Cargando…

Accuracy of the Traditional COVID-19 Phone Triaging System and Phone Triage-Driven Deep Learning Model

OBJECTIVES: During the COVID-19 pandemic, a quick and reliable phone-triage system is critical for early care and efficient distribution of hospital resources. The study aimed to assess the accuracy of the traditional phone-triage system and phone triage-driven deep learning model in the prediction...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Ahmed, Marwa M., Sayed, Amal M., Khafagy, Ghada M., El Sayed, Inas T., Elkholy, Yasmine S., Fares, Ahmed H., Hasan, Marwa D., El Nahas, Heba G., Sarhan, Mai D., Raslan, Eman I., Elsayed, Radwa M., Sayed, Asmaa A., Elmeshmeshy, Eman I., Yassen, Rehab M., Tawfik, Nadia M., Hussein, Hala A., Gaber, Dalia M., Shehata, Mervat M., Fares, Samar
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: SAGE Publications 2022
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9310285/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35869692
http://dx.doi.org/10.1177/21501319221113544
_version_ 1784753357644103680
author Ahmed, Marwa M.
Sayed, Amal M.
Khafagy, Ghada M.
El Sayed, Inas T.
Elkholy, Yasmine S.
Fares, Ahmed H.
Hasan, Marwa D.
El Nahas, Heba G.
Sarhan, Mai D.
Raslan, Eman I.
Elsayed, Radwa M.
Sayed, Asmaa A.
Elmeshmeshy, Eman I.
Yassen, Rehab M.
Tawfik, Nadia M.
Hussein, Hala A.
Gaber, Dalia M.
Shehata, Mervat M.
Fares, Samar
author_facet Ahmed, Marwa M.
Sayed, Amal M.
Khafagy, Ghada M.
El Sayed, Inas T.
Elkholy, Yasmine S.
Fares, Ahmed H.
Hasan, Marwa D.
El Nahas, Heba G.
Sarhan, Mai D.
Raslan, Eman I.
Elsayed, Radwa M.
Sayed, Asmaa A.
Elmeshmeshy, Eman I.
Yassen, Rehab M.
Tawfik, Nadia M.
Hussein, Hala A.
Gaber, Dalia M.
Shehata, Mervat M.
Fares, Samar
author_sort Ahmed, Marwa M.
collection PubMed
description OBJECTIVES: During the COVID-19 pandemic, a quick and reliable phone-triage system is critical for early care and efficient distribution of hospital resources. The study aimed to assess the accuracy of the traditional phone-triage system and phone triage-driven deep learning model in the prediction of positive COVID-19 patients. SETTING: This is a retrospective study conducted at the family medicine department, Cairo University. METHODS: The study included a dataset of 943 suspected COVID-19 patients from the phone triage during the first wave of the pandemic. The accuracy of the phone triaging system was assessed. PCR-dependent and phone triage-driven deep learning model for automated classifications of natural human responses was conducted. RESULTS: Based on the RT-PCR results, we found that myalgia, fever, and contact with a case with respiratory symptoms had the highest sensitivity among the symptoms/ risk factors that were asked during the phone calls (86.3%, 77.5%, and 75.1%, respectively). While immunodeficiency, smoking, and loss of smell or taste had the highest specificity (96.9%, 83.6%, and 74.0%, respectively). The positive predictive value (PPV) of phone triage was 48.4%. The classification accuracy achieved by the deep learning model was 66%, while the PPV was 70.5%. CONCLUSION: Phone triage and deep learning models are feasible and convenient tools for screening COVID-19 patients. Using the deep learning models for symptoms screening will help to provide the proper medical care as early as possible for those at a higher risk of developing severe illness paving the way for a more efficient allocation of the scanty health resources.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-9310285
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2022
publisher SAGE Publications
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-93102852022-07-26 Accuracy of the Traditional COVID-19 Phone Triaging System and Phone Triage-Driven Deep Learning Model Ahmed, Marwa M. Sayed, Amal M. Khafagy, Ghada M. El Sayed, Inas T. Elkholy, Yasmine S. Fares, Ahmed H. Hasan, Marwa D. El Nahas, Heba G. Sarhan, Mai D. Raslan, Eman I. Elsayed, Radwa M. Sayed, Asmaa A. Elmeshmeshy, Eman I. Yassen, Rehab M. Tawfik, Nadia M. Hussein, Hala A. Gaber, Dalia M. Shehata, Mervat M. Fares, Samar J Prim Care Community Health Original Research OBJECTIVES: During the COVID-19 pandemic, a quick and reliable phone-triage system is critical for early care and efficient distribution of hospital resources. The study aimed to assess the accuracy of the traditional phone-triage system and phone triage-driven deep learning model in the prediction of positive COVID-19 patients. SETTING: This is a retrospective study conducted at the family medicine department, Cairo University. METHODS: The study included a dataset of 943 suspected COVID-19 patients from the phone triage during the first wave of the pandemic. The accuracy of the phone triaging system was assessed. PCR-dependent and phone triage-driven deep learning model for automated classifications of natural human responses was conducted. RESULTS: Based on the RT-PCR results, we found that myalgia, fever, and contact with a case with respiratory symptoms had the highest sensitivity among the symptoms/ risk factors that were asked during the phone calls (86.3%, 77.5%, and 75.1%, respectively). While immunodeficiency, smoking, and loss of smell or taste had the highest specificity (96.9%, 83.6%, and 74.0%, respectively). The positive predictive value (PPV) of phone triage was 48.4%. The classification accuracy achieved by the deep learning model was 66%, while the PPV was 70.5%. CONCLUSION: Phone triage and deep learning models are feasible and convenient tools for screening COVID-19 patients. Using the deep learning models for symptoms screening will help to provide the proper medical care as early as possible for those at a higher risk of developing severe illness paving the way for a more efficient allocation of the scanty health resources. SAGE Publications 2022-07-22 /pmc/articles/PMC9310285/ /pubmed/35869692 http://dx.doi.org/10.1177/21501319221113544 Text en © The Author(s) 2022 https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/) which permits non-commercial use, reproduction and distribution of the work without further permission provided the original work is attributed as specified on the SAGE and Open Access pages (https://us.sagepub.com/en-us/nam/open-access-at-sage).
