Cargando…
The White Matter Rounds experience: The importance of a multidisciplinary network to accelerate the diagnostic process for adult patients with rare white matter disorders
INTRODUCTION: Adult genetic leukoencephalopathies are rare neurological disorders that present unique diagnostic challenges due to their clinical and radiological overlap with more common white matter diseases, notably multiple sclerosis (MS). In this context, a strong collaborative multidisciplinar...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
Frontiers Media S.A.
2022
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9359417/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35959404 http://dx.doi.org/10.3389/fneur.2022.928493 |
_version_ | 1784764135686275072 |
---|---|
author | Huang, Yu Tong Giacomini, Paul S. Massie, Rami Venkateswaran, Sunita Trudelle, Anne-Marie Fadda, Giulia Sharifian-Dorche, Maryam Boudjani, Hayet Poliquin-Lasnier, Laurence Airas, Laura Saveriano, Alexander W. Ziller, Matthias Georg Miller, Elka Martinez-Rios, Claudia Wilson, Nagwa Davila, Jorge Rush, Carolina Longbrake, Erin E. Longoni, Giulia Macaron, Gabrielle Bernard, Geneviève Tampieri, Donatella Antel, Jack Brais, Bernard La Piana, Roberta |
author_facet | Huang, Yu Tong Giacomini, Paul S. Massie, Rami Venkateswaran, Sunita Trudelle, Anne-Marie Fadda, Giulia Sharifian-Dorche, Maryam Boudjani, Hayet Poliquin-Lasnier, Laurence Airas, Laura Saveriano, Alexander W. Ziller, Matthias Georg Miller, Elka Martinez-Rios, Claudia Wilson, Nagwa Davila, Jorge Rush, Carolina Longbrake, Erin E. Longoni, Giulia Macaron, Gabrielle Bernard, Geneviève Tampieri, Donatella Antel, Jack Brais, Bernard La Piana, Roberta |
author_sort | Huang, Yu Tong |
collection | PubMed |
description | INTRODUCTION: Adult genetic leukoencephalopathies are rare neurological disorders that present unique diagnostic challenges due to their clinical and radiological overlap with more common white matter diseases, notably multiple sclerosis (MS). In this context, a strong collaborative multidisciplinary network is beneficial for shortening the diagnostic odyssey of these patients and preventing misdiagnosis. The White Matter Rounds (WM Rounds) are multidisciplinary international online meetings attended by more than 30 physicians and scientists from 15 participating sites that gather every month to discuss patients with atypical white matter disorders. We aim to present the experience of the WM Rounds Network and demonstrate the value of collaborative multidisciplinary international case discussion meetings in differentiating and preventing misdiagnoses between genetic white matter diseases and atypical MS. METHODS: We retrospectively reviewed the demographic, clinical and radiological data of all the subjects presented at the WM Rounds since their creation in 2013. RESULTS: Seventy-four patients (mean age 44.3) have been referred and discussed at the WM Rounds since 2013. Twenty-five (33.8%) of these patients were referred by an MS specialist for having an atypical presentation of MS, while in most of the remaining cases, the referring physician was a geneticist (23; 31.1%). Based on the WM Rounds recommendations, a definite diagnosis was made in 36/69 (52.2%) patients for which information was available for retrospective review. Of these diagnosed patients, 20 (55.6%) had a genetic disease, 8 (22.2%) had MS, 3 (8.3%) had both MS and a genetic disorder and 5 (13.9%) had other non-genetic conditions. Interestingly, among the patients initially referred by an MS specialist, 7/25 were definitively diagnosed with MS, 5/25 had a genetic condition (e.g., X-linked adrenoleukodystrophy and hereditary small vessel diseases like Cerebral Autosomal Dominant Arteriopathy with Subcortical Infarcts and Leukoencephalopathy (CADASIL) and COL4A1-related disorder), and one had both MS and a genetic