Cargando…

Establishment of a deep‐learning system to diagnose BI‐RADS4a or higher using breast ultrasound for clinical application

Although the categorization of ultrasound using the Breast Imaging Reporting and Data System (BI‐RADS) has become widespread worldwide, the problem of inter‐observer variability remains. To maintain uniformity in diagnostic accuracy, we have developed a system in which artificial intelligence (AI) c...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Hayashida, Tetsu, Odani, Erina, Kikuchi, Masayuki, Nagayama, Aiko, Seki, Tomoko, Takahashi, Maiko, Futatsugi, Noriyuki, Matsumoto, Akiko, Murata, Takeshi, Watanuki, Rurina, Yokoe, Takamichi, Nakashoji, Ayako, Maeda, Hinako, Onishi, Tatsuya, Asaga, Sota, Hojo, Takashi, Jinno, Hiromitsu, Sotome, Keiichi, Matsui, Akira, Suto, Akihiko, Imoto, Shigeru, Kitagawa, Yuko
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: John Wiley and Sons Inc. 2022
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9530860/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35880248
http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/cas.15511
_version_ 1784801775122907136
author Hayashida, Tetsu
Odani, Erina
Kikuchi, Masayuki
Nagayama, Aiko
Seki, Tomoko
Takahashi, Maiko
Futatsugi, Noriyuki
Matsumoto, Akiko
Murata, Takeshi
Watanuki, Rurina
Yokoe, Takamichi
Nakashoji, Ayako
Maeda, Hinako
Onishi, Tatsuya
Asaga, Sota
Hojo, Takashi
Jinno, Hiromitsu
Sotome, Keiichi
Matsui, Akira
Suto, Akihiko
Imoto, Shigeru
Kitagawa, Yuko
author_facet Hayashida, Tetsu
Odani, Erina
Kikuchi, Masayuki
Nagayama, Aiko
Seki, Tomoko
Takahashi, Maiko
Futatsugi, Noriyuki
Matsumoto, Akiko
Murata, Takeshi
Watanuki, Rurina
Yokoe, Takamichi
Nakashoji, Ayako
Maeda, Hinako
Onishi, Tatsuya
Asaga, Sota
Hojo, Takashi
Jinno, Hiromitsu
Sotome, Keiichi
Matsui, Akira
Suto, Akihiko
Imoto, Shigeru
Kitagawa, Yuko
author_sort Hayashida, Tetsu
collection PubMed
description Although the categorization of ultrasound using the Breast Imaging Reporting and Data System (BI‐RADS) has become widespread worldwide, the problem of inter‐observer variability remains. To maintain uniformity in diagnostic accuracy, we have developed a system in which artificial intelligence (AI) can distinguish whether a static image obtained using a breast ultrasound represents BI‐RADS3 or lower or BI‐RADS4a or higher to determine the medical management that should be performed on a patient whose breast ultrasound shows abnormalities. To establish and validate the AI system, a training dataset consisting of 4028 images containing 5014 lesions and a test dataset consisting of 3166 images containing 3656 lesions were collected and annotated. We selected a setting that maximized the area under the curve (AUC) and minimized the difference in sensitivity and specificity by adjusting the internal parameters of the AI system, achieving an AUC, sensitivity, and specificity of 0.95, 91.2%, and 90.7%, respectively. Furthermore, based on 30 images extracted from the test data, the diagnostic accuracy of 20 clinicians and the AI system was compared, and the AI system was found to be significantly superior to the clinicians (McNemar test, p < 0.001). Although deep‐learning methods to categorize benign and malignant tumors using breast ultrasound have been extensively reported, our work represents the first attempt to establish an AI system to classify BI‐RADS3 or lower and BI‐RADS4a or higher successfully, providing important implications for clinical actions. These results suggest that the AI diagnostic system is sufficient to proceed to the next stage of clinical application.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-9530860
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2022
publisher John Wiley and Sons Inc.
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-95308602022-10-11 Establishment of a deep‐learning system to diagnose BI‐RADS4a or higher using breast ultrasound for clinical application Hayashida, Tetsu Odani, Erina Kikuchi, Masayuki Nagayama, Aiko Seki, Tomoko Takahashi, Maiko Futatsugi, Noriyuki Matsumoto, Akiko Murata, Takeshi Watanuki, Rurina Yokoe, Takamichi Nakashoji, Ayako Maeda, Hinako Onishi, Tatsuya Asaga, Sota Hojo, Takashi Jinno, Hiromitsu Sotome, Keiichi Matsui, Akira Suto, Akihiko Imoto, Shigeru Kitagawa, Yuko Cancer Sci Original Articles Although the categorization of ultrasound using the Breast Imaging Reporting and Data System (BI‐RADS) has become widespread worldwide, the problem of inter‐observer variability remains. To maintain uniformity in diagnostic accuracy, we have developed a system in which artificial intelligence (AI) can distinguish whether a static image obtained using a breast ultrasound represents BI‐RADS3 or lower or BI‐RADS4a or higher to determine the medical management that should be performed on a patient whose breast ultrasound shows abnormalities. To establish and validate the AI system, a training dataset consisting of 4028 images containing 5014 lesions and a test dataset consisting of 3166 images containing 3656 lesions were collected and annotated. We selected a setting that maximized the area under the curve (AUC) and minimized the difference in sensitivity and specificity by adjusting the internal parameters of the AI system, achieving an AUC, sensitivity, and specificity of 0.95, 91.2%, and 90.7%, respectively. Furthermore, based on 30 images extracted from the test data, the diagnostic accuracy of 20 clinicians and the AI system was compared, and the AI system was found to be significantly superior to the clinicians (McNemar test, p < 0.001). Although deep‐learning methods to categorize benign and malignant tumors using breast ultrasound have been extensively reported, our work represents the first attempt to establish an AI system to classify BI‐RADS3 or lower and BI‐RADS4a or higher successfully, providing important implications for clinical actions. These results suggest that the AI diagnostic system is sufficient to proceed to the next stage of clinical application. John Wiley and Sons Inc. 2022-08-03 2022-10 /pmc/articles/PMC9530860/ /pubmed/35880248 http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/cas.15511 Text en © 2022 The Authors. Cancer Science published by John Wiley & Sons Australia, Ltd on behalf of Japanese Cancer Association. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/This is an open access article under the terms of the http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/) License, which permits use and distribution in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited, the use is non‐commercial and no modifications or adaptations are made.
