Mutual Exclusion of Methanobrevibacter Species in the Human Gut Microbiota Facilitates Directed Cultivation of a Candidatus Methanobrevibacter Intestini Representative

Methanogenic Archaea (methanogens) are a phylogenetically diverse group of microorganisms and are considered to be the most abundant archaeal representatives in the human gut. However, the gut methanogen diversity of human populations in many global regions remains poorly investigated. Here, we report the abundance and diversity of gut methanogenic Archaea in a multi-ethnic cohort of healthy Singaporeans by using a concerted approach of metagenomic sequencing, 16S rRNA gene amplicon sequencing, and quantitative PCR. Our results indicate a mutual exclusion of Methanobrevibacter species, i.e., the highly prevalent Methanobrevibacter smithii and the less prevalent Candidatus Methanobrevibacter intestini in more than 80% of the samples when using an amplicon sequencing-based approach. Leveraging on this finding, we were able to select a fecal sample to isolate a representative strain, TLL-48-HuF1, for Candidatus Methanobrevibacter intestini. The analyzed physiological parameters of M. smithii DSM 861(T) and strain TLL-48-HuF1 suggest high similarity of the two species. Comparative genome analysis and the mutual exclusion of the Methanobrevibacter species indicate potentially different niche adaptation strategies in the human host, which may support the designation of Candidatus M. intestini as a novel species. IMPORTANCE Methanogens are important hydrogen consumers in the gut and are associated with differing host health. Here, we determine the prevalence and abundance of archaeal species in the guts of a multi-ethnic cohort of healthy Singapore residents. While Methanobrevibacter smithii is the most prevalent and abundant methanogen in the human gut of local subjects, the recently proposed Candidatus Methanobrevibacter intestini is the abundant methanogen in a minority of individuals that harbor them. The observed potential mutual exclusion of M. smithii and Ca. M. intestini provides further support to the proposal that the two physiologically similar strains may belong to different Methanobrevibacter species.