Challenges, opportunities, and innovative statistical designs for precision oncology trials

In the era of precision oncology, improved understanding of tumor heterogeneity, particularly at the molecular level, has caused a shift from traditionally histology based cancer drug development to molecularly targeted drug development. The shift to the molecular view of cancer leads to increasingly small cancer populations for clinical trials which may be underpowered using traditional statistical designs. This paradigm shift lead to the recent developments of innovative clinical trial designs to address the challenges from precision oncology clinical trials. Hence, this paper reviewed and described innovative trial designs for precision oncology. Different strategies were discussed to account patient and treatment effect heterogeneity, including precision dose-finding designs that tailor the optimal dose to different patients at different time points, master protocol designs that match patients’ molecular alterations with specific targeted agents, and adaptive enrichment designs that dynamically modify eligibility criteria and enroll patients that are most likely to benefit from the novel agents. Despite their superior performance, better understanding of practical barriers is needed to widen their implementation for precision oncology trials. Therefore, this paper also reviewed the practical challenges regarding the implementation of precision oncology clinical trials, along with the strength and weakness of various approaches of precision oncology clinical trial designs.