Cargando…

Effectiveness of rapid SARS-CoV-2 genome sequencing in supporting infection control for hospital-onset COVID-19 infection: Multicentre, prospective study

BACKGROUND: Viral sequencing of SARS-CoV-2 has been used for outbreak investigation, but there is limited evidence supporting routine use for infection prevention and control (IPC) within hospital settings. METHODS: We conducted a prospective non-randomised trial of sequencing at 14 acute UK hospita...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Stirrup, Oliver, Blackstone, James, Mapp, Fiona, MacNeil, Alyson, Panca, Monica, Holmes, Alison, Machin, Nicholas, Shin, Gee Yen, Mahungu, Tabitha, Saeed, Kordo, Saluja, Tranprit, Taha, Yusri, Mahida, Nikunj, Pope, Cassie, Chawla, Anu, Cutino-Moguel, Maria-Teresa, Tamuri, Asif, Williams, Rachel, Darby, Alistair, Robertson, David L, Flaviani, Flavia, Nastouli, Eleni, Robson, Samuel, Smith, Darren, Loose, Matthew, Laing, Kenneth, Monahan, Irene, Kele, Beatrix, Haldenby, Sam, George, Ryan, Bashton, Matthew, Witney, Adam A, Byott, Matthew, Coll, Francesc, Chapman, Michael, Peacock, Sharon J, Hughes, Joseph, Nebbia, Gaia, Partridge, David G, Parker, Matthew, Price, James Richard, Peters, Christine, Roy, Sunando, Snell, Luke B, de Silva, Thushan I, Thomson, Emma, Flowers, Paul, Copas, Andrew, Breuer, Judith
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: eLife Sciences Publications, Ltd 2022
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9596156/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36098502
http://dx.doi.org/10.7554/eLife.78427
_version_ 1784815806247337984
author Stirrup, Oliver
Blackstone, James
Mapp, Fiona
MacNeil, Alyson
Panca, Monica
Holmes, Alison
Machin, Nicholas
Shin, Gee Yen
Mahungu, Tabitha
Saeed, Kordo
Saluja, Tranprit
Taha, Yusri
Mahida, Nikunj
Pope, Cassie
Chawla, Anu
Cutino-Moguel, Maria-Teresa
Tamuri, Asif
Williams, Rachel
Darby, Alistair
Robertson, David L
Flaviani, Flavia
Nastouli, Eleni
Robson, Samuel
Smith, Darren
Loose, Matthew
Laing, Kenneth
Monahan, Irene
Kele, Beatrix
Haldenby, Sam
George, Ryan
Bashton, Matthew
Witney, Adam A
Byott, Matthew
Coll, Francesc
Chapman, Michael
Peacock, Sharon J
Hughes, Joseph
Nebbia, Gaia
Partridge, David G
Parker, Matthew
Price, James Richard
Peters, Christine
Roy, Sunando
Snell, Luke B
de Silva, Thushan I
Thomson, Emma
Flowers, Paul
Copas, Andrew
Breuer, Judith
author_facet Stirrup, Oliver
Blackstone, James
Mapp, Fiona
MacNeil, Alyson
Panca, Monica
Holmes, Alison
Machin, Nicholas
Shin, Gee Yen
Mahungu, Tabitha
Saeed, Kordo
Saluja, Tranprit
Taha, Yusri
Mahida, Nikunj
Pope, Cassie
Chawla, Anu
Cutino-Moguel, Maria-Teresa
Tamuri, Asif
Williams, Rachel
Darby, Alistair
Robertson, David L
Flaviani, Flavia
Nastouli, Eleni
Robson, Samuel
Smith, Darren
Loose, Matthew
Laing, Kenneth
Monahan, Irene
Kele, Beatrix
Haldenby, Sam
George, Ryan
Bashton, Matthew
Witney, Adam A
Byott, Matthew
Coll, Francesc
Chapman, Michael
Peacock, Sharon J
Hughes, Joseph
Nebbia, Gaia
Partridge, David G
Parker, Matthew
Price, James Richard
Peters, Christine
Roy, Sunando
Snell, Luke B
de Silva, Thushan I
Thomson, Emma
Flowers, Paul
Copas, Andrew
Breuer, Judith
author_sort Stirrup, Oliver
collection PubMed
description BACKGROUND: Viral sequencing of SARS-CoV-2 has been used for outbreak investigation, but there is limited evidence supporting routine use for infection prevention and control (IPC) within hospital settings. METHODS: We conducted a prospective non-randomised trial of sequencing at 14 acute UK hospital trusts. Sites each had a 4-week baseline data collection period, followed by intervention periods comprising 8 weeks of ‘rapid’ (<48 hr) and 4 weeks of ‘longer-turnaround’ (5–10 days) sequencing using a sequence reporting tool (SRT). Data were collected on all hospital-onset