Cargando…

A survey of local diagnostic reference levels for the head, thorax, abdomen and pelvis computed tomography in Norway and Canada

BACKGROUND: Computed tomography (CT) contributes to 60% of the collective dose in medical imaging. Literature has demonstrated that patient dose varies across regions and countries. Establishing diagnostic reference levels (DRLs) contributes to the optimization of clinical practices and radiation pr...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Tonkopi, Elena, Wikan, Eline Jahre, Hovland, Tor Olav, Høgset, Sivert, Kofod, Thomas Alexander, Sefenu, Selasi K, Hughes-Ryan, Emily, d´Entremont-O´Connell, Dakota, Gunn, Catherine, Holter, Tanja, Johansen, Safora
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: SAGE Publications 2022
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9549116/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36225897
http://dx.doi.org/10.1177/20584601221131477
_version_ 1784805595876950016
author Tonkopi, Elena
Wikan, Eline Jahre
Hovland, Tor Olav
Høgset, Sivert
Kofod, Thomas Alexander
Sefenu, Selasi K
Hughes-Ryan, Emily
d´Entremont-O´Connell, Dakota
Gunn, Catherine
Holter, Tanja
Johansen, Safora
author_facet Tonkopi, Elena
Wikan, Eline Jahre
Hovland, Tor Olav
Høgset, Sivert
Kofod, Thomas Alexander
Sefenu, Selasi K
Hughes-Ryan, Emily
d´Entremont-O´Connell, Dakota
Gunn, Catherine
Holter, Tanja
Johansen, Safora
author_sort Tonkopi, Elena
collection PubMed
description BACKGROUND: Computed tomography (CT) contributes to 60% of the collective dose in medical imaging. Literature has demonstrated that patient dose varies across regions and countries. Establishing diagnostic reference levels (DRLs) contributes to the optimization of clinical practices and radiation protection. PURPOSE: To survey the dose indices (CTDIvol and dose-length product) for frequently performed CT examinations from the chosen hospitals in Norway and Canada and to determine local DRLs (LDRLs) based on the collected data. MATERIAL AND METHODS: The survey included eight scanners from two Norwegian hospitals and four scanners from four Canadian hospitals. Dosimetry data were collected for the following routine CT examinations: head, contrast-enhanced thorax, and abdomen and pelvis. Overall 480 adult average-sized patients from Norway and 360 from Canada were included in the survey. The LDRLs were determined as the 75th percentile of distributions of median values of dose indicators from different CT scanners. The differences in dose between scanners were determined using single-factor ANOVA. RESULTS: The LDRLs determined in Norway were higher overall than in Canada. The obtained values were compared to the national DRLs. The dose from several scanners in Norway exceeded national Norwegian DRLs, while Canadian LDRLs were below the Canadian reference levels. The differences between the means of the dose distributions from each scanner were statistically significant (p < 0.05) for all examinations with exception of identical scanners located in the same hospital and using the same protocols. CONCLUSION: Observed dose variations even in the same hospital, or from the same scanner model confirmed the need for CT protocol optimization.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-9549116
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2022
publisher SAGE Publications
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-95491162022-10-11 A survey of local diagnostic reference levels for the head, thorax, abdomen and pelvis computed tomography in Norway and Canada Tonkopi, Elena Wikan, Eline Jahre Hovland, Tor Olav Høgset, Sivert Kofod, Thomas Alexander Sefenu, Selasi K Hughes-Ryan, Emily d´Entremont-O´Connell, Dakota Gunn, Catherine Holter, Tanja Johansen, Safora Acta Radiol Open Original Article BACKGROUND: Computed tomography (CT) contributes to 60% of the collective dose in medical imaging. Literature has demonstrated that patient dose varies across regions and countries. Establishing diagnostic reference levels (DRLs) contributes to the optimization of clinical practices and radiation protection. PURPOSE: To survey the dose indices (CTDIvol and dose-length product) for frequently performed CT examinations from the chosen hospitals in Norway and Canada and to determine local DRLs (LDRLs) based on the collected data. MATERIAL AND METHODS: The survey included eight scanners from two Norwegian hospitals and four scanners from four Canadian hospitals. Dosimetry data were collected for the following routine CT examinations: head, contrast-enhanced thorax, and abdomen and pelvis. Overall 480 adult average-sized patients from Norway and 360 from Canada were included in the survey. The LDRLs were determined as the 75th percentile of distributions of median values of dose indicators from different CT scanners. The differences in dose between scanners were determined using single-factor ANOVA. RESULTS: The LDRLs determined in Norway were higher overall than in Canada. The obtained values were compared to the national DRLs. The dose from several scanners in Norway exceeded national Norwegian DRLs, while Canadian LDRLs were below the Canadian reference levels. The differences between the means of the dose distributions from each scanner were statistically significant (p < 0.05) for all examinations with exception of identical scanners located in the same hospital and using the same protocols. CONCLUSION: Observed dose variations even in the same hospital, or from the same scanner model confirmed the need for CT protocol optimization. SAGE Publications 2022-10-07 /pmc/articles/PMC9549116/ /pubmed/36225897 http://dx.doi.org/10.1177/20584601221131477 Text en © The Author(s) 2022 https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/) which permits non-commercial use, reproduction and distribution of the work without further permission provided the original work is attributed as specified on the SAGE and Open Access pages (https://us.sagepub.com/en-us/nam/open-access-at-sage).
