Cargando…

Confirmed disability progression as a marker of permanent disability in multiple sclerosis

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: The prevention of disability over the long term is the main treatment goal in multiple sclerosis (MS); however, randomized clinical trials evaluate only short‐term treatment effects on disability. This study aimed to define criteria for 6‐month confirmed disability progressio...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Sharmin, Sifat, Bovis, Francesca, Malpas, Charles, Horakova, Dana, Havrdova, Eva Kubala, Izquierdo, Guillermo, Eichau, Sara, Trojano, Maria, Prat, Alexandre, Girard, Marc, Duquette, Pierre, Onofrj, Marco, Lugaresi, Alessandra, Grand'Maison, Francois, Grammond, Pierre, Sola, Patrizia, Ferraro, Diana, Terzi, Murat, Gerlach, Oliver, Alroughani, Raed, Boz, Cavit, Shaygannejad, Vahid, van Pesch, Vincent, Cartechini, Elisabetta, Kappos, Ludwig, Lechner‐Scott, Jeannette, Bergamaschi, Roberto, Turkoglu, Recai, Solaro, Claudio, Iuliano, Gerardo, Granella, Franco, Van Wijmeersch, Bart, Spitaleri, Daniele, Slee, Mark, McCombe, Pamela, Prevost, Julie, Ampapa, Radek, Ozakbas, Serkan, Sanchez‐Menoyo, Jose Luis, Soysal, Aysun, Vucic, Steve, Petersen, Thor, de Gans, Koen, Butler, Ernest, Hodgkinson, Suzanne, Sidhom, Youssef, Gouider, Riadh, Cristiano, Edgardo, Castillo‐Triviño, Tamara, Saladino, Maria Laura, Barnett, Michael, Moore, Fraser, Rozsa, Csilla, Yamout, Bassem, Skibina, Olga, van der Walt, Anneke, Buzzard, Katherine, Gray, Orla, Hughes, Stella, Sempere, Angel Perez, Singhal, Bhim, Fragoso, Yara, Shaw, Cameron, Kermode, Allan, Taylor, Bruce, Simo, Magdolna, Shuey, Neil, Al‐Harbi, Talal, Macdonell, Richard, Dominguez, Jose Andres, Csepany, Tunde, Sirbu, Carmen Adella, Sormani, Maria Pia, Butzkueven, Helmut, Kalincik, Tomas
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: John Wiley and Sons Inc. 2022
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9539581/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35582938
http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/ene.15406
_version_ 1784803519974342656
author Sharmin, Sifat
Bovis, Francesca
Malpas, Charles
Horakova, Dana
Havrdova, Eva Kubala
Izquierdo, Guillermo
Eichau, Sara
Trojano, Maria
Prat, Alexandre
Girard, Marc
Duquette, Pierre
Onofrj, Marco
Lugaresi, Alessandra
Grand'Maison, Francois
Grammond, Pierre
Sola, Patrizia
Ferraro, Diana
Terzi, Murat
Gerlach, Oliver
Alroughani, Raed
Boz, Cavit
Shaygannejad, Vahid
van Pesch, Vincent
Cartechini, Elisabetta
Kappos, Ludwig
Lechner‐Scott, Jeannette
Bergamaschi, Roberto
Turkoglu, Recai
Solaro, Claudio
Iuliano, Gerardo
Granella, Franco
Van Wijmeersch, Bart
Spitaleri, Daniele
Slee, Mark
McCombe, Pamela
Prevost, Julie
Ampapa, Radek
Ozakbas, Serkan
Sanchez‐Menoyo, Jose Luis
Soysal, Aysun
Vucic, Steve
Petersen, Thor
de Gans, Koen
Butler, Ernest
Hodgkinson, Suzanne
Sidhom, Youssef
Gouider, Riadh
Cristiano, Edgardo
Castillo‐Triviño, Tamara
Saladino, Maria Laura
Barnett, Michael
Moore, Fraser
Rozsa, Csilla
Yamout, Bassem
Skibina, Olga
van der Walt, Anneke
Buzzard, Katherine
Gray, Orla
Hughes, Stella
Sempere, Angel Perez
Singhal, Bhim
Fragoso, Yara
Shaw, Cameron
Kermode, Allan
Taylor, Bruce
Simo, Magdolna
Shuey, Neil
Al‐Harbi, Talal
Macdonell, Richard
Dominguez, Jose Andres
Csepany, Tunde
Sirbu, Carmen Adella
Sormani, Maria Pia
Butzkueven, Helmut
Kalincik, Tomas
