Voxelwise structural disconnection mapping: Methodological validation and recommendations

Voxelwise disconnection mapping is a novel approach to disclose lesion-symptom relationships for symptoms caused by white matter disconnection. It uses MRI-based fiber tracking in healthy subjects seeded from patient’s focal brain lesions. Resulting individual disconnection maps can then be statistically associated with symptoms. Despite increasing use in the recent years, the validity of this approach remains to be investigated. In this study, we validated both, our own implementation and the implementation provided within BCBtoolkit. For technical validation, we used simulated symptoms based on overlap of 70 real stroke lesions with tracts from a white matter atlas. For clinical validation, paresis scores and lesions from 316 patients with stroke were used. We found that voxelwise disconnection mapping is technically valid and outperforms the standard voxel-based lesion-symptom mapping approach for symptoms caused by white matter disconnection. Supporting its clinical validity and utility, we were able to reproduce the known association between corticospinal tract damage and contralateral hemiparesis. In addition, we demonstrate that the validity can be substantially diminished by relatively minor methodological changes. Based on these results, we derive methodological recommendations for the future use of voxelwise disconnection mapping. Our study highlights the importance of validating novel methodological approaches in the rapidly evolving field of neuroimaging.