COVID-19 infections (HOCIs; detected ≥48 hr from admission). The impact of the sequencing intervention on IPC knowledge and actions, and on the incidence of probable/definite hospital-acquired infections (HAIs), was evaluated. RESULTS: A total of 2170 HOCI cases were recorded from October 2020 to April 2021, corresponding to a period of extreme strain on the health service, with sequence reports returned for 650/1320 (49.2%) during intervention phases. We did not detect a statistically significant change in weekly incidence of HAIs in longer-turnaround (incidence rate ratio 1.60, 95% CI 0.85–3.01; p=0.14) or rapid (0.85, 0.48–1.50; p=0.54) intervention phases compared to baseline phase. However, IPC practice was changed in 7.8 and 7.4% of all HOCI cases in rapid and longer-turnaround phases, respectively, and 17.2 and 11.6% of cases where the report was returned. In a ‘per-protocol’ sensitivity analysis, there was an impact on IPC actions in 20.7% of HOCI cases when the SRT report was returned within 5 days. Capacity to respond effectively to insights from sequencing was breached in most sites by the volume of cases and limited resources. CONCLUSIONS: While we did not demonstrate a direct impact of sequencing on the incidence of nosocomial transmission, our results suggest that sequencing can inform IPC response to HOCIs, particularly when returned within 5 days. FUNDING: COG-UK is supported by funding from the Medical Research Council (MRC) part of UK Research & Innovation (UKRI), the National Institute of Health Research (NIHR) (grant code: MC_PC_19027), and Genome Research Limited, operating as the Wellcome Sanger Institute. CLINICAL TRIAL NUMBER: NCT04405934.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-9596156
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2022
publisher eLife Sciences Publications, Ltd
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-95961562022-10-26 Effectiveness of rapid SARS-CoV-2 genome sequencing in supporting infection control for hospital-onset COVID-19 infection: Multicentre, prospective study Stirrup, Oliver Blackstone, James Mapp, Fiona MacNeil, Alyson Panca, Monica Holmes, Alison Machin, Nicholas Shin, Gee Yen Mahungu, Tabitha Saeed, Kordo Saluja, Tranprit Taha, Yusri Mahida, Nikunj Pope, Cassie Chawla, Anu Cutino-Moguel, Maria-Teresa Tamuri, Asif Williams, Rachel Darby, Alistair Robertson, David L Flaviani, Flavia Nastouli, Eleni Robson, Samuel Smith, Darren Loose, Matthew Laing, Kenneth Monahan, Irene Kele, Beatrix Haldenby, Sam George, Ryan Bashton, Matthew Witney, Adam A Byott, Matthew Coll, Francesc Chapman, Michael Peacock, Sharon J Hughes, Joseph Nebbia, Gaia Partridge, David G Parker, Matthew Price, James Richard Peters, Christine Roy, Sunando Snell, Luke B de Silva, Thushan I Thomson, Emma Flowers, Paul Copas, Andrew Breuer, Judith eLife Epidemiology and Global Health BACKGROUND: Viral sequencing of SARS-CoV-2 has been used for outbreak investigation, but there is limited evidence supporting routine use for infection prevention and control (IPC) within hospital settings. METHODS: We conducted a prospective non-randomised trial of sequencing at 14 acute UK hospital trusts. Sites each had a 4-week baseline data collection period, followed by intervention periods comprising 8 weeks of ‘rapid’ (<48 hr) and 4 weeks of ‘longer-turnaround’ (5–10 days) sequencing using a sequence reporting tool (SRT). Data were collected on all hospital-onset COVID-19 infections (HOCIs; detected ≥48 hr from admission). The impact of the sequencing intervention on IPC knowledge and actions, and on the incidence of probable/definite hospital-acquired infections (HAIs), was evaluated. RESULTS: A total of 2170 HOCI cases were recorded from October 2020 to April 2021, corresponding to a period