author_facet Sharmin, Sifat
Bovis, Francesca
Malpas, Charles
Horakova, Dana
Havrdova, Eva Kubala
Izquierdo, Guillermo
Eichau, Sara
Trojano, Maria
Prat, Alexandre
Girard, Marc
Duquette, Pierre
Onofrj, Marco
Lugaresi, Alessandra
Grand'Maison, Francois
Grammond, Pierre
Sola, Patrizia
Ferraro, Diana
Terzi, Murat
Gerlach, Oliver
Alroughani, Raed
Boz, Cavit
Shaygannejad, Vahid
van Pesch, Vincent
Cartechini, Elisabetta
Kappos, Ludwig
Lechner‐Scott, Jeannette
Bergamaschi, Roberto
Turkoglu, Recai
Solaro, Claudio
Iuliano, Gerardo
Granella, Franco
Van Wijmeersch, Bart
Spitaleri, Daniele
Slee, Mark
McCombe, Pamela
Prevost, Julie
Ampapa, Radek
Ozakbas, Serkan
Sanchez‐Menoyo, Jose Luis
Soysal, Aysun
Vucic, Steve
Petersen, Thor
de Gans, Koen
Butler, Ernest
Hodgkinson, Suzanne
Sidhom, Youssef
Gouider, Riadh
Cristiano, Edgardo
Castillo‐Triviño, Tamara
Saladino, Maria Laura
Barnett, Michael
Moore, Fraser
Rozsa, Csilla
Yamout, Bassem
Skibina, Olga
van der Walt, Anneke
Buzzard, Katherine
Gray, Orla
Hughes, Stella
Sempere, Angel Perez
Singhal, Bhim
Fragoso, Yara
Shaw, Cameron
Kermode, Allan
Taylor, Bruce
Simo, Magdolna
Shuey, Neil
Al‐Harbi, Talal
Macdonell, Richard
Dominguez, Jose Andres
Csepany, Tunde
Sirbu, Carmen Adella
Sormani, Maria Pia
Butzkueven, Helmut
Kalincik, Tomas
author_sort Sharmin, Sifat
collection PubMed
description BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: The prevention of disability over the long term is the main treatment goal in multiple sclerosis (MS); however, randomized clinical trials evaluate only short‐term treatment effects on disability. This study aimed to define criteria for 6‐month confirmed disability progression events of MS with a high probability of resulting in sustained long‐term disability worsening. METHODS: In total, 14,802 6‐month confirmed disability progression events were identified in 8741 patients from the global MSBase registry. For each 6‐month confirmed progression event (13,321 in the development and 1481 in the validation cohort), a sustained progression score was calculated based on the demographic and clinical characteristics at the time of progression that were predictive of long‐term disability worsening. The score was externally validated in the Cladribine Tablets Treating Multiple Sclerosis Orally (CLARITY) trial. RESULTS: The score was based on age, sex, MS phenotype, relapse activity, disability score and its change from baseline, number of affected functional system domains and worsening in six of the domains. In the internal validation cohort, a 61% lower chance of improvement was estimated with each unit increase in the score (hazard ratio 0.39, 95% confidence interval 0.29–0.52; discriminatory index 0.89). The proportions of progression events sustained at 5 years stratified by the score were 1: 72%; 2: 88%; 3: 94%; 4: 100%. The results of the CLARITY trial were confirmed for reduction of disability progression that was >88% likely to be sustained (events with score ˃1.5). CONCLUSIONS: Clinicodemographic characteristics of 6‐month confirmed disability progression events identify those at high risk of sustained long‐term disability. This knowledge will allow future trials to better assess the effect of therapy on long‐term disability accrual.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-9539581
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2022
publisher John Wiley and Sons Inc.
