Cargando…

Recommendations for OCT Angiography Reporting in Retinal Vascular Disease: A Delphi Approach by International Experts

PURPOSE: To develop a consensus nomenclature for reporting OCT angiography (OCTA) findings in retinal vascular disease (e.g., diabetic retinopathy, retinal vein occlusion) by international experts. DESIGN: Delphi-based survey. SUBJECTS, PARTICIPANTS, AND/OR CONTROLS: Twenty-five retinal vascular dis...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Munk, Marion R., Kashani, Amir H., Tadayoni, Ramin, Korobelnik, Jean-Francois, Wolf, Sebastian, Pichi, Francesco, Koh, Adrian, Ishibazawa, Akihiro, Gaudric, Alain, Loewenstein, Anat, Lumbroso, Bruno, Ferrara, Daniela, Sarraf, David, Wong, David T., Skondra, Dimitra, Rodriguez, Francisco J., Staurenghi, Giovanni, Pearce, Ian, Kim, Judy E., Freund, K. Bailey, Battaglia Parodi, Maurizio, Waheed, Nadia K., Rosen, Richard, Spaide, Richard F., Nakao, Shintaro, Sadda, SriniVas, Vujosevic, Stela, Wong, Tien Yin, Murata, Toshinori, Chakravarthy, Usha, Ogura, Yuichiro, Huf, Wolfgang, Tian, Meng
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: 2022
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9393205/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35202889
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.oret.2022.02.007
_version_ 1784771219764019200
author Munk, Marion R.
Kashani, Amir H.
Tadayoni, Ramin
Korobelnik, Jean-Francois
Wolf, Sebastian
Pichi, Francesco
Koh, Adrian
Ishibazawa, Akihiro
Gaudric, Alain
Loewenstein, Anat
Lumbroso, Bruno
Ferrara, Daniela
Sarraf, David
Wong, David T.
Skondra, Dimitra
Rodriguez, Francisco J.
Staurenghi, Giovanni
Pearce, Ian
Kim, Judy E.
Freund, K. Bailey
Battaglia Parodi, Maurizio
Waheed, Nadia K.
Rosen, Richard
Spaide, Richard F.
Nakao, Shintaro
Sadda, SriniVas
Vujosevic, Stela
Wong, Tien Yin
Murata, Toshinori
Chakravarthy, Usha
Ogura, Yuichiro
Huf, Wolfgang
Tian, Meng
author_facet Munk, Marion R.
Kashani, Amir H.
Tadayoni, Ramin
Korobelnik, Jean-Francois
Wolf, Sebastian
Pichi, Francesco
Koh, Adrian
Ishibazawa, Akihiro
Gaudric, Alain
Loewenstein, Anat
Lumbroso, Bruno
Ferrara, Daniela
Sarraf, David
Wong, David T.
Skondra, Dimitra
Rodriguez, Francisco J.
Staurenghi, Giovanni
Pearce, Ian
Kim, Judy E.
Freund, K. Bailey
Battaglia Parodi, Maurizio
Waheed, Nadia K.
Rosen, Richard
Spaide, Richard F.
Nakao, Shintaro
Sadda, SriniVas
Vujosevic, Stela
Wong, Tien Yin
Murata, Toshinori
Chakravarthy, Usha
Ogura, Yuichiro
Huf, Wolfgang
Tian, Meng
author_sort Munk, Marion R.
collection PubMed
description PURPOSE: To develop a consensus nomenclature for reporting OCT angiography (OCTA) findings in retinal vascular disease (e.g., diabetic retinopathy, retinal vein occlusion) by international experts. DESIGN: Delphi-based survey. SUBJECTS, PARTICIPANTS, AND/OR CONTROLS: Twenty-five retinal vascular disease and OCTA imaging experts. METHODS, INTERVENTION, OR TESTING: A Delphi method of consensus development was used, comprising 2 rounds of online questionnaires, followed by a face-to-face meeting conducted virtually. Twenty-five experts in retinal vascular disease and retinal OCTA imaging were selected to constitute the OCTA Nomenclature in Delphi Study Group for retinal vascular disease. The 4 main areas of consensus were: definition of the parameters of “wide-field (WF)” OCTA, measurement of decreased vascular flow on conventional and WF-OCTA, nomenclature of OCTA findings, and OCTA in retinal vascular disease management and staging. The study end point was defined by the degree of consensus for each question: “strong consensus” was defined as ≥85% agreement, “consensus” as 80% to 84%, and “near consensus” as 70% to 79%. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Consensus and near consensus on OCTA nomenclature in retinal vascular disease. RESULTS: A consensus was reached that a meaningful change in percentage of flow on WF-OCTA imaging should be an increase or decrease ≥30% of the absolute imaged area of flow signal and that a “large area” of WF-OCTA reduced flow signal should also be defined as ≥30% of the absolute imaged area. The presence of new vessels and intraretinal microvascular abnormalities, the foveal avascular zone parameters, the presence and amount of “no-flow areas,” and the assessment of vessel density in various retinal layers should be added for the staging and classification of diabetic retinopathy. Decreased flow ≥30% of the absolute imaged area should define an ischemic central retinal vein occlusion. Several other items did not meet consensus requirements or were rejected in the final discussion round. CONCLUSIONS: This study provides international consensus recommendations for reporting OCTA findings in retinal vascular disease, which may help to improve the interpretability and description in clinic and clinical trials. Further validation in these settings is warranted and ongoing. Efforts are continuing to address unresolved questions.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-9393205
