Cargando…

Cross-cultural analysis of the stigmatising attitudes of psychiatrists across Europe and measurement invariance of the Opening Minds Stigma Scale for healthcare providers

INTRODUCTION: Since the literature investigating the stigmatising attitudes of psychiatrists is scarce, this is the first study which examines the phenomena across Europe. The Opening Minds Stigma Scale for Health Care Providers (OMS-HC) is a widely used questionnaire to measure stigma in healthcare...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Ori, D., Szocsics, P., Molnar, T., Rozsa, S., Wallies, M., Kazakova, O., Bankovska-Motlova, L., Boivin, S., Raaj, S., Overgaard Ingeholm Klinkby, I.M., Cabacos, C., Pereira, A.T., Matheiken, S., Kakar, S., Greguras, S., Maslak, J., Nechepurenko, N., Kotsis, K., Yilmaz Kafali, H., Mirkovic, A., Rus Prelog, P., Bruna, K., Guevara, K., Strumila, R., Mörkl, S., Abdulhakim, M., Carbone, E.A., Panayi, A., Ivanović, I., Dashi, E., Grech, G., Vircik, M., Schuster, F., Soler-Vidal, J., Pomarol-Clotet, E., Ahmadova, G., Hargi, A., Kisand, H., Grinko, N., Gyorffy, Z.
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Cambridge University Press 2022
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9565287/
http://dx.doi.org/10.1192/j.eurpsy.2022.539
_version_ 1784808851906756608
author Ori, D.
Szocsics, P.
Molnar, T.
Rozsa, S.
Wallies, M.
Kazakova, O.
Bankovska-Motlova, L.
Boivin, S.
Raaj, S.
Overgaard Ingeholm Klinkby, I.M.
Cabacos, C.
Pereira, A.T.
Matheiken, S.
Kakar, S.
Greguras, S.
Maslak, J.
Nechepurenko, N.
Kotsis, K.
Yilmaz Kafali, H.
Mirkovic, A.
Rus Prelog, P.
Bruna, K.
Guevara, K.
Strumila, R.
Mörkl, S.
Abdulhakim, M.
Carbone, E.A.
Panayi, A.
Ivanović, I.
Dashi, E.
Grech, G.
Vircik, M.
Schuster, F.
Soler-Vidal, J.
Pomarol-Clotet, E.
Ahmadova, G.
Hargi, A.
Kisand, H.
Grinko, N.
Gyorffy, Z.
author_facet Ori, D.
Szocsics, P.
Molnar, T.
Rozsa, S.
Wallies, M.
Kazakova, O.
Bankovska-Motlova, L.
Boivin, S.
Raaj, S.
Overgaard Ingeholm Klinkby, I.M.
Cabacos, C.
Pereira, A.T.
Matheiken, S.
Kakar, S.
Greguras, S.
Maslak, J.
Nechepurenko, N.
Kotsis, K.
Yilmaz Kafali, H.
Mirkovic, A.
Rus Prelog, P.
Bruna, K.
Guevara, K.
Strumila, R.
Mörkl, S.
Abdulhakim, M.
Carbone, E.A.
Panayi, A.
Ivanović, I.
Dashi, E.
Grech, G.
Vircik, M.
Schuster, F.
Soler-Vidal, J.
Pomarol-Clotet, E.
Ahmadova, G.
Hargi, A.
Kisand, H.
Grinko, N.
Gyorffy, Z.
author_sort Ori, D.
