Cargando…

A machine-learning algorithm for diagnosis of multisystem inflammatory syndrome in children and Kawasaki disease in the USA: a retrospective model development and validation study

BACKGROUND: Multisystem inflammatory syndrome in children (MIS-C) is a novel disease that was identified during the COVID-19 pandemic and is characterised by systemic inflammation following SARS-CoV-2 infection. Early detection of MIS-C is a challenge given its clinical similarities to Kawasaki dise...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Lam, Jonathan Y, Shimizu, Chisato, Tremoulet, Adriana H, Bainto, Emelia, Roberts, Samantha C, Sivilay, Nipha, Gardiner, Michael A, Kanegaye, John T, Hogan, Alexander H, Salazar, Juan C, Mohandas, Sindhu, Szmuszkovicz, Jacqueline R, Mahanta, Simran, Dionne, Audrey, Newburger, Jane W, Ansusinha, Emily, DeBiasi, Roberta L, Hao, Shiying, Ling, Xuefeng B, Cohen, Harvey J, Nemati, Shamim, Burns, Jane C
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: The Author(s). Published by Elsevier Ltd. 2022
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9507344/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36150781
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S2589-7500(22)00149-2
_version_ 1784796854187196416
author Lam, Jonathan Y
Shimizu, Chisato
Tremoulet, Adriana H
Bainto, Emelia
Roberts, Samantha C
Sivilay, Nipha
Gardiner, Michael A
Kanegaye, John T
Hogan, Alexander H
Salazar, Juan C
Mohandas, Sindhu
Szmuszkovicz, Jacqueline R
Mahanta, Simran
Dionne, Audrey
Newburger, Jane W
Ansusinha, Emily
DeBiasi, Roberta L
Hao, Shiying
Ling, Xuefeng B
Cohen, Harvey J
Nemati, Shamim
Burns, Jane C
author_facet Lam, Jonathan Y
Shimizu, Chisato
Tremoulet, Adriana H
Bainto, Emelia
Roberts, Samantha C
Sivilay, Nipha
Gardiner, Michael A
Kanegaye, John T
Hogan, Alexander H
Salazar, Juan C
Mohandas, Sindhu
Szmuszkovicz, Jacqueline R
Mahanta, Simran
Dionne, Audrey
Newburger, Jane W
Ansusinha, Emily
DeBiasi, Roberta L
Hao, Shiying
Ling, Xuefeng B
Cohen, Harvey J
Nemati, Shamim
Burns, Jane C
author_sort Lam, Jonathan Y
collection PubMed
description BACKGROUND: Multisystem inflammatory syndrome in children (MIS-C) is a novel disease that was identified during the COVID-19 pandemic and is characterised by systemic inflammation following SARS-CoV-2 infection. Early detection of MIS-C is a challenge given its clinical similarities to Kawasaki disease and other acute febrile childhood illnesses. We aimed to develop and validate an artificial intelligence algorithm that can distinguish among MIS-C, Kawasaki disease, and other similar febrile illnesses and aid in the diagnosis of patients in the emergency department and acute care setting. METHODS: In this retrospective model development and validation study, we developed a deep-learning algorithm called KIDMATCH (Kawasaki Disease vs Multisystem Inflammatory Syndrome in Children) using patient age, the five classic clinical Kawasaki disease signs, and 17 laboratory measurements. All features were prospectively collected at the time of initial evaluation from patients diagnosed with Kawasaki disease or other febrile illness between Jan 1, 2009, and Dec 31, 2019, at Rady Children's Hospital in San Diego (CA, USA). For patients with MIS-C, the same data were collected from patients between May 7, 2020, and July 20, 2021, at Rady Children's Hospital, Connecticut Children's Medical Center in Hartford (CT, USA), and Children's Hospital Los Angeles (CA, USA). We trained a two-stage model consisting of feedforward neural networks to distinguish between patients with MIS-C and those without and then those with Kawasaki disease and other febrile illnesses. After internally validating the algorithm using stratified tenfold cross-validation, we incorporated a conformal prediction framework to tag patients with erroneous data or distribution shifts. We finally externally validated KIDMATCH on patients with MIS-C enrolled between April 22, 2020, and July 21, 2021, from Boston Children's Hospital (MA, USA), Children's National Hospital (Washington, DC, USA), and the CHARMS Study Group consortium of 14 US hospitals. FINDINGS: 1517 patients diagnosed at Rady Children's Hospital between Jan 1, 2009, and June 7, 2021, with MIS-C (n=69), Kawasaki disease (n=775), or other febrile illnesses (n=673) were identified for internal validation, with an additional 16 patients with MIS-C included from Connecticut Children's Medical Center and 50 from Children's Hospital Los Angeles between May 7, 2020, and July 