Cargando…

The effect of gender bias on acceptance of antibiotic stewardship recommendations by clinical pharmacists

Background: Clinical pharmacists are a critical part of antibiotic stewardship. Stewardship often relies on relationships and persuasion, which may be affected by gender bias. Thus, we aimed to assess the association of sex with the acceptance of antibiotic stewardship recommendations. Methods: Betw...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Vaughn, Valerie, Giesler, Daniel, Brancaccio, Adamo, Mashrah, Daraoun, Sandison, Katie, Wu, Chaorong, Horowitz, Jennifer, Bashaw, Linda, Hersh, Adam
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Cambridge University Press 2022
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9614869/
http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/ash.2022.188
_version_ 1784820289342799872
author Vaughn, Valerie
Giesler, Daniel
Brancaccio, Adamo
Mashrah, Daraoun
Sandison, Katie
Wu, Chaorong
Horowitz, Jennifer
Bashaw, Linda
Hersh, Adam
author_facet Vaughn, Valerie
Giesler, Daniel
Brancaccio, Adamo
Mashrah, Daraoun
Sandison, Katie
Wu, Chaorong
Horowitz, Jennifer
Bashaw, Linda
Hersh, Adam
author_sort Vaughn, Valerie
collection PubMed
description Background: Clinical pharmacists are a critical part of antibiotic stewardship. Stewardship often relies on relationships and persuasion, which may be affected by gender bias. Thus, we aimed to assess the association of sex with the acceptance of antibiotic stewardship recommendations. Methods: Between May and October 2019, medicine pharmacists at single hospital reviewed patients on antibiotics and–when a discharge was anticipated–led an antibiotic discussion (or “timeout”) prior to discharge. To explore differences in antibiotic timeout effectiveness by gender, we assessed the association of pharmacist sex with suggestion and acceptance of antibiotic changes using logistic regression controlling for patient characteristics. We also assessed whether hospitalist sex was associated with or moderated the effect of pharmacist sex on acceptance of timeout recommendations. Results: Between May 1, 2019, and October 31, 2019, pharmacists conducted 295 timeouts (patient characteristics in Fig. 1). Overall, 54% of timeouts were conducted by 12 female pharmacists and the remaining 46% were conducted by 8 male pharmacists. Overall, 82 (29%) of 295 timeouts resulted in a pharmacist recommending an antibiotic change, and male pharmacists were more likely to recommend a change: 52 (38%) of 137 versus 30 (19%) 158 (P Conclusions: In this discharge antibiotic intervention, timeouts conducted by women were less likely to result in an antibiotic change than those conducted by men. The difference in effectiveness resulted both from female pharmacists being less likely to recommend a change and from hospitalists being less likely to accept recommendations from a female pharmacist. These findings suggest that gender bias may play a role acceptance of antibiotic stewardship recommendations, which could affect antibiotic use, pharmacist job satisfaction, and patient outcomes. Funding: None Disclosures: None
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-9614869
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2022
publisher Cambridge University Press
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-96148692022-10-29 The effect of gender bias on acceptance of antibiotic stewardship recommendations by clinical pharmacists Vaughn, Valerie Giesler, Daniel Brancaccio, Adamo Mashrah, Daraoun Sandison, Katie Wu, Chaorong Horowitz, Jennifer Bashaw, Linda Hersh, Adam Antimicrob Steward Healthc Epidemiol Antibiotic Stewardship Background: Clinical pharmacists are a critical part of antibiotic stewardship. Stewardship often relies on relationships and persuasion, which may be affected by gender bias. Thus, we aimed to assess the association of sex with the acceptance of antibiotic stewardship recommendations. Methods: Between May and October 2019, medicine pharmacists at single hospital reviewed patients on antibiotics and–when a discharge was anticipated–led an antibiotic discussion (or “timeout”) prior to discharge. To explore differences in antibiotic timeout effectiveness by gender, we assessed the association of pharmacist sex with suggestion and acceptance of antibiotic changes using logistic regression controlling for patient characteristics. We also assessed whether hospitalist sex was associated with or moderated the effect of pharmacist sex on acceptance of timeout recommendations. Results: Between May 1, 2019, and