Cargando…

Recording of ’COVID-19 vaccine declined‘: a cohort study on 57.9 million National Health Service patients’ records in situ using OpenSAFELY, England, 8 December 2020 to 25 May 2021

BACKGROUND: Priority patients in England were offered COVID-19 vaccination by mid-April 2021. Codes in clinical record systems can denote the vaccine being declined. AIM: We describe records of COVID-19 vaccines being declined, according to clinical and demographic factors. METHODS: With the approva...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Curtis, Helen J, Inglesby, Peter, MacKenna, Brian, Croker, Richard, Hulme, William J, Rentsch, Christopher T, Bhaskaran, Krishnan, Mathur, Rohini, Morton, Caroline E, Bacon, Sebastian CJ, Smith, Rebecca M, Evans, David, Mehrkar, Amir, Tomlinson, Laurie, Walker, Alex J, Bates, Christopher, Hickman, George, Ward, Tom, Morley, Jessica, Cockburn, Jonathan, Davy, Simon, Williamson, Elizabeth J, Eggo, Rosalind M, Parry, John, Hester, Frank, Harper, Sam, O’Hanlon, Shaun, Eavis, Alex, Jarvis, Richard, Avramov, Dima, Griffiths, Paul, Fowles, Aaron, Parkes, Nasreen, Evans, Stephen JW, Douglas, Ian J, Smeeth, Liam, Goldacre, Ben
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control (ECDC) 2022
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9389857/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35983770
http://dx.doi.org/10.2807/1560-7917.ES.2022.27.33.2100885
_version_ 1784770546877071360
author Curtis, Helen J
Inglesby, Peter
MacKenna, Brian
Croker, Richard
Hulme, William J
Rentsch, Christopher T
Bhaskaran, Krishnan
Mathur, Rohini
Morton, Caroline E
Bacon, Sebastian CJ
Smith, Rebecca M
Evans, David
Mehrkar, Amir
Tomlinson, Laurie
Walker, Alex J
Bates, Christopher
Hickman, George
Ward, Tom
Morley, Jessica
Cockburn, Jonathan
Davy, Simon
Williamson, Elizabeth J
Eggo, Rosalind M
Parry, John
Hester, Frank
Harper, Sam
O’Hanlon, Shaun
Eavis, Alex
Jarvis, Richard
Avramov, Dima
Griffiths, Paul
Fowles, Aaron
Parkes, Nasreen
Evans, Stephen JW
Douglas, Ian J
Smeeth, Liam
Goldacre, Ben
author_facet Curtis, Helen J
Inglesby, Peter
MacKenna, Brian
Croker, Richard
Hulme, William J
Rentsch, Christopher T
Bhaskaran, Krishnan
Mathur, Rohini
Morton, Caroline E
Bacon, Sebastian CJ
Smith, Rebecca M
Evans, David
Mehrkar, Amir
Tomlinson, Laurie
Walker, Alex J
Bates, Christopher
Hickman, George
Ward, Tom
Morley, Jessica
Cockburn, Jonathan
Davy, Simon
Williamson, Elizabeth J
Eggo, Rosalind M
Parry, John
Hester, Frank
Harper, Sam
O’Hanlon, Shaun
Eavis, Alex
Jarvis, Richard
Avramov, Dima
Griffiths, Paul
Fowles, Aaron
Parkes, Nasreen
Evans, Stephen JW
Douglas, Ian J
Smeeth, Liam
Goldacre, Ben
author_sort Curtis, Helen J
collection PubMed
description BACKGROUND: Priority patients in England were offered COVID-19 vaccination by mid-April 2021. Codes in clinical record systems can denote the vaccine being declined. AIM: We describe records of COVID-19 vaccines being declined, according to clinical and demographic factors. METHODS: With the approval of NHS England, we conducted a retrospective cohort study between 8 December 2020 and 25 May 2021 with primary care records for 57.9 million patients using OpenSAFELY, a secure health analytics platform. COVID-19 vaccination priority patients were those aged ≥ 50 years or ≥ 16 years clinically extremely vulnerable (CEV) or ’at risk’. We describe the proportion recorded as declining vaccination for each group and stratified by clinical and demographic subgroups, subsequent vaccination and distribution of clinical code usage across general practices. RESULTS: Of 24.5 million priority patients, 663,033 (2.7%) had a decline recorded, while 2,155,076 (8.8%) had neither a vaccine nor decline recorded. Those recorded as declining, who were subsequently vaccinated (n = 125,587; 18.9%) were overrepresented in the South Asian population (32.3% vs 22.8% for other ethnicities aged ≥ 65 years). The proportion of declining unvaccinated patients was highest in CEV (3.3%), varied strongly with ethnicity (black 15.3%, South Asian 5.6%, white 1.5% for ≥ 80 years) and correlated positively with increasing deprivation. CONCLUSIONS: Clinical codes indicative of COVID-19 vaccinations being declined are commonly used in England, but substantially more common among black and South Asian people, and in more deprived areas. Qualitative research is needed to determine typical reasons for recorded declines, including to what extent they reflect patients actively declining.