Cargando…

The Relationship between Animal Welfare and Farm Profitability in Cage and Free-Range Housing Systems for Laying Hens in China

SIMPLE SUMMARY: With public concern increasing in China for animal welfare in livestock production, the welfare and economic outcomes of different farming systems for laying hens needs to be examined. Animal welfare outcomes and initiatives are linked to the economic efficiency of the farm, which fo...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: He, Shuai, Lin, Jiao, Jin, Qiongyu, Ma, Xiaohan, Liu, Zhongying, Chen, Hui, Ma, Ji, Zhang, Huancheng, Descovich, Kris, Phillips, Clive J. C., Hartcher, Kate, Wu, Zhonghong
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: MDPI 2022
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9405104/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36009680
http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/ani12162090
_version_ 1784773798917046272
author He, Shuai
Lin, Jiao
Jin, Qiongyu
Ma, Xiaohan
Liu, Zhongying
Chen, Hui
Ma, Ji
Zhang, Huancheng
Descovich, Kris
Phillips, Clive J. C.
Hartcher, Kate
Wu, Zhonghong
author_facet He, Shuai
Lin, Jiao
Jin, Qiongyu
Ma, Xiaohan
Liu, Zhongying
Chen, Hui
Ma, Ji
Zhang, Huancheng
Descovich, Kris
Phillips, Clive J. C.
Hartcher, Kate
Wu, Zhonghong
author_sort He, Shuai
collection PubMed
description SIMPLE SUMMARY: With public concern increasing in China for animal welfare in livestock production, the welfare and economic outcomes of different farming systems for laying hens needs to be examined. Animal welfare outcomes and initiatives are linked to the economic efficiency of the farm, which for the producer may require a balance or trade-off between these issues. This study investigated animal welfare, egg production and economic parameters in cage and free-range farms in China. Our results identified potential welfare issues that can be addressed on both farm types, and potential points of income that can be improved by enhancing hen welfare. Therefore, our results offer some directions for welfare and economic improvements on cage and free-range egg farms in China. ABSTRACT: Several countries and regions have regulations in place to provide standards for the welfare of production animals, which have implications for breeding, management and trade. In the chicken egg production industry, the welfare impacts of this are not well understood. In the past decades, free-range systems were widely used for local chicken breeds in poultry industry in China, but their use has gradually declined due to the lower competitiveness compared to commercial cage systems. However, the practices of free-range systems for hens raising have gradually increased again over the past decade, as consumer individualized demand for higher food quality and animal welfare has increased. We recruited 14 free-range farms and 45 cage farms from Beijing, Shandong, Hebei, Anhui, Yunnan, Gansu and Jiangsu provinces in China, for an evaluation of hen welfare, production and economic outcomes from farm operations. This study provides data for the welfare outcomes of laying hens in China and preliminarily explored the relationship between welfare level and economic income within farming system types. The researchers visited the farms and used Welfare Quality measures to investigate the welfare, and farm self-reported profits. Nonparametric Mann–Whitney U tests were used to compare the welfare scores between cage and free-range rearing farms. Correlation and regression are used for the analysis of the animal welfare scores, economic data, and production metrics. The general income from free-range farms was linearly correlated with red mite score and stocking density (p < 0.001 and p < 0.05, respectively). The results showed less centimeters of feeder and drinker space per animal in the free-range system than in cage systems (p < 0.05 and p < 0.01, respectively). Welfare scores for both the stocking density and beak condition were significantly better in the free-range systems than the cage systems (p < 0.001), as were qualitative behavior assessment scores (p < 0.05). The total egg production and peak egg production in cage farms were much higher than in free-range farms (p < 0.001), and egg loss rate was significantly lower (p < 0.001). While the production efficiency of free-range farms was lower than that of cage farms, general income per 10,000 hens was actually higher. Our results provide some evidence that some welfare indicators and general income (per 10,000 hens) in free-range farms in China were better than those of cage farms. The results indicate that better parasite control and lower stocking densities may result in improved hen welfare on free-range farms and potentially improve profitability. The level of welfare and economic benefits of free-range farms vary widely, and there was potential room for improvement in feeding space, drinking water space and human–animal relationship.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-9405104
