Cargando…

Prediction of Liver Triglyceride Content in Early Lactation Multiparous Holstein Cows Using Blood Metabolite, Mineral, and Protein Biomarker Concentrations

SIMPLE SUMMARY: Bovine fatty liver syndrome is a metabolic disorder in transition dairy cows that has been associated with adverse consequences such as lower milk production and fertility. Fatty liver syndrome is difficult to monitor and diagnose in applied practice and research settings because it...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Pralle, Ryan S., Holdorf, Henry T., Caputo Oliveira, Rafael, Seely, Claira R., Kendall, Sophia J., White, Heather M.
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: MDPI 2022
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9558982/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36230297
http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/ani12192556
_version_ 1784807563192172544
author Pralle, Ryan S.
Holdorf, Henry T.
Caputo Oliveira, Rafael
Seely, Claira R.
Kendall, Sophia J.
White, Heather M.
author_facet Pralle, Ryan S.
Holdorf, Henry T.
Caputo Oliveira, Rafael
Seely, Claira R.
Kendall, Sophia J.
White, Heather M.
author_sort Pralle, Ryan S.
collection PubMed
description SIMPLE SUMMARY: Bovine fatty liver syndrome is a metabolic disorder in transition dairy cows that has been associated with adverse consequences such as lower milk production and fertility. Fatty liver syndrome is difficult to monitor and diagnose in applied practice and research settings because it requires a liver tissue biopsy to determine liver triglyceride content. This study aimed to develop and validate a panel of blood metabolite, protein, and mineral biomarkers as a less invasive and more accessible tool to assess liver triglyceride content. We investigated a variety of panels using blood measurements from a single timepoint or multiple timepoints, as well as different combinations of biomarkers based on their perceived accessibility. Both the single and multiple timepoint biomarker panels accurately classified cows with high liver triglyceride content (top 33.3% vs. lower 66.7%), but accuracy was lower for classifying cows with or without maximum liver triglyceride in the top 50% or top 66.7% of liver triglyceride content. We suggest that the blood biomarker models predicting high triglyceride content may be useful for monitoring fatty liver in research and applied practice, as well as enable larger scale research studies investigating fatty liver in dairy cows. ABSTRACT: Bovine fatty liver syndrome (bFLS) is difficult to diagnose because a liver tissue biopsy is required to assess liver triglyceride (TG) content. We hypothesized that a blood biomarker panel could be a convenient alternative method of liver TG content assessment and bFLS diagnosis. Our objectives were to predict liver TG using blood biomarker concentrations across days in milk (DIM; longitudinal, LT) or at a single timepoint (ST; 3, 7, or 14 DIM), as well as different biomarker combination based on their perceived accessibility. Data from two separate experiments (n = 65 cows) was used for model training and validation. Response variables were based on the maximum liver TG observed in 1 and 14 DIM liver biopsies: Max TG (continuous), Low TG (TG > 13.3% dry matter; DM), Median TG (TG > 17.1% DM), and High TG (TG > 22.0% DM). Model performance varied but High TG was well predicted by sparse partial least squares—discriminate analysis models using LT and ST data, achieving balanced error rates ≤ 15.4% for several model variations during cross-validation. In conclusion, blood biomarker panels using 7 DIM, 14 DIM, or LT data may be a useful diagnostic tool for bFLS in research and field settings.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-9558982
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2022
publisher MDPI
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-95589822022-10-14 Prediction of Liver Triglyceride Content in Early Lactation Multiparous Holstein Cows Using Blood Metabolite, Mineral, and Protein Biomarker Concentrations Pralle, Ryan S. Holdorf, Henry T. Caputo Oliveira, Rafael Seely, Claira R. Kendall, Sophia J. White, Heather M. Animals (Basel) Article SIMPLE SUMMARY: Bovine fatty liver syndrome is a metabolic disorder in transition dairy cows that has been associated with adverse consequences such as lower milk production and fertility. Fatty liver syndrome is difficult to monitor and diagnose in applied practice and research settings because it requires a liver tissue biopsy to determine liver triglyceride content. This study aimed to develop and validate a panel of blood metabolite, protein, and mineral