20, 2021. KIDMATCH achieved a median area under the receiver operating characteristic curve during internal validation of 98·8% (IQR 98·0–99·3) in the first stage and 96·0% (95·6–97·2) in the second stage. We externally validated KIDMATCH on 175 patients with MIS-C from Boston Children's Hospital (n=50), Children's National Hospital (n=42), and the CHARMS Study Group consortium of 14 US hospitals (n=83). External validation of KIDMATCH on patients with MIS-C correctly classified 76 of 81 patients (94% accuracy, two rejected by conformal prediction) from 14 hospitals in the CHARMS Study Group consortium, 47 of 49 patients (96% accuracy, one rejected by conformal prediction) from Boston Children's Hospital, and 36 of 40 patients (90% accuracy, two rejected by conformal prediction) from Children's National Hospital. INTERPRETATION: KIDMATCH has the potential to aid front-line clinicians to distinguish between MIS-C, Kawasaki disease, and other similar febrile illnesses to allow prompt treatment and prevent severe complications. FUNDING: US Eunice Kennedy Shriver National Institute of Child Health and Human Development, US National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute, US Patient-Centered Outcomes Research Institute, US National Library of Medicine, the McCance Foundation, and the Gordon and Marilyn Macklin Foundation.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-9507344
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2022
publisher The Author(s). Published by Elsevier Ltd.
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-95073442022-09-26 A machine-learning algorithm for diagnosis of multisystem inflammatory syndrome in children and Kawasaki disease in the USA: a retrospective model development and validation study Lam, Jonathan Y Shimizu, Chisato Tremoulet, Adriana H Bainto, Emelia Roberts, Samantha C Sivilay, Nipha Gardiner, Michael A Kanegaye, John T Hogan, Alexander H Salazar, Juan C Mohandas, Sindhu Szmuszkovicz, Jacqueline R Mahanta, Simran Dionne, Audrey Newburger, Jane W Ansusinha, Emily DeBiasi, Roberta L Hao, Shiying Ling, Xuefeng B Cohen, Harvey J Nemati, Shamim Burns, Jane C Lancet Digit Health Articles BACKGROUND: Multisystem inflammatory syndrome in children (MIS-C) is a novel disease that was identified during the COVID-19 pandemic and is characterised by systemic inflammation following SARS-CoV-2 infection. Early detection of MIS-C is a challenge given its clinical similarities to Kawasaki disease and other acute febrile childhood illnesses. We aimed to develop and validate an artificial intelligence algorithm that can distinguish among MIS-C, Kawasaki disease, and other similar febrile illnesses and aid in the diagnosis of patients in the emergency department and acute care setting. METHODS: In this retrospective model development and validation study, we developed a deep-learning algorithm called KIDMATCH (Kawasaki Disease vs Multisystem Inflammatory Syndrome in Children) using patient age, the five classic clinical Kawasaki disease signs, and 17 laboratory measurements. All features were prospectively collected at the time of initial evaluation from patients diagnosed with Kawasaki disease or other febrile illness between Jan 1, 2009, and Dec 31, 2019, at Rady Children's Hospital in San Diego (CA, USA). For patients with MIS-C, the same data were collected from patients between May 7, 2020, and July 20, 2021, at Rady Children's Hospital, Connecticut Children's Medical Center in Hartford (CT, USA), and Children's Hospital Los Angeles (CA, USA). We trained a two-stage model consisting of feedforward neural networks to distinguish between patients with MIS-C and those without and then those with Kawasaki disease and other febrile illnesses. After internally validating the algorithm using stratified tenfold cross-validation, we incorporated a conformal prediction framework to tag patients with erroneous data or distribution shifts. We finally externally validated KIDMATCH on patients with MIS-C enrolled between April 22, 2020, and July 21, 2021, from Boston Children's Hospital (MA, USA), Children's National Hospital (Washington, DC, USA), and the CHARMS Study Group consortium of 14 US hospitals. FINDINGS: 1517 patients diagnosed at Rady Children's Hospital between Jan 1, 2009, and June 7, 2021, with MIS-C (n=69), Kawasaki disease (n=775), or other febrile illnesses (n=673) were identified for internal validation, with an additional 16 patients with MIS-C included from Connecticut Children's Medical Center and 