Cargando…

A Questionnaire-Based Ensemble Learning Model to Predict the Diagnosis of Vertigo: Model Development and Validation Study

BACKGROUND: Questionnaires have been used in the past 2 decades to predict the diagnosis of vertigo and assist clinical decision-making. A questionnaire-based machine learning model is expected to improve the efficiency of diagnosis of vestibular disorders. OBJECTIVE: This study aims to develop and...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Yu, Fangzhou, Wu, Peixia, Deng, Haowen, Wu, Jingfang, Sun, Shan, Yu, Huiqian, Yang, Jianming, Luo, Xianyang, He, Jing, Ma, Xiulan, Wen, Junxiong, Qiu, Danhong, Nie, Guohui, Liu, Rizhao, Hu, Guohua, Chen, Tao, Zhang, Cheng, Li, Huawei
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: JMIR Publications 2022
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9386585/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35921135
http://dx.doi.org/10.2196/34126
_version_ 1784769846061301760
author Yu, Fangzhou
Wu, Peixia
Deng, Haowen
Wu, Jingfang
Sun, Shan
Yu, Huiqian
Yang, Jianming
Luo, Xianyang
He, Jing
Ma, Xiulan
Wen, Junxiong
Qiu, Danhong
Nie, Guohui
Liu, Rizhao
Hu, Guohua
Chen, Tao
Zhang, Cheng
Li, Huawei
author_facet Yu, Fangzhou
Wu, Peixia
Deng, Haowen
Wu, Jingfang
Sun, Shan
Yu, Huiqian
Yang, Jianming
Luo, Xianyang
He, Jing
Ma, Xiulan
Wen, Junxiong
Qiu, Danhong
Nie, Guohui
Liu, Rizhao
Hu, Guohua
Chen, Tao
Zhang, Cheng
Li, Huawei
author_sort Yu, Fangzhou
collection PubMed
description BACKGROUND: Questionnaires have been used in the past 2 decades to predict the diagnosis of vertigo and assist clinical decision-making. A questionnaire-based machine learning model is expected to improve the efficiency of diagnosis of vestibular disorders. OBJECTIVE: This study aims to develop and validate a questionnaire-based machine learning model that predicts the diagnosis of vertigo. METHODS: In this multicenter prospective study, patients presenting with vertigo entered a consecutive cohort at their first visit to the ENT and vertigo clinics of 7 tertiary referral centers from August 2019 to March 2021, with a follow-up period of 2 months. All participants completed a diagnostic questionnaire after eligibility screening. Patients who received only 1 final diagnosis by their treating specialists for their primary complaint were included in model development and validation. The data of patients enrolled before February 1, 2021 were used for modeling and cross-validation, while patients enrolled afterward entered external validation. RESULTS: A total of 1693 patients were enrolled, with a response rate of 96.2% (1693/1760). The median age was 51 (IQR 38-61) years, with 991 (58.5%) females; 1041 (61.5%) patients received the final diagnosis during the study period. Among them, 928 (54.8%) patients were included in model development and validation, and 113 (6.7%) patients who enrolled later were used as a test set for external validation. They were classified into 5 diagnostic categories. We compared 9 candidate machine learning methods, and the recalibrated model of light gradient boosting machine achieved the best performance, with an area under the curve of 0.937 (95% CI 0.917-0.962) in cross-validation and 0.954 (95% CI 0.944-0.967) in external validation. CONCLUSIONS: The questionnaire-based light gradient boosting machine was able to predict common vestibular disorders and assist decision-making in ENT and vertigo clinics. Further studies with a larger sample size and the participation of neurologists will help assess the generalization and robustness of this machine learning method.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-9386585