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2022
publisher MDPI
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-94051042022-08-26 The Relationship between Animal Welfare and Farm Profitability in Cage and Free-Range Housing Systems for Laying Hens in China He, Shuai Lin, Jiao Jin, Qiongyu Ma, Xiaohan Liu, Zhongying Chen, Hui Ma, Ji Zhang, Huancheng Descovich, Kris Phillips, Clive J. C. Hartcher, Kate Wu, Zhonghong Animals (Basel) Article SIMPLE SUMMARY: With public concern increasing in China for animal welfare in livestock production, the welfare and economic outcomes of different farming systems for laying hens needs to be examined. Animal welfare outcomes and initiatives are linked to the economic efficiency of the farm, which for the producer may require a balance or trade-off between these issues. This study investigated animal welfare, egg production and economic parameters in cage and free-range farms in China. Our results identified potential welfare issues that can be addressed on both farm types, and potential points of income that can be improved by enhancing hen welfare. Therefore, our results offer some directions for welfare and economic improvements on cage and free-range egg farms in China. ABSTRACT: Several countries and regions have regulations in place to provide standards for the welfare of production animals, which have implications for breeding, management and trade. In the chicken egg production industry, the welfare impacts of this are not well understood. In the past decades, free-range systems were widely used for local chicken breeds in poultry industry in China, but their use has gradually declined due to the lower competitiveness compared to commercial cage systems. However, the practices of free-range systems for hens raising have gradually increased again over the past decade, as consumer individualized demand for higher food quality and animal welfare has increased. We recruited 14 free-range farms and 45 cage farms from Beijing, Shandong, Hebei, Anhui, Yunnan, Gansu and Jiangsu provinces in China, for an evaluation of hen welfare, production and economic outcomes from farm operations. This study provides data for the welfare outcomes of laying hens in China and preliminarily explored the relationship between welfare level and economic income within farming system types. The researchers visited the farms and used Welfare Quality measures to investigate the welfare, and farm self-reported profits. Nonparametric Mann–Whitney U tests were used to compare the welfare scores between cage and free-range rearing farms. Correlation and regression are used for the analysis of the animal welfare scores, economic data, and production metrics. The general income from free-range farms was linearly correlated with red mite score and stocking density (p < 0.001 and p < 0.05, respectively). The results showed less centimeters of feeder and drinker space per animal in the free-range system than in cage systems (p < 0.05 and p < 0.01, respectively). Welfare scores for both the stocking density and beak condition were significantly better in the free-range systems than the cage systems (p < 0.001), as were qualitative behavior assessment scores (p < 0.05). The total egg production and peak egg production in cage farms were much higher than in free-range farms (p < 0.001), and egg loss rate was significantly lower (p < 0.001). While the production efficiency of free-range farms was lower than that of cage farms, general income per 10,000 hens was actually higher. Our results provide some evidence that some welfare indicators and general income (per 10,000 hens) in free-range farms in China were better than those of cage farms. The results indicate that better parasite control and lower stocking densities may result in improved hen welfare on free-range farms and potentially improve profitability. The level of welfare and economic benefits of free-range farms vary widely, and there was potential room for improvement in feeding space, drinking water space and human–animal relationship. MDPI 2022-08-16 /pmc/articles/PMC9405104/ /pubmed/36009680 http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/ani12162090 Text en © 2022 by the authors. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
spellingShingle Article
He, Shuai
Lin, Jiao
Jin, Qiongyu
Ma, Xiaohan
Liu, Zhongying
Chen, Hui
Ma, Ji
Zhang, Huancheng
Descovich, Kris
Phillips, Clive J. C.
