Cargando…

Machine learning-based scoring system to predict in-hospital outcomes in patients hospitalized with COVID-19()

BACKGROUND: The evolution of patients hospitalized with coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) is still hard to predict, even after several months of dealing with the pandemic. AIMS: To develop and validate a score to predict outcomes in patients hospitalized with COVID-19. METHODS: All consecutive adu...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Weizman, Orianne, Duceau, Baptiste, Trimaille, Antonin, Pommier, Thibaut, Cellier, Joffrey, Geneste, Laura, Panagides, Vassili, Marsou, Wassima, Deney, Antoine, Attou, Sabir, Delmotte, Thomas, Ribeyrolles, Sophie, Chemaly, Pascale, Karsenty, Clément, Giordano, Gauthier, Gautier, Alexandre, Chaumont, Corentin, Guilleminot, Pierre, Sagnard, Audrey, Pastier, Julie, Ezzouhairi, Nacim, Perin, Benjamin, Zakine, Cyril, Levasseur, Thomas, Ma, Iris, Chavignier, Diane, Noirclerc, Nathalie, Darmon, Arthur, Mevelec, Marine, Sutter, Willy, Mika, Delphine, Fauvel, Charles, Pezel, Théo, Waldmann, Victor, Cohen, Ariel, Bonnet, Guillaume
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Published by Elsevier Masson SAS. 2022
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9595484/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36376208
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.acvd.2022.08.003
_version_ 1784815661350912000
author Weizman, Orianne
Duceau, Baptiste
Trimaille, Antonin
Pommier, Thibaut
Cellier, Joffrey
Geneste, Laura
Panagides, Vassili
Marsou, Wassima
Deney, Antoine
Attou, Sabir
Delmotte, Thomas
Ribeyrolles, Sophie
Chemaly, Pascale
Karsenty, Clément
Giordano, Gauthier
Gautier, Alexandre
Chaumont, Corentin
Guilleminot, Pierre
Sagnard, Audrey
Pastier, Julie
Ezzouhairi, Nacim
Perin, Benjamin
Zakine, Cyril
Levasseur, Thomas
Ma, Iris
Chavignier, Diane
Noirclerc, Nathalie
Darmon, Arthur
Mevelec, Marine
Sutter, Willy
Mika, Delphine
Fauvel, Charles
Pezel, Théo
Waldmann, Victor
Cohen, Ariel
Bonnet, Guillaume
author_facet Weizman, Orianne
Duceau, Baptiste
Trimaille, Antonin
Pommier, Thibaut
Cellier, Joffrey
Geneste, Laura
Panagides, Vassili
Marsou, Wassima
Deney, Antoine
Attou, Sabir
Delmotte, Thomas
Ribeyrolles, Sophie
Chemaly, Pascale
Karsenty, Clément
Giordano, Gauthier
Gautier, Alexandre
Chaumont, Corentin
Guilleminot, Pierre
Sagnard, Audrey
Pastier, Julie
Ezzouhairi, Nacim
Perin, Benjamin
Zakine, Cyril
Levasseur, Thomas
Ma, Iris
Chavignier, Diane
Noirclerc, Nathalie
Darmon, Arthur
Mevelec, Marine
Sutter, Willy
Mika, Delphine
Fauvel, Charles
Pezel, Théo
Waldmann, Victor
Cohen, Ariel
Bonnet, Guillaume
author_sort Weizman, Orianne
collection PubMed
description BACKGROUND: The evolution of patients hospitalized with coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) is still hard to predict, even after several months of dealing with the pandemic. AIMS: To develop and validate a score to predict outcomes in patients hospitalized with COVID-19. METHODS: All consecutive adults hospitalized for COVID-19 from February to April 2020 were included in a nationwide observational study. Primary composite outcome was transfer to an intensive care unit from an emergency department or conventional ward, or in-hospital death. A score that estimates the risk of experiencing the primary outcome was constructed from a derivation cohort using stacked LASSO (Least Absolute Shrinkage and Selection Operator), and was tested in a validation cohort. RESULTS: Among 2873 patients analysed (57.9% men; 66.6 ± 17.0 years), the primary outcome occurred in 838 (29.2%) patients: 551 (19.2%) were transferred to an intensive care unit; and 287 (10.0%) died in-hospital without transfer to an intensive care unit. Using stacked LASSO, we identified 11 variables independently associated with the primary outcome in multivariable analysis in the derivation cohort (n = 2313), including demographics (sex), triage vitals (body temperature, dyspnoea, respiratory rate, fraction of inspired oxygen, blood oxygen saturation) and biological variables (pH, platelets, C-reactive protein, aspartate aminotransferase, estimated glomerular filtration rate). The Critical COVID-19 France (CCF) risk score was then developed, and displayed accurate calibration and discrimination in the derivation cohort, with C-statistics of 0.78 (95% confidence interval 0.75–0.80). The CCF risk score performed significantly better (i.e. higher C-statistics) than the usual critical care risk scores. CONCLUSIONS: The CCF risk score was built using data collected routinely at hospital admission to predict outcomes in patients with COVID-19. This score holds promise to improve early triage of patients and allocation of healthcare resources.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-9595484
