Cargando…

Nomenclature and Definition of Atrophic Lesions in Small Bowel Capsule Endoscopy: A Delphi Consensus Statement of the International CApsule endoscopy REsearch (I-CARE) Group

(1) Background: Villous atrophy is an indication for small bowel capsule endoscopy (SBCE). However, SBCE findings are not described uniformly and atrophic features are sometimes not recognized; (2) Methods: The Delphi technique was employed to reach agreement among a panel of SBCE experts. The nomen...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Elli, Luca, Marinoni, Beatrice, Sidhu, Reena, Bojarski, Christian, Branchi, Federica, Tontini, Gian Eugenio, Chetcuti Zammit, Stefania, Khater, Sherine, Eliakim, Rami, Rondonotti, Emanuele, Saurin, Jean Cristhophe, Bruno, Mauro, Buchkremer, Juliane, Cadoni, Sergio, Cavallaro, Flaminia, Dray, Xavier, Ellul, Pierre, Urien, Ignacio Fernandez, Keuchel, Martin, Kopylov, Uri, Koulaouzidis, Anastasios, Leenhardt, Romain, Baltes, Peter, Beaumont, Hanneke, Marmo, Clelia, McNamara, Deirdre, Mussetto, Alessandro, Nemeth, Artur, Cuadrado Robles, Enrique Perez, Perrod, Guillame, Rahmi, Gabriel, Riccioni, Maria Elena, Robertson, Alexander, Spada, Cristiano, Toth, Ervin, Triantafyllou, Konstantinos, Wurm Johansson, Gabriele, Rimondi, Alessandro
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: MDPI 2022
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9325291/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35885608
http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/diagnostics12071704
_version_ 1784757013867134976
author Elli, Luca
Marinoni, Beatrice
Sidhu, Reena
Bojarski, Christian
Branchi, Federica
Tontini, Gian Eugenio
Chetcuti Zammit, Stefania
Khater, Sherine
Eliakim, Rami
Rondonotti, Emanuele
Saurin, Jean Cristhophe
Bruno, Mauro
Buchkremer, Juliane
Cadoni, Sergio
Cavallaro, Flaminia
Dray, Xavier
Ellul, Pierre
Urien, Ignacio Fernandez
Keuchel, Martin
Kopylov, Uri
Koulaouzidis, Anastasios
Leenhardt, Romain
Baltes, Peter
Beaumont, Hanneke
Marmo, Clelia
McNamara, Deirdre
Mussetto, Alessandro
Nemeth, Artur
Cuadrado Robles, Enrique Perez
Perrod, Guillame
Rahmi, Gabriel
Riccioni, Maria Elena
Robertson, Alexander
Spada, Cristiano
Toth, Ervin
Triantafyllou, Konstantinos
Wurm Johansson, Gabriele
Rimondi, Alessandro
author_facet Elli, Luca
Marinoni, Beatrice
Sidhu, Reena
Bojarski, Christian
Branchi, Federica
Tontini, Gian Eugenio
Chetcuti Zammit, Stefania
Khater, Sherine
Eliakim, Rami
Rondonotti, Emanuele
Saurin, Jean Cristhophe
Bruno, Mauro
Buchkremer, Juliane
Cadoni, Sergio
Cavallaro, Flaminia
Dray, Xavier
Ellul, Pierre
Urien, Ignacio Fernandez
Keuchel, Martin
Kopylov, Uri
Koulaouzidis, Anastasios
Leenhardt, Romain
Baltes, Peter
Beaumont, Hanneke
Marmo, Clelia
McNamara, Deirdre
Mussetto, Alessandro
Nemeth, Artur
Cuadrado Robles, Enrique Perez
Perrod, Guillame
Rahmi, Gabriel
Riccioni, Maria Elena
Robertson, Alexander
Spada, Cristiano
Toth, Ervin
Triantafyllou, Konstantinos
Wurm Johansson, Gabriele
Rimondi, Alessandro
author_sort Elli, Luca
collection PubMed
description (1) Background: Villous atrophy is an indication for small bowel capsule endoscopy (SBCE). However, SBCE findings are not described uniformly and atrophic features are sometimes not recognized; (2) Methods: The Delphi technique was employed to reach agreement among a panel of SBCE experts. The nomenclature and definitions of SBCE lesions suggesting the presence of atrophy were decided in a core group of 10 experts. Four images of each lesion were chosen from a large SBCE database and agreement on the correspondence between the picture and the definition was evaluated using the Delphi method in a broadened group of 36 experts. All images corresponded to histologically proven mucosal atrophy; (3) Results: Four types of atrophic lesions were identified: mosaicism, scalloping, folds reduction, and granular mucosa. The core group succeeded in reaching agreement on the nomenclature and the descriptions of these items. Consensus in matching the agreed definitions for the proposed set of images was met for mosaicism (88.9% in the first round), scalloping (97.2% in the first round), and folds reduction (94.4% in the first round), but granular mucosa failed to achieve consensus (75.0% in the third round); (4) Conclusions: Consensus among SBCE experts on atrophic lesions was met for the first time. Mosaicism, scalloping, and folds reduction are the most reliable signs, while the description of granular mucosa remains uncertain.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-9325291