50 from Children's Hospital Los Angeles between May 7, 2020, and July 20, 2021. KIDMATCH achieved a median area under the receiver operating characteristic curve during internal validation of 98·8% (IQR 98·0–99·3) in the first stage and 96·0% (95·6–97·2) in the second stage. We externally validated KIDMATCH on 175 patients with MIS-C from Boston Children's Hospital (n=50), Children's National Hospital (n=42), and the CHARMS Study Group consortium of 14 US hospitals (n=83). External validation of KIDMATCH on patients with MIS-C correctly classified 76 of 81 patients (94% accuracy, two rejected by conformal prediction) from 14 hospitals in the CHARMS Study Group consortium, 47 of 49 patients (96% accuracy, one rejected by conformal prediction) from Boston Children's Hospital, and 36 of 40 patients (90% accuracy, two rejected by conformal prediction) from Children's National Hospital. INTERPRETATION: KIDMATCH has the potential to aid front-line clinicians to distinguish between MIS-C, Kawasaki disease, and other similar febrile illnesses to allow prompt treatment and prevent severe complications. FUNDING: US Eunice Kennedy Shriver National Institute of Child Health and Human Development, US National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute, US Patient-Centered Outcomes Research Institute, US National Library of Medicine, the McCance Foundation, and the Gordon and Marilyn Macklin Foundation. The Author(s). Published by Elsevier Ltd. 2022-10 2022-09-20 /pmc/articles/PMC9507344/ /pubmed/36150781 http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S2589-7500(22)00149-2 Text en © 2022 The Author(s). Published by Elsevier Ltd. This is an Open Access article under the CC BY-NC-ND 4.0 license Since January 2020 Elsevier has created a COVID-19 resource centre with free information in English and Mandarin on the novel coronavirus COVID-19. The COVID-19 resource centre is hosted on Elsevier Connect, the company's public news and information website. Elsevier hereby grants permission to make all its COVID-19-related research that is available on the COVID-19 resource centre - including this research content - immediately available in PubMed Central and other publicly funded repositories, such as the WHO COVID database with rights for unrestricted research re-use and analyses in any form or by any means with acknowledgement of the original source. These permissions are granted for free by Elsevier for as long as the COVID-19 resource centre remains active.
spellingShingle Articles
Lam, Jonathan Y
Shimizu, Chisato
Tremoulet, Adriana H
Bainto, Emelia
Roberts, Samantha C
Sivilay, Nipha
Gardiner, Michael A
Kanegaye, John T
Hogan, Alexander H
Salazar, Juan C
Mohandas, Sindhu
Szmuszkovicz, Jacqueline R
Mahanta, Simran
Dionne, Audrey
Newburger, Jane W
Ansusinha, Emily
DeBiasi, Roberta L
Hao, Shiying
Ling, Xuefeng B
Cohen, Harvey J
Nemati, Shamim
Burns, Jane C
A machine-learning algorithm for diagnosis of multisystem inflammatory syndrome in children and Kawasaki disease in the USA: a retrospective model development and validation study
title A machine-learning algorithm for diagnosis of multisystem inflammatory syndrome in children and Kawasaki disease in the USA: a retrospective model development and validation study
title_full A machine-learning algorithm for diagnosis of multisystem inflammatory syndrome in children and Kawasaki disease in the USA: a retrospective model development and validation study
title_fullStr A machine-learning algorithm for diagnosis of multisystem inflammatory syndrome in children and Kawasaki disease in the USA: a retrospective model development and validation study
title_full_unstemmed A machine-learning algorithm for diagnosis of multisystem inflammatory syndrome in children and Kawasaki disease in the USA: a retrospective model development and validation study
title_short A machine-learning algorithm for diagnosis of multisystem inflammatory syndrome in children and Kawasaki disease in the USA: a retrospective model development and validation study
title_sort machine-learning algorithm for diagnosis of multisystem inflammatory syndrome in children and kawasaki disease in the usa: a retrospective model development and validation study
topic Articles
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9507344/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36150781
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S2589-7500(22)00149-2