demyelinating neuropathy. Thanks to the WM Rounds collaborative efforts, the subjects who currently remain without a definite diagnosis, despite extensive investigations performed in the clinical setting, have been recruited in research studies aimed at identifying novel forms of genetic MS mimickers. CONCLUSIONS: The experience of the WM Rounds Network demonstrates the benefit of collective discussions on complex cases to increase the diagnostic rate and decrease misdiagnosis in patients with rare or atypical white matter diseases. Networks of this nature allow physicians and scientists to compare and share information on challenging cases from across the world, provide a basis for future multicenter research studies, and serve as model for other rare diseases. |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-9359417 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2022 |
publisher | Frontiers Media S.A. |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-93594172022-08-10 The White Matter Rounds experience: The importance of a multidisciplinary network to accelerate the diagnostic process for adult patients with rare white matter disorders Huang, Yu Tong Giacomini, Paul S. Massie, Rami Venkateswaran, Sunita Trudelle, Anne-Marie Fadda, Giulia Sharifian-Dorche, Maryam Boudjani, Hayet Poliquin-Lasnier, Laurence Airas, Laura Saveriano, Alexander W. Ziller, Matthias Georg Miller, Elka Martinez-Rios, Claudia Wilson, Nagwa Davila, Jorge Rush, Carolina Longbrake, Erin E. Longoni, Giulia Macaron, Gabrielle Bernard, Geneviève Tampieri, Donatella Antel, Jack Brais, Bernard La Piana, Roberta Front Neurol Neurology INTRODUCTION: Adult genetic leukoencephalopathies are rare neurological disorders that present unique diagnostic challenges due to their clinical and radiological overlap with more common white matter diseases, notably multiple sclerosis (MS). In this context, a strong collaborative multidisciplinary network is beneficial for shortening the diagnostic odyssey of these patients and preventing misdiagnosis. The White Matter Rounds (WM Rounds) are multidisciplinary international online meetings attended by more than 30 physicians and scientists from 15 participating sites that gather every month to discuss patients with atypical white matter disorders. We aim to present the experience of the WM Rounds Network and demonstrate the value of collaborative multidisciplinary international case discussion meetings in differentiating and preventing misdiagnoses between genetic white matter diseases and atypical MS. METHODS: We retrospectively reviewed the demographic, clinical and radiological data of all the subjects presented at the WM Rounds since their creation in 2013. RESULTS: Seventy-four patients (mean age 44.3) have been referred and discussed at the WM Rounds since 2013. Twenty-five (33.8%) of these patients were referred by an MS specialist for having an atypical presentation of MS, while in most of the remaining cases, the referring physician was a geneticist (23; 31.1%). Based on the WM Rounds recommendations, a definite diagnosis was made in 36/69 (52.2%) patients for which information was available for retrospective review. Of these diagnosed patients, 20 (55.6%) had a genetic disease, 8 (22.2%) had MS, 3 (8.3%) had both MS and a genetic disorder and 5 (13.9%) had other non-genetic conditions. Interestingly, among the patients initially referred by an MS specialist, 7/25 were definitively diagnosed with MS, 5/25 had a genetic condition (e.g., X-linked adrenoleukodystrophy and hereditary small vessel diseases like Cerebral Autosomal Dominant Arteriopathy with Subcortical Infarcts and Leukoencephalopathy (CADASIL) and COL4A1-related disorder), and one had both MS and a genetic demyelinating neuropathy. Thanks to the WM Rounds collaborative efforts, the subjects who currently remain without a definite