Cargando…

The Family Level Assessment of Screen Use–Mobile Approach: Development of an Approach to Measure Children’s Mobile Device Use

BACKGROUND: There is a strong association between increased mobile device use and worse dietary habits, worse sleep outcomes, and poor academic performance in children. Self-report or parent-proxy report of children’s screen time has been the most common method of measuring screen time, which may be...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Perez, Oriana, Kumar Vadathya, Anil, Beltran, Alicia, Barnett, R Matthew, Hindera, Olivia, Garza, Tatyana, Musaad, Salma M, Baranowski, Tom, Hughes, Sheryl O, Mendoza, Jason A, Sabharwal, Ashutosh, Veeraraghavan, Ashok, O'Connor, Teresia M
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: JMIR Publications 2022
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9636534/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36269651
http://dx.doi.org/10.2196/40452
_version_ 1784824965594349568
author Perez, Oriana
Kumar Vadathya, Anil
Beltran, Alicia
Barnett, R Matthew
Hindera, Olivia
Garza, Tatyana
Musaad, Salma M
Baranowski, Tom
Hughes, Sheryl O
Mendoza, Jason A
Sabharwal, Ashutosh
Veeraraghavan, Ashok
O'Connor, Teresia M
author_facet Perez, Oriana
Kumar Vadathya, Anil
Beltran, Alicia
Barnett, R Matthew
Hindera, Olivia
Garza, Tatyana
Musaad, Salma M
Baranowski, Tom
Hughes, Sheryl O
Mendoza, Jason A
Sabharwal, Ashutosh
Veeraraghavan, Ashok
O'Connor, Teresia M
author_sort Perez, Oriana
collection PubMed
description BACKGROUND: There is a strong association between increased mobile device use and worse dietary habits, worse sleep outcomes, and poor academic performance in children. Self-report or parent-proxy report of children’s screen time has been the most common method of measuring screen time, which may be imprecise or biased. OBJECTIVE: The objective of this study was to assess the feasibility of measuring the screen time of children on mobile devices using the Family Level Assessment of Screen Use (FLASH)–mobile approach, an innovative method that leverages the existing features of the Android platform. METHODS: This pilot study consisted of 2 laboratory-based observational feasibility studies and 2 home-based feasibility studies in the United States. A total of 48 parent-child dyads consisting of a parent and child aged 6 to 11 years participated in the pilot study. The children had to have their own or shared Android device. The laboratory-based studies included a standardized series of tasks while using the mobile device or watching television, which were video recorded. Video recordings were coded by staff for a gold standard comparison. The home-based studies instructed the parent-child dyads to use their mobile device as they typically use it over 3 days. Parents received a copy of the use logs at the end of the study and completed an exit interview in which they were asked to review their logs and share their perceptions and suggestions for the improvement of the FLASH-mobile approach. RESULTS: The final version of the FLASH-mobile approach resulted in user identification compliance rates of >90% for smartphones and >80% for tablets. For laboratory-based studies, a mean agreement of 73.6% (SD 16.15%) was achieved compared with the gold standard (human coding of video recordings) in capturing the target child’s mobile use. Qualitative feedback from parents and children revealed that parents found the FLASH-mobile approach useful for tracking how much time their child spends using the mobile device as well as tracking the apps they used. Some parents revealed concerns over privacy and provided suggestions for improving the FLASH-mobile approach. CONCLUSIONS: The FLASH-mobile approach offers an important new research approach to measure children’s use of mobile devices more accurately across several days, even when the child shares the device with other family members. With additional enhancement and validation studies, this approach can significantly advance the measurement of mobile device use among young children.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-9636534
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2022