of extreme strain on the health service, with sequence reports returned for 650/1320 (49.2%) during intervention phases. We did not detect a statistically significant change in weekly incidence of HAIs in longer-turnaround (incidence rate ratio 1.60, 95% CI 0.85–3.01; p=0.14) or rapid (0.85, 0.48–1.50; p=0.54) intervention phases compared to baseline phase. However, IPC practice was changed in 7.8 and 7.4% of all HOCI cases in rapid and longer-turnaround phases, respectively, and 17.2 and 11.6% of cases where the report was returned. In a ‘per-protocol’ sensitivity analysis, there was an impact on IPC actions in 20.7% of HOCI cases when the SRT report was returned within 5 days. Capacity to respond effectively to insights from sequencing was breached in most sites by the volume of cases and limited resources. CONCLUSIONS: While we did not demonstrate a direct impact of sequencing on the incidence of nosocomial transmission, our results suggest that sequencing can inform IPC response to HOCIs, particularly when returned within 5 days. FUNDING: COG-UK is supported by funding from the Medical Research Council (MRC) part of UK Research & Innovation (UKRI), the National Institute of Health Research (NIHR) (grant code: MC_PC_19027), and Genome Research Limited, operating as the Wellcome Sanger Institute. CLINICAL TRIAL NUMBER: NCT04405934. eLife Sciences Publications, Ltd 2022-09-13 /pmc/articles/PMC9596156/ /pubmed/36098502 http://dx.doi.org/10.7554/eLife.78427 Text en © 2022, Stirrup et al https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) , which permits unrestricted use and redistribution provided that the original author and source are credited.
spellingShingle Epidemiology and Global Health
Stirrup, Oliver
Blackstone, James
Mapp, Fiona
MacNeil, Alyson
Panca, Monica
Holmes, Alison
Machin, Nicholas
Shin, Gee Yen
Mahungu, Tabitha
Saeed, Kordo
Saluja, Tranprit
Taha, Yusri
Mahida, Nikunj
Pope, Cassie
Chawla, Anu
Cutino-Moguel, Maria-Teresa
Tamuri, Asif
Williams, Rachel
Darby, Alistair
Robertson, David L
Flaviani, Flavia
Nastouli, Eleni
Robson, Samuel
Smith, Darren
Loose, Matthew
Laing, Kenneth
Monahan, Irene
Kele, Beatrix
Haldenby, Sam
George, Ryan
Bashton, Matthew
Witney, Adam A
Byott, Matthew
Coll, Francesc
Chapman, Michael
Peacock, Sharon J
Hughes, Joseph
Nebbia, Gaia
Partridge, David G
Parker, Matthew
Price, James Richard
Peters, Christine
Roy, Sunando
Snell, Luke B
de Silva, Thushan I
Thomson, Emma
Flowers, Paul
Copas, Andrew
Breuer, Judith
Effectiveness of rapid SARS-CoV-2 genome sequencing in supporting infection control for hospital-onset COVID-19 infection: Multicentre, prospective study
title Effectiveness of rapid SARS-CoV-2 genome sequencing in supporting infection control for hospital-onset COVID-19 infection: Multicentre, prospective study
title_full Effectiveness of rapid SARS-CoV-2 genome sequencing in supporting infection control for hospital-onset COVID-19 infection: Multicentre, prospective study
title_fullStr Effectiveness of rapid SARS-CoV-2 genome sequencing in supporting infection control for hospital-onset COVID-19 infection: Multicentre, prospective study
title_full_unstemmed Effectiveness of rapid SARS-CoV-2 genome sequencing in supporting infection control for hospital-onset COVID-19 infection: Multicentre, prospective study
title_short Effectiveness of rapid SARS-CoV-2 genome sequencing in supporting infection control for hospital-onset COVID-19 infection: Multicentre, prospective study
title_sort effectiveness of rapid sars-cov-2 genome sequencing in supporting infection control for hospital-onset covid-19 infection: multicentre, prospective study
topic Epidemiology and Global Health
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9596156/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36098502
http://dx.doi.org/10.7554/eLife.78427
work_keys_str_mv AT stirrupoliver effectivenessofrapidsarscov2genomesequencinginsupportinginfectioncontrolforhospitalonsetcovid19infectionmulticentreprospectivestudy
AT blackstonejames effectivenessofrapidsarscov2genomesequencinginsupportinginfectioncontrolforhospitalonsetcovid19infectionmulticentreprospectivestudy
AT mappfiona effectivenessofrapidsarscov2genomesequencinginsupportinginfectioncontrolforhospitalonsetcovid19infectionmulticentreprospectivestudy
AT macneilalyson effectivenessofrapidsarscov2genomesequencinginsupportinginfectioncontrolforhospitalonsetcovid19infectionmulticentreprospectivestudy
AT pancamonica effectivenessofrapidsarscov2genomesequencinginsupportinginfectioncontrolforhospitalonsetcovid19infectionmulticentreprospectivestudy
AT holmesalison effectivenessofrapidsarscov2genomesequencinginsupportinginfectioncontrolforhospitalonsetcovid19infectionmulticentreprospectivestudy
AT machinnicholas effectivenessofrapidsarscov2genomesequencinginsupportinginfectioncontrolforhospitalonsetcovid19infectionmulticentreprospectivestudy
AT shingeeyen effectivenessofrapidsarscov2genomesequencinginsupportinginfectioncontrolforhospitalonsetcovid19infectionmulticentreprospectivestudy
AT mahungutabitha effectivenessofrapidsarscov2genomesequencinginsupportinginfectioncontrolforhospitalonsetcovid19infectionmulticentreprospectivestudy
AT saeedkordo effectivenessofrapidsarscov2genomesequencinginsupportinginfectioncontrolforhospitalonsetcovid19infectionmulticentreprospectivestudy
AT salujatranprit effectivenessofrapidsarscov2genomesequencinginsupportinginfectioncontrolforhospitalonsetcovid19infectionmulticentreprospectivestudy
AT tahayusri effectivenessofrapidsarscov2genomesequencinginsupportinginfectioncontrolforhospitalonsetcovid19infectionmulticentreprospectivestudy
AT mahidanikunj effectivenessofrapidsarscov2genomesequencinginsupportinginfectioncontrolforhospitalonsetcovid19infectionmulticentreprospectivestudy
AT popecassie effectivenessofrapidsarscov2genomesequencinginsupportinginfectioncontrolforhospitalonsetcovid19infectionmulticentreprospectivestudy
AT chawlaanu effectivenessofrapidsarscov2genomesequencinginsupportinginfectioncontrolforhospitalonsetcovid19infectionmulticentreprospectivestudy
AT cutinomoguelmariateresa effectivenessofrapidsarscov2genomesequencinginsupportinginfectioncontrolforhospitalonsetcovid19infectionmulticentreprospectivestudy
AT tamuriasif effectivenessofrapidsarscov2genomesequencinginsupportinginfectioncontrolforhospitalonsetcovid19infectionmulticentreprospectivestudy
AT williamsrachel effectivenessofrapidsarscov2genomesequencinginsupportinginfectioncontrolforhospitalonsetcovid19infectionmulticentreprospectivestudy
AT darbyalistair effectivenessofrapidsarscov2genomesequencinginsupportinginfectioncontrolforhospitalonsetcovid19infectionmulticentreprospectivestudy
AT robertsondavidl effectivenessofrapidsarscov2genomesequencinginsupportinginfectioncontrolforhospitalonsetcovid19infectionmulticentreprospectivestudy
AT flavianiflavia effectivenessofrapidsarscov2genomesequencinginsupportinginfectioncontrolforhospitalonsetcovid19infectionmulticentreprospectivestudy
AT nastoulieleni effectivenessofrapidsarscov2genomesequencinginsupportinginfectioncontrolforhospitalonsetcovid19infectionmulticentreprospectivestudy
AT robsonsamuel effectivenessofrapidsarscov2genomesequencinginsupportinginfectioncontrolforhospitalonsetcovid19infectionmulticentreprospectivestudy
AT smithdarren effectivenessofrapidsarscov2genomesequencinginsupportinginfectioncontrolforhospitalonsetcovid19infectionmulticentreprospectivestudy
AT loosematthew effectivenessofrapidsarscov2genomesequencinginsupportinginfectioncontrolforhospitalonsetcovid19infectionmulticentreprospectivestudy