October 31, 2019, pharmacists conducted 295 timeouts (patient characteristics in Fig. 1). Overall, 54% of timeouts were conducted by 12 female pharmacists and the remaining 46% were conducted by 8 male pharmacists. Overall, 82 (29%) of 295 timeouts resulted in a pharmacist recommending an antibiotic change, and male pharmacists were more likely to recommend a change: 52 (38%) of 137 versus 30 (19%) 158 (P Conclusions: In this discharge antibiotic intervention, timeouts conducted by women were less likely to result in an antibiotic change than those conducted by men. The difference in effectiveness resulted both from female pharmacists being less likely to recommend a change and from hospitalists being less likely to accept recommendations from a female pharmacist. These findings suggest that gender bias may play a role acceptance of antibiotic stewardship recommendations, which could affect antibiotic use, pharmacist job satisfaction, and patient outcomes. Funding: None Disclosures: None Cambridge University Press 2022-05-16 /pmc/articles/PMC9614869/ http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/ash.2022.188 Text en © The Society for Healthcare Epidemiology of America 2022 https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an Open Access article, distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution licence (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted re-use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
spellingShingle Antibiotic Stewardship
Vaughn, Valerie
Giesler, Daniel
Brancaccio, Adamo
Mashrah, Daraoun
Sandison, Katie
Wu, Chaorong
Horowitz, Jennifer
Bashaw, Linda
Hersh, Adam
The effect of gender bias on acceptance of antibiotic stewardship recommendations by clinical pharmacists
title The effect of gender bias on acceptance of antibiotic stewardship recommendations by clinical pharmacists
title_full The effect of gender bias on acceptance of antibiotic stewardship recommendations by clinical pharmacists
title_fullStr The effect of gender bias on acceptance of antibiotic stewardship recommendations by clinical pharmacists
title_full_unstemmed The effect of gender bias on acceptance of antibiotic stewardship recommendations by clinical pharmacists
title_short The effect of gender bias on acceptance of antibiotic stewardship recommendations by clinical pharmacists
title_sort effect of gender bias on acceptance of antibiotic stewardship recommendations by clinical pharmacists
topic Antibiotic Stewardship
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9614869/
http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/ash.2022.188
work_keys_str_mv AT vaughnvalerie theeffectofgenderbiasonacceptanceofantibioticstewardshiprecommendationsbyclinicalpharmacists
AT gieslerdaniel theeffectofgenderbiasonacceptanceofantibioticstewardshiprecommendationsbyclinicalpharmacists
AT brancaccioadamo theeffectofgenderbiasonacceptanceofantibioticstewardshiprecommendationsbyclinicalpharmacists
AT mashrahdaraoun theeffectofgenderbiasonacceptanceofantibioticstewardshiprecommendationsbyclinicalpharmacists
AT sandisonkatie theeffectofgenderbiasonacceptanceofantibioticstewardshiprecommendationsbyclinicalpharmacists
AT wuchaorong theeffectofgenderbiasonacceptanceofantibioticstewardshiprecommendationsbyclinicalpharmacists
AT horowitzjennifer theeffectofgenderbiasonacceptanceofantibioticstewardshiprecommendationsbyclinicalpharmacists
AT bashawlinda theeffectofgenderbiasonacceptanceofantibioticstewardshiprecommendationsbyclinicalpharmacists
AT hershadam theeffectofgenderbiasonacceptanceofantibioticstewardshiprecommendationsbyclinicalpharmacists
AT vaughnvalerie effectofgenderbiasonacceptanceofantibioticstewardshiprecommendationsbyclinicalpharmacists
AT gieslerdaniel effectofgenderbiasonacceptanceofantibioticstewardshiprecommendationsbyclinicalpharmacists
AT brancaccioadamo effectofgenderbiasonacceptanceofantibioticstewardshiprecommendationsbyclinicalpharmacists
AT mashrahdaraoun effectofgenderbiasonacceptanceofantibioticstewardshiprecommendationsbyclinicalpharmacists
AT sandisonkatie effectofgenderbiasonacceptanceofantibioticstewardshiprecommendationsbyclinicalpharmacists
AT wuchaorong effectofgenderbiasonacceptanceofantibioticstewardshiprecommendationsbyclinicalpharmacists
AT horowitzjennifer effectofgenderbiasonacceptanceofantibioticstewardshiprecommendationsbyclinicalpharmacists
AT bashawlinda effectofgenderbiasonacceptanceofantibioticstewardshiprecommendationsbyclinicalpharmacists
AT hershadam effectofgenderbiasonacceptanceofantibioticstewardshiprecommendationsbyclinicalpharmacists