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-95395812022-10-14 Confirmed disability progression as a marker of permanent disability in multiple sclerosis Sharmin, Sifat Bovis, Francesca Malpas, Charles Horakova, Dana Havrdova, Eva Kubala Izquierdo, Guillermo Eichau, Sara Trojano, Maria Prat, Alexandre Girard, Marc Duquette, Pierre Onofrj, Marco Lugaresi, Alessandra Grand'Maison, Francois Grammond, Pierre Sola, Patrizia Ferraro, Diana Terzi, Murat Gerlach, Oliver Alroughani, Raed Boz, Cavit Shaygannejad, Vahid van Pesch, Vincent Cartechini, Elisabetta Kappos, Ludwig Lechner‐Scott, Jeannette Bergamaschi, Roberto Turkoglu, Recai Solaro, Claudio Iuliano, Gerardo Granella, Franco Van Wijmeersch, Bart Spitaleri, Daniele Slee, Mark McCombe, Pamela Prevost, Julie Ampapa, Radek Ozakbas, Serkan Sanchez‐Menoyo, Jose Luis Soysal, Aysun Vucic, Steve Petersen, Thor de Gans, Koen Butler, Ernest Hodgkinson, Suzanne Sidhom, Youssef Gouider, Riadh Cristiano, Edgardo Castillo‐Triviño, Tamara Saladino, Maria Laura Barnett, Michael Moore, Fraser Rozsa, Csilla Yamout, Bassem Skibina, Olga van der Walt, Anneke Buzzard, Katherine Gray, Orla Hughes, Stella Sempere, Angel Perez Singhal, Bhim Fragoso, Yara Shaw, Cameron Kermode, Allan Taylor, Bruce Simo, Magdolna Shuey, Neil Al‐Harbi, Talal Macdonell, Richard Dominguez, Jose Andres Csepany, Tunde Sirbu, Carmen Adella Sormani, Maria Pia Butzkueven, Helmut Kalincik, Tomas Eur J Neurol Multiple Sclerosis BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: The prevention of disability over the long term is the main treatment goal in multiple sclerosis (MS); however, randomized clinical trials evaluate only short‐term treatment effects on disability. This study aimed to define criteria for 6‐month confirmed disability progression events of MS with a high probability of resulting in sustained long‐term disability worsening. METHODS: In total, 14,802 6‐month confirmed disability progression events were identified in 8741 patients from the global MSBase registry. For each 6‐month confirmed progression event (13,321 in the development and 1481 in the validation cohort), a sustained progression score was calculated based on the demographic and clinical characteristics at the time of progression that were predictive of long‐term disability worsening. The score was externally validated in the Cladribine Tablets Treating Multiple Sclerosis Orally (CLARITY) trial. RESULTS: The score was based on age, sex, MS phenotype, relapse activity, disability score and its change from baseline, number of affected functional system domains and worsening in six of the domains. In the internal validation cohort, a 61% lower chance of improvement was estimated with each unit increase in the score (hazard ratio 0.39, 95% confidence interval 0.29–0.52; discriminatory index 0.89). The proportions of progression events sustained at 5 years stratified by the score were 1: 72%; 2: 88%; 3: 94%; 4: 100%. The results of the CLARITY trial were confirmed for reduction of disability progression that was >88% likely to be sustained (events with score ˃1.5). CONCLUSIONS: Clinicodemographic characteristics of 6‐month confirmed disability progression events identify those at high risk of sustained long‐term disability. This knowledge will allow future trials to better assess the effect of therapy on long‐term disability accrual. John Wiley and Sons Inc. 2022-06-09 2022-08 /pmc/articles/PMC9539581/ /pubmed/35582938 http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/ene.15406 Text en © 2022 The Authors. European Journal of Neurology published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd on behalf of European Academy of Neurology. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/This is an open access article under the terms of the http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/ (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/) License, which permits use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited and is not used for commercial purposes.
