Cargando…

Beyond bariatric surgery and weight loss medicaments. A systematic review of the current practice in obesity rehabilitative inpatient programs in adults and pediatrics

BACKGROUND: Obesity treatment strategies mainly include outpatient lifestyle modification, drugs and bariatric surgery. Voluntary rehabilitative inpatient programs are gaining relevance as potential alternative settings of care that focus on weight loss and prevention of weight regain through a mult...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Spadaccini, Daniele, Guazzotti, Silvia, Goncalves Correia, Filipa Patricia, Daffara, Tommaso, Tini, Sabrina, Antonioli, Alessandro, Aimaretti, Gianluca, Marzullo, Paolo, Caputo, Marina, Antoniotti, Valentina, Prodam, Flavia
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Frontiers Media S.A. 2022
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9556721/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36245519
http://dx.doi.org/10.3389/fnut.2022.963709
_version_ 1784807129644793856
author Spadaccini, Daniele
Guazzotti, Silvia
Goncalves Correia, Filipa Patricia
Daffara, Tommaso
Tini, Sabrina
Antonioli, Alessandro
Aimaretti, Gianluca
Marzullo, Paolo
Caputo, Marina
Antoniotti, Valentina
Prodam, Flavia
author_facet Spadaccini, Daniele
Guazzotti, Silvia
Goncalves Correia, Filipa Patricia
Daffara, Tommaso
Tini, Sabrina
Antonioli, Alessandro
Aimaretti, Gianluca
Marzullo, Paolo
Caputo, Marina
Antoniotti, Valentina
Prodam, Flavia
author_sort Spadaccini, Daniele
collection PubMed
description BACKGROUND: Obesity treatment strategies mainly include outpatient lifestyle modification, drugs and bariatric surgery. Voluntary rehabilitative inpatient programs are gaining relevance as potential alternative settings of care that focus on weight loss and prevention of weight regain through a multidisciplinary approach, but their prevalence is still limited due to the high costs. AIM: Considering the lack of evidence in this area, the objective of this study is to systematically review the currently available literature on non-pharmacological and non-surgical inpatient programs aimed at weight loss, to clarify the efficacy and the characteristics of these interventions. METHODS: Proper English language articles from 2000 to 2022 were searched on relevant databases. Quality assessment was performed by two different authors using ROB2 and robvis tools. Adult and pediatric studies were reviewed separately and their characteristics were systematically displayed. RESULTS: 36 articles were included (20 on adults, 16 on children, and adolescents) for a total of 5,510 individuals. The multidisciplinary approach was mainly comprehensive of a low-calorie diet, scheduled physical activity, and psychological support based on behavioral treatment. Educational and cooking sessions were present at a lower rate. Globally, inpatient weight loss programs showed a consistent efficacy in reducing body weight and inducing beneficial effects on quality of life, psychological well-being, eating behavior, physical performance, and fatigue. Follow-up data were scarce, but with a high percentage of patients regaining weight after a short period. CONCLUSION: Weight loss inpatient rehabilitation is a promising area that has evidence of all-rounded success in the amelioration of several aspects related to obesity. Nevertheless, it appears to be quite inconsistent in preserving these benefits after the intervention. This might slow the innovation process in this area and preclude further investments from national healthcare. Personalized and enriched programs could show greater impact when focusing on the behavioral and educational aspects, which are crucial points, in particular in pediatrics, for setting up a long-lasting lifestyle modification. More studies are therefore necessary to evaluate long-term efficacy based on the different work-up models.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-9556721
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2022
publisher Frontiers Media S.A.
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-95567212022-10-14 Beyond bariatric surgery and weight loss medicaments. A systematic review of the current practice in obesity rehabilitative inpatient programs in adults and pediatrics Spadaccini, Daniele Guazzotti, Silvia Goncalves Correia, Filipa Patricia Daffara, Tommaso Tini, Sabrina Antonioli, Alessandro Aimaretti, Gianluca Marzullo, Paolo Caputo, Marina Antoniotti, Valentina Prodam, Flavia Front Nutr Nutrition BACKGROUND: Obesity treatment strategies mainly include outpatient lifestyle modification, drugs and bariatric surgery. Voluntary rehabilitative inpatient programs are gaining relevance as potential alternative settings of care that focus on weight loss and prevention of weight regain through a multidisciplinary approach, but their prevalence is still limited due to the high costs. AIM: Considering the lack of evidence in this area, the objective of this study is to systematically review the currently available literature on non-pharmacological and non-surgical inpatient programs aimed at weight loss, to clarify the efficacy and the characteristics of these interventions. METHODS: Proper English language articles from 2000 to 2022 were searched on relevant databases. Quality assessment was performed by two different authors using ROB2 and robvis tools. Adult and pediatric studies were reviewed separately and their characteristics were systematically displayed. RESULTS: 36 articles were included (20 on adults, 16 on children, and adolescents) for a total of 5,510 individuals. The multidisciplinary approach was mainly comprehensive of a low-calorie diet, scheduled physical activity, and psychological support based on behavioral treatment. Educational and cooking sessions were present at a lower rate. Globally, inpatient weight loss programs showed a consistent efficacy in reducing body weight and inducing beneficial effects on quality of life, psychological well-being, eating behavior, physical performance, and fatigue. Follow-up data were scarce, but with a high percentage of patients regaining weight after a short period. CONCLUSION: Weight loss inpatient rehabilitation is a promising area that has evidence of all-rounded success in the amelioration of several aspects related to obesity. Nevertheless, it appears to be quite inconsistent in preserving these benefits after the intervention. This might slow the innovation process in this area and preclude further investments from national healthcare. Personalized and enriched programs could show greater impact when focusing on the behavioral and educational aspects, which are crucial points, in particular in pediatrics, for setting up a long-lasting lifestyle modification. More studies are therefore necessary to evaluate long-term efficacy based on the different work-up models. Frontiers Media S.A. 2022-09-29 /pmc/articles/PMC9556721/ /pubmed/36245519 http://dx.doi.org/10.3389/fnut.2022.963709 Text en Copyright © 2022 Spadaccini, Guazzotti, Goncalves Correia, Daffara, Tini, Antonioli, Aimaretti, Marzullo, Caputo, Antoniotti and Prodam. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY). The use, distribution or reproduction in other forums is permitted, provided the original author(s) and the copyright owner(s) are credited and that the original publication in this journal is cited, in accordance with accepted academic practice. No use, distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not comply with these terms.