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2022
publisher MDPI
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-93252912022-07-27 Nomenclature and Definition of Atrophic Lesions in Small Bowel Capsule Endoscopy: A Delphi Consensus Statement of the International CApsule endoscopy REsearch (I-CARE) Group Elli, Luca Marinoni, Beatrice Sidhu, Reena Bojarski, Christian Branchi, Federica Tontini, Gian Eugenio Chetcuti Zammit, Stefania Khater, Sherine Eliakim, Rami Rondonotti, Emanuele Saurin, Jean Cristhophe Bruno, Mauro Buchkremer, Juliane Cadoni, Sergio Cavallaro, Flaminia Dray, Xavier Ellul, Pierre Urien, Ignacio Fernandez Keuchel, Martin Kopylov, Uri Koulaouzidis, Anastasios Leenhardt, Romain Baltes, Peter Beaumont, Hanneke Marmo, Clelia McNamara, Deirdre Mussetto, Alessandro Nemeth, Artur Cuadrado Robles, Enrique Perez Perrod, Guillame Rahmi, Gabriel Riccioni, Maria Elena Robertson, Alexander Spada, Cristiano Toth, Ervin Triantafyllou, Konstantinos Wurm Johansson, Gabriele Rimondi, Alessandro Diagnostics (Basel) Article (1) Background: Villous atrophy is an indication for small bowel capsule endoscopy (SBCE). However, SBCE findings are not described uniformly and atrophic features are sometimes not recognized; (2) Methods: The Delphi technique was employed to reach agreement among a panel of SBCE experts. The nomenclature and definitions of SBCE lesions suggesting the presence of atrophy were decided in a core group of 10 experts. Four images of each lesion were chosen from a large SBCE database and agreement on the correspondence between the picture and the definition was evaluated using the Delphi method in a broadened group of 36 experts. All images corresponded to histologically proven mucosal atrophy; (3) Results: Four types of atrophic lesions were identified: mosaicism, scalloping, folds reduction, and granular mucosa. The core group succeeded in reaching agreement on the nomenclature and the descriptions of these items. Consensus in matching the agreed definitions for the proposed set of images was met for mosaicism (88.9% in the first round), scalloping (97.2% in the first round), and folds reduction (94.4% in the first round), but granular mucosa failed to achieve consensus (75.0% in the third round); (4) Conclusions: Consensus among SBCE experts on atrophic lesions was met for the first time. Mosaicism, scalloping, and folds reduction are the most reliable signs, while the description of granular mucosa remains uncertain. MDPI 2022-07-13 /pmc/articles/PMC9325291/ /pubmed/35885608 http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/diagnostics12071704 Text en © 2022 by the authors. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
spellingShingle Article
Elli, Luca
Marinoni, Beatrice
Sidhu, Reena
Bojarski, Christian
Branchi, Federica
Tontini, Gian Eugenio
Chetcuti Zammit, Stefania
Khater, Sherine
Eliakim, Rami
Rondonotti, Emanuele
Saurin, Jean Cristhophe
Bruno, Mauro
Buchkremer, Juliane
Cadoni, Sergio
Cavallaro, Flaminia
Dray, Xavier
Ellul, Pierre
Urien, Ignacio Fernandez
Keuchel, Martin
Kopylov, Uri
Koulaouzidis, Anastasios
Leenhardt, Romain
Baltes, Peter
Beaumont, Hanneke
Marmo, Clelia
McNamara, Deirdre
Mussetto, Alessandro
Nemeth, Artur
Cuadrado Robles, Enrique Perez
Perrod, Guillame
Rahmi, Gabriel
Riccioni, Maria Elena
Robertson, Alexander
Spada, Cristiano
Toth, Ervin
Triantafyllou, Konstantinos
