthschallengesandlessonslearned