Cargando…

The microbiological and sensory status of dual-purpose chickens (Lohmann Dual), male Lohmann Brown Plus chickens, and conventional laying hens slaughtered in a laying hen abattoir compared to conventional broilers slaughtered in a broiler abattoir

Alternatives to conventional chicken meat and egg production are increasingly under discussion, especially because of the common practice of killing male day-old chicks from laying lines which has been banned from the beginning of 2022 in Germany and is planned to be banned during 2022 in other coun...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Langkabel, Nina, Oswaldi, Verena, Merle, Roswitha, Fleischhauer, Cornelia, Heinke, Cathleen, Alter, Thomas, Ellerboek, Lüppo, Fries, Reinhard, Meemken, Diana
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Public Library of Science 2022
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9662725/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36374923
http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0277609
_version_ 1784830729049341952
author Langkabel, Nina
Oswaldi, Verena
Merle, Roswitha
Fleischhauer, Cornelia
Heinke, Cathleen
Alter, Thomas
Ellerboek, Lüppo
Fries, Reinhard
Meemken, Diana
author_facet Langkabel, Nina
Oswaldi, Verena
Merle, Roswitha
Fleischhauer, Cornelia
Heinke, Cathleen
Alter, Thomas
Ellerboek, Lüppo
Fries, Reinhard
Meemken, Diana
author_sort Langkabel, Nina
collection PubMed
description Alternatives to conventional chicken meat and egg production are increasingly under discussion, especially because of the common practice of killing male day-old chicks from laying lines which has been banned from the beginning of 2022 in Germany and is planned to be banned during 2022 in other countries. Production of dual-purpose chicken lines is one possible solution, as such lines combine moderate laying and growth performance. The microbiological status of products from such breeds must be comparable to existing products on the market for food safety purposes. Additionally, the production of such products will take longer because of the feeding regimes required, and again, comparability should be safeguarded for the best consumer protection. The dual-purpose chicken line, Lohmann Dual (males), was compared to males from the laying line Lohmann Brown Plus, conventional laying hens (all slaughtered and processed in the same conventional laying hen abattoir), and conventional broilers (slaughtered in a conventional broiler abattoir). Neck skin samples were taken before chilling at the end of each slaughter line to determine the microbial status of the carcasses. Additionally, fresh and cooked meat sensory analysis was performed on meat from broilers and male and female Lohmann Dual and Lohmann Brown Plus chickens (for three carcasses of each group) at the German Agricultural Society Test Center in Kassel. The focus was on the performance of male Lohmann Dual compared to the other lines. There was no difference in the Enterobacteriaceae count of the dual-purpose chicken line compared to conventional broilers, whereas laying hens had a significantly higher microbial load before chilling, as based on neck skin examinations (p<0.001). According to sensory test results, the meat from dual-purpose chickens was the best (as no defects were found) among the five chicken meat types examined. In conclusion, based on their microbial status and sensory analysis of fresh and cooked meat, Lohmann Dual males slaughtered in a laying hen abattoir can be considered as an alternative to conventionally kept broilers slaughtered in a broiler abattoir.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-9662725
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2022
publisher Public Library of Science