spellingShingle Original Article
Tonkopi, Elena
Wikan, Eline Jahre
Hovland, Tor Olav
Høgset, Sivert
Kofod, Thomas Alexander
Sefenu, Selasi K
Hughes-Ryan, Emily
d´Entremont-O´Connell, Dakota
Gunn, Catherine
Holter, Tanja
Johansen, Safora
A survey of local diagnostic reference levels for the head, thorax, abdomen and pelvis computed tomography in Norway and Canada
title A survey of local diagnostic reference levels for the head, thorax, abdomen and pelvis computed tomography in Norway and Canada
title_full A survey of local diagnostic reference levels for the head, thorax, abdomen and pelvis computed tomography in Norway and Canada
title_fullStr A survey of local diagnostic reference levels for the head, thorax, abdomen and pelvis computed tomography in Norway and Canada
title_full_unstemmed A survey of local diagnostic reference levels for the head, thorax, abdomen and pelvis computed tomography in Norway and Canada
title_short A survey of local diagnostic reference levels for the head, thorax, abdomen and pelvis computed tomography in Norway and Canada
title_sort survey of local diagnostic reference levels for the head, thorax, abdomen and pelvis computed tomography in norway and canada
topic Original Article
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9549116/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36225897
http://dx.doi.org/10.1177/20584601221131477
work_keys_str_mv AT tonkopielena asurveyoflocaldiagnosticreferencelevelsfortheheadthoraxabdomenandpelviscomputedtomographyinnorwayandcanada
AT wikanelinejahre asurveyoflocaldiagnosticreferencelevelsfortheheadthoraxabdomenandpelviscomputedtomographyinnorwayandcanada
AT hovlandtorolav asurveyoflocaldiagnosticreferencelevelsfortheheadthoraxabdomenandpelviscomputedtomographyinnorwayandcanada
AT høgsetsivert asurveyoflocaldiagnosticreferencelevelsfortheheadthoraxabdomenandpelviscomputedtomographyinnorwayandcanada
AT kofodthomasalexander asurveyoflocaldiagnosticreferencelevelsfortheheadthoraxabdomenandpelviscomputedtomographyinnorwayandcanada
AT sefenuselasik asurveyoflocaldiagnosticreferencelevelsfortheheadthoraxabdomenandpelviscomputedtomographyinnorwayandcanada
AT hughesryanemily asurveyoflocaldiagnosticreferencelevelsfortheheadthoraxabdomenandpelviscomputedtomographyinnorwayandcanada
AT dentremontoconnelldakota asurveyoflocaldiagnosticreferencelevelsfortheheadthoraxabdomenandpelviscomputedtomographyinnorwayandcanada
AT gunncatherine asurveyoflocaldiagnosticreferencelevelsfortheheadthoraxabdomenandpelviscomputedtomographyinnorwayandcanada
AT holtertanja asurveyoflocaldiagnosticreferencelevelsfortheheadthoraxabdomenandpelviscomputedtomographyinnorwayandcanada
AT johansensafora asurveyoflocaldiagnosticreferencelevelsfortheheadthoraxabdomenandpelviscomputedtomographyinnorwayandcanada
AT tonkopielena surveyoflocaldiagnosticreferencelevelsfortheheadthoraxabdomenandpelviscomputedtomographyinnorwayandcanada
AT wikanelinejahre surveyoflocaldiagnosticreferencelevelsfortheheadthoraxabdomenandpelviscomputedtomographyinnorwayandcanada
AT hovlandtorolav surveyoflocaldiagnosticreferencelevelsfortheheadthoraxabdomenandpelviscomputedtomographyinnorwayandcanada
AT høgsetsivert surveyoflocaldiagnosticreferencelevelsfortheheadthoraxabdomenandpelviscomputedtomographyinnorwayandcanada
AT kofodthomasalexander surveyoflocaldiagnosticreferencelevelsfortheheadthoraxabdomenandpelviscomputedtomographyinnorwayandcanada
AT sefenuselasik surveyoflocaldiagnosticreferencelevelsfortheheadthoraxabdomenandpelviscomputedtomographyinnorwayandcanada
AT hughesryanemily surveyoflocaldiagnosticreferencelevelsfortheheadthoraxabdomenandpelviscomputedtomographyinnorwayandcanada
AT dentremontoconnelldakota surveyoflocaldiagnosticreferencelevelsfortheheadthoraxabdomenandpelviscomputedtomographyinnorwayandcanada
AT gunncatherine surveyoflocaldiagnosticreferencelevelsfortheheadthoraxabdomenandpelviscomputedtomographyinnorwayandcanada
AT holtertanja surveyoflocaldiagnosticreferencelevelsfortheheadthoraxabdomenandpelviscomputedtomographyinnorwayandcanada
AT johansensafora surveyoflocaldiagnosticreferencelevelsfortheheadthoraxabdomenandpelviscomputedtomographyinnorwayandcanada