collection PubMed
description INTRODUCTION: Since the literature investigating the stigmatising attitudes of psychiatrists is scarce, this is the first study which examines the phenomena across Europe. The Opening Minds Stigma Scale for Health Care Providers (OMS-HC) is a widely used questionnaire to measure stigma in healthcare providers towards people with mental illness, although it has not been validated in many European countries. OBJECTIVES: A cross-sectional, observational, multi-centre study was conducted in 32 European countries to investigate the attitudes towards patients among specialists and trainees in general adult and child psychiatry. In order to be able to compare stigma scores across cultures, we aimed to calculate measurement invariance. METHODS: An internet-based, anonymous survey was distributed in the participating countries, which was completed by n=4245 psychiatrists. The factor structure of the scale was investigated by using separate confirmatory factor analyses for each country. The cross-cultural validation was based on multigroup confirmatory factor analyses. RESULTS: When country data were analysed separately, the three dimensions of the OMS-HC were confirmed, and the bifactor model showed the best model fit. However, in some countries, a few items were found to be weak. The attitudes towards patients seemed favourable since stigma scores were less than half of the reachable maximum. Results allowed comparison to be made between stigma scores in different countries and subgroups. CONCLUSIONS: This international cooperation has led to the cross-cultural validation of the OMS-HC on a large sample of practicing psychiatrists. The results will be useful in the evaluation of future anti-stigma interventions and will contribute to the knowledge of stigma. DISCLOSURE: No significant relationships.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-9565287
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2022
publisher Cambridge University Press
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-95652872022-10-17 Cross-cultural analysis of the stigmatising attitudes of psychiatrists across Europe and measurement invariance of the Opening Minds Stigma Scale for healthcare providers Ori, D. Szocsics, P. Molnar, T. Rozsa, S. Wallies, M. Kazakova, O. Bankovska-Motlova, L. Boivin, S. Raaj, S. Overgaard Ingeholm Klinkby, I.M. Cabacos, C. Pereira, A.T. Matheiken, S. Kakar, S. Greguras, S. Maslak, J. Nechepurenko, N. Kotsis, K. Yilmaz Kafali, H. Mirkovic, A. Rus Prelog, P. Bruna, K. Guevara, K. Strumila, R. Mörkl, S. Abdulhakim, M. Carbone, E.A. Panayi, A. Ivanović, I. Dashi, E. Grech, G. Vircik, M. Schuster, F. Soler-Vidal, J. Pomarol-Clotet, E. Ahmadova, G. Hargi, A. Kisand, H. Grinko, N. Gyorffy, Z. Eur Psychiatry Abstract INTRODUCTION: Since the literature investigating the stigmatising attitudes of psychiatrists is scarce, this is the first study which examines the phenomena across Europe. The Opening Minds Stigma Scale for Health Care Providers (OMS-HC) is a widely used questionnaire to measure stigma in healthcare providers towards people with mental illness, although it has not been validated in many European countries. OBJECTIVES: A cross-sectional, observational, multi-centre study was conducted in 32 European countries to investigate the attitudes towards patients among specialists and trainees in general adult and child psychiatry. In order to be able to compare stigma scores across cultures, we aimed to calculate measurement invariance. METHODS: An internet-based, anonymous survey was distributed in the participating countries, which was completed by n=4245 psychiatrists. The factor structure of the scale was investigated by using separate confirmatory factor analyses for each country. The cross-cultural validation was based on multigroup confirmatory factor analyses. RESULTS: When country data were analysed separately, the three dimensions of the OMS-HC were confirmed, and the bifactor model showed the best model fit. However, in some countries, a few items were found to be weak. The attitudes towards patients seemed favourable since stigma scores were less than half of the reachable maximum. Results allowed comparison to be made between stigma scores in different countries and subgroups. CONCLUSIONS: This international cooperation has led to the cross-cultural validation of the OMS-HC on a large sample of practicing psychiatrists. The results will be useful in the evaluation of future anti-stigma interventions and will contribute to the knowledge of stigma. DISCLOSURE: No significant relationships. Cambridge University Press 2022-09-01 /pmc/articles/PMC9565287/ http://dx.doi.org/10.1192/j.eurpsy.2022.539 Text en © The Author(s) 2022 https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an Open Access article, distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution licence (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted re-use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
spellingShingle Abstract
Ori, D.
Szocsics, P.
Molnar, T.
Rozsa, S.
Wallies, M.
Kazakova, O.
Bankovska-Motlova, L.
Boivin, S.
Raaj, S.
Overgaard Ingeholm Klinkby, I.M.
Cabacos, C.
Pereira, A.T.
Matheiken, S.
Kakar, S.
Greguras, S.
Maslak, J.
Nechepurenko, N.
Kotsis, K.
Yilmaz Kafali, H.
Mirkovic, A.
Rus Prelog, P.
Bruna, K.
Guevara, K.
Strumila, R.
Mörkl, S.
Abdulhakim, M.
Carbone, E.A.
Panayi, A.
Ivanović, I.
Dashi, E.
Grech, G.
Vircik, M.
Schuster, F.
Soler-Vidal, J.
Pomarol-Clotet, E.
Ahmadova, G.
Hargi, A.
Kisand, H.
Grinko, N.
Gyorffy, Z.