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-96627252022-11-15 The microbiological and sensory status of dual-purpose chickens (Lohmann Dual), male Lohmann Brown Plus chickens, and conventional laying hens slaughtered in a laying hen abattoir compared to conventional broilers slaughtered in a broiler abattoir Langkabel, Nina Oswaldi, Verena Merle, Roswitha Fleischhauer, Cornelia Heinke, Cathleen Alter, Thomas Ellerboek, Lüppo Fries, Reinhard Meemken, Diana PLoS One Research Article Alternatives to conventional chicken meat and egg production are increasingly under discussion, especially because of the common practice of killing male day-old chicks from laying lines which has been banned from the beginning of 2022 in Germany and is planned to be banned during 2022 in other countries. Production of dual-purpose chicken lines is one possible solution, as such lines combine moderate laying and growth performance. The microbiological status of products from such breeds must be comparable to existing products on the market for food safety purposes. Additionally, the production of such products will take longer because of the feeding regimes required, and again, comparability should be safeguarded for the best consumer protection. The dual-purpose chicken line, Lohmann Dual (males), was compared to males from the laying line Lohmann Brown Plus, conventional laying hens (all slaughtered and processed in the same conventional laying hen abattoir), and conventional broilers (slaughtered in a conventional broiler abattoir). Neck skin samples were taken before chilling at the end of each slaughter line to determine the microbial status of the carcasses. Additionally, fresh and cooked meat sensory analysis was performed on meat from broilers and male and female Lohmann Dual and Lohmann Brown Plus chickens (for three carcasses of each group) at the German Agricultural Society Test Center in Kassel. The focus was on the performance of male Lohmann Dual compared to the other lines. There was no difference in the Enterobacteriaceae count of the dual-purpose chicken line compared to conventional broilers, whereas laying hens had a significantly higher microbial load before chilling, as based on neck skin examinations (p<0.001). According to sensory test results, the meat from dual-purpose chickens was the best (as no defects were found) among the five chicken meat types examined. In conclusion, based on their microbial status and sensory analysis of fresh and cooked meat, Lohmann Dual males slaughtered in a laying hen abattoir can be considered as an alternative to conventionally kept broilers slaughtered in a broiler abattoir. Public Library of Science 2022-11-14 /pmc/articles/PMC9662725/ /pubmed/36374923 http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0277609 Text en © 2022 Langkabel et al https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) , which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
spellingShingle Research Article
Langkabel, Nina
Oswaldi, Verena
Merle, Roswitha
Fleischhauer, Cornelia
Heinke, Cathleen
Alter, Thomas
Ellerboek, Lüppo
Fries, Reinhard
Meemken, Diana
The microbiological and sensory status of dual-purpose chickens (Lohmann Dual), male Lohmann Brown Plus chickens, and conventional laying hens slaughtered in a laying hen abattoir compared to conventional broilers slaughtered in a broiler abattoir
title The microbiological and sensory status of dual-purpose chickens (Lohmann Dual), male Lohmann Brown Plus chickens, and conventional laying hens slaughtered in a laying hen abattoir compared to conventional broilers slaughtered in a broiler abattoir
title_full The microbiological and sensory status of dual-purpose chickens (Lohmann Dual), male Lohmann Brown Plus chickens, and conventional laying hens slaughtered in a laying hen abattoir compared to conventional broilers slaughtered in a broiler abattoir
title_fullStr The microbiological and sensory status of dual-purpose chickens (Lohmann Dual), male Lohmann Brown Plus chickens, and conventional laying hens slaughtered in a laying hen abattoir compared to conventional broilers slaughtered in a broiler abattoir
title_full_unstemmed The microbiological and sensory status of dual-purpose chickens (Lohmann Dual), male Lohmann Brown Plus chickens, and conventional laying hens slaughtered in a laying hen abattoir compared to conventional broilers slaughtered in a broiler abattoir
title_short The microbiological and sensory status of dual-purpose chickens (Lohmann Dual), male Lohmann Brown Plus chickens, and conventional laying hens slaughtered in a laying hen abattoir compared to conventional broilers slaughtered in a broiler abattoir
title_sort microbiological and sensory status of dual-purpose chickens (lohmann dual), male lohmann brown plus chickens, and conventional laying hens slaughtered in a laying hen abattoir compared to conventional broilers slaughtered in a broiler abattoir