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2022
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-93932052022-09-12 Recommendations for OCT Angiography Reporting in Retinal Vascular Disease: A Delphi Approach by International Experts Munk, Marion R. Kashani, Amir H. Tadayoni, Ramin Korobelnik, Jean-Francois Wolf, Sebastian Pichi, Francesco Koh, Adrian Ishibazawa, Akihiro Gaudric, Alain Loewenstein, Anat Lumbroso, Bruno Ferrara, Daniela Sarraf, David Wong, David T. Skondra, Dimitra Rodriguez, Francisco J. Staurenghi, Giovanni Pearce, Ian Kim, Judy E. Freund, K. Bailey Battaglia Parodi, Maurizio Waheed, Nadia K. Rosen, Richard Spaide, Richard F. Nakao, Shintaro Sadda, SriniVas Vujosevic, Stela Wong, Tien Yin Murata, Toshinori Chakravarthy, Usha Ogura, Yuichiro Huf, Wolfgang Tian, Meng Ophthalmol Retina Article PURPOSE: To develop a consensus nomenclature for reporting OCT angiography (OCTA) findings in retinal vascular disease (e.g., diabetic retinopathy, retinal vein occlusion) by international experts. DESIGN: Delphi-based survey. SUBJECTS, PARTICIPANTS, AND/OR CONTROLS: Twenty-five retinal vascular disease and OCTA imaging experts. METHODS, INTERVENTION, OR TESTING: A Delphi method of consensus development was used, comprising 2 rounds of online questionnaires, followed by a face-to-face meeting conducted virtually. Twenty-five experts in retinal vascular disease and retinal OCTA imaging were selected to constitute the OCTA Nomenclature in Delphi Study Group for retinal vascular disease. The 4 main areas of consensus were: definition of the parameters of “wide-field (WF)” OCTA, measurement of decreased vascular flow on conventional and WF-OCTA, nomenclature of OCTA findings, and OCTA in retinal vascular disease management and staging. The study end point was defined by the degree of consensus for each question: “strong consensus” was defined as ≥85% agreement, “consensus” as 80% to 84%, and “near consensus” as 70% to 79%. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Consensus and near consensus on OCTA nomenclature in retinal vascular disease. RESULTS: A consensus was reached that a meaningful change in percentage of flow on WF-OCTA imaging should be an increase or decrease ≥30% of the absolute imaged area of flow signal and that a “large area” of WF-OCTA reduced flow signal should also be defined as ≥30% of the absolute imaged area. The presence of new vessels and intraretinal microvascular abnormalities, the foveal avascular zone parameters, the presence and amount of “no-flow areas,” and the assessment of vessel density in various retinal layers should be added for the staging and classification of diabetic retinopathy. Decreased flow ≥30% of the absolute imaged area should define an ischemic central retinal vein occlusion. Several other items did not meet consensus requirements or were rejected in the final discussion round. CONCLUSIONS: This study provides international consensus recommendations for reporting OCTA findings in retinal vascular disease, which may help to improve the interpretability and description in clinic and clinical trials. Further validation in these settings is warranted and ongoing. Efforts are continuing to address unresolved questions. 2022-02-22 /pmc/articles/PMC9393205/ /pubmed/35202889 http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.oret.2022.02.007 Text en https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/) ).
spellingShingle Article
Munk, Marion R.
Kashani, Amir H.
Tadayoni, Ramin
Korobelnik, Jean-Francois
Wolf, Sebastian
Pichi, Francesco
Koh, Adrian
Ishibazawa, Akihiro
Gaudric, Alain
Loewenstein, Anat
Lumbroso, Bruno
Ferrara, Daniela
Sarraf, David
Wong, David T.
Skondra, Dimitra
Rodriguez, Francisco J.
Staurenghi, Giovanni
Pearce, Ian
Kim, Judy E.
Freund, K. Bailey
Battaglia Parodi, Maurizio
Waheed, Nadia K.
Rosen, Richard
Spaide, Richard F.