diagnosis, despite extensive investigations performed in the clinical setting, have been recruited in research studies aimed at identifying novel forms of genetic MS mimickers. CONCLUSIONS: The experience of the WM Rounds Network demonstrates the benefit of collective discussions on complex cases to increase the diagnostic rate and decrease misdiagnosis in patients with rare or atypical white matter diseases. Networks of this nature allow physicians and scientists to compare and share information on challenging cases from across the world, provide a basis for future multicenter research studies, and serve as model for other rare diseases. Frontiers Media S.A. 2022-07-25 /pmc/articles/PMC9359417/ /pubmed/35959404 http://dx.doi.org/10.3389/fneur.2022.928493 Text en Copyright © 2022 Huang, Giacomini, Massie, Venkateswaran, Trudelle, Fadda, Sharifian-Dorche, Boudjani, Poliquin-Lasnier, Airas, Saveriano, Ziller, Miller, Martinez-Rios, Wilson, Davila, Rush, Longbrake, Longoni, Macaron, Bernard, Tampieri, Antel, Brais and La Piana. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY). The use, distribution or reproduction in other forums is permitted, provided the original author(s) and the copyright owner(s) are credited and that the original publication in this journal is cited, in accordance with accepted academic practice. No use, distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not comply with these terms. |
spellingShingle | Neurology Huang, Yu Tong Giacomini, Paul S. Massie, Rami Venkateswaran, Sunita Trudelle, Anne-Marie Fadda, Giulia Sharifian-Dorche, Maryam Boudjani, Hayet Poliquin-Lasnier, Laurence Airas, Laura Saveriano, Alexander W. Ziller, Matthias Georg Miller, Elka Martinez-Rios, Claudia Wilson, Nagwa Davila, Jorge Rush, Carolina Longbrake, Erin E. Longoni, Giulia Macaron, Gabrielle Bernard, Geneviève Tampieri, Donatella Antel, Jack Brais, Bernard La Piana, Roberta The White Matter Rounds experience: The importance of a multidisciplinary network to accelerate the diagnostic process for adult patients with rare white matter disorders |
title | The White Matter Rounds experience: The importance of a multidisciplinary network to accelerate the diagnostic process for adult patients with rare white matter disorders |
title_full | The White Matter Rounds experience: The importance of a multidisciplinary network to accelerate the diagnostic process for adult patients with rare white matter disorders |
title_fullStr | The White Matter Rounds experience: The importance of a multidisciplinary network to accelerate the diagnostic process for adult patients with rare white matter disorders |
title_full_unstemmed | The White Matter Rounds experience: The importance of a multidisciplinary network to accelerate the diagnostic process for adult patients with rare white matter disorders |
title_short | The White Matter Rounds experience: The importance of a multidisciplinary network to accelerate the diagnostic process for adult patients with rare white matter disorders |
title_sort | white matter rounds experience: the importance of a multidisciplinary network to accelerate the diagnostic process for adult patients with rare white matter disorders |
topic | Neurology |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9359417/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35959404 http://dx.doi.org/10.3389/fneur.2022.928493 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT huangyutong thewhitematterroundsexperiencetheimportanceofamultidisciplinarynetworktoacceleratethediagnosticprocessforadultpatientswithrarewhitematterdisorders AT giacominipauls thewhitematterroundsexperiencetheimportanceofamultidisciplinarynetworktoacceleratethediagnosticprocessforadultpatientswithrarewhitematterdisorders AT massierami thewhitematterroundsexperiencetheimportanceofamultidisciplinarynetworktoacceleratethediagnosticprocessforadultpatientswithrarewhitematterdisorders