Investigating Machine Learning Techniques for Predicting the Process Characteristics of Stencil Printing

Stencil printing is the most crucial process in reflow soldering for the mass assembly of electronic circuits. This paper investigates different machine learning-based methods to predict the essential process characteristics of stencil printing: the area, thickness, and volume of deposited solder paste. The training dataset was obtained experimentally by varying the printing speed (from 20 to 120 mm/s), the size (area ratio from 0.35 to 1.7) of stencil apertures, and the particle size (characterized by a log-normal distribution) in the solder paste. Various machine learning-based methods were assessed; ANFIS–adaptive neuro-fuzzy inference systems; ANN artificial neural networks (with different learning methods); boosted trees, regression trees, SVM–support vector machines. Each method was optimized and fine-tuned with hyperparameter optimization, and the overfitting phenomenon was also prevented with cross-validation. The regression tree was the best performing approach for modelling the stencil printing, while ANN with the Bayesian regularization learning method was only slightly worse. The presented methodology for fine-tuning, parameter optimization, and the comparison of different machine learning-based methods can easily be adapted to any application field in electronics manufacturing.