Cargando…

Case report: Senescence as mechanism of resistance to Pembrolizumab in a Lymphoma patient who failed CD19-Targeted CAR-T cell therapy

BACKGROUND: T cells engineered to target CD19 antigen on neoplastic B cells represent the most striking example of CAR-T cell therapy. The success rate of this therapy is affected by several limitations: target antigen loss, and/or acquisition of a senescent/exhausted phenotype by CAR and non-CAR T...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: De Matteis, Serena, Casadei, Beatrice, Lolli, Ginevra, Dicataldo, Michele, Barbato, Francesco, Dan, Elisa, Paccagnella, Andrea, Sinigaglia, Barbara, Bertuzzi, Clara, Arcari, Annalisa, Zazzeroni, Luca, Bernuzzi, Patrizia, Laprovitera, Noemi, Storci, Gianluca, Bertuccio, Salvatore Nicola, Ferracin, Manuela, Bonafè, Massimiliano, Zinzani, Pier Luigi, Bonifazi, Francesca
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Frontiers Media S.A. 2022
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9584643/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36275688
http://dx.doi.org/10.3389/fimmu.2022.994731
_version_ 1784813315256483840
author De Matteis, Serena
Casadei, Beatrice
Lolli, Ginevra
Dicataldo, Michele
Barbato, Francesco
Dan, Elisa
Paccagnella, Andrea
Sinigaglia, Barbara
Bertuzzi, Clara
Arcari, Annalisa
Zazzeroni, Luca
Bernuzzi, Patrizia
Laprovitera, Noemi
Storci, Gianluca
Bertuccio, Salvatore Nicola
Ferracin, Manuela
Bonafè, Massimiliano
Zinzani, Pier Luigi
Bonifazi, Francesca
author_facet De Matteis, Serena
Casadei, Beatrice
Lolli, Ginevra
Dicataldo, Michele
Barbato, Francesco
Dan, Elisa
Paccagnella, Andrea
Sinigaglia, Barbara
Bertuzzi, Clara
Arcari, Annalisa
Zazzeroni, Luca
Bernuzzi, Patrizia
Laprovitera, Noemi
Storci, Gianluca
Bertuccio, Salvatore Nicola
Ferracin, Manuela
Bonafè, Massimiliano
Zinzani, Pier Luigi
Bonifazi, Francesca
author_sort De Matteis, Serena
collection PubMed
description BACKGROUND: T cells engineered to target CD19 antigen on neoplastic B cells represent the most striking example of CAR-T cell therapy. The success rate of this therapy is affected by several limitations: target antigen loss, and/or acquisition of a senescent/exhausted phenotype by CAR and non-CAR T cells. CASE PRESENTATION: We report on a patient affected by refractory Diffuse Large B-cell Lymphoma who was resistant to CAR T-cell therapy and to two cycles post CAR-T of pembrolizumab (PBZ) due to the evolution into a B-cell Hodgkin-like lymphoma. Owing to the CD30 expression and the Hodgkin-like phenotype, the patient was ultimately treated with Brentuximab-Vedotin and finally underwent remission. Upon PBZ treatment, 100% of circulating CAR-T(+) cells showed a persistent CD8(+) senescent/exhausted phenotype, while an increase in the percentage of senescent cells was found in the non-CAR CD8(+) T cells compartment. CONCLUSIONS: PBZ is not able to reinvigorate exhausted CAR(+) T cells and to confer durable clinical response. We hypothesize that the phenomenon is due to the senescent phenotype of CAR(+) T cells, which did not allow PBZ-induced reactivation and proliferative rescue. The phenomenon, together with the loss of CAR-T target CD19 and the shift of non-CAR CD8(+) T cells towards a senescent phenotype likely contributed to set up an immune landscape with poor antitumor capacity.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-9584643
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2022
publisher Frontiers Media S.A.
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-95846432022-10-21 Case report: Senescence as mechanism of resistance to Pembrolizumab in a Lymphoma patient who failed CD19-Targeted CAR-T cell therapy De Matteis, Serena Casadei, Beatrice Lolli, Ginevra Dicataldo, Michele Barbato, Francesco Dan, Elisa Paccagnella, Andrea Sinigaglia, Barbara Bertuzzi, Clara Arcari, Annalisa Zazzeroni, Luca Bernuzzi, Patrizia Laprovitera, Noemi Storci, Gianluca Bertuccio, Salvatore Nicola Ferracin, Manuela Bonafè, Massimiliano Zinzani, Pier Luigi Bonifazi, Francesca Front Immunol Immunology BACKGROUND: T cells engineered to target CD19 antigen on neoplastic B cells represent the most striking example of CAR-T cell therapy. The success rate of this therapy is affected by several limitations: target antigen loss, and/or acquisition of a senescent/exhausted phenotype by CAR and non-CAR T cells. CASE PRESENTATION: We report on a patient affected by refractory Diffuse Large B-cell Lymphoma who was resistant to CAR T-cell therapy and to two cycles post CAR-T of pembrolizumab (PBZ) due to the evolution into a B-cell Hodgkin-like lymphoma. Owing to the CD30 expression and the Hodgkin-like phenotype, the patient was ultimately treated with Brentuximab-Vedotin and finally underwent remission. Upon PBZ treatment, 100% of circulating CAR-T(+) cells showed a persistent CD8(+) senescent/exhausted phenotype, while an increase in the percentage of senescent cells was found in the non-CAR CD8(+) T cells compartment. CONCLUSIONS: PBZ is not able to reinvigorate exhausted CAR(+) T cells and to confer durable clinical response. We hypothesize that the phenomenon is due to the senescent phenotype of CAR(+) T cells, which did not allow PBZ-induced reactivation and proliferative rescue. The phenomenon, together with the loss of CAR-T target CD19 and the shift of non-CAR CD8(+) T cells towards a senescent phenotype likely contributed to set up an immune landscape with poor antitumor capacity. Frontiers Media S.A. 2022-10-06 /pmc/articles/PMC9584643/ /pubmed/36275688 http://dx.doi.org/10.3389/fimmu.2022.994731 Text en Copyright © 2022 De Matteis, Casadei, Lolli, Dicataldo, Barbato, Dan, Paccagnella, Sinigaglia, Bertuzzi, Arcari, Zazzeroni, Bernuzzi, Laprovitera, Storci, Bertuccio, Ferracin, Bonafè, Zinzani and Bonifazi https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY). The use, distribution or reproduction in other forums is permitted, provided the original author(s) and the copyright owner(s) are credited and that the original publication in this journal is cited, in accordance with accepted academic practice. No use, distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not comply with these terms.