Cross-cultural analysis of the stigmatising attitudes of psychiatrists across Europe and measurement invariance of the Opening Minds Stigma Scale for healthcare providers
title Cross-cultural analysis of the stigmatising attitudes of psychiatrists across Europe and measurement invariance of the Opening Minds Stigma Scale for healthcare providers
title_full Cross-cultural analysis of the stigmatising attitudes of psychiatrists across Europe and measurement invariance of the Opening Minds Stigma Scale for healthcare providers
title_fullStr Cross-cultural analysis of the stigmatising attitudes of psychiatrists across Europe and measurement invariance of the Opening Minds Stigma Scale for healthcare providers
title_full_unstemmed Cross-cultural analysis of the stigmatising attitudes of psychiatrists across Europe and measurement invariance of the Opening Minds Stigma Scale for healthcare providers
title_short Cross-cultural analysis of the stigmatising attitudes of psychiatrists across Europe and measurement invariance of the Opening Minds Stigma Scale for healthcare providers
title_sort cross-cultural analysis of the stigmatising attitudes of psychiatrists across europe and measurement invariance of the opening minds stigma scale for healthcare providers
topic Abstract
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9565287/
http://dx.doi.org/10.1192/j.eurpsy.2022.539
work_keys_str_mv AT orid crossculturalanalysisofthestigmatisingattitudesofpsychiatristsacrosseuropeandmeasurementinvarianceoftheopeningmindsstigmascaleforhealthcareproviders
AT szocsicsp crossculturalanalysisofthestigmatisingattitudesofpsychiatristsacrosseuropeandmeasurementinvarianceoftheopeningmindsstigmascaleforhealthcareproviders
AT molnart crossculturalanalysisofthestigmatisingattitudesofpsychiatristsacrosseuropeandmeasurementinvarianceoftheopeningmindsstigmascaleforhealthcareproviders
AT rozsas crossculturalanalysisofthestigmatisingattitudesofpsychiatristsacrosseuropeandmeasurementinvarianceoftheopeningmindsstigmascaleforhealthcareproviders
AT walliesm crossculturalanalysisofthestigmatisingattitudesofpsychiatristsacrosseuropeandmeasurementinvarianceoftheopeningmindsstigmascaleforhealthcareproviders
AT kazakovao crossculturalanalysisofthestigmatisingattitudesofpsychiatristsacrosseuropeandmeasurementinvarianceoftheopeningmindsstigmascaleforhealthcareproviders
AT bankovskamotloval crossculturalanalysisofthestigmatisingattitudesofpsychiatristsacrosseuropeandmeasurementinvarianceoftheopeningmindsstigmascaleforhealthcareproviders
AT boivins crossculturalanalysisofthestigmatisingattitudesofpsychiatristsacrosseuropeandmeasurementinvarianceoftheopeningmindsstigmascaleforhealthcareproviders
AT raajs crossculturalanalysisofthestigmatisingattitudesofpsychiatristsacrosseuropeandmeasurementinvarianceoftheopeningmindsstigmascaleforhealthcareproviders
AT overgaardingeholmklinkbyim crossculturalanalysisofthestigmatisingattitudesofpsychiatristsacrosseuropeandmeasurementinvarianceoftheopeningmindsstigmascaleforhealthcareproviders
AT cabacosc crossculturalanalysisofthestigmatisingattitudesofpsychiatristsacrosseuropeandmeasurementinvarianceoftheopeningmindsstigmascaleforhealthcareproviders
AT pereiraat crossculturalanalysisofthestigmatisingattitudesofpsychiatristsacrosseuropeandmeasurementinvarianceoftheopeningmindsstigmascaleforhealthcareproviders
AT matheikens crossculturalanalysisofthestigmatisingattitudesofpsychiatristsacrosseuropeandmeasurementinvarianceoftheopeningmindsstigmascaleforhealthcareproviders
AT kakars crossculturalanalysisofthestigmatisingattitudesofpsychiatristsacrosseuropeandmeasurementinvarianceoftheopeningmindsstigmascaleforhealthcareproviders
AT gregurass crossculturalanalysisofthestigmatisingattitudesofpsychiatristsacrosseuropeandmeasurementinvarianceoftheopeningmindsstigmascaleforhealthcareproviders
AT maslakj crossculturalanalysisofthestigmatisingattitudesofpsychiatristsacrosseuropeandmeasurementinvarianceoftheopeningmindsstigmascaleforhealthcareproviders