AT laingkenneth effectivenessofrapidsarscov2genomesequencinginsupportinginfectioncontrolforhospitalonsetcovid19infectionmulticentreprospectivestudy
AT monahanirene effectivenessofrapidsarscov2genomesequencinginsupportinginfectioncontrolforhospitalonsetcovid19infectionmulticentreprospectivestudy
AT kelebeatrix effectivenessofrapidsarscov2genomesequencinginsupportinginfectioncontrolforhospitalonsetcovid19infectionmulticentreprospectivestudy
AT haldenbysam effectivenessofrapidsarscov2genomesequencinginsupportinginfectioncontrolforhospitalonsetcovid19infectionmulticentreprospectivestudy
AT georgeryan effectivenessofrapidsarscov2genomesequencinginsupportinginfectioncontrolforhospitalonsetcovid19infectionmulticentreprospectivestudy
AT bashtonmatthew effectivenessofrapidsarscov2genomesequencinginsupportinginfectioncontrolforhospitalonsetcovid19infectionmulticentreprospectivestudy
AT witneyadama effectivenessofrapidsarscov2genomesequencinginsupportinginfectioncontrolforhospitalonsetcovid19infectionmulticentreprospectivestudy
AT byottmatthew effectivenessofrapidsarscov2genomesequencinginsupportinginfectioncontrolforhospitalonsetcovid19infectionmulticentreprospectivestudy
AT collfrancesc effectivenessofrapidsarscov2genomesequencinginsupportinginfectioncontrolforhospitalonsetcovid19infectionmulticentreprospectivestudy
AT chapmanmichael effectivenessofrapidsarscov2genomesequencinginsupportinginfectioncontrolforhospitalonsetcovid19infectionmulticentreprospectivestudy
AT peacocksharonj effectivenessofrapidsarscov2genomesequencinginsupportinginfectioncontrolforhospitalonsetcovid19infectionmulticentreprospectivestudy
AT effectivenessofrapidsarscov2genomesequencinginsupportinginfectioncontrolforhospitalonsetcovid19infectionmulticentreprospectivestudy
AT effectivenessofrapidsarscov2genomesequencinginsupportinginfectioncontrolforhospitalonsetcovid19infectionmulticentreprospectivestudy
AT hughesjoseph effectivenessofrapidsarscov2genomesequencinginsupportinginfectioncontrolforhospitalonsetcovid19infectionmulticentreprospectivestudy
AT nebbiagaia effectivenessofrapidsarscov2genomesequencinginsupportinginfectioncontrolforhospitalonsetcovid19infectionmulticentreprospectivestudy
AT partridgedavidg effectivenessofrapidsarscov2genomesequencinginsupportinginfectioncontrolforhospitalonsetcovid19infectionmulticentreprospectivestudy
AT parkermatthew effectivenessofrapidsarscov2genomesequencinginsupportinginfectioncontrolforhospitalonsetcovid19infectionmulticentreprospectivestudy
AT pricejamesrichard effectivenessofrapidsarscov2genomesequencinginsupportinginfectioncontrolforhospitalonsetcovid19infectionmulticentreprospectivestudy
AT peterschristine effectivenessofrapidsarscov2genomesequencinginsupportinginfectioncontrolforhospitalonsetcovid19infectionmulticentreprospectivestudy
AT roysunando effectivenessofrapidsarscov2genomesequencinginsupportinginfectioncontrolforhospitalonsetcovid19infectionmulticentreprospectivestudy
AT snelllukeb effectivenessofrapidsarscov2genomesequencinginsupportinginfectioncontrolforhospitalonsetcovid19infectionmulticentreprospectivestudy
AT desilvathushani effectivenessofrapidsarscov2genomesequencinginsupportinginfectioncontrolforhospitalonsetcovid19infectionmulticentreprospectivestudy
AT thomsonemma effectivenessofrapidsarscov2genomesequencinginsupportinginfectioncontrolforhospitalonsetcovid19infectionmulticentreprospectivestudy
AT flowerspaul effectivenessofrapidsarscov2genomesequencinginsupportinginfectioncontrolforhospitalonsetcovid19infectionmulticentreprospectivestudy
AT copasandrew effectivenessofrapidsarscov2genomesequencinginsupportinginfectioncontrolforhospitalonsetcovid19infectionmulticentreprospectivestudy
AT breuerjudith effectivenessofrapidsarscov2genomesequencinginsupportinginfectioncontrolforhospitalonsetcovid19infectionmulticentreprospectivestudy