topic Research Article
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9662725/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36374923
http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0277609
work_keys_str_mv AT langkabelnina themicrobiologicalandsensorystatusofdualpurposechickenslohmanndualmalelohmannbrownpluschickensandconventionallayinghensslaughteredinalayinghenabattoircomparedtoconventionalbroilersslaughteredinabroilerabattoir
AT oswaldiverena themicrobiologicalandsensorystatusofdualpurposechickenslohmanndualmalelohmannbrownpluschickensandconventionallayinghensslaughteredinalayinghenabattoircomparedtoconventionalbroilersslaughteredinabroilerabattoir
AT merleroswitha themicrobiologicalandsensorystatusofdualpurposechickenslohmanndualmalelohmannbrownpluschickensandconventionallayinghensslaughteredinalayinghenabattoircomparedtoconventionalbroilersslaughteredinabroilerabattoir
AT fleischhauercornelia themicrobiologicalandsensorystatusofdualpurposechickenslohmanndualmalelohmannbrownpluschickensandconventionallayinghensslaughteredinalayinghenabattoircomparedtoconventionalbroilersslaughteredinabroilerabattoir
AT heinkecathleen themicrobiologicalandsensorystatusofdualpurposechickenslohmanndualmalelohmannbrownpluschickensandconventionallayinghensslaughteredinalayinghenabattoircomparedtoconventionalbroilersslaughteredinabroilerabattoir
AT alterthomas themicrobiologicalandsensorystatusofdualpurposechickenslohmanndualmalelohmannbrownpluschickensandconventionallayinghensslaughteredinalayinghenabattoircomparedtoconventionalbroilersslaughteredinabroilerabattoir
AT ellerboekluppo themicrobiologicalandsensorystatusofdualpurposechickenslohmanndualmalelohmannbrownpluschickensandconventionallayinghensslaughteredinalayinghenabattoircomparedtoconventionalbroilersslaughteredinabroilerabattoir
AT friesreinhard themicrobiologicalandsensorystatusofdualpurposechickenslohmanndualmalelohmannbrownpluschickensandconventionallayinghensslaughteredinalayinghenabattoircomparedtoconventionalbroilersslaughteredinabroilerabattoir
AT meemkendiana themicrobiologicalandsensorystatusofdualpurposechickenslohmanndualmalelohmannbrownpluschickensandconventionallayinghensslaughteredinalayinghenabattoircomparedtoconventionalbroilersslaughteredinabroilerabattoir
AT langkabelnina microbiologicalandsensorystatusofdualpurposechickenslohmanndualmalelohmannbrownpluschickensandconventionallayinghensslaughteredinalayinghenabattoircomparedtoconventionalbroilersslaughteredinabroilerabattoir
AT oswaldiverena microbiologicalandsensorystatusofdualpurposechickenslohmanndualmalelohmannbrownpluschickensandconventionallayinghensslaughteredinalayinghenabattoircomparedtoconventionalbroilersslaughteredinabroilerabattoir
AT merleroswitha microbiologicalandsensorystatusofdualpurposechickenslohmanndualmalelohmannbrownpluschickensandconventionallayinghensslaughteredinalayinghenabattoircomparedtoconventionalbroilersslaughteredinabroilerabattoir
AT fleischhauercornelia microbiologicalandsensorystatusofdualpurposechickenslohmanndualmalelohmannbrownpluschickensandconventionallayinghensslaughteredinalayinghenabattoircomparedtoconventionalbroilersslaughteredinabroilerabattoir
AT heinkecathleen microbiologicalandsensorystatusofdualpurposechickenslohmanndualmalelohmannbrownpluschickensandconventionallayinghensslaughteredinalayinghenabattoircomparedtoconventionalbroilersslaughteredinabroilerabattoir
AT alterthomas microbiologicalandsensorystatusofdualpurposechickenslohmanndualmalelohmannbrownpluschickensandconventionallayinghensslaughteredinalayinghenabattoircomparedtoconventionalbroilersslaughteredinabroilerabattoir
AT ellerboekluppo microbiologicalandsensorystatusofdualpurposechickenslohmanndualmalelohmannbrownpluschickensandconventionallayinghensslaughteredinalayinghenabattoircomparedtoconventionalbroilersslaughteredinabroilerabattoir
AT friesreinhard microbiologicalandsensorystatusofdualpurposechickenslohmanndualmalelohmannbrownpluschickensandconventionallayinghensslaughteredinalayinghenabattoircomparedtoconventionalbroilersslaughteredinabroilerabattoir
AT meemkendiana microbiologicalandsensorystatusofdualpurposechickenslohmanndualmalelohmannbrownpluschickensandconventionallayinghensslaughteredinalayinghenabattoircomparedtoconventionalbroilersslaughteredinabroilerabattoir