Wurm Johansson, Gabriele
Rimondi, Alessandro
Nomenclature and Definition of Atrophic Lesions in Small Bowel Capsule Endoscopy: A Delphi Consensus Statement of the International CApsule endoscopy REsearch (I-CARE) Group
title Nomenclature and Definition of Atrophic Lesions in Small Bowel Capsule Endoscopy: A Delphi Consensus Statement of the International CApsule endoscopy REsearch (I-CARE) Group
title_full Nomenclature and Definition of Atrophic Lesions in Small Bowel Capsule Endoscopy: A Delphi Consensus Statement of the International CApsule endoscopy REsearch (I-CARE) Group
title_fullStr Nomenclature and Definition of Atrophic Lesions in Small Bowel Capsule Endoscopy: A Delphi Consensus Statement of the International CApsule endoscopy REsearch (I-CARE) Group
title_full_unstemmed Nomenclature and Definition of Atrophic Lesions in Small Bowel Capsule Endoscopy: A Delphi Consensus Statement of the International CApsule endoscopy REsearch (I-CARE) Group
title_short Nomenclature and Definition of Atrophic Lesions in Small Bowel Capsule Endoscopy: A Delphi Consensus Statement of the International CApsule endoscopy REsearch (I-CARE) Group
title_sort nomenclature and definition of atrophic lesions in small bowel capsule endoscopy: a delphi consensus statement of the international capsule endoscopy research (i-care) group
topic Article
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9325291/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35885608
http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/diagnostics12071704
work_keys_str_mv AT elliluca nomenclatureanddefinitionofatrophiclesionsinsmallbowelcapsuleendoscopyadelphiconsensusstatementoftheinternationalcapsuleendoscopyresearchicaregroup
AT marinonibeatrice nomenclatureanddefinitionofatrophiclesionsinsmallbowelcapsuleendoscopyadelphiconsensusstatementoftheinternationalcapsuleendoscopyresearchicaregroup
AT sidhureena nomenclatureanddefinitionofatrophiclesionsinsmallbowelcapsuleendoscopyadelphiconsensusstatementoftheinternationalcapsuleendoscopyresearchicaregroup
AT bojarskichristian nomenclatureanddefinitionofatrophiclesionsinsmallbowelcapsuleendoscopyadelphiconsensusstatementoftheinternationalcapsuleendoscopyresearchicaregroup
AT branchifederica nomenclatureanddefinitionofatrophiclesionsinsmallbowelcapsuleendoscopyadelphiconsensusstatementoftheinternationalcapsuleendoscopyresearchicaregroup
AT tontinigianeugenio nomenclatureanddefinitionofatrophiclesionsinsmallbowelcapsuleendoscopyadelphiconsensusstatementoftheinternationalcapsuleendoscopyresearchicaregroup
AT chetcutizammitstefania nomenclatureanddefinitionofatrophiclesionsinsmallbowelcapsuleendoscopyadelphiconsensusstatementoftheinternationalcapsuleendoscopyresearchicaregroup
AT khatersherine nomenclatureanddefinitionofatrophiclesionsinsmallbowelcapsuleendoscopyadelphiconsensusstatementoftheinternationalcapsuleendoscopyresearchicaregroup
AT eliakimrami nomenclatureanddefinitionofatrophiclesionsinsmallbowelcapsuleendoscopyadelphiconsensusstatementoftheinternationalcapsuleendoscopyresearchicaregroup
AT rondonottiemanuele nomenclatureanddefinitionofatrophiclesionsinsmallbowelcapsuleendoscopyadelphiconsensusstatementoftheinternationalcapsuleendoscopyresearchicaregroup
AT saurinjeancristhophe nomenclatureanddefinitionofatrophiclesionsinsmallbowelcapsuleendoscopyadelphiconsensusstatementoftheinternationalcapsuleendoscopyresearchicaregroup
AT brunomauro nomenclatureanddefinitionofatrophiclesionsinsmallbowelcapsuleendoscopyadelphiconsensusstatementoftheinternationalcapsuleendoscopyresearchicaregroup
AT buchkremerjuliane nomenclatureanddefinitionofatrophiclesionsinsmallbowelcapsuleendoscopyadelphiconsensusstatementoftheinternationalcapsuleendoscopyresearchicaregroup
AT cadonisergio nomenclatureanddefinitionofatrophiclesionsinsmallbowelcapsuleendoscopyadelphiconsensusstatementoftheinternationalcapsuleendoscopyresearchicaregroup