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2022
publisher JMIR Publications
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-93865852022-08-19 A Questionnaire-Based Ensemble Learning Model to Predict the Diagnosis of Vertigo: Model Development and Validation Study Yu, Fangzhou Wu, Peixia Deng, Haowen Wu, Jingfang Sun, Shan Yu, Huiqian Yang, Jianming Luo, Xianyang He, Jing Ma, Xiulan Wen, Junxiong Qiu, Danhong Nie, Guohui Liu, Rizhao Hu, Guohua Chen, Tao Zhang, Cheng Li, Huawei J Med Internet Res Original Paper BACKGROUND: Questionnaires have been used in the past 2 decades to predict the diagnosis of vertigo and assist clinical decision-making. A questionnaire-based machine learning model is expected to improve the efficiency of diagnosis of vestibular disorders. OBJECTIVE: This study aims to develop and validate a questionnaire-based machine learning model that predicts the diagnosis of vertigo. METHODS: In this multicenter prospective study, patients presenting with vertigo entered a consecutive cohort at their first visit to the ENT and vertigo clinics of 7 tertiary referral centers from August 2019 to March 2021, with a follow-up period of 2 months. All participants completed a diagnostic questionnaire after eligibility screening. Patients who received only 1 final diagnosis by their treating specialists for their primary complaint were included in model development and validation. The data of patients enrolled before February 1, 2021 were used for modeling and cross-validation, while patients enrolled afterward entered external validation. RESULTS: A total of 1693 patients were enrolled, with a response rate of 96.2% (1693/1760). The median age was 51 (IQR 38-61) years, with 991 (58.5%) females; 1041 (61.5%) patients received the final diagnosis during the study period. Among them, 928 (54.8%) patients were included in model development and validation, and 113 (6.7%) patients who enrolled later were used as a test set for external validation. They were classified into 5 diagnostic categories. We compared 9 candidate machine learning methods, and the recalibrated model of light gradient boosting machine achieved the best performance, with an area under the curve of 0.937 (95% CI 0.917-0.962) in cross-validation and 0.954 (95% CI 0.944-0.967) in external validation. CONCLUSIONS: The questionnaire-based light gradient boosting machine was able to predict common vestibular disorders and assist decision-making in ENT and vertigo clinics. Further studies with a larger sample size and the participation of neurologists will help assess the generalization and robustness of this machine learning method. JMIR Publications 2022-08-03 /pmc/articles/PMC9386585/ /pubmed/35921135 http://dx.doi.org/10.2196/34126 Text en ©Fangzhou Yu, Peixia Wu, Haowen Deng, Jingfang Wu, Shan Sun, Huiqian Yu, Jianming Yang, Xianyang Luo, Jing He, Xiulan Ma, Junxiong Wen, Danhong Qiu, Guohui Nie, Rizhao Liu, Guohua Hu, Tao Chen, Cheng Zhang, Huawei Li. Originally published in the Journal of Medical Internet Research (https://www.jmir.org), 03.08.2022. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work, first published in the Journal of Medical Internet Research, is properly cited. The complete bibliographic information, a link to the original publication on https://www.jmir.org/, as well as this copyright and license information must be included.