AT venkateswaransunita thewhitematterroundsexperiencetheimportanceofamultidisciplinarynetworktoacceleratethediagnosticprocessforadultpatientswithrarewhitematterdisorders AT trudelleannemarie thewhitematterroundsexperiencetheimportanceofamultidisciplinarynetworktoacceleratethediagnosticprocessforadultpatientswithrarewhitematterdisorders AT faddagiulia thewhitematterroundsexperiencetheimportanceofamultidisciplinarynetworktoacceleratethediagnosticprocessforadultpatientswithrarewhitematterdisorders AT sharifiandorchemaryam thewhitematterroundsexperiencetheimportanceofamultidisciplinarynetworktoacceleratethediagnosticprocessforadultpatientswithrarewhitematterdisorders AT boudjanihayet thewhitematterroundsexperiencetheimportanceofamultidisciplinarynetworktoacceleratethediagnosticprocessforadultpatientswithrarewhitematterdisorders AT poliquinlasnierlaurence thewhitematterroundsexperiencetheimportanceofamultidisciplinarynetworktoacceleratethediagnosticprocessforadultpatientswithrarewhitematterdisorders AT airaslaura thewhitematterroundsexperiencetheimportanceofamultidisciplinarynetworktoacceleratethediagnosticprocessforadultpatientswithrarewhitematterdisorders AT saverianoalexanderw thewhitematterroundsexperiencetheimportanceofamultidisciplinarynetworktoacceleratethediagnosticprocessforadultpatientswithrarewhitematterdisorders AT zillermatthiasgeorg thewhitematterroundsexperiencetheimportanceofamultidisciplinarynetworktoacceleratethediagnosticprocessforadultpatientswithrarewhitematterdisorders AT millerelka thewhitematterroundsexperiencetheimportanceofamultidisciplinarynetworktoacceleratethediagnosticprocessforadultpatientswithrarewhitematterdisorders AT martinezriosclaudia thewhitematterroundsexperiencetheimportanceofamultidisciplinarynetworktoacceleratethediagnosticprocessforadultpatientswithrarewhitematterdisorders AT wilsonnagwa thewhitematterroundsexperiencetheimportanceofamultidisciplinarynetworktoacceleratethediagnosticprocessforadultpatientswithrarewhitematterdisorders AT davilajorge thewhitematterroundsexperiencetheimportanceofamultidisciplinarynetworktoacceleratethediagnosticprocessforadultpatientswithrarewhitematterdisorders AT rushcarolina thewhitematterroundsexperiencetheimportanceofamultidisciplinarynetworktoacceleratethediagnosticprocessforadultpatientswithrarewhitematterdisorders AT longbrakeerine thewhitematterroundsexperiencetheimportanceofamultidisciplinarynetworktoacceleratethediagnosticprocessforadultpatientswithrarewhitematterdisorders AT longonigiulia thewhitematterroundsexperiencetheimportanceofamultidisciplinarynetworktoacceleratethediagnosticprocessforadultpatientswithrarewhitematterdisorders AT macarongabrielle thewhitematterroundsexperiencetheimportanceofamultidisciplinarynetworktoacceleratethediagnosticprocessforadultpatientswithrarewhitematterdisorders AT bernardgenevieve thewhitematterroundsexperiencetheimportanceofamultidisciplinarynetworktoacceleratethediagnosticprocessforadultpatientswithrarewhitematterdisorders AT tampieridonatella thewhitematterroundsexperiencetheimportanceofamultidisciplinarynetworktoacceleratethediagnosticprocessforadultpatientswithrarewhitematterdisorders AT anteljack thewhitematterroundsexperiencetheimportanceofamultidisciplinarynetworktoacceleratethediagnosticprocessforadultpatientswithrarewhitematterdisorders AT braisbernard thewhitematterroundsexperiencetheimportanceofamultidisciplinarynetworktoacceleratethediagnosticprocessforadultpatientswithrarewhitematterdisorders AT lapianaroberta thewhitematterroundsexperiencetheimportanceofamultidisciplinarynetworktoacceleratethediagnosticprocessforadultpatientswithrarewhitematterdisorders AT huangyutong whitematterroundsexperiencetheimportanceofamultidisciplinarynetworktoacceleratethediagnosticprocessforadultpatientswithrarewhitematterdisorders AT giacominipauls