Hartcher, Kate
Wu, Zhonghong
The Relationship between Animal Welfare and Farm Profitability in Cage and Free-Range Housing Systems for Laying Hens in China
title The Relationship between Animal Welfare and Farm Profitability in Cage and Free-Range Housing Systems for Laying Hens in China
title_full The Relationship between Animal Welfare and Farm Profitability in Cage and Free-Range Housing Systems for Laying Hens in China
title_fullStr The Relationship between Animal Welfare and Farm Profitability in Cage and Free-Range Housing Systems for Laying Hens in China
title_full_unstemmed The Relationship between Animal Welfare and Farm Profitability in Cage and Free-Range Housing Systems for Laying Hens in China
title_short The Relationship between Animal Welfare and Farm Profitability in Cage and Free-Range Housing Systems for Laying Hens in China
title_sort relationship between animal welfare and farm profitability in cage and free-range housing systems for laying hens in china
topic Article
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9405104/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36009680
http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/ani12162090
work_keys_str_mv AT heshuai therelationshipbetweenanimalwelfareandfarmprofitabilityincageandfreerangehousingsystemsforlayinghensinchina
AT linjiao therelationshipbetweenanimalwelfareandfarmprofitabilityincageandfreerangehousingsystemsforlayinghensinchina
AT jinqiongyu therelationshipbetweenanimalwelfareandfarmprofitabilityincageandfreerangehousingsystemsforlayinghensinchina
AT maxiaohan therelationshipbetweenanimalwelfareandfarmprofitabilityincageandfreerangehousingsystemsforlayinghensinchina
AT liuzhongying therelationshipbetweenanimalwelfareandfarmprofitabilityincageandfreerangehousingsystemsforlayinghensinchina
AT chenhui therelationshipbetweenanimalwelfareandfarmprofitabilityincageandfreerangehousingsystemsforlayinghensinchina
AT maji therelationshipbetweenanimalwelfareandfarmprofitabilityincageandfreerangehousingsystemsforlayinghensinchina
AT zhanghuancheng therelationshipbetweenanimalwelfareandfarmprofitabilityincageandfreerangehousingsystemsforlayinghensinchina
AT descovichkris therelationshipbetweenanimalwelfareandfarmprofitabilityincageandfreerangehousingsystemsforlayinghensinchina
AT phillipsclivejc therelationshipbetweenanimalwelfareandfarmprofitabilityincageandfreerangehousingsystemsforlayinghensinchina
AT hartcherkate therelationshipbetweenanimalwelfareandfarmprofitabilityincageandfreerangehousingsystemsforlayinghensinchina
AT wuzhonghong therelationshipbetweenanimalwelfareandfarmprofitabilityincageandfreerangehousingsystemsforlayinghensinchina
AT heshuai relationshipbetweenanimalwelfareandfarmprofitabilityincageandfreerangehousingsystemsforlayinghensinchina
AT linjiao relationshipbetweenanimalwelfareandfarmprofitabilityincageandfreerangehousingsystemsforlayinghensinchina
AT jinqiongyu relationshipbetweenanimalwelfareandfarmprofitabilityincageandfreerangehousingsystemsforlayinghensinchina
AT maxiaohan relationshipbetweenanimalwelfareandfarmprofitabilityincageandfreerangehousingsystemsforlayinghensinchina
AT liuzhongying relationshipbetweenanimalwelfareandfarmprofitabilityincageandfreerangehousingsystemsforlayinghensinchina
AT chenhui relationshipbetweenanimalwelfareandfarmprofitabilityincageandfreerangehousingsystemsforlayinghensinchina
AT maji relationshipbetweenanimalwelfareandfarmprofitabilityincageandfreerangehousingsystemsforlayinghensinchina
AT zhanghuancheng relationshipbetweenanimalwelfareandfarmprofitabilityincageandfreerangehousingsystemsforlayinghensinchina
AT descovichkris relationshipbetweenanimalwelfareandfarmprofitabilityincageandfreerangehousingsystemsforlayinghensinchina
AT phillipsclivejc relationshipbetweenanimalwelfareandfarmprofitabilityincageandfreerangehousingsystemsforlayinghensinchina
AT hartcherkate relationshipbetweenanimalwelfareandfarmprofitabilityincageandfreerangehousingsystemsforlayinghensinchina
AT wuzhonghong relationshipbetweenanimalwelfareandfarmprofitabilityincageandfreerangehousingsystemsforlayinghensinchina