spellingShingle Multiple Sclerosis
Sharmin, Sifat
Bovis, Francesca
Malpas, Charles
Horakova, Dana
Havrdova, Eva Kubala
Izquierdo, Guillermo
Eichau, Sara
Trojano, Maria
Prat, Alexandre
Girard, Marc
Duquette, Pierre
Onofrj, Marco
Lugaresi, Alessandra
Grand'Maison, Francois
Grammond, Pierre
Sola, Patrizia
Ferraro, Diana
Terzi, Murat
Gerlach, Oliver
Alroughani, Raed
Boz, Cavit
Shaygannejad, Vahid
van Pesch, Vincent
Cartechini, Elisabetta
Kappos, Ludwig
Lechner‐Scott, Jeannette
Bergamaschi, Roberto
Turkoglu, Recai
Solaro, Claudio
Iuliano, Gerardo
Granella, Franco
Van Wijmeersch, Bart
Spitaleri, Daniele
Slee, Mark
McCombe, Pamela
Prevost, Julie
Ampapa, Radek
Ozakbas, Serkan
Sanchez‐Menoyo, Jose Luis
Soysal, Aysun
Vucic, Steve
Petersen, Thor
de Gans, Koen
Butler, Ernest
Hodgkinson, Suzanne
Sidhom, Youssef
Gouider, Riadh
Cristiano, Edgardo
Castillo‐Triviño, Tamara
Saladino, Maria Laura
Barnett, Michael
Moore, Fraser
Rozsa, Csilla
Yamout, Bassem
Skibina, Olga
van der Walt, Anneke
Buzzard, Katherine
Gray, Orla
Hughes, Stella
Sempere, Angel Perez
Singhal, Bhim
Fragoso, Yara
Shaw, Cameron
Kermode, Allan
Taylor, Bruce
Simo, Magdolna
Shuey, Neil
Al‐Harbi, Talal
Macdonell, Richard
Dominguez, Jose Andres
Csepany, Tunde
Sirbu, Carmen Adella
Sormani, Maria Pia
Butzkueven, Helmut
Kalincik, Tomas
Confirmed disability progression as a marker of permanent disability in multiple sclerosis
title Confirmed disability progression as a marker of permanent disability in multiple sclerosis
title_full Confirmed disability progression as a marker of permanent disability in multiple sclerosis
title_fullStr Confirmed disability progression as a marker of permanent disability in multiple sclerosis
title_full_unstemmed Confirmed disability progression as a marker of permanent disability in multiple sclerosis
title_short Confirmed disability progression as a marker of permanent disability in multiple sclerosis
title_sort confirmed disability progression as a marker of permanent disability in multiple sclerosis
topic Multiple Sclerosis
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9539581/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35582938
http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/ene.15406
work_keys_str_mv AT sharminsifat confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT bovisfrancesca confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT malpascharles confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT horakovadana confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT havrdovaevakubala confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT izquierdoguillermo confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT eichausara confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT trojanomaria confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT pratalexandre confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT girardmarc confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT duquettepierre confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT onofrjmarco confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT lugaresialessandra confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT grandmaisonfrancois confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT grammondpierre confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT solapatrizia confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT ferrarodiana confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT terzimurat confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT gerlacholiver confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT alroughaniraed confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT bozcavit confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT shaygannejadvahid confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT vanpeschvincent confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT cartechinielisabetta confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT kapposludwig confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT lechnerscottjeannette confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT bergamaschiroberto confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT turkoglurecai confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT solaroclaudio confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT iulianogerardo confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT granellafranco confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT vanwijmeerschbart confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT spitaleridaniele confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT sleemark confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT mccombepamela confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT prevostjulie confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT ampaparadek confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT ozakbasserkan confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT sanchezmenoyojoseluis confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT soysalaysun confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT vucicsteve confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT petersenthor confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT deganskoen confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT butlerernest confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT hodgkinsonsuzanne confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT sidhomyoussef confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT gouiderriadh confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT cristianoedgardo confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT castillotrivinotamara confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT saladinomarialaura confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT barnettmichael confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT moorefraser confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT rozsacsilla confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT yamoutbassem confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT skibinaolga confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT vanderwaltanneke confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT buzzardkatherine confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT grayorla confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT hughesstella confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT sempereangelperez confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT singhalbhim confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT fragosoyara confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT shawcameron confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT kermodeallan confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT taylorbruce confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT simomagdolna confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT shueyneil confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT alharbitalal confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT macdonellrichard confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT dominguezjoseandres confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT csepanytunde confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT sirbucarmenadella confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT sormanimariapia confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT butzkuevenhelmut confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis
AT kalinciktomas confirmeddisabilityprogressionasamarkerofpermanentdisabilityinmultiplesclerosis