Cargando…
A SARS-CoV-2 Negative Antigen Rapid Diagnostic in RT-qPCR Positive Samples Correlates With a Low Likelihood of Infectious Viruses in the Nasopharynx
Severe acute respiratory syndrome-related coronavirus (SARS-CoV-2) transmission occurs even among fully vaccinated individuals; thus, prompt identification of infected patients is central to control viral circulation. Antigen rapid diagnostic tests (Ag-RDTs) are highly specific, but sensitivity is v...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
Frontiers Media S.A.
2022
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9364907/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35966714 http://dx.doi.org/10.3389/fmicb.2022.912138 |
_version_ | 1784765237150351360 |
---|---|
author | Corrêa, Isadora Alonso Faffe, Débora Souza Galliez, Rafael Mello Gonçalves, Cássia Cristina Alves Maia, Richard Araújo da Silva, Gustavo Peixoto Moreira, Filipe Romero Rebello Mariani, Diana Campos, Mariana Freire Leitão, Isabela de Carvalho de Souza, Marcos Romário Cunha, Marcela Sabino Nascimento, Érica Ramos dos Santos Ribeiro, Liane de Jesus da Cruz, Thais Felix Cordeiro Policarpo, Cintia Gonzales, Luis Rodgers, Mary A. Berg, Michael Vijesurier, Roy Cloherty, Gavin A. Hackett, John Ferreira, Orlando da Costa Castiñeiras, Terezinha Marta Pereira Pinto Tanuri, Amilcar da Costa, Luciana Jesus |
author_facet | Corrêa, Isadora Alonso Faffe, Débora Souza Galliez, Rafael Mello Gonçalves, Cássia Cristina Alves Maia, Richard Araújo da Silva, Gustavo Peixoto Moreira, Filipe Romero Rebello Mariani, Diana Campos, Mariana Freire Leitão, Isabela de Carvalho de Souza, Marcos Romário Cunha, Marcela Sabino Nascimento, Érica Ramos dos Santos Ribeiro, Liane de Jesus da Cruz, Thais Felix Cordeiro Policarpo, Cintia Gonzales, Luis Rodgers, Mary A. Berg, Michael Vijesurier, Roy Cloherty, Gavin A. Hackett, John Ferreira, Orlando da Costa Castiñeiras, Terezinha Marta Pereira Pinto Tanuri, Amilcar da Costa, Luciana Jesus |
author_sort | Corrêa, Isadora Alonso |
collection | PubMed |
description | Severe acute respiratory syndrome-related coronavirus (SARS-CoV-2) transmission occurs even among fully vaccinated individuals; thus, prompt identification of infected patients is central to control viral circulation. Antigen rapid diagnostic tests (Ag-RDTs) are highly specific, but sensitivity is variable. Discordant RT-qPCR vs. Ag-RDT results are reported, raising the question of whether negative Ag-RDT in positive RT-qPCR samples could imply the absence of infectious viruses. To study the relationship between negative Ag-RDT results with virological, molecular, and serological parameters, we selected a cross-sectional and a follow-up dataset and analyzed virus culture, subgenomic RNA quantification, and sequencing to determine infectious viruses and mutations. We demonstrated that RT-qPCR positive while SARS-CoV-2 Ag-RDT negative discordant results correlate with the absence of infectious virus in nasopharyngeal samples. A decrease in sgRNA detection together with an expected increase in detectable anti-S and anti-N IgGs was also verified in these samples. The data clearly demonstrate that a negative Ag-RDT sample is less likely to harbor infectious SARS-CoV-2 and, consequently, has a lower transmissible potential. |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-9364907 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2022 |