work_keys_str_mv AT lamjonathany amachinelearningalgorithmfordiagnosisofmultisysteminflammatorysyndromeinchildrenandkawasakidiseaseintheusaaretrospectivemodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT shimizuchisato amachinelearningalgorithmfordiagnosisofmultisysteminflammatorysyndromeinchildrenandkawasakidiseaseintheusaaretrospectivemodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT tremouletadrianah amachinelearningalgorithmfordiagnosisofmultisysteminflammatorysyndromeinchildrenandkawasakidiseaseintheusaaretrospectivemodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT baintoemelia amachinelearningalgorithmfordiagnosisofmultisysteminflammatorysyndromeinchildrenandkawasakidiseaseintheusaaretrospectivemodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT robertssamanthac amachinelearningalgorithmfordiagnosisofmultisysteminflammatorysyndromeinchildrenandkawasakidiseaseintheusaaretrospectivemodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT sivilaynipha amachinelearningalgorithmfordiagnosisofmultisysteminflammatorysyndromeinchildrenandkawasakidiseaseintheusaaretrospectivemodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT gardinermichaela amachinelearningalgorithmfordiagnosisofmultisysteminflammatorysyndromeinchildrenandkawasakidiseaseintheusaaretrospectivemodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT kanegayejohnt amachinelearningalgorithmfordiagnosisofmultisysteminflammatorysyndromeinchildrenandkawasakidiseaseintheusaaretrospectivemodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT hoganalexanderh amachinelearningalgorithmfordiagnosisofmultisysteminflammatorysyndromeinchildrenandkawasakidiseaseintheusaaretrospectivemodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT salazarjuanc amachinelearningalgorithmfordiagnosisofmultisysteminflammatorysyndromeinchildrenandkawasakidiseaseintheusaaretrospectivemodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT mohandassindhu amachinelearningalgorithmfordiagnosisofmultisysteminflammatorysyndromeinchildrenandkawasakidiseaseintheusaaretrospectivemodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT szmuszkoviczjacqueliner amachinelearningalgorithmfordiagnosisofmultisysteminflammatorysyndromeinchildrenandkawasakidiseaseintheusaaretrospectivemodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT mahantasimran amachinelearningalgorithmfordiagnosisofmultisysteminflammatorysyndromeinchildrenandkawasakidiseaseintheusaaretrospectivemodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT dionneaudrey amachinelearningalgorithmfordiagnosisofmultisysteminflammatorysyndromeinchildrenandkawasakidiseaseintheusaaretrospectivemodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT newburgerjanew amachinelearningalgorithmfordiagnosisofmultisysteminflammatorysyndromeinchildrenandkawasakidiseaseintheusaaretrospectivemodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT ansusinhaemily amachinelearningalgorithmfordiagnosisofmultisysteminflammatorysyndromeinchildrenandkawasakidiseaseintheusaaretrospectivemodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT debiasirobertal amachinelearningalgorithmfordiagnosisofmultisysteminflammatorysyndromeinchildrenandkawasakidiseaseintheusaaretrospectivemodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT haoshiying amachinelearningalgorithmfordiagnosisofmultisysteminflammatorysyndromeinchildrenandkawasakidiseaseintheusaaretrospectivemodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT lingxuefengb amachinelearningalgorithmfordiagnosisofmultisysteminflammatorysyndromeinchildrenandkawasakidiseaseintheusaaretrospectivemodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT cohenharveyj amachinelearningalgorithmfordiagnosisofmultisysteminflammatorysyndromeinchildrenandkawasakidiseaseintheusaaretrospectivemodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT nematishamim amachinelearningalgorithmfordiagnosisofmultisysteminflammatorysyndromeinchildrenandkawasakidiseaseintheusaaretrospectivemodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT burnsjanec amachinelearningalgorithmfordiagnosisofmultisysteminflammatorysyndromeinchildrenandkawasakidiseaseintheusaaretrospectivemodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT amachinelearningalgorithmfordiagnosisofmultisysteminflammatorysyndromeinchildrenandkawasakidiseaseintheusaaretrospectivemodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT amachinelearningalgorithmfordiagnosisofmultisysteminflammatorysyndromeinchildrenandkawasakidiseaseintheusaaretrospectivemodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT lamjonathany