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-9389857
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2022
publisher European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control (ECDC)
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-93898572022-09-13 Recording of ’COVID-19 vaccine declined‘: a cohort study on 57.9 million National Health Service patients’ records in situ using OpenSAFELY, England, 8 December 2020 to 25 May 2021 Curtis, Helen J Inglesby, Peter MacKenna, Brian Croker, Richard Hulme, William J Rentsch, Christopher T Bhaskaran, Krishnan Mathur, Rohini Morton, Caroline E Bacon, Sebastian CJ Smith, Rebecca M Evans, David Mehrkar, Amir Tomlinson, Laurie Walker, Alex J Bates, Christopher Hickman, George Ward, Tom Morley, Jessica Cockburn, Jonathan Davy, Simon Williamson, Elizabeth J Eggo, Rosalind M Parry, John Hester, Frank Harper, Sam O’Hanlon, Shaun Eavis, Alex Jarvis, Richard Avramov, Dima Griffiths, Paul Fowles, Aaron Parkes, Nasreen Evans, Stephen JW Douglas, Ian J Smeeth, Liam Goldacre, Ben Euro Surveill Research BACKGROUND: Priority patients in England were offered COVID-19 vaccination by mid-April 2021. Codes in clinical record systems can denote the vaccine being declined. AIM: We describe records of COVID-19 vaccines being declined, according to clinical and demographic factors. METHODS: With the approval of NHS England, we conducted a retrospective cohort study between 8 December 2020 and 25 May 2021 with primary care records for 57.9 million patients using OpenSAFELY, a secure health analytics platform. COVID-19 vaccination priority patients were those aged ≥ 50 years or ≥ 16 years clinically extremely vulnerable (CEV) or ’at risk’. We describe the proportion recorded as declining vaccination for each group and stratified by clinical and demographic subgroups, subsequent vaccination and distribution of clinical code usage across general practices. RESULTS: Of 24.5 million priority patients, 663,033 (2.7%) had a decline recorded, while 2,155,076 (8.8%) had neither a vaccine nor decline recorded. Those recorded as declining, who were subsequently vaccinated (n = 125,587; 18.9%) were overrepresented in the South Asian population (32.3% vs 22.8% for other ethnicities aged ≥ 65 years). The proportion of declining unvaccinated patients was highest in CEV (3.3%), varied strongly with ethnicity (black 15.3%, South Asian 5.6%, white 1.5% for ≥ 80 years) and correlated positively with increasing deprivation. CONCLUSIONS: Clinical codes indicative of COVID-19 vaccinations being declined are commonly used in England, but substantially more common among black and South Asian people, and in more deprived areas. Qualitative research is needed to determine typical reasons for recorded declines, including to what extent they reflect patients actively declining. European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control (ECDC) 2022-08-18 /pmc/articles/PMC9389857/ /pubmed/35983770 http://dx.doi.org/10.2807/1560-7917.ES.2022.27.33.2100885 Text en This article is copyright of the authors or their affiliated institutions, 2022. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY 4.0) Licence. You may share and adapt the material, but must give appropriate credit to the source, provide a link to the licence, and indicate if changes were made.
