Cargando…
A Bayesian approach for estimating typhoid fever incidence from large‐scale facility‐based passive surveillance data
Decisions about typhoid fever prevention and control are based on estimates of typhoid incidence and their uncertainty. Lack of specific clinical diagnostic criteria, poorly sensitive diagnostic tests, and scarcity of accurate and complete datasets contribute to difficulties in calculating age‐speci...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
2021
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9291985/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/34428309 http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/sim.9159 |
_version_ | 1784749262061436928 |
---|---|
author | Phillips, Maile T. Meiring, James E. Voysey, Merryn Warren, Joshua L. Baker, Stephen Basnyat, Buddha Clemens, John D. Dolecek, Christiane Dunstan, Sarah J. Dougan, Gordon Gordon, Melita A. Thindwa, Deus Heyderman, Robert S. Holt, Kathryn E. Qadri, Firdausi Pollard, Andrew J. Pitzer, Virginia E. |
author_facet | Phillips, Maile T. Meiring, James E. Voysey, Merryn Warren, Joshua L. Baker, Stephen Basnyat, Buddha Clemens, John D. Dolecek, Christiane Dunstan, Sarah J. Dougan, Gordon Gordon, Melita A. Thindwa, Deus Heyderman, Robert S. Holt, Kathryn E. Qadri, Firdausi Pollard, Andrew J. Pitzer, Virginia E. |
author_sort | Phillips, Maile T. |
collection | PubMed |
description | Decisions about typhoid fever prevention and control are based on estimates of typhoid incidence and their uncertainty. Lack of specific clinical diagnostic criteria, poorly sensitive diagnostic tests, and scarcity of accurate and complete datasets contribute to difficulties in calculating age‐specific population‐level typhoid incidence. Using data from the Strategic Typhoid Alliance across Africa and Asia program, we integrated demographic censuses, healthcare utilization surveys, facility‐based surveillance, and serological surveillance from Malawi, Nepal, and Bangladesh to account for under‐detection of cases. We developed a Bayesian approach that adjusts the count of reported blood‐culture‐positive cases for blood culture detection, blood culture collection, and healthcare seeking—and how these factors vary by age—while combining information from prior published studies. We validated the model using simulated data. The ratio of observed to adjusted incidence rates was 7.7 (95% credible interval [CrI]: 6.0‐12.4) in Malawi, 14.4 (95% CrI: 9.3‐24.9) in Nepal, and 7.0 (95% CrI: 5.6‐9.2) in Bangladesh. The probability of blood culture collection led to the largest adjustment in Malawi, while the probability of seeking healthcare contributed the most in Nepal and Bangladesh; adjustment factors varied by age. Adjusted incidence rates were within or below the seroincidence rate limits of typhoid infection. Estimates of blood‐culture‐confirmed typhoid fever without these adjustments results in considerable underestimation of the true incidence of typhoid fever. Our approach allows each phase of the reporting process to be synthesized to estimate the adjusted incidence of typhoid fever while correctly characterizing uncertainty, which can inform decision‐making for typhoid prevention and control. |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-9291985 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2021 |
publisher | John Wiley & Sons, Inc. |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-92919852022-07-20 A Bayesian approach for estimating typhoid fever incidence from large‐scale facility‐based passive surveillance data Phillips, Maile T. Meiring, James E. Voysey, Merryn Warren, Joshua L. Baker, Stephen Basnyat, Buddha Clemens, John D. Dolecek, Christiane Dunstan, Sarah J. Dougan, Gordon Gordon, Melita A. Thindwa, Deus Heyderman, Robert S. Holt, Kathryn E. Qadri, Firdausi Pollard, Andrew J. Pitzer, Virginia E. Stat Med Research Articles Decisions about typhoid fever prevention and control are based on estimates