spellingShingle Nutrition
Spadaccini, Daniele
Guazzotti, Silvia
Goncalves Correia, Filipa Patricia
Daffara, Tommaso
Tini, Sabrina
Antonioli, Alessandro
Aimaretti, Gianluca
Marzullo, Paolo
Caputo, Marina
Antoniotti, Valentina
Prodam, Flavia
Beyond bariatric surgery and weight loss medicaments. A systematic review of the current practice in obesity rehabilitative inpatient programs in adults and pediatrics
title Beyond bariatric surgery and weight loss medicaments. A systematic review of the current practice in obesity rehabilitative inpatient programs in adults and pediatrics
title_full Beyond bariatric surgery and weight loss medicaments. A systematic review of the current practice in obesity rehabilitative inpatient programs in adults and pediatrics
title_fullStr Beyond bariatric surgery and weight loss medicaments. A systematic review of the current practice in obesity rehabilitative inpatient programs in adults and pediatrics
title_full_unstemmed Beyond bariatric surgery and weight loss medicaments. A systematic review of the current practice in obesity rehabilitative inpatient programs in adults and pediatrics
title_short Beyond bariatric surgery and weight loss medicaments. A systematic review of the current practice in obesity rehabilitative inpatient programs in adults and pediatrics
title_sort beyond bariatric surgery and weight loss medicaments. a systematic review of the current practice in obesity rehabilitative inpatient programs in adults and pediatrics
topic Nutrition
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9556721/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36245519
http://dx.doi.org/10.3389/fnut.2022.963709
work_keys_str_mv AT spadaccinidaniele beyondbariatricsurgeryandweightlossmedicamentsasystematicreviewofthecurrentpracticeinobesityrehabilitativeinpatientprogramsinadultsandpediatrics
AT guazzottisilvia beyondbariatricsurgeryandweightlossmedicamentsasystematicreviewofthecurrentpracticeinobesityrehabilitativeinpatientprogramsinadultsandpediatrics
AT goncalvescorreiafilipapatricia beyondbariatricsurgeryandweightlossmedicamentsasystematicreviewofthecurrentpracticeinobesityrehabilitativeinpatientprogramsinadultsandpediatrics
AT daffaratommaso beyondbariatricsurgeryandweightlossmedicamentsasystematicreviewofthecurrentpracticeinobesityrehabilitativeinpatientprogramsinadultsandpediatrics
AT tinisabrina beyondbariatricsurgeryandweightlossmedicamentsasystematicreviewofthecurrentpracticeinobesityrehabilitativeinpatientprogramsinadultsandpediatrics
AT antoniolialessandro beyondbariatricsurgeryandweightlossmedicamentsasystematicreviewofthecurrentpracticeinobesityrehabilitativeinpatientprogramsinadultsandpediatrics
AT aimarettigianluca beyondbariatricsurgeryandweightlossmedicamentsasystematicreviewofthecurrentpracticeinobesityrehabilitativeinpatientprogramsinadultsandpediatrics
AT marzullopaolo beyondbariatricsurgeryandweightlossmedicamentsasystematicreviewofthecurrentpracticeinobesityrehabilitativeinpatientprogramsinadultsandpediatrics
AT caputomarina beyondbariatricsurgeryandweightlossmedicamentsasystematicreviewofthecurrentpracticeinobesityrehabilitativeinpatientprogramsinadultsandpediatrics
AT antoniottivalentina beyondbariatricsurgeryandweightlossmedicamentsasystematicreviewofthecurrentpracticeinobesityrehabilitativeinpatientprogramsinadultsandpediatrics
AT prodamflavia beyondbariatricsurgeryandweightlossmedicamentsasystematicreviewofthecurrentpracticeinobesityrehabilitativeinpatientprogramsinadultsandpediatrics