Cargando…

Local Hyperthermia Versus Cryotherapy for Treatment of Plantar Warts: A Prospective Multi-centre Non-randomized Concurrent Controlled Clinical Trial

Cryotherapy is one of the most common treatments for warts; however, pain during treatment and relatively high recurrence rates limit its use. Local hyperthermia has also been used successfully in the treatment of plantar warts. The aim of this study was to compare the clinical effectiveness of loca...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: HUO, Wei, GAO, Ya-Li, WANG, Hong-Yi, BI, Gui-Jiao, QIAO, Shuai, CAI, Yun-Fei, QI, Rui-Qun, YANG, Yang, LAN, Jing, YAO, Zhi-Rong, HAN, Xiu-Ping, ZHANG, Jian-Zhong, GAO, Tian-Wen, YANG, Sen, GU, Heng, WU, Ri-Na, LU, Hong-Guang, ZENG, Fan-Qin, CHEN, Xiang, QIAO, You-Lin, GAO, Xing-Hua
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Society for Publication of Acta Dermato-Venereologica 2022
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9558746/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35083495
http://dx.doi.org/10.2340/actadv.v102.1082
_version_ 1784807510078652416
author HUO, Wei
GAO, Ya-Li
WANG, Hong-Yi
BI, Gui-Jiao
QIAO, Shuai
CAI, Yun-Fei
QI, Rui-Qun
YANG, Yang
LAN, Jing
YAO, Zhi-Rong
HAN, Xiu-Ping
ZHANG, Jian-Zhong
GAO, Tian-Wen
YANG, Sen
GU, Heng
WU, Ri-Na
LU, Hong-Guang
ZENG, Fan-Qin
CHEN, Xiang
QIAO, You-Lin
GAO, Xing-Hua
author_facet HUO, Wei
GAO, Ya-Li
WANG, Hong-Yi
BI, Gui-Jiao
QIAO, Shuai
CAI, Yun-Fei
QI, Rui-Qun
YANG, Yang
LAN, Jing
YAO, Zhi-Rong
HAN, Xiu-Ping
ZHANG, Jian-Zhong
GAO, Tian-Wen
YANG, Sen
GU, Heng
WU, Ri-Na
LU, Hong-Guang
ZENG, Fan-Qin
CHEN, Xiang
QIAO, You-Lin
GAO, Xing-Hua
author_sort HUO, Wei
collection PubMed
description Cryotherapy is one of the most common treatments for warts; however, pain during treatment and relatively high recurrence rates limit its use. Local hyperthermia has also been used successfully in the treatment of plantar warts. The aim of this study was to compare the clinical effectiveness of local hyperthermia vs cryotherapy for the treatment of plantar warts. This multi-centre, open, 2-arm, non-randomized concurrent controlled trial included 1,027 patients, who received either cryotherapy or local hyperthermia treatment. Three months after treatment, local hyperthermia and cryotherapy achieved complete clearance rates of 50.9% and 54.3%, respectively. Recurrence rates were 0.8% and 12%, respectively. Pain scores during local hyperthermia were significantly lower than for cryotherapy. Both local hyperthermia and cryotherapy demonstrated similar efficacy for clearance of plantar warts; while local hyperthermia had a lower recurrence rate and lower pain sensation during treatment.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-9558746
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2022
publisher Society for Publication of Acta Dermato-Venereologica
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-95587462022-10-20 Local Hyperthermia Versus Cryotherapy for Treatment of Plantar Warts: A Prospective Multi-centre Non-randomized Concurrent Controlled Clinical Trial HUO, Wei GAO, Ya-Li WANG, Hong-Yi BI, Gui-Jiao QIAO, Shuai CAI, Yun-Fei QI, Rui-Qun YANG, Yang LAN, Jing YAO, Zhi-Rong HAN, Xiu-Ping ZHANG, Jian-Zhong GAO, Tian-Wen YANG, Sen GU, Heng WU, Ri-Na LU, Hong-Guang ZENG, Fan-Qin CHEN, Xiang QIAO, You-Lin GAO, Xing-Hua Acta Derm Venereol Original Article Cryotherapy is one of the most common treatments for warts; however, pain during treatment and relatively high recurrence rates limit its use. Local hyperthermia has also been used successfully in the treatment of plantar warts. The aim of this study was to compare the clinical effectiveness of local hyperthermia vs cryotherapy for the treatment of plantar warts. This multi-centre, open, 2-arm, non-randomized concurrent controlled trial included 1,027 patients, who received either cryotherapy or local hyperthermia treatment. Three months after treatment, local hyperthermia and cryotherapy achieved complete clearance rates of 50.9% and 54.3%, respectively. Recurrence rates were 0.8% and 12%, respectively. Pain scores during local hyperthermia were significantly lower than for cryotherapy. Both local hyperthermia and cryotherapy demonstrated similar efficacy for clearance of plantar warts; while local hyperthermia had a lower recurrence rate and lower pain sensation during treatment. Society for Publication of Acta Dermato-Venereologica 2022-02-28 /pmc/articles/PMC9558746/ /pubmed/35083495 http://dx.doi.org/10.2340/actadv.v102.1082 Text en © 2022 Acta Dermato-Venereologica https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC license