spellingShingle Original Paper
Yu, Fangzhou
Wu, Peixia
Deng, Haowen
Wu, Jingfang
Sun, Shan
Yu, Huiqian
Yang, Jianming
Luo, Xianyang
He, Jing
Ma, Xiulan
Wen, Junxiong
Qiu, Danhong
Nie, Guohui
Liu, Rizhao
Hu, Guohua
Chen, Tao
Zhang, Cheng
Li, Huawei
A Questionnaire-Based Ensemble Learning Model to Predict the Diagnosis of Vertigo: Model Development and Validation Study
title A Questionnaire-Based Ensemble Learning Model to Predict the Diagnosis of Vertigo: Model Development and Validation Study
title_full A Questionnaire-Based Ensemble Learning Model to Predict the Diagnosis of Vertigo: Model Development and Validation Study
title_fullStr A Questionnaire-Based Ensemble Learning Model to Predict the Diagnosis of Vertigo: Model Development and Validation Study
title_full_unstemmed A Questionnaire-Based Ensemble Learning Model to Predict the Diagnosis of Vertigo: Model Development and Validation Study
title_short A Questionnaire-Based Ensemble Learning Model to Predict the Diagnosis of Vertigo: Model Development and Validation Study
title_sort questionnaire-based ensemble learning model to predict the diagnosis of vertigo: model development and validation study
topic Original Paper
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9386585/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35921135
http://dx.doi.org/10.2196/34126
work_keys_str_mv AT yufangzhou aquestionnairebasedensemblelearningmodeltopredictthediagnosisofvertigomodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT wupeixia aquestionnairebasedensemblelearningmodeltopredictthediagnosisofvertigomodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT denghaowen aquestionnairebasedensemblelearningmodeltopredictthediagnosisofvertigomodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT wujingfang aquestionnairebasedensemblelearningmodeltopredictthediagnosisofvertigomodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT sunshan aquestionnairebasedensemblelearningmodeltopredictthediagnosisofvertigomodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT yuhuiqian aquestionnairebasedensemblelearningmodeltopredictthediagnosisofvertigomodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT yangjianming aquestionnairebasedensemblelearningmodeltopredictthediagnosisofvertigomodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT luoxianyang aquestionnairebasedensemblelearningmodeltopredictthediagnosisofvertigomodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT hejing aquestionnairebasedensemblelearningmodeltopredictthediagnosisofvertigomodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT maxiulan aquestionnairebasedensemblelearningmodeltopredictthediagnosisofvertigomodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT wenjunxiong aquestionnairebasedensemblelearningmodeltopredictthediagnosisofvertigomodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT qiudanhong aquestionnairebasedensemblelearningmodeltopredictthediagnosisofvertigomodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT nieguohui aquestionnairebasedensemblelearningmodeltopredictthediagnosisofvertigomodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT liurizhao aquestionnairebasedensemblelearningmodeltopredictthediagnosisofvertigomodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT huguohua aquestionnairebasedensemblelearningmodeltopredictthediagnosisofvertigomodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT chentao aquestionnairebasedensemblelearningmodeltopredictthediagnosisofvertigomodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT zhangcheng aquestionnairebasedensemblelearningmodeltopredictthediagnosisofvertigomodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT lihuawei aquestionnairebasedensemblelearningmodeltopredictthediagnosisofvertigomodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT yufangzhou questionnairebasedensemblelearningmodeltopredictthediagnosisofvertigomodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT wupeixia questionnairebasedensemblelearningmodeltopredictthediagnosisofvertigomodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT denghaowen questionnairebasedensemblelearningmodeltopredictthediagnosisofvertigomodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT wujingfang questionnairebasedensemblelearningmodeltopredictthediagnosisofvertigomodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT sunshan questionnairebasedensemblelearningmodeltopredictthediagnosisofvertigomodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT yuhuiqian questionnairebasedensemblelearningmodeltopredictthediagnosisofvertigomodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT yangjianming questionnairebasedensemblelearningmodeltopredictthediagnosisofvertigomodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT luoxianyang questionnairebasedensemblelearningmodeltopredictthediagnosisofvertigomodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT hejing questionnairebasedensemblelearningmodeltopredictthediagnosisofvertigomodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT maxiulan questionnairebasedensemblelearningmodeltopredictthediagnosisofvertigomodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT wenjunxiong questionnairebasedensemblelearningmodeltopredictthediagnosisofvertigomodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT qiudanhong questionnairebasedensemblelearningmodeltopredictthediagnosisofvertigomodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT nieguohui questionnairebasedensemblelearningmodeltopredictthediagnosisofvertigomodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT liurizhao questionnairebasedensemblelearningmodeltopredictthediagnosisofvertigomodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT huguohua questionnairebasedensemblelearningmodeltopredictthediagnosisofvertigomodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT chentao questionnairebasedensemblelearningmodeltopredictthediagnosisofvertigomodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT zhangcheng questionnairebasedensemblelearningmodeltopredictthediagnosisofvertigomodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT lihuawei questionnairebasedensemblelearningmodeltopredictthediagnosisofvertigomodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy