Cargando…

Does global health governance walk the talk? Gender representation in World Health Assemblies, 1948–2021

BACKGROUND: While an estimated 70%–75% of the health workforce are women, this is not reflected in the leadership roles of most health organisations—including global decision-making bodies such as the World Health Assembly (WHA). METHODS: We analysed gender representation in WHA delegations of Membe...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: van Daalen, Kim Robin, Chowdhury, Maisoon, Dada, Sara, Khorsand, Parnian, El-Gamal, Salma, Kaidarova, Galiya, Jung, Laura, Othman, Razan, O'Leary, Charlotte Anne, Ashworth, Henry Charles, Socha, Anna, Olaniyan, Dolapo, Azeezat, Fajembola Temilade, Abouhala, Siwaar, Abdulkareem, Toyyib, Dhatt, Roopa, Rajan, Dheepa
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: BMJ Publishing Group 2022
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9403126/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35998979
http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/bmjgh-2022-009312
_version_ 1784773302285238272
author van Daalen, Kim Robin
Chowdhury, Maisoon
Dada, Sara
Khorsand, Parnian
El-Gamal, Salma
Kaidarova, Galiya
Jung, Laura
Othman, Razan
O'Leary, Charlotte Anne
Ashworth, Henry Charles
Socha, Anna
Olaniyan, Dolapo
Azeezat, Fajembola Temilade
Abouhala, Siwaar
Abdulkareem, Toyyib
Dhatt, Roopa
Rajan, Dheepa
author_facet van Daalen, Kim Robin
Chowdhury, Maisoon
Dada, Sara
Khorsand, Parnian
El-Gamal, Salma
Kaidarova, Galiya
Jung, Laura
Othman, Razan
O'Leary, Charlotte Anne
Ashworth, Henry Charles
Socha, Anna
Olaniyan, Dolapo
Azeezat, Fajembola Temilade
Abouhala, Siwaar
Abdulkareem, Toyyib
Dhatt, Roopa
Rajan, Dheepa
author_sort van Daalen, Kim Robin
collection PubMed
description BACKGROUND: While an estimated 70%–75% of the health workforce are women, this is not reflected in the leadership roles of most health organisations—including global decision-making bodies such as the World Health Assembly (WHA). METHODS: We analysed gender representation in WHA delegations of Member States, Associate Members and Observers (country/territory), using data from 10 944 WHA delegations and 75 815 delegation members over 1948–2021. Delegates’ information was extracted from WHO documentation. Likely gender was inferred based on prefixes, pronouns and other gendered language. A gender-to-name algorithm was used as a last resort (4.6%). Time series of 5-year rolling averages of the percentage of women across WHO region, income group and delegate roles are presented. We estimated (%) change ±SE of inferred women delegation members at the WHA per year, and estimated years±SE until gender parity from 2010 to 2019 across regions, income groups, delegate roles and countries. Correlations with these measures were assessed with countries’ gender inequality index and two Worldwide Governance indicators. RESULTS: While upwards trends could be observed in the percentage of women delegates over the past 74 years, men remained over-represented in most WHA delegations. Over 1948–2021, 82.9% of delegations were composed of a majority of men, and no WHA had more than 30% of women Chief Delegates (ranging from 0% to 30%). Wide variation in trends over time could be observed across different geographical regions, income groups and countries. Some countries may take over 100 years to reach gender parity in their WHA delegations, if current estimated trends continue. CONCLUSION: Despite commitments to gender equality in leadership, women remain gravely under-represented in global health governance. An intersectional approach to representation in global health governance, which prioritises equity in participation beyond gender, can enable transformative policymaking that fosters transparent, accountable and just health systems.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-9403126
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2022
publisher BMJ Publishing Group
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-94031262022-09-06 Does global health governance walk the talk? Gender representation in World Health Assemblies, 1948–2021 van Daalen, Kim Robin Chowdhury, Maisoon Dada, Sara Khorsand, Parnian El-Gamal, Salma Kaidarova, Galiya Jung, Laura Othman, Razan O'Leary, Charlotte Anne Ashworth, Henry Charles Socha, Anna Olaniyan, Dolapo Azeezat, Fajembola Temilade Abouhala, Siwaar Abdulkareem, Toyyib Dhatt, Roopa Rajan, Dheepa BMJ Glob Health Original Research BACKGROUND: While an estimated 70%–75% of the health workforce are women, this is not reflected in the leadership roles of most health organisations—including global decision-making bodies such as the World Health Assembly (WHA). METHODS: We analysed gender representation in WHA delegations of Member States, Associate Members and Observers (country/territory), using data from 10 944 WHA delegations and 75 815 delegation members over 1948–2021. Delegates’ information was extracted from WHO documentation. Likely gender was inferred based on prefixes, pronouns and other gendered language. A gender-to-name algorithm was used as a last resort (4.6%). Time series of 5-year rolling averages of the percentage of women across WHO region, income group and delegate roles are presented. We estimated (%) change ±SE of inferred women delegation members at the WHA per year, and estimated years±SE until gender parity from 2010 to 2019 across regions, income groups, delegate roles and countries. Correlations with these measures were assessed with countries’ gender inequality index and two Worldwide Governance indicators. RESULTS: While upwards trends could be observed in the percentage of women delegates over the past 74 years, men remained over-represented in most WHA delegations. Over 1948–2021, 82.9% of delegations were composed of a majority of men, and no WHA had more than 30% of women Chief Delegates (ranging from 0% to 30%). Wide variation in trends over time could be observed across different geographical regions, income groups and countries. Some countries may take over 100 years to reach gender parity in their WHA delegations, if current estimated trends continue. CONCLUSION: Despite commitments to gender equality in leadership, women remain gravely under-represented in global health governance. An intersectional approach to representation in global health governance, which prioritises equity in participation beyond gender, can enable transformative policymaking that fosters transparent, accountable and just health systems. BMJ Publishing Group 2022-08-23 /pmc/articles/PMC9403126/ /pubmed/35998979 http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/bmjgh-2022-009312 Text en © Author(s) (or their employer(s)) 2022. Re-use permitted under CC BY. Published by BMJ. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an open access article distributed in accordance with the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 Unported (CC BY 4.0) license, which permits others to copy, redistribute, remix, transform and build upon this work for any purpose, provided the original work is properly cited, a link to the licence is given, and indication of whether changes were made. See: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
spellingShingle Original Research
van Daalen, Kim Robin
Chowdhury, Maisoon
Dada, Sara
Khorsand, Parnian
El-Gamal, Salma
Kaidarova, Galiya
Jung, Laura
Othman, Razan
O'Leary, Charlotte Anne
Ashworth, Henry Charles
Socha, Anna
Olaniyan, Dolapo
Azeezat, Fajembola Temilade
Abouhala, Siwaar
Abdulkareem, Toyyib
Dhatt, Roopa
Rajan, Dheepa
Does global health governance walk the talk? Gender representation in World Health Assemblies, 1948–2021
title Does global health governance walk the talk? Gender representation in World Health Assemblies, 1948–2021
title_full Does global health governance walk the talk? Gender representation in World Health Assemblies, 1948–2021
title_fullStr Does global health governance walk the talk? Gender representation in World Health Assemblies, 1948–2021
title_full_unstemmed Does global health governance walk the talk? Gender representation in World Health Assemblies, 1948–2021
title_short Does global health governance walk the talk? Gender representation in World Health Assemblies, 1948–2021
title_sort does global health governance walk the talk? gender representation in world health assemblies, 1948–2021
topic Original Research
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9403126/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35998979
http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/bmjgh-2022-009312
work_keys_str_mv AT vandaalenkimrobin doesglobalhealthgovernancewalkthetalkgenderrepresentationinworldhealthassemblies19482021
AT chowdhurymaisoon doesglobalhealthgovernancewalkthetalkgenderrepresentationinworldhealthassemblies19482021
AT dadasara doesglobalhealthgovernancewalkthetalkgenderrepresentationinworldhealthassemblies19482021
AT khorsandparnian doesglobalhealthgovernancewalkthetalkgenderrepresentationinworldhealthassemblies19482021
AT elgamalsalma doesglobalhealthgovernancewalkthetalkgenderrepresentationinworldhealthassemblies19482021
AT kaidarovagaliya doesglobalhealthgovernancewalkthetalkgenderrepresentationinworldhealthassemblies19482021
AT junglaura doesglobalhealthgovernancewalkthetalkgenderrepresentationinworldhealthassemblies19482021
AT othmanrazan doesglobalhealthgovernancewalkthetalkgenderrepresentationinworldhealthassemblies19482021
AT olearycharlotteanne doesglobalhealthgovernancewalkthetalkgenderrepresentationinworldhealthassemblies19482021
AT ashworthhenrycharles doesglobalhealthgovernancewalkthetalkgenderrepresentationinworldhealthassemblies19482021
AT sochaanna doesglobalhealthgovernancewalkthetalkgenderrepresentationinworldhealthassemblies19482021
AT olaniyandolapo doesglobalhealthgovernancewalkthetalkgenderrepresentationinworldhealthassemblies19482021
AT azeezatfajembolatemilade doesglobalhealthgovernancewalkthetalkgenderrepresentationinworldhealthassemblies19482021
AT abouhalasiwaar doesglobalhealthgovernancewalkthetalkgenderrepresentationinworldhealthassemblies19482021
AT abdulkareemtoyyib doesglobalhealthgovernancewalkthetalkgenderrepresentationinworldhealthassemblies19482021
AT dhattroopa doesglobalhealthgovernancewalkthetalkgenderrepresentationinworldhealthassemblies19482021
AT rajandheepa doesglobalhealthgovernancewalkthetalkgenderrepresentationinworldhealthassemblies19482021