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2022
publisher Published by Elsevier Masson SAS.
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-95954842022-10-25 Machine learning-based scoring system to predict in-hospital outcomes in patients hospitalized with COVID-19() Weizman, Orianne Duceau, Baptiste Trimaille, Antonin Pommier, Thibaut Cellier, Joffrey Geneste, Laura Panagides, Vassili Marsou, Wassima Deney, Antoine Attou, Sabir Delmotte, Thomas Ribeyrolles, Sophie Chemaly, Pascale Karsenty, Clément Giordano, Gauthier Gautier, Alexandre Chaumont, Corentin Guilleminot, Pierre Sagnard, Audrey Pastier, Julie Ezzouhairi, Nacim Perin, Benjamin Zakine, Cyril Levasseur, Thomas Ma, Iris Chavignier, Diane Noirclerc, Nathalie Darmon, Arthur Mevelec, Marine Sutter, Willy Mika, Delphine Fauvel, Charles Pezel, Théo Waldmann, Victor Cohen, Ariel Bonnet, Guillaume Arch Cardiovasc Dis Clinical Research BACKGROUND: The evolution of patients hospitalized with coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) is still hard to predict, even after several months of dealing with the pandemic. AIMS: To develop and validate a score to predict outcomes in patients hospitalized with COVID-19. METHODS: All consecutive adults hospitalized for COVID-19 from February to April 2020 were included in a nationwide observational study. Primary composite outcome was transfer to an intensive care unit from an emergency department or conventional ward, or in-hospital death. A score that estimates the risk of experiencing the primary outcome was constructed from a derivation cohort using stacked LASSO (Least Absolute Shrinkage and Selection Operator), and was tested in a validation cohort. RESULTS: Among 2873 patients analysed (57.9% men; 66.6 ± 17.0 years), the primary outcome occurred in 838 (29.2%) patients: 551 (19.2%) were transferred to an intensive care unit; and 287 (10.0%) died in-hospital without transfer to an intensive care unit. Using stacked LASSO, we identified 11 variables independently associated with the primary outcome in multivariable analysis in the derivation cohort (n = 2313), including demographics (sex), triage vitals (body temperature, dyspnoea, respiratory rate, fraction of inspired oxygen, blood oxygen saturation) and biological variables (pH, platelets, C-reactive protein, aspartate aminotransferase, estimated glomerular filtration rate). The Critical COVID-19 France (CCF) risk score was then developed, and displayed accurate calibration and discrimination in the derivation cohort, with C-statistics of 0.78 (95% confidence interval 0.75–0.80). The CCF risk score performed significantly better (i.e. higher C-statistics) than the usual critical care risk scores. CONCLUSIONS: The CCF risk score was built using data collected routinely at hospital admission to predict outcomes in patients with COVID-19. This score holds promise to improve early triage of patients and allocation of healthcare resources. Published by Elsevier Masson SAS. 2022-12 2022-10-22 /pmc/articles/PMC9595484/ /pubmed/36376208 http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.acvd.2022.08.003 Text en © 2022 Published by Elsevier Masson SAS. Since January 2020 Elsevier has created a COVID-19 resource centre with free information in English and Mandarin on the novel coronavirus COVID-19. The COVID-19 resource centre is hosted on Elsevier Connect, the company's public news and information website. Elsevier hereby grants permission to make all its COVID-19-related research that is available on the COVID-19 resource centre - including this research content - immediately available in PubMed Central and other publicly funded repositories, such as the WHO COVID database with rights for unrestricted research re-use and analyses in any form or by any means with acknowledgement of the original source. These permissions are granted for free by Elsevier for as long as the COVID-19 resource centre remains active.