publisher | Frontiers Media S.A. |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-93649072022-08-11 A SARS-CoV-2 Negative Antigen Rapid Diagnostic in RT-qPCR Positive Samples Correlates With a Low Likelihood of Infectious Viruses in the Nasopharynx Corrêa, Isadora Alonso Faffe, Débora Souza Galliez, Rafael Mello Gonçalves, Cássia Cristina Alves Maia, Richard Araújo da Silva, Gustavo Peixoto Moreira, Filipe Romero Rebello Mariani, Diana Campos, Mariana Freire Leitão, Isabela de Carvalho de Souza, Marcos Romário Cunha, Marcela Sabino Nascimento, Érica Ramos dos Santos Ribeiro, Liane de Jesus da Cruz, Thais Felix Cordeiro Policarpo, Cintia Gonzales, Luis Rodgers, Mary A. Berg, Michael Vijesurier, Roy Cloherty, Gavin A. Hackett, John Ferreira, Orlando da Costa Castiñeiras, Terezinha Marta Pereira Pinto Tanuri, Amilcar da Costa, Luciana Jesus Front Microbiol Microbiology Severe acute respiratory syndrome-related coronavirus (SARS-CoV-2) transmission occurs even among fully vaccinated individuals; thus, prompt identification of infected patients is central to control viral circulation. Antigen rapid diagnostic tests (Ag-RDTs) are highly specific, but sensitivity is variable. Discordant RT-qPCR vs. Ag-RDT results are reported, raising the question of whether negative Ag-RDT in positive RT-qPCR samples could imply the absence of infectious viruses. To study the relationship between negative Ag-RDT results with virological, molecular, and serological parameters, we selected a cross-sectional and a follow-up dataset and analyzed virus culture, subgenomic RNA quantification, and sequencing to determine infectious viruses and mutations. We demonstrated that RT-qPCR positive while SARS-CoV-2 Ag-RDT negative discordant results correlate with the absence of infectious virus in nasopharyngeal samples. A decrease in sgRNA detection together with an expected increase in detectable anti-S and anti-N IgGs was also verified in these samples. The data clearly demonstrate that a negative Ag-RDT sample is less likely to harbor infectious SARS-CoV-2 and, consequently, has a lower transmissible potential. Frontiers Media S.A. 2022-07-27 /pmc/articles/PMC9364907/ /pubmed/35966714 http://dx.doi.org/10.3389/fmicb.2022.912138 Text en Copyright © 2022 Corrêa, Faffe, Galliez, Gonçalves, Maia, da Silva, Moreira, Mariani, Campos, Leitão, de Souza, Cunha, Nascimento, Ribeiro, da Cruz, Policarpo, Gonzales, Rodgers, Berg, Vijesurier, Cloherty, Hackett Jr., Ferreira Jr., Castiñeiras, Tanuri and da Costa. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY). The use, distribution or reproduction in other forums is permitted, provided the original author(s) and the copyright owner(s) are credited and that the original publication in this journal is cited, in accordance with accepted academic practice. No use, distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not comply with these terms. |
spellingShingle | Microbiology Corrêa, Isadora Alonso Faffe, Débora Souza Galliez, Rafael Mello Gonçalves, Cássia Cristina Alves Maia, Richard Araújo da Silva, Gustavo Peixoto Moreira, Filipe Romero Rebello Mariani, Diana Campos, Mariana Freire Leitão, Isabela de Carvalho de Souza, Marcos Romário Cunha, Marcela Sabino Nascimento, Érica Ramos dos Santos Ribeiro, Liane de Jesus da Cruz, Thais Felix Cordeiro Policarpo, Cintia Gonzales, Luis Rodgers, Mary A. Berg, Michael Vijesurier, Roy Cloherty, Gavin A. Hackett, John Ferreira, Orlando da Costa Castiñeiras, Terezinha Marta Pereira Pinto Tanuri, Amilcar da Costa, Luciana Jesus A SARS-CoV-2 Negative Antigen Rapid Diagnostic in RT-qPCR Positive Samples Correlates With a Low Likelihood of Infectious Viruses in the Nasopharynx |
title | A SARS-CoV-2 Negative Antigen Rapid Diagnostic in RT-qPCR Positive Samples Correlates With a Low Likelihood of Infectious Viruses in the Nasopharynx |
title_full | A SARS-CoV-2 Negative Antigen Rapid Diagnostic in RT-qPCR Positive Samples Correlates With a Low Likelihood of Infectious Viruses in the Nasopharynx |
title_fullStr | A SARS-CoV-2 Negative Antigen Rapid Diagnostic in RT-qPCR Positive Samples Correlates With a Low Likelihood of Infectious Viruses in the Nasopharynx |
title_full_unstemmed | A SARS-CoV-2 Negative Antigen Rapid Diagnostic in RT-qPCR Positive Samples Correlates With a Low Likelihood of Infectious Viruses in the Nasopharynx |
title_short | A SARS-CoV-2 Negative Antigen Rapid Diagnostic in RT-qPCR Positive Samples Correlates With a Low Likelihood of Infectious Viruses in the Nasopharynx |
title_sort | sars-cov-2 negative antigen rapid diagnostic in rt-qpcr positive samples correlates with a low likelihood of infectious viruses in the nasopharynx |