publisher JMIR Publications
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-96365342022-11-06 The Family Level Assessment of Screen Use–Mobile Approach: Development of an Approach to Measure Children’s Mobile Device Use Perez, Oriana Kumar Vadathya, Anil Beltran, Alicia Barnett, R Matthew Hindera, Olivia Garza, Tatyana Musaad, Salma M Baranowski, Tom Hughes, Sheryl O Mendoza, Jason A Sabharwal, Ashutosh Veeraraghavan, Ashok O'Connor, Teresia M JMIR Form Res Original Paper BACKGROUND: There is a strong association between increased mobile device use and worse dietary habits, worse sleep outcomes, and poor academic performance in children. Self-report or parent-proxy report of children’s screen time has been the most common method of measuring screen time, which may be imprecise or biased. OBJECTIVE: The objective of this study was to assess the feasibility of measuring the screen time of children on mobile devices using the Family Level Assessment of Screen Use (FLASH)–mobile approach, an innovative method that leverages the existing features of the Android platform. METHODS: This pilot study consisted of 2 laboratory-based observational feasibility studies and 2 home-based feasibility studies in the United States. A total of 48 parent-child dyads consisting of a parent and child aged 6 to 11 years participated in the pilot study. The children had to have their own or shared Android device. The laboratory-based studies included a standardized series of tasks while using the mobile device or watching television, which were video recorded. Video recordings were coded by staff for a gold standard comparison. The home-based studies instructed the parent-child dyads to use their mobile device as they typically use it over 3 days. Parents received a copy of the use logs at the end of the study and completed an exit interview in which they were asked to review their logs and share their perceptions and suggestions for the improvement of the FLASH-mobile approach. RESULTS: The final version of the FLASH-mobile approach resulted in user identification compliance rates of >90% for smartphones and >80% for tablets. For laboratory-based studies, a mean agreement of 73.6% (SD 16.15%) was achieved compared with the gold standard (human coding of video recordings) in capturing the target child’s mobile use. Qualitative feedback from parents and children revealed that parents found the FLASH-mobile approach useful for tracking how much time their child spends using the mobile device as well as tracking the apps they used. Some parents revealed concerns over privacy and provided suggestions for improving the FLASH-mobile approach. CONCLUSIONS: The FLASH-mobile approach offers an important new research approach to measure children’s use of mobile devices more accurately across several days, even when the child shares the device with other family members. With additional enhancement and validation studies, this approach can significantly advance the measurement of mobile device use among young children. JMIR Publications 2022-10-21 /pmc/articles/PMC9636534/ /pubmed/36269651 http://dx.doi.org/10.2196/40452 Text en ©Oriana Perez, Anil Kumar Vadathya, Alicia Beltran, R Matthew Barnett, Olivia Hindera, Tatyana Garza, Salma M Musaad, Tom Baranowski, Sheryl O Hughes, Jason A Mendoza, Ashutosh Sabharwal, Ashok Veeraraghavan, Teresia M O'Connor. Originally published in JMIR Formative Research (https://formative.jmir.org), 21.10.2022. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work, first published in JMIR Formative Research, is properly cited. The complete bibliographic information, a link to the original publication on https://formative.jmir.org, as well as this copyright and license information must be included.
spellingShingle Original Paper
Perez, Oriana
Kumar Vadathya, Anil
Beltran, Alicia
Barnett, R Matthew
Hindera, Olivia
Garza, Tatyana
Musaad, Salma M
Baranowski, Tom
Hughes, Sheryl O
Mendoza, Jason A
Sabharwal, Ashutosh
Veeraraghavan, Ashok
O'Connor, Teresia M
The Family Level Assessment of Screen Use–Mobile Approach: Development of an Approach to Measure Children’s Mobile Device Use