spellingShingle Clinical Research
Weizman, Orianne
Duceau, Baptiste
Trimaille, Antonin
Pommier, Thibaut
Cellier, Joffrey
Geneste, Laura
Panagides, Vassili
Marsou, Wassima
Deney, Antoine
Attou, Sabir
Delmotte, Thomas
Ribeyrolles, Sophie
Chemaly, Pascale
Karsenty, Clément
Giordano, Gauthier
Gautier, Alexandre
Chaumont, Corentin
Guilleminot, Pierre
Sagnard, Audrey
Pastier, Julie
Ezzouhairi, Nacim
Perin, Benjamin
Zakine, Cyril
Levasseur, Thomas
Ma, Iris
Chavignier, Diane
Noirclerc, Nathalie
Darmon, Arthur
Mevelec, Marine
Sutter, Willy
Mika, Delphine
Fauvel, Charles
Pezel, Théo
Waldmann, Victor
Cohen, Ariel
Bonnet, Guillaume
Machine learning-based scoring system to predict in-hospital outcomes in patients hospitalized with COVID-19()
title Machine learning-based scoring system to predict in-hospital outcomes in patients hospitalized with COVID-19()
title_full Machine learning-based scoring system to predict in-hospital outcomes in patients hospitalized with COVID-19()
title_fullStr Machine learning-based scoring system to predict in-hospital outcomes in patients hospitalized with COVID-19()
title_full_unstemmed Machine learning-based scoring system to predict in-hospital outcomes in patients hospitalized with COVID-19()
title_short Machine learning-based scoring system to predict in-hospital outcomes in patients hospitalized with COVID-19()
title_sort machine learning-based scoring system to predict in-hospital outcomes in patients hospitalized with covid-19()
topic Clinical Research
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9595484/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36376208
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.acvd.2022.08.003
work_keys_str_mv AT weizmanorianne machinelearningbasedscoringsystemtopredictinhospitaloutcomesinpatientshospitalizedwithcovid19
AT duceaubaptiste machinelearningbasedscoringsystemtopredictinhospitaloutcomesinpatientshospitalizedwithcovid19
AT trimailleantonin machinelearningbasedscoringsystemtopredictinhospitaloutcomesinpatientshospitalizedwithcovid19
AT pommierthibaut machinelearningbasedscoringsystemtopredictinhospitaloutcomesinpatientshospitalizedwithcovid19
AT cellierjoffrey machinelearningbasedscoringsystemtopredictinhospitaloutcomesinpatientshospitalizedwithcovid19
AT genestelaura machinelearningbasedscoringsystemtopredictinhospitaloutcomesinpatientshospitalizedwithcovid19
AT panagidesvassili machinelearningbasedscoringsystemtopredictinhospitaloutcomesinpatientshospitalizedwithcovid19
AT marsouwassima machinelearningbasedscoringsystemtopredictinhospitaloutcomesinpatientshospitalizedwithcovid19
AT deneyantoine machinelearningbasedscoringsystemtopredictinhospitaloutcomesinpatientshospitalizedwithcovid19
AT attousabir machinelearningbasedscoringsystemtopredictinhospitaloutcomesinpatientshospitalizedwithcovid19
AT delmottethomas machinelearningbasedscoringsystemtopredictinhospitaloutcomesinpatientshospitalizedwithcovid19