machinelearningalgorithmfordiagnosisofmultisysteminflammatorysyndromeinchildrenandkawasakidiseaseintheusaaretrospectivemodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT shimizuchisato machinelearningalgorithmfordiagnosisofmultisysteminflammatorysyndromeinchildrenandkawasakidiseaseintheusaaretrospectivemodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT tremouletadrianah machinelearningalgorithmfordiagnosisofmultisysteminflammatorysyndromeinchildrenandkawasakidiseaseintheusaaretrospectivemodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT baintoemelia machinelearningalgorithmfordiagnosisofmultisysteminflammatorysyndromeinchildrenandkawasakidiseaseintheusaaretrospectivemodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT robertssamanthac machinelearningalgorithmfordiagnosisofmultisysteminflammatorysyndromeinchildrenandkawasakidiseaseintheusaaretrospectivemodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT sivilaynipha machinelearningalgorithmfordiagnosisofmultisysteminflammatorysyndromeinchildrenandkawasakidiseaseintheusaaretrospectivemodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT gardinermichaela machinelearningalgorithmfordiagnosisofmultisysteminflammatorysyndromeinchildrenandkawasakidiseaseintheusaaretrospectivemodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT kanegayejohnt machinelearningalgorithmfordiagnosisofmultisysteminflammatorysyndromeinchildrenandkawasakidiseaseintheusaaretrospectivemodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT hoganalexanderh machinelearningalgorithmfordiagnosisofmultisysteminflammatorysyndromeinchildrenandkawasakidiseaseintheusaaretrospectivemodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT salazarjuanc machinelearningalgorithmfordiagnosisofmultisysteminflammatorysyndromeinchildrenandkawasakidiseaseintheusaaretrospectivemodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT mohandassindhu machinelearningalgorithmfordiagnosisofmultisysteminflammatorysyndromeinchildrenandkawasakidiseaseintheusaaretrospectivemodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT szmuszkoviczjacqueliner machinelearningalgorithmfordiagnosisofmultisysteminflammatorysyndromeinchildrenandkawasakidiseaseintheusaaretrospectivemodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT mahantasimran machinelearningalgorithmfordiagnosisofmultisysteminflammatorysyndromeinchildrenandkawasakidiseaseintheusaaretrospectivemodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT dionneaudrey machinelearningalgorithmfordiagnosisofmultisysteminflammatorysyndromeinchildrenandkawasakidiseaseintheusaaretrospectivemodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT newburgerjanew machinelearningalgorithmfordiagnosisofmultisysteminflammatorysyndromeinchildrenandkawasakidiseaseintheusaaretrospectivemodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT ansusinhaemily machinelearningalgorithmfordiagnosisofmultisysteminflammatorysyndromeinchildrenandkawasakidiseaseintheusaaretrospectivemodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT debiasirobertal machinelearningalgorithmfordiagnosisofmultisysteminflammatorysyndromeinchildrenandkawasakidiseaseintheusaaretrospectivemodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT haoshiying machinelearningalgorithmfordiagnosisofmultisysteminflammatorysyndromeinchildrenandkawasakidiseaseintheusaaretrospectivemodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT lingxuefengb machinelearningalgorithmfordiagnosisofmultisysteminflammatorysyndromeinchildrenandkawasakidiseaseintheusaaretrospectivemodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT cohenharveyj machinelearningalgorithmfordiagnosisofmultisysteminflammatorysyndromeinchildrenandkawasakidiseaseintheusaaretrospectivemodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT nematishamim machinelearningalgorithmfordiagnosisofmultisysteminflammatorysyndromeinchildrenandkawasakidiseaseintheusaaretrospectivemodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT burnsjanec machinelearningalgorithmfordiagnosisofmultisysteminflammatorysyndromeinchildrenandkawasakidiseaseintheusaaretrospectivemodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT machinelearningalgorithmfordiagnosisofmultisysteminflammatorysyndromeinchildrenandkawasakidiseaseintheusaaretrospectivemodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy
AT machinelearningalgorithmfordiagnosisofmultisysteminflammatorysyndromeinchildrenandkawasakidiseaseintheusaaretrospectivemodeldevelopmentandvalidationstudy