spellingShingle Original Article
HUO, Wei
GAO, Ya-Li
WANG, Hong-Yi
BI, Gui-Jiao
QIAO, Shuai
CAI, Yun-Fei
QI, Rui-Qun
YANG, Yang
LAN, Jing
YAO, Zhi-Rong
HAN, Xiu-Ping
ZHANG, Jian-Zhong
GAO, Tian-Wen
YANG, Sen
GU, Heng
WU, Ri-Na
LU, Hong-Guang
ZENG, Fan-Qin
CHEN, Xiang
QIAO, You-Lin
GAO, Xing-Hua
Local Hyperthermia Versus Cryotherapy for Treatment of Plantar Warts: A Prospective Multi-centre Non-randomized Concurrent Controlled Clinical Trial
title Local Hyperthermia Versus Cryotherapy for Treatment of Plantar Warts: A Prospective Multi-centre Non-randomized Concurrent Controlled Clinical Trial
title_full Local Hyperthermia Versus Cryotherapy for Treatment of Plantar Warts: A Prospective Multi-centre Non-randomized Concurrent Controlled Clinical Trial
title_fullStr Local Hyperthermia Versus Cryotherapy for Treatment of Plantar Warts: A Prospective Multi-centre Non-randomized Concurrent Controlled Clinical Trial
title_full_unstemmed Local Hyperthermia Versus Cryotherapy for Treatment of Plantar Warts: A Prospective Multi-centre Non-randomized Concurrent Controlled Clinical Trial
title_short Local Hyperthermia Versus Cryotherapy for Treatment of Plantar Warts: A Prospective Multi-centre Non-randomized Concurrent Controlled Clinical Trial
title_sort local hyperthermia versus cryotherapy for treatment of plantar warts: a prospective multi-centre non-randomized concurrent controlled clinical trial
topic Original Article
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9558746/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35083495
http://dx.doi.org/10.2340/actadv.v102.1082
work_keys_str_mv AT huowei localhyperthermiaversuscryotherapyfortreatmentofplantarwartsaprospectivemulticentrenonrandomizedconcurrentcontrolledclinicaltrial
AT gaoyali localhyperthermiaversuscryotherapyfortreatmentofplantarwartsaprospectivemulticentrenonrandomizedconcurrentcontrolledclinicaltrial
AT wanghongyi localhyperthermiaversuscryotherapyfortreatmentofplantarwartsaprospectivemulticentrenonrandomizedconcurrentcontrolledclinicaltrial
AT biguijiao localhyperthermiaversuscryotherapyfortreatmentofplantarwartsaprospectivemulticentrenonrandomizedconcurrentcontrolledclinicaltrial
AT qiaoshuai localhyperthermiaversuscryotherapyfortreatmentofplantarwartsaprospectivemulticentrenonrandomizedconcurrentcontrolledclinicaltrial
AT caiyunfei localhyperthermiaversuscryotherapyfortreatmentofplantarwartsaprospectivemulticentrenonrandomizedconcurrentcontrolledclinicaltrial
AT qiruiqun localhyperthermiaversuscryotherapyfortreatmentofplantarwartsaprospectivemulticentrenonrandomizedconcurrentcontrolledclinicaltrial
AT yangyang localhyperthermiaversuscryotherapyfortreatmentofplantarwartsaprospectivemulticentrenonrandomizedconcurrentcontrolledclinicaltrial
AT lanjing localhyperthermiaversuscryotherapyfortreatmentofplantarwartsaprospectivemulticentrenonrandomizedconcurrentcontrolledclinicaltrial
AT yaozhirong localhyperthermiaversuscryotherapyfortreatmentofplantarwartsaprospectivemulticentrenonrandomizedconcurrentcontrolledclinicaltrial
AT hanxiuping localhyperthermiaversuscryotherapyfortreatmentofplantarwartsaprospectivemulticentrenonrandomizedconcurrentcontrolledclinicaltrial
AT zhangjianzhong localhyperthermiaversuscryotherapyfortreatmentofplantarwartsaprospectivemulticentrenonrandomizedconcurrentcontrolledclinicaltrial
AT gaotianwen localhyperthermiaversuscryotherapyfortreatmentofplantarwartsaprospectivemulticentrenonrandomizedconcurrentcontrolledclinicaltrial
AT yangsen localhyperthermiaversuscryotherapyfortreatmentofplantarwartsaprospectivemulticentrenonrandomizedconcurrentcontrolledclinicaltrial
AT guheng localhyperthermiaversuscryotherapyfortreatmentofplantarwartsaprospectivemulticentrenonrandomizedconcurrentcontrolledclinicaltrial
AT wurina localhyperthermiaversuscryotherapyfortreatmentofplantarwartsaprospectivemulticentrenonrandomizedconcurrentcontrolledclinicaltrial
AT luhongguang localhyperthermiaversuscryotherapyfortreatmentofplantarwartsaprospectivemulticentrenonrandomizedconcurrentcontrolledclinicaltrial
AT zengfanqin localhyperthermiaversuscryotherapyfortreatmentofplantarwartsaprospectivemulticentrenonrandomizedconcurrentcontrolledclinicaltrial
AT chenxiang localhyperthermiaversuscryotherapyfortreatmentofplantarwartsaprospectivemulticentrenonrandomizedconcurrentcontrolledclinicaltrial
AT qiaoyoulin localhyperthermiaversuscryotherapyfortreatmentofplantarwartsaprospectivemulticentrenonrandomizedconcurrentcontrolledclinicaltrial
AT gaoxinghua localhyperthermiaversuscryotherapyfortreatmentofplantarwartsaprospectivemulticentrenonrandomizedconcurrentcontrolledclinicaltrial