spellingShingle Research
Curtis, Helen J
Inglesby, Peter
MacKenna, Brian
Croker, Richard
Hulme, William J
Rentsch, Christopher T
Bhaskaran, Krishnan
Mathur, Rohini
Morton, Caroline E
Bacon, Sebastian CJ
Smith, Rebecca M
Evans, David
Mehrkar, Amir
Tomlinson, Laurie
Walker, Alex J
Bates, Christopher
Hickman, George
Ward, Tom
Morley, Jessica
Cockburn, Jonathan
Davy, Simon
Williamson, Elizabeth J
Eggo, Rosalind M
Parry, John
Hester, Frank
Harper, Sam
O’Hanlon, Shaun
Eavis, Alex
Jarvis, Richard
Avramov, Dima
Griffiths, Paul
Fowles, Aaron
Parkes, Nasreen
Evans, Stephen JW
Douglas, Ian J
Smeeth, Liam
Goldacre, Ben
Recording of ’COVID-19 vaccine declined‘: a cohort study on 57.9 million National Health Service patients’ records in situ using OpenSAFELY, England, 8 December 2020 to 25 May 2021
title Recording of ’COVID-19 vaccine declined‘: a cohort study on 57.9 million National Health Service patients’ records in situ using OpenSAFELY, England, 8 December 2020 to 25 May 2021
title_full Recording of ’COVID-19 vaccine declined‘: a cohort study on 57.9 million National Health Service patients’ records in situ using OpenSAFELY, England, 8 December 2020 to 25 May 2021
title_fullStr Recording of ’COVID-19 vaccine declined‘: a cohort study on 57.9 million National Health Service patients’ records in situ using OpenSAFELY, England, 8 December 2020 to 25 May 2021
title_full_unstemmed Recording of ’COVID-19 vaccine declined‘: a cohort study on 57.9 million National Health Service patients’ records in situ using OpenSAFELY, England, 8 December 2020 to 25 May 2021
title_short Recording of ’COVID-19 vaccine declined‘: a cohort study on 57.9 million National Health Service patients’ records in situ using OpenSAFELY, England, 8 December 2020 to 25 May 2021
title_sort recording of ’covid-19 vaccine declined‘: a cohort study on 57.9 million national health service patients’ records in situ using opensafely, england, 8 december 2020 to 25 may 2021
topic Research
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9389857/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35983770
http://dx.doi.org/10.2807/1560-7917.ES.2022.27.33.2100885
work_keys_str_mv AT curtishelenj recordingofcovid19vaccinedeclinedacohortstudyon579millionnationalhealthservicepatientsrecordsinsituusingopensafelyengland8december2020to25may2021
AT inglesbypeter recordingofcovid19vaccinedeclinedacohortstudyon579millionnationalhealthservicepatientsrecordsinsituusingopensafelyengland8december2020to25may2021
AT mackennabrian recordingofcovid19vaccinedeclinedacohortstudyon579millionnationalhealthservicepatientsrecordsinsituusingopensafelyengland8december2020to25may2021
AT crokerrichard recordingofcovid19vaccinedeclinedacohortstudyon579millionnationalhealthservicepatientsrecordsinsituusingopensafelyengland8december2020to25may2021
AT hulmewilliamj recordingofcovid19vaccinedeclinedacohortstudyon579millionnationalhealthservicepatientsrecordsinsituusingopensafelyengland8december2020to25may2021
AT rentschchristophert recordingofcovid19vaccinedeclinedacohortstudyon579millionnationalhealthservicepatientsrecordsinsituusingopensafelyengland8december2020to25may2021
AT bhaskarankrishnan recordingofcovid19vaccinedeclinedacohortstudyon579millionnationalhealthservicepatientsrecordsinsituusingopensafelyengland8december2020to25may2021
AT mathurrohini recordingofcovid19vaccinedeclinedacohortstudyon579millionnationalhealthservicepatientsrecordsinsituusingopensafelyengland8december2020to25may2021
AT mortoncarolinee recordingofcovid19vaccinedeclinedacohortstudyon579millionnationalhealthservicepatientsrecordsinsituusingopensafelyengland8december2020to25may2021
AT baconsebastiancj recordingofcovid19vaccinedeclinedacohortstudyon579millionnationalhealthservicepatientsrecordsinsituusingopensafelyengland8december2020to25may2021
AT smithrebeccam recordingofcovid19vaccinedeclinedacohortstudyon579millionnationalhealthservicepatientsrecordsinsituusingopensafelyengland8december2020to25may2021
AT evansdavid recordingofcovid19vaccinedeclinedacohortstudyon579millionnationalhealthservicepatientsrecordsinsituusingopensafelyengland8december2020to25may2021