Nakao, Shintaro
Sadda, SriniVas
Vujosevic, Stela
Wong, Tien Yin
Murata, Toshinori
Chakravarthy, Usha
Ogura, Yuichiro
Huf, Wolfgang
Tian, Meng
Recommendations for OCT Angiography Reporting in Retinal Vascular Disease: A Delphi Approach by International Experts
title Recommendations for OCT Angiography Reporting in Retinal Vascular Disease: A Delphi Approach by International Experts
title_full Recommendations for OCT Angiography Reporting in Retinal Vascular Disease: A Delphi Approach by International Experts
title_fullStr Recommendations for OCT Angiography Reporting in Retinal Vascular Disease: A Delphi Approach by International Experts
title_full_unstemmed Recommendations for OCT Angiography Reporting in Retinal Vascular Disease: A Delphi Approach by International Experts
title_short Recommendations for OCT Angiography Reporting in Retinal Vascular Disease: A Delphi Approach by International Experts
title_sort recommendations for oct angiography reporting in retinal vascular disease: a delphi approach by international experts
topic Article
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9393205/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35202889
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.oret.2022.02.007
work_keys_str_mv AT munkmarionr recommendationsforoctangiographyreportinginretinalvasculardiseaseadelphiapproachbyinternationalexperts
AT kashaniamirh recommendationsforoctangiographyreportinginretinalvasculardiseaseadelphiapproachbyinternationalexperts
AT tadayoniramin recommendationsforoctangiographyreportinginretinalvasculardiseaseadelphiapproachbyinternationalexperts
AT korobelnikjeanfrancois recommendationsforoctangiographyreportinginretinalvasculardiseaseadelphiapproachbyinternationalexperts
AT wolfsebastian recommendationsforoctangiographyreportinginretinalvasculardiseaseadelphiapproachbyinternationalexperts
AT pichifrancesco recommendationsforoctangiographyreportinginretinalvasculardiseaseadelphiapproachbyinternationalexperts
AT kohadrian recommendationsforoctangiographyreportinginretinalvasculardiseaseadelphiapproachbyinternationalexperts
AT ishibazawaakihiro recommendationsforoctangiographyreportinginretinalvasculardiseaseadelphiapproachbyinternationalexperts
AT gaudricalain recommendationsforoctangiographyreportinginretinalvasculardiseaseadelphiapproachbyinternationalexperts
AT loewensteinanat recommendationsforoctangiographyreportinginretinalvasculardiseaseadelphiapproachbyinternationalexperts
AT lumbrosobruno recommendationsforoctangiographyreportinginretinalvasculardiseaseadelphiapproachbyinternationalexperts
AT ferraradaniela recommendationsforoctangiographyreportinginretinalvasculardiseaseadelphiapproachbyinternationalexperts
AT sarrafdavid recommendationsforoctangiographyreportinginretinalvasculardiseaseadelphiapproachbyinternationalexperts
AT wongdavidt recommendationsforoctangiographyreportinginretinalvasculardiseaseadelphiapproachbyinternationalexperts
AT skondradimitra recommendationsforoctangiographyreportinginretinalvasculardiseaseadelphiapproachbyinternationalexperts
AT rodriguezfranciscoj recommendationsforoctangiographyreportinginretinalvasculardiseaseadelphiapproachbyinternationalexperts
AT staurenghigiovanni recommendationsforoctangiographyreportinginretinalvasculardiseaseadelphiapproachbyinternationalexperts
AT pearceian recommendationsforoctangiographyreportinginretinalvasculardiseaseadelphiapproachbyinternationalexperts
AT kimjudye recommendationsforoctangiographyreportinginretinalvasculardiseaseadelphiapproachbyinternationalexperts
AT freundkbailey recommendationsforoctangiographyreportinginretinalvasculardiseaseadelphiapproachbyinternationalexperts
AT battagliaparodimaurizio recommendationsforoctangiographyreportinginretinalvasculardiseaseadelphiapproachbyinternationalexperts
AT waheednadiak recommendationsforoctangiographyreportinginretinalvasculardiseaseadelphiapproachbyinternationalexperts
AT rosenrichard recommendationsforoctangiographyreportinginretinalvasculardiseaseadelphiapproachbyinternationalexperts
AT spaiderichardf recommendationsforoctangiographyreportinginretinalvasculardiseaseadelphiapproachbyinternationalexperts
AT nakaoshintaro recommendationsforoctangiographyreportinginretinalvasculardiseaseadelphiapproachbyinternationalexperts
AT saddasrinivas recommendationsforoctangiographyreportinginretinalvasculardiseaseadelphiapproachbyinternationalexperts
AT vujosevicstela recommendationsforoctangiographyreportinginretinalvasculardiseaseadelphiapproachbyinternationalexperts
AT wongtienyin recommendationsforoctangiographyreportinginretinalvasculardiseaseadelphiapproachbyinternationalexperts
AT muratatoshinori recommendationsforoctangiographyreportinginretinalvasculardiseaseadelphiapproachbyinternationalexperts
AT chakravarthyusha recommendationsforoctangiographyreportinginretinalvasculardiseaseadelphiapproachbyinternationalexperts
AT ogurayuichiro recommendationsforoctangiographyreportinginretinalvasculardiseaseadelphiapproachbyinternationalexperts
AT hufwolfgang recommendationsforoctangiographyreportinginretinalvasculardiseaseadelphiapproachbyinternationalexperts
AT tianmeng recommendationsforoctangiographyreportinginretinalvasculardiseaseadelphiapproachbyinternationalexperts