spellingShingle Original Research
Ahmed, Marwa M.
Sayed, Amal M.
Khafagy, Ghada M.
El Sayed, Inas T.
Elkholy, Yasmine S.
Fares, Ahmed H.
Hasan, Marwa D.
El Nahas, Heba G.
Sarhan, Mai D.
Raslan, Eman I.
Elsayed, Radwa M.
Sayed, Asmaa A.
Elmeshmeshy, Eman I.
Yassen, Rehab M.
Tawfik, Nadia M.
Hussein, Hala A.
Gaber, Dalia M.
Shehata, Mervat M.
Fares, Samar
Accuracy of the Traditional COVID-19 Phone Triaging System and Phone Triage-Driven Deep Learning Model
title Accuracy of the Traditional COVID-19 Phone Triaging System and Phone Triage-Driven Deep Learning Model
title_full Accuracy of the Traditional COVID-19 Phone Triaging System and Phone Triage-Driven Deep Learning Model
title_fullStr Accuracy of the Traditional COVID-19 Phone Triaging System and Phone Triage-Driven Deep Learning Model
title_full_unstemmed Accuracy of the Traditional COVID-19 Phone Triaging System and Phone Triage-Driven Deep Learning Model
title_short Accuracy of the Traditional COVID-19 Phone Triaging System and Phone Triage-Driven Deep Learning Model
title_sort accuracy of the traditional covid-19 phone triaging system and phone triage-driven deep learning model
topic Original Research
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9310285/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35869692
http://dx.doi.org/10.1177/21501319221113544
work_keys_str_mv AT ahmedmarwam accuracyofthetraditionalcovid19phonetriagingsystemandphonetriagedrivendeeplearningmodel
AT sayedamalm accuracyofthetraditionalcovid19phonetriagingsystemandphonetriagedrivendeeplearningmodel
AT khafagyghadam accuracyofthetraditionalcovid19phonetriagingsystemandphonetriagedrivendeeplearningmodel
AT elsayedinast accuracyofthetraditionalcovid19phonetriagingsystemandphonetriagedrivendeeplearningmodel
AT elkholyyasmines accuracyofthetraditionalcovid19phonetriagingsystemandphonetriagedrivendeeplearningmodel
AT faresahmedh accuracyofthetraditionalcovid19phonetriagingsystemandphonetriagedrivendeeplearningmodel
AT hasanmarwad accuracyofthetraditionalcovid19phonetriagingsystemandphonetriagedrivendeeplearningmodel
AT elnahashebag accuracyofthetraditionalcovid19phonetriagingsystemandphonetriagedrivendeeplearningmodel
AT sarhanmaid accuracyofthetraditionalcovid19phonetriagingsystemandphonetriagedrivendeeplearningmodel
AT raslanemani accuracyofthetraditionalcovid19phonetriagingsystemandphonetriagedrivendeeplearningmodel
AT elsayedradwam accuracyofthetraditionalcovid19phonetriagingsystemandphonetriagedrivendeeplearningmodel
AT sayedasmaaa accuracyofthetraditionalcovid19phonetriagingsystemandphonetriagedrivendeeplearningmodel
AT elmeshmeshyemani accuracyofthetraditionalcovid19phonetriagingsystemandphonetriagedrivendeeplearningmodel
AT yassenrehabm accuracyofthetraditionalcovid19phonetriagingsystemandphonetriagedrivendeeplearningmodel
AT tawfiknadiam accuracyofthetraditionalcovid19phonetriagingsystemandphonetriagedrivendeeplearningmodel
AT husseinhalaa accuracyofthetraditionalcovid19phonetriagingsystemandphonetriagedrivendeeplearningmodel
AT gaberdaliam accuracyofthetraditionalcovid19phonetriagingsystemandphonetriagedrivendeeplearningmodel
AT shehatamervatm accuracyofthetraditionalcovid19phonetriagingsystemandphonetriagedrivendeeplearningmodel
AT faressamar accuracyofthetraditionalcovid19phonetriagingsystemandphonetriagedrivendeeplearningmodel