of typhoid incidence and their uncertainty. Lack of specific clinical diagnostic criteria, poorly sensitive diagnostic tests, and scarcity of accurate and complete datasets contribute to difficulties in calculating age‐specific population‐level typhoid incidence. Using data from the Strategic Typhoid Alliance across Africa and Asia program, we integrated demographic censuses, healthcare utilization surveys, facility‐based surveillance, and serological surveillance from Malawi, Nepal, and Bangladesh to account for under‐detection of cases. We developed a Bayesian approach that adjusts the count of reported blood‐culture‐positive cases for blood culture detection, blood culture collection, and healthcare seeking—and how these factors vary by age—while combining information from prior published studies. We validated the model using simulated data. The ratio of observed to adjusted incidence rates was 7.7 (95% credible interval [CrI]: 6.0‐12.4) in Malawi, 14.4 (95% CrI: 9.3‐24.9) in Nepal, and 7.0 (95% CrI: 5.6‐9.2) in Bangladesh. The probability of blood culture collection led to the largest adjustment in Malawi, while the probability of seeking healthcare contributed the most in Nepal and Bangladesh; adjustment factors varied by age. Adjusted incidence rates were within or below the seroincidence rate limits of typhoid infection. Estimates of blood‐culture‐confirmed typhoid fever without these adjustments results in considerable underestimation of the true incidence of typhoid fever. Our approach allows each phase of the reporting process to be synthesized to estimate the adjusted incidence of typhoid fever while correctly characterizing uncertainty, which can inform decision‐making for typhoid prevention and control. John Wiley & Sons, Inc. 2021-08-24 2021-11-20 /pmc/articles/PMC9291985/ /pubmed/34428309 http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/sim.9159 Text en © 2021 The Authors. Statistics in Medicine published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an open access article under the terms of the http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) License, which permits use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. |
spellingShingle | Research Articles Phillips, Maile T. Meiring, James E. Voysey, Merryn Warren, Joshua L. Baker, Stephen Basnyat, Buddha Clemens, John D. Dolecek, Christiane Dunstan, Sarah J. Dougan, Gordon Gordon, Melita A. Thindwa, Deus Heyderman, Robert S. Holt, Kathryn E. Qadri, Firdausi Pollard, Andrew J. Pitzer, Virginia E. A Bayesian approach for estimating typhoid fever incidence from large‐scale facility‐based passive surveillance data |
title | A Bayesian approach for estimating typhoid fever incidence from large‐scale facility‐based passive surveillance
data |
title_full | A Bayesian approach for estimating typhoid fever incidence from large‐scale facility‐based passive surveillance
data |
title_fullStr | A Bayesian approach for estimating typhoid fever incidence from large‐scale facility‐based passive surveillance
data |
title_full_unstemmed | A Bayesian approach for estimating typhoid fever incidence from large‐scale facility‐based passive surveillance
data |
title_short | A Bayesian approach for estimating typhoid fever incidence from large‐scale facility‐based passive surveillance
data |
title_sort | bayesian approach for estimating typhoid fever incidence from large‐scale facility‐based passive surveillance
data |
