Cargando…

What is the gender representation in authorship in later phase systemic clinical trials in biliary tract cancer (BTC)? - a retrospective review of the published literature

OBJECTIVES: Female physicians in medicine are increasing, but disparities in female authorship exist. The aim of this study was to characterise factors associated with female first (FF) and female senior (SF) authorship in later phase systemic oncological clinical trials in biliary tract cancer (BTC...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: McNamara, Mairéad G, Bridgewater, John, Goyal, Lipika, Jacobs, Timothy, Wagner, Anna D, Goldstein, David, Shroff, Rachna, Moehler, Markus, Lowery, Maeve, Bekaii-Saab, Tanios, Kelley, Robin K, Furuse, Junji, Rimassa, Lorenza, Morizane, Chigusa, Lamarca, Angela, Hubner, Richard, Knox, Jennifer, Valle, Juan
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: BMJ Publishing Group 2022
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9615988/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36288834
http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2022-064954
_version_ 1784820549818515456
author McNamara, Mairéad G
Bridgewater, John
Goyal, Lipika
Jacobs, Timothy
Wagner, Anna D
Goldstein, David
Shroff, Rachna
Moehler, Markus
Lowery, Maeve
Bekaii-Saab, Tanios
Kelley, Robin K
Furuse, Junji
Rimassa, Lorenza
Morizane, Chigusa
Lamarca, Angela
Hubner, Richard
Knox, Jennifer
Valle, Juan
author_facet McNamara, Mairéad G
Bridgewater, John
Goyal, Lipika
Jacobs, Timothy
Wagner, Anna D
Goldstein, David
Shroff, Rachna
Moehler, Markus
Lowery, Maeve
Bekaii-Saab, Tanios
Kelley, Robin K
Furuse, Junji
Rimassa, Lorenza
Morizane, Chigusa
Lamarca, Angela
Hubner, Richard
Knox, Jennifer
Valle, Juan
author_sort McNamara, Mairéad G
collection PubMed
description OBJECTIVES: Female physicians in medicine are increasing, but disparities in female authorship exist. The aim of this study was to characterise factors associated with female first (FF) and female senior (SF) authorship in later phase systemic oncological clinical trials in biliary tract cancer (BTC) and identify any changes over time. SETTING: Embase/Medline identified trial publications in BTC (2000–2020) were included. χ(2) tests and log regression were used (assessed factors associated with FF and SF authorship, including changes over time (STATA V.16)). PRIMARY OUTCOME MEASURE: FF and SF authorship in later phase systemic oncological clinical trials in BTC. SECONDARY OUTCOME MEASURE: Any changes over time? RESULTS: Of 501 publications, 163 met inclusion criteria. The median percentage of female author representation in publications was 25%; there were no female authors in 13% of publications. Geographic location of the home institution of the first and senior authors was Asia (42%/42%), Europe (29%/29%), USA (24%/22%) and other (4%/6%), respectively. Overall, FF and SF author representation was 20% and 10%, respectively. The median position of the first female author was second in all the publication author lists. The phase of trial, journal-impact factor, industry funding or whether the study met its primary endpoint did not impact FF/SF author representation. More SF authors had home institutions in ‘other’ geographic locations (40% in 10 trials) (p=0.02) versus Asia (6%), Europe (8%) and USA (14%). There were no significant changes in FF/SF representation over time (p=0.61 and p=0.33 respectively). CONCLUSIONS: FF and SF author representation in later phase systemic clinical trial publications in BTC is low and has not changed significantly over time. The underlying reasons for this imbalance need to be better understood and addressed.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-9615988
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2022
publisher BMJ Publishing Group
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-96159882022-10-29 What is the gender representation in authorship in later phase systemic clinical trials in biliary tract cancer (BTC)? - a retrospective review of the published literature McNamara, Mairéad G Bridgewater, John Goyal, Lipika Jacobs, Timothy Wagner, Anna D Goldstein, David Shroff, Rachna Moehler, Markus Lowery, Maeve Bekaii-Saab, Tanios Kelley, Robin K Furuse, Junji Rimassa, Lorenza Morizane, Chigusa Lamarca, Angela Hubner, Richard Knox, Jennifer Valle, Juan BMJ Open Oncology OBJECTIVES: Female physicians in medicine are increasing, but disparities in female authorship exist. The aim of this study was to characterise factors associated with female first (FF) and female senior (SF) authorship in later phase systemic oncological clinical trials in biliary tract cancer (BTC) and identify any changes over time. SETTING: Embase/Medline identified trial publications in BTC (2000–2020) were included. χ(2) tests and log regression were used (assessed factors associated with FF and SF authorship, including changes over time (STATA V.16)). PRIMARY OUTCOME MEASURE: FF and SF authorship in later phase systemic oncological clinical trials in BTC. SECONDARY OUTCOME MEASURE: Any changes over time? RESULTS: Of 501 publications, 163 met inclusion criteria. The median percentage of female author representation in publications was 25%; there were no female authors in 13% of publications. Geographic location of the home institution of the first and senior authors was Asia (42%/42%), Europe (29%/29%), USA (24%/22%) and other (4%/6%), respectively. Overall, FF and SF author representation was 20% and 10%, respectively. The median position of the first female author was second in all the publication author lists. The phase of trial, journal-impact factor, industry funding or whether the study met its primary endpoint did not impact FF/SF author representation. More SF authors had home institutions in ‘other’ geographic locations (40% in 10 trials) (p=0.02) versus Asia (6%), Europe (8%) and USA (14%). There were no significant changes in FF/SF representation over time (p=0.61 and p=0.33 respectively). CONCLUSIONS: FF and SF author representation in later phase systemic clinical trial publications in BTC is low and has not changed significantly over time. The underlying reasons for this imbalance need to be better understood and addressed. BMJ Publishing Group 2022-10-26 /pmc/articles/PMC9615988/ /pubmed/36288834 http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2022-064954 Text en © Author(s) (or their employer(s)) 2022. Re-use permitted under CC BY-NC. No commercial re-use. See rights and permissions. Published by BMJ. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/This is an open access article distributed in accordance with the Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial (CC BY-NC 4.0) license, which permits others to distribute, remix, adapt, build upon this work non-commercially, and license their derivative works on different terms, provided the original work is properly cited, appropriate credit is given, any changes made indicated, and the use is non-commercial. See: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/ (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/) .