AT nechepurenkon crossculturalanalysisofthestigmatisingattitudesofpsychiatristsacrosseuropeandmeasurementinvarianceoftheopeningmindsstigmascaleforhealthcareproviders
AT kotsisk crossculturalanalysisofthestigmatisingattitudesofpsychiatristsacrosseuropeandmeasurementinvarianceoftheopeningmindsstigmascaleforhealthcareproviders
AT yilmazkafalih crossculturalanalysisofthestigmatisingattitudesofpsychiatristsacrosseuropeandmeasurementinvarianceoftheopeningmindsstigmascaleforhealthcareproviders
AT mirkovica crossculturalanalysisofthestigmatisingattitudesofpsychiatristsacrosseuropeandmeasurementinvarianceoftheopeningmindsstigmascaleforhealthcareproviders
AT rusprelogp crossculturalanalysisofthestigmatisingattitudesofpsychiatristsacrosseuropeandmeasurementinvarianceoftheopeningmindsstigmascaleforhealthcareproviders
AT brunak crossculturalanalysisofthestigmatisingattitudesofpsychiatristsacrosseuropeandmeasurementinvarianceoftheopeningmindsstigmascaleforhealthcareproviders
AT guevarak crossculturalanalysisofthestigmatisingattitudesofpsychiatristsacrosseuropeandmeasurementinvarianceoftheopeningmindsstigmascaleforhealthcareproviders
AT strumilar crossculturalanalysisofthestigmatisingattitudesofpsychiatristsacrosseuropeandmeasurementinvarianceoftheopeningmindsstigmascaleforhealthcareproviders
AT morkls crossculturalanalysisofthestigmatisingattitudesofpsychiatristsacrosseuropeandmeasurementinvarianceoftheopeningmindsstigmascaleforhealthcareproviders
AT abdulhakimm crossculturalanalysisofthestigmatisingattitudesofpsychiatristsacrosseuropeandmeasurementinvarianceoftheopeningmindsstigmascaleforhealthcareproviders
AT carboneea crossculturalanalysisofthestigmatisingattitudesofpsychiatristsacrosseuropeandmeasurementinvarianceoftheopeningmindsstigmascaleforhealthcareproviders
AT panayia crossculturalanalysisofthestigmatisingattitudesofpsychiatristsacrosseuropeandmeasurementinvarianceoftheopeningmindsstigmascaleforhealthcareproviders
AT ivanovici crossculturalanalysisofthestigmatisingattitudesofpsychiatristsacrosseuropeandmeasurementinvarianceoftheopeningmindsstigmascaleforhealthcareproviders
AT dashie crossculturalanalysisofthestigmatisingattitudesofpsychiatristsacrosseuropeandmeasurementinvarianceoftheopeningmindsstigmascaleforhealthcareproviders
AT grechg crossculturalanalysisofthestigmatisingattitudesofpsychiatristsacrosseuropeandmeasurementinvarianceoftheopeningmindsstigmascaleforhealthcareproviders
AT vircikm crossculturalanalysisofthestigmatisingattitudesofpsychiatristsacrosseuropeandmeasurementinvarianceoftheopeningmindsstigmascaleforhealthcareproviders
AT schusterf crossculturalanalysisofthestigmatisingattitudesofpsychiatristsacrosseuropeandmeasurementinvarianceoftheopeningmindsstigmascaleforhealthcareproviders
AT solervidalj crossculturalanalysisofthestigmatisingattitudesofpsychiatristsacrosseuropeandmeasurementinvarianceoftheopeningmindsstigmascaleforhealthcareproviders
AT pomarolclotete crossculturalanalysisofthestigmatisingattitudesofpsychiatristsacrosseuropeandmeasurementinvarianceoftheopeningmindsstigmascaleforhealthcareproviders
AT ahmadovag crossculturalanalysisofthestigmatisingattitudesofpsychiatristsacrosseuropeandmeasurementinvarianceoftheopeningmindsstigmascaleforhealthcareproviders
AT hargia crossculturalanalysisofthestigmatisingattitudesofpsychiatristsacrosseuropeandmeasurementinvarianceoftheopeningmindsstigmascaleforhealthcareproviders
AT kisandh crossculturalanalysisofthestigmatisingattitudesofpsychiatristsacrosseuropeandmeasurementinvarianceoftheopeningmindsstigmascaleforhealthcareproviders
AT grinkon crossculturalanalysisofthestigmatisingattitudesofpsychiatristsacrosseuropeandmeasurementinvarianceoftheopeningmindsstigmascaleforhealthcareproviders
AT gyorffyz crossculturalanalysisofthestigmatisingattitudesofpsychiatristsacrosseuropeandmeasurementinvarianceoftheopeningmindsstigmascaleforhealthcareproviders