topic | Research Articles |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9291985/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/34428309 http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/sim.9159 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT phillipsmailet abayesianapproachforestimatingtyphoidfeverincidencefromlargescalefacilitybasedpassivesurveillancedata AT meiringjamese abayesianapproachforestimatingtyphoidfeverincidencefromlargescalefacilitybasedpassivesurveillancedata AT voyseymerryn abayesianapproachforestimatingtyphoidfeverincidencefromlargescalefacilitybasedpassivesurveillancedata AT warrenjoshual abayesianapproachforestimatingtyphoidfeverincidencefromlargescalefacilitybasedpassivesurveillancedata AT bakerstephen abayesianapproachforestimatingtyphoidfeverincidencefromlargescalefacilitybasedpassivesurveillancedata AT basnyatbuddha abayesianapproachforestimatingtyphoidfeverincidencefromlargescalefacilitybasedpassivesurveillancedata AT clemensjohnd abayesianapproachforestimatingtyphoidfeverincidencefromlargescalefacilitybasedpassivesurveillancedata AT dolecekchristiane abayesianapproachforestimatingtyphoidfeverincidencefromlargescalefacilitybasedpassivesurveillancedata AT dunstansarahj abayesianapproachforestimatingtyphoidfeverincidencefromlargescalefacilitybasedpassivesurveillancedata AT dougangordon abayesianapproachforestimatingtyphoidfeverincidencefromlargescalefacilitybasedpassivesurveillancedata AT gordonmelitaa abayesianapproachforestimatingtyphoidfeverincidencefromlargescalefacilitybasedpassivesurveillancedata AT thindwadeus abayesianapproachforestimatingtyphoidfeverincidencefromlargescalefacilitybasedpassivesurveillancedata AT heydermanroberts abayesianapproachforestimatingtyphoidfeverincidencefromlargescalefacilitybasedpassivesurveillancedata AT holtkathryne abayesianapproachforestimatingtyphoidfeverincidencefromlargescalefacilitybasedpassivesurveillancedata AT qadrifirdausi abayesianapproachforestimatingtyphoidfeverincidencefromlargescalefacilitybasedpassivesurveillancedata AT pollardandrewj abayesianapproachforestimatingtyphoidfeverincidencefromlargescalefacilitybasedpassivesurveillancedata AT pitzervirginiae abayesianapproachforestimatingtyphoidfeverincidencefromlargescalefacilitybasedpassivesurveillancedata AT abayesianapproachforestimatingtyphoidfeverincidencefromlargescalefacilitybasedpassivesurveillancedata AT phillipsmailet bayesianapproachforestimatingtyphoidfeverincidencefromlargescalefacilitybasedpassivesurveillancedata AT meiringjamese bayesianapproachforestimatingtyphoidfeverincidencefromlargescalefacilitybasedpassivesurveillancedata AT voyseymerryn bayesianapproachforestimatingtyphoidfeverincidencefromlargescalefacilitybasedpassivesurveillancedata AT warrenjoshual bayesianapproachforestimatingtyphoidfeverincidencefromlargescalefacilitybasedpassivesurveillancedata AT bakerstephen bayesianapproachforestimatingtyphoidfeverincidencefromlargescalefacilitybasedpassivesurveillancedata AT basnyatbuddha bayesianapproachforestimatingtyphoidfeverincidencefromlargescalefacilitybasedpassivesurveillancedata AT clemensjohnd bayesianapproachforestimatingtyphoidfeverincidencefromlargescalefacilitybasedpassivesurveillancedata AT dolecekchristiane bayesianapproachforestimatingtyphoidfeverincidencefromlargescalefacilitybasedpassivesurveillancedata AT dunstansarahj bayesianapproachforestimatingtyphoidfeverincidencefromlargescalefacilitybasedpassivesurveillancedata AT dougangordon bayesianapproachforestimatingtyphoidfeverincidencefromlargescalefacilitybasedpassivesurveillancedata AT gordonmelitaa bayesianapproachforestimatingtyphoidfeverincidencefromlargescalefacilitybasedpassivesurveillancedata AT thindwadeus bayesianapproachforestimatingtyphoidfeverincidencefromlargescalefacilitybasedpassivesurveillancedata AT heydermanroberts bayesianapproachforestimatingtyphoidfeverincidencefromlargescalefacilitybasedpassivesurveillancedata AT holtkathryne bayesianapproachforestimatingtyphoidfeverincidencefromlargescalefacilitybasedpassivesurveillancedata AT qadrifirdausi bayesianapproachforestimatingtyphoidfeverincidencefromlargescalefacilitybasedpassivesurveillancedata AT pollardandrewj bayesianapproachforestimatingtyphoidfeverincidencefromlargescalefacilitybasedpassivesurveillancedata AT pitzervirginiae bayesianapproachforestimatingtyphoidfeverincidencefromlargescalefacilitybasedpassivesurveillancedata AT bayesianapproachforestimatingtyphoidfeverincidencefromlargescalefacilitybasedpassivesurveillancedata |