AT mehrkaramir recordingofcovid19vaccinedeclinedacohortstudyon579millionnationalhealthservicepatientsrecordsinsituusingopensafelyengland8december2020to25may2021
AT tomlinsonlaurie recordingofcovid19vaccinedeclinedacohortstudyon579millionnationalhealthservicepatientsrecordsinsituusingopensafelyengland8december2020to25may2021
AT walkeralexj recordingofcovid19vaccinedeclinedacohortstudyon579millionnationalhealthservicepatientsrecordsinsituusingopensafelyengland8december2020to25may2021
AT bateschristopher recordingofcovid19vaccinedeclinedacohortstudyon579millionnationalhealthservicepatientsrecordsinsituusingopensafelyengland8december2020to25may2021
AT hickmangeorge recordingofcovid19vaccinedeclinedacohortstudyon579millionnationalhealthservicepatientsrecordsinsituusingopensafelyengland8december2020to25may2021
AT wardtom recordingofcovid19vaccinedeclinedacohortstudyon579millionnationalhealthservicepatientsrecordsinsituusingopensafelyengland8december2020to25may2021
AT morleyjessica recordingofcovid19vaccinedeclinedacohortstudyon579millionnationalhealthservicepatientsrecordsinsituusingopensafelyengland8december2020to25may2021
AT cockburnjonathan recordingofcovid19vaccinedeclinedacohortstudyon579millionnationalhealthservicepatientsrecordsinsituusingopensafelyengland8december2020to25may2021
AT davysimon recordingofcovid19vaccinedeclinedacohortstudyon579millionnationalhealthservicepatientsrecordsinsituusingopensafelyengland8december2020to25may2021
AT williamsonelizabethj recordingofcovid19vaccinedeclinedacohortstudyon579millionnationalhealthservicepatientsrecordsinsituusingopensafelyengland8december2020to25may2021
AT eggorosalindm recordingofcovid19vaccinedeclinedacohortstudyon579millionnationalhealthservicepatientsrecordsinsituusingopensafelyengland8december2020to25may2021
AT parryjohn recordingofcovid19vaccinedeclinedacohortstudyon579millionnationalhealthservicepatientsrecordsinsituusingopensafelyengland8december2020to25may2021
AT hesterfrank recordingofcovid19vaccinedeclinedacohortstudyon579millionnationalhealthservicepatientsrecordsinsituusingopensafelyengland8december2020to25may2021
AT harpersam recordingofcovid19vaccinedeclinedacohortstudyon579millionnationalhealthservicepatientsrecordsinsituusingopensafelyengland8december2020to25may2021
AT ohanlonshaun recordingofcovid19vaccinedeclinedacohortstudyon579millionnationalhealthservicepatientsrecordsinsituusingopensafelyengland8december2020to25may2021
AT eavisalex recordingofcovid19vaccinedeclinedacohortstudyon579millionnationalhealthservicepatientsrecordsinsituusingopensafelyengland8december2020to25may2021
AT jarvisrichard recordingofcovid19vaccinedeclinedacohortstudyon579millionnationalhealthservicepatientsrecordsinsituusingopensafelyengland8december2020to25may2021
AT avramovdima recordingofcovid19vaccinedeclinedacohortstudyon579millionnationalhealthservicepatientsrecordsinsituusingopensafelyengland8december2020to25may2021
AT griffithspaul recordingofcovid19vaccinedeclinedacohortstudyon579millionnationalhealthservicepatientsrecordsinsituusingopensafelyengland8december2020to25may2021
AT fowlesaaron recordingofcovid19vaccinedeclinedacohortstudyon579millionnationalhealthservicepatientsrecordsinsituusingopensafelyengland8december2020to25may2021
AT parkesnasreen recordingofcovid19vaccinedeclinedacohortstudyon579millionnationalhealthservicepatientsrecordsinsituusingopensafelyengland8december2020to25may2021
AT evansstephenjw recordingofcovid19vaccinedeclinedacohortstudyon579millionnationalhealthservicepatientsrecordsinsituusingopensafelyengland8december2020to25may2021
AT douglasianj recordingofcovid19vaccinedeclinedacohortstudyon579millionnationalhealthservicepatientsrecordsinsituusingopensafelyengland8december2020to25may2021
AT smeethliam recordingofcovid19vaccinedeclinedacohortstudyon579millionnationalhealthservicepatientsrecordsinsituusingopensafelyengland8december2020to25may2021
AT goldacreben recordingofcovid19vaccinedeclinedacohortstudyon579millionnationalhealthservicepatientsrecordsinsituusingopensafelyengland8december2020to25may2021