spellingShingle Oncology
McNamara, Mairéad G
Bridgewater, John
Goyal, Lipika
Jacobs, Timothy
Wagner, Anna D
Goldstein, David
Shroff, Rachna
Moehler, Markus
Lowery, Maeve
Bekaii-Saab, Tanios
Kelley, Robin K
Furuse, Junji
Rimassa, Lorenza
Morizane, Chigusa
Lamarca, Angela
Hubner, Richard
Knox, Jennifer
Valle, Juan
What is the gender representation in authorship in later phase systemic clinical trials in biliary tract cancer (BTC)? - a retrospective review of the published literature
title What is the gender representation in authorship in later phase systemic clinical trials in biliary tract cancer (BTC)? - a retrospective review of the published literature
title_full What is the gender representation in authorship in later phase systemic clinical trials in biliary tract cancer (BTC)? - a retrospective review of the published literature
title_fullStr What is the gender representation in authorship in later phase systemic clinical trials in biliary tract cancer (BTC)? - a retrospective review of the published literature
title_full_unstemmed What is the gender representation in authorship in later phase systemic clinical trials in biliary tract cancer (BTC)? - a retrospective review of the published literature
title_short What is the gender representation in authorship in later phase systemic clinical trials in biliary tract cancer (BTC)? - a retrospective review of the published literature
title_sort what is the gender representation in authorship in later phase systemic clinical trials in biliary tract cancer (btc)? - a retrospective review of the published literature
topic Oncology
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9615988/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36288834
http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2022-064954
work_keys_str_mv AT mcnamaramaireadg whatisthegenderrepresentationinauthorshipinlaterphasesystemicclinicaltrialsinbiliarytractcancerbtcaretrospectivereviewofthepublishedliterature
AT bridgewaterjohn whatisthegenderrepresentationinauthorshipinlaterphasesystemicclinicaltrialsinbiliarytractcancerbtcaretrospectivereviewofthepublishedliterature
AT goyallipika whatisthegenderrepresentationinauthorshipinlaterphasesystemicclinicaltrialsinbiliarytractcancerbtcaretrospectivereviewofthepublishedliterature
AT jacobstimothy whatisthegenderrepresentationinauthorshipinlaterphasesystemicclinicaltrialsinbiliarytractcancerbtcaretrospectivereviewofthepublishedliterature
AT wagnerannad whatisthegenderrepresentationinauthorshipinlaterphasesystemicclinicaltrialsinbiliarytractcancerbtcaretrospectivereviewofthepublishedliterature
AT goldsteindavid whatisthegenderrepresentationinauthorshipinlaterphasesystemicclinicaltrialsinbiliarytractcancerbtcaretrospectivereviewofthepublishedliterature
AT shroffrachna whatisthegenderrepresentationinauthorshipinlaterphasesystemicclinicaltrialsinbiliarytractcancerbtcaretrospectivereviewofthepublishedliterature
AT moehlermarkus whatisthegenderrepresentationinauthorshipinlaterphasesystemicclinicaltrialsinbiliarytractcancerbtcaretrospectivereviewofthepublishedliterature
AT lowerymaeve whatisthegenderrepresentationinauthorshipinlaterphasesystemicclinicaltrialsinbiliarytractcancerbtcaretrospectivereviewofthepublishedliterature
AT bekaiisaabtanios whatisthegenderrepresentationinauthorshipinlaterphasesystemicclinicaltrialsinbiliarytractcancerbtcaretrospectivereviewofthepublishedliterature
AT kelleyrobink whatisthegenderrepresentationinauthorshipinlaterphasesystemicclinicaltrialsinbiliarytractcancerbtcaretrospectivereviewofthepublishedliterature
AT furusejunji whatisthegenderrepresentationinauthorshipinlaterphasesystemicclinicaltrialsinbiliarytractcancerbtcaretrospectivereviewofthepublishedliterature
AT rimassalorenza whatisthegenderrepresentationinauthorshipinlaterphasesystemicclinicaltrialsinbiliarytractcancerbtcaretrospectivereviewofthepublishedliterature
AT morizanechigusa whatisthegenderrepresentationinauthorshipinlaterphasesystemicclinicaltrialsinbiliarytractcancerbtcaretrospectivereviewofthepublishedliterature
AT lamarcaangela whatisthegenderrepresentationinauthorshipinlaterphasesystemicclinicaltrialsinbiliarytractcancerbtcaretrospectivereviewofthepublishedliterature
AT hubnerrichard whatisthegenderrepresentationinauthorshipinlaterphasesystemicclinicaltrialsinbiliarytractcancerbtcaretrospectivereviewofthepublishedliterature
AT knoxjennifer whatisthegenderrepresentationinauthorshipinlaterphasesystemicclinicaltrialsinbiliarytractcancerbtcaretrospectivereviewofthepublishedliterature
AT vallejuan whatisthegenderrepresentationinauthorshipinlaterphasesystemicclinicaltrialsinbiliarytractcancerbtcaretrospectivereviewofthepublishedliterature