topic | Microbiology |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9364907/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35966714 http://dx.doi.org/10.3389/fmicb.2022.912138 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT correaisadoraalonso asarscov2negativeantigenrapiddiagnosticinrtqpcrpositivesamplescorrelateswithalowlikelihoodofinfectiousvirusesinthenasopharynx AT faffedeborasouza asarscov2negativeantigenrapiddiagnosticinrtqpcrpositivesamplescorrelateswithalowlikelihoodofinfectiousvirusesinthenasopharynx AT galliezrafaelmello asarscov2negativeantigenrapiddiagnosticinrtqpcrpositivesamplescorrelateswithalowlikelihoodofinfectiousvirusesinthenasopharynx AT goncalvescassiacristinaalves asarscov2negativeantigenrapiddiagnosticinrtqpcrpositivesamplescorrelateswithalowlikelihoodofinfectiousvirusesinthenasopharynx AT maiarichardaraujo asarscov2negativeantigenrapiddiagnosticinrtqpcrpositivesamplescorrelateswithalowlikelihoodofinfectiousvirusesinthenasopharynx AT dasilvagustavopeixoto asarscov2negativeantigenrapiddiagnosticinrtqpcrpositivesamplescorrelateswithalowlikelihoodofinfectiousvirusesinthenasopharynx AT moreirafiliperomerorebello asarscov2negativeantigenrapiddiagnosticinrtqpcrpositivesamplescorrelateswithalowlikelihoodofinfectiousvirusesinthenasopharynx AT marianidiana asarscov2negativeantigenrapiddiagnosticinrtqpcrpositivesamplescorrelateswithalowlikelihoodofinfectiousvirusesinthenasopharynx AT camposmarianafreire asarscov2negativeantigenrapiddiagnosticinrtqpcrpositivesamplescorrelateswithalowlikelihoodofinfectiousvirusesinthenasopharynx AT leitaoisabeladecarvalho asarscov2negativeantigenrapiddiagnosticinrtqpcrpositivesamplescorrelateswithalowlikelihoodofinfectiousvirusesinthenasopharynx AT desouzamarcosromario asarscov2negativeantigenrapiddiagnosticinrtqpcrpositivesamplescorrelateswithalowlikelihoodofinfectiousvirusesinthenasopharynx AT cunhamarcelasabino asarscov2negativeantigenrapiddiagnosticinrtqpcrpositivesamplescorrelateswithalowlikelihoodofinfectiousvirusesinthenasopharynx AT nascimentoericaramosdossantos asarscov2negativeantigenrapiddiagnosticinrtqpcrpositivesamplescorrelateswithalowlikelihoodofinfectiousvirusesinthenasopharynx AT ribeirolianedejesus asarscov2negativeantigenrapiddiagnosticinrtqpcrpositivesamplescorrelateswithalowlikelihoodofinfectiousvirusesinthenasopharynx AT dacruzthaisfelixcordeiro asarscov2negativeantigenrapiddiagnosticinrtqpcrpositivesamplescorrelateswithalowlikelihoodofinfectiousvirusesinthenasopharynx AT policarpocintia asarscov2negativeantigenrapiddiagnosticinrtqpcrpositivesamplescorrelateswithalowlikelihoodofinfectiousvirusesinthenasopharynx AT gonzalesluis asarscov2negativeantigenrapiddiagnosticinrtqpcrpositivesamplescorrelateswithalowlikelihoodofinfectiousvirusesinthenasopharynx AT rodgersmarya asarscov2negativeantigenrapiddiagnosticinrtqpcrpositivesamplescorrelateswithalowlikelihoodofinfectiousvirusesinthenasopharynx AT bergmichael asarscov2negativeantigenrapiddiagnosticinrtqpcrpositivesamplescorrelateswithalowlikelihoodofinfectiousvirusesinthenasopharynx AT vijesurierroy asarscov2negativeantigenrapiddiagnosticinrtqpcrpositivesamplescorrelateswithalowlikelihoodofinfectiousvirusesinthenasopharynx AT clohertygavina asarscov2negativeantigenrapiddiagnosticinrtqpcrpositivesamplescorrelateswithalowlikelihoodofinfectiousvirusesinthenasopharynx AT hackettjohn asarscov2negativeantigenrapiddiagnosticinrtqpcrpositivesamplescorrelateswithalowlikelihoodofinfectiousvirusesinthenasopharynx AT ferreiraorlandodacosta asarscov2negativeantigenrapiddiagnosticinrtqpcrpositivesamplescorrelateswithalowlikelihoodofinfectiousvirusesinthenasopharynx AT castineirasterezinhamartapereirapinto asarscov2negativeantigenrapiddiagnosticinrtqpcrpositivesamplescorrelateswithalowlikelihoodofinfectiousvirusesinthenasopharynx AT tanuriamilcar asarscov2negativeantigenrapiddiagnosticinrtqpcrpositivesamplescorrelateswithalowlikelihoodofinfectiousvirusesinthenasopharynx