AT cavallaroflaminia nomenclatureanddefinitionofatrophiclesionsinsmallbowelcapsuleendoscopyadelphiconsensusstatementoftheinternationalcapsuleendoscopyresearchicaregroup
AT drayxavier nomenclatureanddefinitionofatrophiclesionsinsmallbowelcapsuleendoscopyadelphiconsensusstatementoftheinternationalcapsuleendoscopyresearchicaregroup
AT ellulpierre nomenclatureanddefinitionofatrophiclesionsinsmallbowelcapsuleendoscopyadelphiconsensusstatementoftheinternationalcapsuleendoscopyresearchicaregroup
AT urienignaciofernandez nomenclatureanddefinitionofatrophiclesionsinsmallbowelcapsuleendoscopyadelphiconsensusstatementoftheinternationalcapsuleendoscopyresearchicaregroup
AT keuchelmartin nomenclatureanddefinitionofatrophiclesionsinsmallbowelcapsuleendoscopyadelphiconsensusstatementoftheinternationalcapsuleendoscopyresearchicaregroup
AT kopylovuri nomenclatureanddefinitionofatrophiclesionsinsmallbowelcapsuleendoscopyadelphiconsensusstatementoftheinternationalcapsuleendoscopyresearchicaregroup
AT koulaouzidisanastasios nomenclatureanddefinitionofatrophiclesionsinsmallbowelcapsuleendoscopyadelphiconsensusstatementoftheinternationalcapsuleendoscopyresearchicaregroup
AT leenhardtromain nomenclatureanddefinitionofatrophiclesionsinsmallbowelcapsuleendoscopyadelphiconsensusstatementoftheinternationalcapsuleendoscopyresearchicaregroup
AT baltespeter nomenclatureanddefinitionofatrophiclesionsinsmallbowelcapsuleendoscopyadelphiconsensusstatementoftheinternationalcapsuleendoscopyresearchicaregroup
AT beaumonthanneke nomenclatureanddefinitionofatrophiclesionsinsmallbowelcapsuleendoscopyadelphiconsensusstatementoftheinternationalcapsuleendoscopyresearchicaregroup
AT marmoclelia nomenclatureanddefinitionofatrophiclesionsinsmallbowelcapsuleendoscopyadelphiconsensusstatementoftheinternationalcapsuleendoscopyresearchicaregroup
AT mcnamaradeirdre nomenclatureanddefinitionofatrophiclesionsinsmallbowelcapsuleendoscopyadelphiconsensusstatementoftheinternationalcapsuleendoscopyresearchicaregroup
AT mussettoalessandro nomenclatureanddefinitionofatrophiclesionsinsmallbowelcapsuleendoscopyadelphiconsensusstatementoftheinternationalcapsuleendoscopyresearchicaregroup
AT nemethartur nomenclatureanddefinitionofatrophiclesionsinsmallbowelcapsuleendoscopyadelphiconsensusstatementoftheinternationalcapsuleendoscopyresearchicaregroup
AT cuadradoroblesenriqueperez nomenclatureanddefinitionofatrophiclesionsinsmallbowelcapsuleendoscopyadelphiconsensusstatementoftheinternationalcapsuleendoscopyresearchicaregroup
AT perrodguillame nomenclatureanddefinitionofatrophiclesionsinsmallbowelcapsuleendoscopyadelphiconsensusstatementoftheinternationalcapsuleendoscopyresearchicaregroup
AT rahmigabriel nomenclatureanddefinitionofatrophiclesionsinsmallbowelcapsuleendoscopyadelphiconsensusstatementoftheinternationalcapsuleendoscopyresearchicaregroup
AT riccionimariaelena nomenclatureanddefinitionofatrophiclesionsinsmallbowelcapsuleendoscopyadelphiconsensusstatementoftheinternationalcapsuleendoscopyresearchicaregroup
AT robertsonalexander nomenclatureanddefinitionofatrophiclesionsinsmallbowelcapsuleendoscopyadelphiconsensusstatementoftheinternationalcapsuleendoscopyresearchicaregroup
AT spadacristiano nomenclatureanddefinitionofatrophiclesionsinsmallbowelcapsuleendoscopyadelphiconsensusstatementoftheinternationalcapsuleendoscopyresearchicaregroup
AT tothervin nomenclatureanddefinitionofatrophiclesionsinsmallbowelcapsuleendoscopyadelphiconsensusstatementoftheinternationalcapsuleendoscopyresearchicaregroup
AT triantafylloukonstantinos nomenclatureanddefinitionofatrophiclesionsinsmallbowelcapsuleendoscopyadelphiconsensusstatementoftheinternationalcapsuleendoscopyresearchicaregroup
AT wurmjohanssongabriele nomenclatureanddefinitionofatrophiclesionsinsmallbowelcapsuleendoscopyadelphiconsensusstatementoftheinternationalcapsuleendoscopyresearchicaregroup
AT rimondialessandro nomenclatureanddefinitionofatrophiclesionsinsmallbowelcapsuleendoscopyadelphiconsensusstatementoftheinternationalcapsuleendoscopyresearchicaregroup