spellingShingle Immunology
De Matteis, Serena
Casadei, Beatrice
Lolli, Ginevra
Dicataldo, Michele
Barbato, Francesco
Dan, Elisa
Paccagnella, Andrea
Sinigaglia, Barbara
Bertuzzi, Clara
Arcari, Annalisa
Zazzeroni, Luca
Bernuzzi, Patrizia
Laprovitera, Noemi
Storci, Gianluca
Bertuccio, Salvatore Nicola
Ferracin, Manuela
Bonafè, Massimiliano
Zinzani, Pier Luigi
Bonifazi, Francesca
Case report: Senescence as mechanism of resistance to Pembrolizumab in a Lymphoma patient who failed CD19-Targeted CAR-T cell therapy
title Case report: Senescence as mechanism of resistance to Pembrolizumab in a Lymphoma patient who failed CD19-Targeted CAR-T cell therapy
title_full Case report: Senescence as mechanism of resistance to Pembrolizumab in a Lymphoma patient who failed CD19-Targeted CAR-T cell therapy
title_fullStr Case report: Senescence as mechanism of resistance to Pembrolizumab in a Lymphoma patient who failed CD19-Targeted CAR-T cell therapy
title_full_unstemmed Case report: Senescence as mechanism of resistance to Pembrolizumab in a Lymphoma patient who failed CD19-Targeted CAR-T cell therapy
title_short Case report: Senescence as mechanism of resistance to Pembrolizumab in a Lymphoma patient who failed CD19-Targeted CAR-T cell therapy
title_sort case report: senescence as mechanism of resistance to pembrolizumab in a lymphoma patient who failed cd19-targeted car-t cell therapy
topic Immunology
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9584643/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36275688
http://dx.doi.org/10.3389/fimmu.2022.994731
work_keys_str_mv AT dematteisserena casereportsenescenceasmechanismofresistancetopembrolizumabinalymphomapatientwhofailedcd19targetedcartcelltherapy
AT casadeibeatrice casereportsenescenceasmechanismofresistancetopembrolizumabinalymphomapatientwhofailedcd19targetedcartcelltherapy
AT lolliginevra casereportsenescenceasmechanismofresistancetopembrolizumabinalymphomapatientwhofailedcd19targetedcartcelltherapy
AT dicataldomichele casereportsenescenceasmechanismofresistancetopembrolizumabinalymphomapatientwhofailedcd19targetedcartcelltherapy
AT barbatofrancesco casereportsenescenceasmechanismofresistancetopembrolizumabinalymphomapatientwhofailedcd19targetedcartcelltherapy
AT danelisa casereportsenescenceasmechanismofresistancetopembrolizumabinalymphomapatientwhofailedcd19targetedcartcelltherapy
AT paccagnellaandrea casereportsenescenceasmechanismofresistancetopembrolizumabinalymphomapatientwhofailedcd19targetedcartcelltherapy
AT sinigagliabarbara casereportsenescenceasmechanismofresistancetopembrolizumabinalymphomapatientwhofailedcd19targetedcartcelltherapy
AT bertuzziclara casereportsenescenceasmechanismofresistancetopembrolizumabinalymphomapatientwhofailedcd19targetedcartcelltherapy
AT arcariannalisa casereportsenescenceasmechanismofresistancetopembrolizumabinalymphomapatientwhofailedcd19targetedcartcelltherapy
AT zazzeroniluca casereportsenescenceasmechanismofresistancetopembrolizumabinalymphomapatientwhofailedcd19targetedcartcelltherapy
AT bernuzzipatrizia casereportsenescenceasmechanismofresistancetopembrolizumabinalymphomapatientwhofailedcd19targetedcartcelltherapy
AT laproviteranoemi casereportsenescenceasmechanismofresistancetopembrolizumabinalymphomapatientwhofailedcd19targetedcartcelltherapy
AT storcigianluca casereportsenescenceasmechanismofresistancetopembrolizumabinalymphomapatientwhofailedcd19targetedcartcelltherapy
AT bertucciosalvatorenicola casereportsenescenceasmechanismofresistancetopembrolizumabinalymphomapatientwhofailedcd19targetedcartcelltherapy
AT ferracinmanuela casereportsenescenceasmechanismofresistancetopembrolizumabinalymphomapatientwhofailedcd19targetedcartcelltherapy
AT bonafemassimiliano casereportsenescenceasmechanismofresistancetopembrolizumabinalymphomapatientwhofailedcd19targetedcartcelltherapy
AT zinzanipierluigi casereportsenescenceasmechanismofresistancetopembrolizumabinalymphomapatientwhofailedcd19targetedcartcelltherapy
AT bonifazifrancesca casereportsenescenceasmechanismofresistancetopembrolizumabinalymphomapatientwhofailedcd19targetedcartcelltherapy