biomarkers as a less invasive and more accessible tool to assess liver triglyceride content. We investigated a variety of panels using blood measurements from a single timepoint or multiple timepoints, as well as different combinations of biomarkers based on their perceived accessibility. Both the single and multiple timepoint biomarker panels accurately classified cows with high liver triglyceride content (top 33.3% vs. lower 66.7%), but accuracy was lower for classifying cows with or without maximum liver triglyceride in the top 50% or top 66.7% of liver triglyceride content. We suggest that the blood biomarker models predicting high triglyceride content may be useful for monitoring fatty liver in research and applied practice, as well as enable larger scale research studies investigating fatty liver in dairy cows. ABSTRACT: Bovine fatty liver syndrome (bFLS) is difficult to diagnose because a liver tissue biopsy is required to assess liver triglyceride (TG) content. We hypothesized that a blood biomarker panel could be a convenient alternative method of liver TG content assessment and bFLS diagnosis. Our objectives were to predict liver TG using blood biomarker concentrations across days in milk (DIM; longitudinal, LT) or at a single timepoint (ST; 3, 7, or 14 DIM), as well as different biomarker combination based on their perceived accessibility. Data from two separate experiments (n = 65 cows) was used for model training and validation. Response variables were based on the maximum liver TG observed in 1 and 14 DIM liver biopsies: Max TG (continuous), Low TG (TG > 13.3% dry matter; DM), Median TG (TG > 17.1% DM), and High TG (TG > 22.0% DM). Model performance varied but High TG was well predicted by sparse partial least squares—discriminate analysis models using LT and ST data, achieving balanced error rates ≤ 15.4% for several model variations during cross-validation. In conclusion, blood biomarker panels using 7 DIM, 14 DIM, or LT data may be a useful diagnostic tool for bFLS in research and field settings. MDPI 2022-09-24 /pmc/articles/PMC9558982/ /pubmed/36230297 http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/ani12192556 Text en © 2022 by the authors. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
spellingShingle Article
Pralle, Ryan S.
Holdorf, Henry T.
Caputo Oliveira, Rafael
Seely, Claira R.
Kendall, Sophia J.
White, Heather M.
Prediction of Liver Triglyceride Content in Early Lactation Multiparous Holstein Cows Using Blood Metabolite, Mineral, and Protein Biomarker Concentrations
title Prediction of Liver Triglyceride Content in Early Lactation Multiparous Holstein Cows Using Blood Metabolite, Mineral, and Protein Biomarker Concentrations
title_full Prediction of Liver Triglyceride Content in Early Lactation Multiparous Holstein Cows Using Blood Metabolite, Mineral, and Protein Biomarker Concentrations
title_fullStr Prediction of Liver Triglyceride Content in Early Lactation Multiparous Holstein Cows Using Blood Metabolite, Mineral, and Protein Biomarker Concentrations
title_full_unstemmed Prediction of Liver Triglyceride Content in Early Lactation Multiparous Holstein Cows Using Blood Metabolite, Mineral, and Protein Biomarker Concentrations
title_short Prediction of Liver Triglyceride Content in Early Lactation Multiparous Holstein Cows Using Blood Metabolite, Mineral, and Protein Biomarker Concentrations
title_sort prediction of liver triglyceride content in early lactation multiparous holstein cows using blood metabolite, mineral, and protein biomarker concentrations
topic Article
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9558982/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36230297
http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/ani12192556
work_keys_str_mv AT pralleryans predictionoflivertriglyceridecontentinearlylactationmultiparousholsteincowsusingbloodmetabolitemineralandproteinbiomarkerconcentrations
AT holdorfhenryt predictionoflivertriglyceridecontentinearlylactationmultiparousholsteincowsusingbloodmetabolitemineralandproteinbiomarkerconcentrations
AT caputooliveirarafael predictionoflivertriglyceridecontentinearlylactationmultiparousholsteincowsusingbloodmetabolitemineralandproteinbiomarkerconcentrations
AT seelyclairar predictionoflivertriglyceridecontentinearlylactationmultiparousholsteincowsusingbloodmetabolitemineralandproteinbiomarkerconcentrations
AT kendallsophiaj predictionoflivertriglyceridecontentinearlylactationmultiparousholsteincowsusingbloodmetabolitemineralandproteinbiomarkerconcentrations
AT whiteheatherm predictionoflivertriglyceridecontentinearlylactationmultiparousholsteincowsusingbloodmetabolitemineralandproteinbiomarkerconcentrations