AT ribeyrollessophie machinelearningbasedscoringsystemtopredictinhospitaloutcomesinpatientshospitalizedwithcovid19
AT chemalypascale machinelearningbasedscoringsystemtopredictinhospitaloutcomesinpatientshospitalizedwithcovid19
AT karsentyclement machinelearningbasedscoringsystemtopredictinhospitaloutcomesinpatientshospitalizedwithcovid19
AT giordanogauthier machinelearningbasedscoringsystemtopredictinhospitaloutcomesinpatientshospitalizedwithcovid19
AT gautieralexandre machinelearningbasedscoringsystemtopredictinhospitaloutcomesinpatientshospitalizedwithcovid19
AT chaumontcorentin machinelearningbasedscoringsystemtopredictinhospitaloutcomesinpatientshospitalizedwithcovid19
AT guilleminotpierre machinelearningbasedscoringsystemtopredictinhospitaloutcomesinpatientshospitalizedwithcovid19
AT sagnardaudrey machinelearningbasedscoringsystemtopredictinhospitaloutcomesinpatientshospitalizedwithcovid19
AT pastierjulie machinelearningbasedscoringsystemtopredictinhospitaloutcomesinpatientshospitalizedwithcovid19
AT ezzouhairinacim machinelearningbasedscoringsystemtopredictinhospitaloutcomesinpatientshospitalizedwithcovid19
AT perinbenjamin machinelearningbasedscoringsystemtopredictinhospitaloutcomesinpatientshospitalizedwithcovid19
AT zakinecyril machinelearningbasedscoringsystemtopredictinhospitaloutcomesinpatientshospitalizedwithcovid19
AT levasseurthomas machinelearningbasedscoringsystemtopredictinhospitaloutcomesinpatientshospitalizedwithcovid19
AT mairis machinelearningbasedscoringsystemtopredictinhospitaloutcomesinpatientshospitalizedwithcovid19
AT chavignierdiane machinelearningbasedscoringsystemtopredictinhospitaloutcomesinpatientshospitalizedwithcovid19
AT noirclercnathalie machinelearningbasedscoringsystemtopredictinhospitaloutcomesinpatientshospitalizedwithcovid19
AT darmonarthur machinelearningbasedscoringsystemtopredictinhospitaloutcomesinpatientshospitalizedwithcovid19
AT mevelecmarine machinelearningbasedscoringsystemtopredictinhospitaloutcomesinpatientshospitalizedwithcovid19
AT sutterwilly machinelearningbasedscoringsystemtopredictinhospitaloutcomesinpatientshospitalizedwithcovid19
AT mikadelphine machinelearningbasedscoringsystemtopredictinhospitaloutcomesinpatientshospitalizedwithcovid19
AT fauvelcharles machinelearningbasedscoringsystemtopredictinhospitaloutcomesinpatientshospitalizedwithcovid19
AT pezeltheo machinelearningbasedscoringsystemtopredictinhospitaloutcomesinpatientshospitalizedwithcovid19
AT waldmannvictor machinelearningbasedscoringsystemtopredictinhospitaloutcomesinpatientshospitalizedwithcovid19
AT cohenariel machinelearningbasedscoringsystemtopredictinhospitaloutcomesinpatientshospitalizedwithcovid19
AT bonnetguillaume machinelearningbasedscoringsystemtopredictinhospitaloutcomesinpatientshospitalizedwithcovid19
AT machinelearningbasedscoringsystemtopredictinhospitaloutcomesinpatientshospitalizedwithcovid19