whitematterroundsexperiencetheimportanceofamultidisciplinarynetworktoacceleratethediagnosticprocessforadultpatientswithrarewhitematterdisorders AT massierami whitematterroundsexperiencetheimportanceofamultidisciplinarynetworktoacceleratethediagnosticprocessforadultpatientswithrarewhitematterdisorders AT venkateswaransunita whitematterroundsexperiencetheimportanceofamultidisciplinarynetworktoacceleratethediagnosticprocessforadultpatientswithrarewhitematterdisorders AT trudelleannemarie whitematterroundsexperiencetheimportanceofamultidisciplinarynetworktoacceleratethediagnosticprocessforadultpatientswithrarewhitematterdisorders AT faddagiulia whitematterroundsexperiencetheimportanceofamultidisciplinarynetworktoacceleratethediagnosticprocessforadultpatientswithrarewhitematterdisorders AT sharifiandorchemaryam whitematterroundsexperiencetheimportanceofamultidisciplinarynetworktoacceleratethediagnosticprocessforadultpatientswithrarewhitematterdisorders AT boudjanihayet whitematterroundsexperiencetheimportanceofamultidisciplinarynetworktoacceleratethediagnosticprocessforadultpatientswithrarewhitematterdisorders AT poliquinlasnierlaurence whitematterroundsexperiencetheimportanceofamultidisciplinarynetworktoacceleratethediagnosticprocessforadultpatientswithrarewhitematterdisorders AT airaslaura whitematterroundsexperiencetheimportanceofamultidisciplinarynetworktoacceleratethediagnosticprocessforadultpatientswithrarewhitematterdisorders AT saverianoalexanderw whitematterroundsexperiencetheimportanceofamultidisciplinarynetworktoacceleratethediagnosticprocessforadultpatientswithrarewhitematterdisorders AT zillermatthiasgeorg whitematterroundsexperiencetheimportanceofamultidisciplinarynetworktoacceleratethediagnosticprocessforadultpatientswithrarewhitematterdisorders AT millerelka whitematterroundsexperiencetheimportanceofamultidisciplinarynetworktoacceleratethediagnosticprocessforadultpatientswithrarewhitematterdisorders AT martinezriosclaudia whitematterroundsexperiencetheimportanceofamultidisciplinarynetworktoacceleratethediagnosticprocessforadultpatientswithrarewhitematterdisorders AT wilsonnagwa whitematterroundsexperiencetheimportanceofamultidisciplinarynetworktoacceleratethediagnosticprocessforadultpatientswithrarewhitematterdisorders AT davilajorge whitematterroundsexperiencetheimportanceofamultidisciplinarynetworktoacceleratethediagnosticprocessforadultpatientswithrarewhitematterdisorders AT rushcarolina whitematterroundsexperiencetheimportanceofamultidisciplinarynetworktoacceleratethediagnosticprocessforadultpatientswithrarewhitematterdisorders AT longbrakeerine whitematterroundsexperiencetheimportanceofamultidisciplinarynetworktoacceleratethediagnosticprocessforadultpatientswithrarewhitematterdisorders AT longonigiulia whitematterroundsexperiencetheimportanceofamultidisciplinarynetworktoacceleratethediagnosticprocessforadultpatientswithrarewhitematterdisorders AT macarongabrielle whitematterroundsexperiencetheimportanceofamultidisciplinarynetworktoacceleratethediagnosticprocessforadultpatientswithrarewhitematterdisorders AT bernardgenevieve whitematterroundsexperiencetheimportanceofamultidisciplinarynetworktoacceleratethediagnosticprocessforadultpatientswithrarewhitematterdisorders AT tampieridonatella whitematterroundsexperiencetheimportanceofamultidisciplinarynetworktoacceleratethediagnosticprocessforadultpatientswithrarewhitematterdisorders AT anteljack whitematterroundsexperiencetheimportanceofamultidisciplinarynetworktoacceleratethediagnosticprocessforadultpatientswithrarewhitematterdisorders AT braisbernard whitematterroundsexperiencetheimportanceofamultidisciplinarynetworktoacceleratethediagnosticprocessforadultpatientswithrarewhitematterdisorders AT lapianaroberta whitematterroundsexperiencetheimportanceofamultidisciplinarynetworktoacceleratethediagnosticprocessforadultpatientswithrarewhitematterdisorders |