title The Family Level Assessment of Screen Use–Mobile Approach: Development of an Approach to Measure Children’s Mobile Device Use
title_full The Family Level Assessment of Screen Use–Mobile Approach: Development of an Approach to Measure Children’s Mobile Device Use
title_fullStr The Family Level Assessment of Screen Use–Mobile Approach: Development of an Approach to Measure Children’s Mobile Device Use
title_full_unstemmed The Family Level Assessment of Screen Use–Mobile Approach: Development of an Approach to Measure Children’s Mobile Device Use
title_short The Family Level Assessment of Screen Use–Mobile Approach: Development of an Approach to Measure Children’s Mobile Device Use
title_sort family level assessment of screen use–mobile approach: development of an approach to measure children’s mobile device use
topic Original Paper
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9636534/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36269651
http://dx.doi.org/10.2196/40452
work_keys_str_mv AT perezoriana thefamilylevelassessmentofscreenusemobileapproachdevelopmentofanapproachtomeasurechildrensmobiledeviceuse
AT kumarvadathyaanil thefamilylevelassessmentofscreenusemobileapproachdevelopmentofanapproachtomeasurechildrensmobiledeviceuse
AT beltranalicia thefamilylevelassessmentofscreenusemobileapproachdevelopmentofanapproachtomeasurechildrensmobiledeviceuse
AT barnettrmatthew thefamilylevelassessmentofscreenusemobileapproachdevelopmentofanapproachtomeasurechildrensmobiledeviceuse
AT hinderaolivia thefamilylevelassessmentofscreenusemobileapproachdevelopmentofanapproachtomeasurechildrensmobiledeviceuse
AT garzatatyana thefamilylevelassessmentofscreenusemobileapproachdevelopmentofanapproachtomeasurechildrensmobiledeviceuse
AT musaadsalmam thefamilylevelassessmentofscreenusemobileapproachdevelopmentofanapproachtomeasurechildrensmobiledeviceuse
AT baranowskitom thefamilylevelassessmentofscreenusemobileapproachdevelopmentofanapproachtomeasurechildrensmobiledeviceuse
AT hughessherylo thefamilylevelassessmentofscreenusemobileapproachdevelopmentofanapproachtomeasurechildrensmobiledeviceuse
AT mendozajasona thefamilylevelassessmentofscreenusemobileapproachdevelopmentofanapproachtomeasurechildrensmobiledeviceuse
AT sabharwalashutosh thefamilylevelassessmentofscreenusemobileapproachdevelopmentofanapproachtomeasurechildrensmobiledeviceuse
AT veeraraghavanashok thefamilylevelassessmentofscreenusemobileapproachdevelopmentofanapproachtomeasurechildrensmobiledeviceuse
AT oconnorteresiam thefamilylevelassessmentofscreenusemobileapproachdevelopmentofanapproachtomeasurechildrensmobiledeviceuse
AT perezoriana familylevelassessmentofscreenusemobileapproachdevelopmentofanapproachtomeasurechildrensmobiledeviceuse
AT kumarvadathyaanil familylevelassessmentofscreenusemobileapproachdevelopmentofanapproachtomeasurechildrensmobiledeviceuse
AT beltranalicia familylevelassessmentofscreenusemobileapproachdevelopmentofanapproachtomeasurechildrensmobiledeviceuse
AT barnettrmatthew familylevelassessmentofscreenusemobileapproachdevelopmentofanapproachtomeasurechildrensmobiledeviceuse
AT hinderaolivia familylevelassessmentofscreenusemobileapproachdevelopmentofanapproachtomeasurechildrensmobiledeviceuse
AT garzatatyana familylevelassessmentofscreenusemobileapproachdevelopmentofanapproachtomeasurechildrensmobiledeviceuse
AT musaadsalmam familylevelassessmentofscreenusemobileapproachdevelopmentofanapproachtomeasurechildrensmobiledeviceuse
AT baranowskitom familylevelassessmentofscreenusemobileapproachdevelopmentofanapproachtomeasurechildrensmobiledeviceuse
AT hughessherylo familylevelassessmentofscreenusemobileapproachdevelopmentofanapproachtomeasurechildrensmobiledeviceuse
AT mendozajasona familylevelassessmentofscreenusemobileapproachdevelopmentofanapproachtomeasurechildrensmobiledeviceuse
AT sabharwalashutosh familylevelassessmentofscreenusemobileapproachdevelopmentofanapproachtomeasurechildrensmobiledeviceuse
AT veeraraghavanashok familylevelassessmentofscreenusemobileapproachdevelopmentofanapproachtomeasurechildrensmobiledeviceuse
AT oconnorteresiam familylevelassessmentofscreenusemobileapproachdevelopmentofanapproachtomeasurechildrensmobiledeviceuse