Placebo Response in Trials of Negative Symptoms in Schizophrenia: A Critical Reassessment of the Evidence

BACKGROUND: Summarizing evidence from clinical trials of patients with schizophrenia with predominant or prominent negative symptoms (NS), a prior meta-analysis reported a large placebo effect in negative symptoms (Cohen’s d = 2.909). Assuming that such an effect was clinically not plausible, we performed a critical re-assessment and an update of the previous results with newly available data from add-on and monotherapy studies. STUDY DESIGN: Random-effect meta/regression analysis of trials that focused on predominant or prominent NS; and adopted a double-blind, randomized, placebo-controlled design. The final pooled meta-analytic database, based on the available add-on and monotherapy studies combined, included 24 publications containing data on a total of 25 studies (21 add-on, 4 monotherapy). STUDY RESULTS: The pooled overall estimate for the placebo effect from the primary analysis for all included studies had a medium effect size, with a Cohen’s d value of 0.6444 (SE = 0.091). The estimates were similar in the add-on and monotherapy studies. Meta-regression indicated that the high placebo response was significantly associated with clinical trial characteristics, including the high ratio of patients assigned to active vs. placebo treatment and short trial duration. CONCLUSIONS: These results represent a major downward correction for a current effect size estimate of the placebo response in the negative symptoms of schizophrenia. Our findings also pinpoint certain clinical trial characteristics, which may serve as important predictors of the placebo response. The knowledge of these factors can have important implications for drug development and trial design for new drugs for negative symptoms of schizophrenia.