spellingShingle Original Articles
Hayashida, Tetsu
Odani, Erina
Kikuchi, Masayuki
Nagayama, Aiko
Seki, Tomoko
Takahashi, Maiko
Futatsugi, Noriyuki
Matsumoto, Akiko
Murata, Takeshi
Watanuki, Rurina
Yokoe, Takamichi
Nakashoji, Ayako
Maeda, Hinako
Onishi, Tatsuya
Asaga, Sota
Hojo, Takashi
Jinno, Hiromitsu
Sotome, Keiichi
Matsui, Akira
Suto, Akihiko
Imoto, Shigeru
Kitagawa, Yuko
Establishment of a deep‐learning system to diagnose BI‐RADS4a or higher using breast ultrasound for clinical application
title Establishment of a deep‐learning system to diagnose BI‐RADS4a or higher using breast ultrasound for clinical application
title_full Establishment of a deep‐learning system to diagnose BI‐RADS4a or higher using breast ultrasound for clinical application
title_fullStr Establishment of a deep‐learning system to diagnose BI‐RADS4a or higher using breast ultrasound for clinical application
title_full_unstemmed Establishment of a deep‐learning system to diagnose BI‐RADS4a or higher using breast ultrasound for clinical application
title_short Establishment of a deep‐learning system to diagnose BI‐RADS4a or higher using breast ultrasound for clinical application
title_sort establishment of a deep‐learning system to diagnose bi‐rads4a or higher using breast ultrasound for clinical application
topic Original Articles
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9530860/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35880248
http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/cas.15511
work_keys_str_mv AT hayashidatetsu establishmentofadeeplearningsystemtodiagnosebirads4aorhigherusingbreastultrasoundforclinicalapplication
AT odanierina establishmentofadeeplearningsystemtodiagnosebirads4aorhigherusingbreastultrasoundforclinicalapplication
AT kikuchimasayuki establishmentofadeeplearningsystemtodiagnosebirads4aorhigherusingbreastultrasoundforclinicalapplication
AT nagayamaaiko establishmentofadeeplearningsystemtodiagnosebirads4aorhigherusingbreastultrasoundforclinicalapplication
AT sekitomoko establishmentofadeeplearningsystemtodiagnosebirads4aorhigherusingbreastultrasoundforclinicalapplication
AT takahashimaiko establishmentofadeeplearningsystemtodiagnosebirads4aorhigherusingbreastultrasoundforclinicalapplication
AT futatsuginoriyuki establishmentofadeeplearningsystemtodiagnosebirads4aorhigherusingbreastultrasoundforclinicalapplication
AT matsumotoakiko establishmentofadeeplearningsystemtodiagnosebirads4aorhigherusingbreastultrasoundforclinicalapplication
AT muratatakeshi establishmentofadeeplearningsystemtodiagnosebirads4aorhigherusingbreastultrasoundforclinicalapplication
AT watanukirurina establishmentofadeeplearningsystemtodiagnosebirads4aorhigherusingbreastultrasoundforclinicalapplication
AT yokoetakamichi establishmentofadeeplearningsystemtodiagnosebirads4aorhigherusingbreastultrasoundforclinicalapplication
AT nakashojiayako establishmentofadeeplearningsystemtodiagnosebirads4aorhigherusingbreastultrasoundforclinicalapplication
AT maedahinako establishmentofadeeplearningsystemtodiagnosebirads4aorhigherusingbreastultrasoundforclinicalapplication
AT onishitatsuya establishmentofadeeplearningsystemtodiagnosebirads4aorhigherusingbreastultrasoundforclinicalapplication
AT asagasota establishmentofadeeplearningsystemtodiagnosebirads4aorhigherusingbreastultrasoundforclinicalapplication
AT hojotakashi establishmentofadeeplearningsystemtodiagnosebirads4aorhigherusingbreastultrasoundforclinicalapplication
AT jinnohiromitsu establishmentofadeeplearningsystemtodiagnosebirads4aorhigherusingbreastultrasoundforclinicalapplication
AT sotomekeiichi establishmentofadeeplearningsystemtodiagnosebirads4aorhigherusingbreastultrasoundforclinicalapplication
AT matsuiakira establishmentofadeeplearningsystemtodiagnosebirads4aorhigherusingbreastultrasoundforclinicalapplication
AT sutoakihiko establishmentofadeeplearningsystemtodiagnosebirads4aorhigherusingbreastultrasoundforclinicalapplication
AT imotoshigeru establishmentofadeeplearningsystemtodiagnosebirads4aorhigherusingbreastultrasoundforclinicalapplication
AT kitagawayuko establishmentofadeeplearningsystemtodiagnosebirads4aorhigherusingbreastultrasoundforclinicalapplication