Preoperative localization of lung nodules: a comparative analysis of hookwire and radio-guided procedures

BACKGROUND: Histological diagnosis of pulmonary nodules requires surgical resection on many occasions. There are multiple localization strategies each with their own benefits and complications. The objective of this study is to compare preoperative lung nodule localization with hookwire and radiotracer injection (radioguided occult lesion localization, ROLL). To compare results, complications, and volume of the sample resected with both techniques. METHODS: Patients undergoing resection of pulmonary nodules with video-assisted thoracoscopy and pre-surgical localization with hookwire or ROLL were studied. Eighty-eight pulmonary nodules were resected in 76 patients: 52 with a hook wire and 36 with a radiotracer. The localization rate, the shortest distance between the nodule and the pleura, the intrapulmonary distance of the locator, the complications, the volume of the resection piece, and the histological result were all assessed. In addition, the factors that influence the volume of the surgical piece were analyzed. RESULTS: All the nodules were resected with both techniques. The intrapulmonary path of the locator is longer for the ROLL group (23.91 vs. 16.28 mm; P=0.04), with no differences in the distance from the nodule to the pleura. The rate of pneumothorax was significantly higher after the placement of a hook wire (69.2% vs. 24.2%; P<0.0001), while there were no differences in the presence of hemorrhage. The volume of the pieces resected using ROLL was more minor than with hookwire, although not statistically significant (20.19 vs. 34.26 cc; P=0.07). CONCLUSIONS: Preoperative localization with the ROLL technique is safer than the placement of hookwire. In addition, the ROLL technique shows a tendency to obtain a smaller volume of resected tissue since the marking is not affected by the intrapulmonary route used during marker placement. ROLL technique allows to locate lung nodules with fewer complications than hookwire and probably gets smaller resection samples.