AT dacostalucianajesus asarscov2negativeantigenrapiddiagnosticinrtqpcrpositivesamplescorrelateswithalowlikelihoodofinfectiousvirusesinthenasopharynx AT correaisadoraalonso sarscov2negativeantigenrapiddiagnosticinrtqpcrpositivesamplescorrelateswithalowlikelihoodofinfectiousvirusesinthenasopharynx AT faffedeborasouza sarscov2negativeantigenrapiddiagnosticinrtqpcrpositivesamplescorrelateswithalowlikelihoodofinfectiousvirusesinthenasopharynx AT galliezrafaelmello sarscov2negativeantigenrapiddiagnosticinrtqpcrpositivesamplescorrelateswithalowlikelihoodofinfectiousvirusesinthenasopharynx AT goncalvescassiacristinaalves sarscov2negativeantigenrapiddiagnosticinrtqpcrpositivesamplescorrelateswithalowlikelihoodofinfectiousvirusesinthenasopharynx AT maiarichardaraujo sarscov2negativeantigenrapiddiagnosticinrtqpcrpositivesamplescorrelateswithalowlikelihoodofinfectiousvirusesinthenasopharynx AT dasilvagustavopeixoto sarscov2negativeantigenrapiddiagnosticinrtqpcrpositivesamplescorrelateswithalowlikelihoodofinfectiousvirusesinthenasopharynx AT moreirafiliperomerorebello sarscov2negativeantigenrapiddiagnosticinrtqpcrpositivesamplescorrelateswithalowlikelihoodofinfectiousvirusesinthenasopharynx AT marianidiana sarscov2negativeantigenrapiddiagnosticinrtqpcrpositivesamplescorrelateswithalowlikelihoodofinfectiousvirusesinthenasopharynx AT camposmarianafreire sarscov2negativeantigenrapiddiagnosticinrtqpcrpositivesamplescorrelateswithalowlikelihoodofinfectiousvirusesinthenasopharynx AT leitaoisabeladecarvalho sarscov2negativeantigenrapiddiagnosticinrtqpcrpositivesamplescorrelateswithalowlikelihoodofinfectiousvirusesinthenasopharynx AT desouzamarcosromario sarscov2negativeantigenrapiddiagnosticinrtqpcrpositivesamplescorrelateswithalowlikelihoodofinfectiousvirusesinthenasopharynx AT cunhamarcelasabino sarscov2negativeantigenrapiddiagnosticinrtqpcrpositivesamplescorrelateswithalowlikelihoodofinfectiousvirusesinthenasopharynx AT nascimentoericaramosdossantos sarscov2negativeantigenrapiddiagnosticinrtqpcrpositivesamplescorrelateswithalowlikelihoodofinfectiousvirusesinthenasopharynx AT ribeirolianedejesus sarscov2negativeantigenrapiddiagnosticinrtqpcrpositivesamplescorrelateswithalowlikelihoodofinfectiousvirusesinthenasopharynx AT dacruzthaisfelixcordeiro sarscov2negativeantigenrapiddiagnosticinrtqpcrpositivesamplescorrelateswithalowlikelihoodofinfectiousvirusesinthenasopharynx AT policarpocintia sarscov2negativeantigenrapiddiagnosticinrtqpcrpositivesamplescorrelateswithalowlikelihoodofinfectiousvirusesinthenasopharynx AT gonzalesluis sarscov2negativeantigenrapiddiagnosticinrtqpcrpositivesamplescorrelateswithalowlikelihoodofinfectiousvirusesinthenasopharynx AT rodgersmarya sarscov2negativeantigenrapiddiagnosticinrtqpcrpositivesamplescorrelateswithalowlikelihoodofinfectiousvirusesinthenasopharynx AT bergmichael sarscov2negativeantigenrapiddiagnosticinrtqpcrpositivesamplescorrelateswithalowlikelihoodofinfectiousvirusesinthenasopharynx AT vijesurierroy sarscov2negativeantigenrapiddiagnosticinrtqpcrpositivesamplescorrelateswithalowlikelihoodofinfectiousvirusesinthenasopharynx AT clohertygavina sarscov2negativeantigenrapiddiagnosticinrtqpcrpositivesamplescorrelateswithalowlikelihoodofinfectiousvirusesinthenasopharynx AT hackettjohn sarscov2negativeantigenrapiddiagnosticinrtqpcrpositivesamplescorrelateswithalowlikelihoodofinfectiousvirusesinthenasopharynx AT ferreiraorlandodacosta sarscov2negativeantigenrapiddiagnosticinrtqpcrpositivesamplescorrelateswithalowlikelihoodofinfectiousvirusesinthenasopharynx AT castineirasterezinhamartapereirapinto sarscov2negativeantigenrapiddiagnosticinrtqpcrpositivesamplescorrelateswithalowlikelihoodofinfectiousvirusesinthenasopharynx AT tanuriamilcar sarscov2negativeantigenrapiddiagnosticinrtqpcrpositivesamplescorrelateswithalowlikelihoodofinfectiousvirusesinthenasopharynx AT dacostalucianajesus sarscov2negativeantigenrapiddiagnosticinrtqpcrpositivesamplescorrelateswithalowlikelihoodofinfectiousvirusesinthenasopharynx |