Cargando…

The Bias of Physicians and Lack of Education in Patients of Color With Melanoma as Causes of Increased Mortality: A Scoping Review

Minorities, particularly non-White minorities, often encounter implicit biases from healthcare professionals that may impact their standard of care and quality of life. The study of dermatology has long been based on Whites, unintentionally affecting the treatment of non-White patients. Melanoma, al...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Rizvi, Zehra, Kunder, Viktor, Stewart, Hanna, Torres, Paola, Moon, Sana, Lingappa, Nimisha, Kazaleh, Mallory, Mallireddigari, Varshini, Perez, Julian, John, Nigel, Sedani, Anika, Jacobs, Robin J
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Cureus 2022
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9762426/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36545166
http://dx.doi.org/10.7759/cureus.31669
_version_ 1784852859890696192
author Rizvi, Zehra
Kunder, Viktor
Stewart, Hanna
Torres, Paola
Moon, Sana
Lingappa, Nimisha
Kazaleh, Mallory
Mallireddigari, Varshini
Perez, Julian
John, Nigel
Sedani, Anika
Jacobs, Robin J
author_facet Rizvi, Zehra
Kunder, Viktor
Stewart, Hanna
Torres, Paola
Moon, Sana
Lingappa, Nimisha
Kazaleh, Mallory
Mallireddigari, Varshini
Perez, Julian
John, Nigel
Sedani, Anika
Jacobs, Robin J
author_sort Rizvi, Zehra
collection PubMed
description Minorities, particularly non-White minorities, often encounter implicit biases from healthcare professionals that may impact their standard of care and quality of life. The study of dermatology has long been based on Whites, unintentionally affecting the treatment of non-White patients. Melanoma, although mostly curable, can become fatal in those presenting with advanced stages at diagnosis. Despite being rare in racial minorities, melanoma is associated with a worse prognosis among them compared to White populations. In light of this, the objective of this study was to determine the role of education in preventing biases and improving the diagnosis and treatment of melanoma in minority groups to improve patient outcomes. This study was designed as a scoping review to gather evidence on the impact of implicit bias and lack of education on the treatment of melanoma in people of color. Following Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines, we searched for peer-reviewed studies involving melanoma, education, and treatment bias in people of color on the databases PubMed, Medline EBSCO, CINAHL, and Cochrane. The data were extracted pertaining to the following main aspects: (1) risk factors, (2) surveys of current knowledge, and 3) educational interventions. This scoping review identified socioeconomic factors, bias, and lack of education in minority populations as causes of increased mortality rates in melanoma. Moreover, because preventative dermatology is largely based on White skin types, incorporating darker skin tones into education will help dispel implicit bias. Additionally, there is evidence to indicate that current patient knowledge and understanding of skin cancer is inaccurate among many and can be significantly improved through educational interventions, such as brochures and videos. Further educational interventions may be beneficial to increase understanding of melanoma in populations of color to address health disparities in dermatological care.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-9762426
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2022
publisher Cureus
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-97624262022-12-20 The Bias of Physicians and Lack of Education in Patients of Color With Melanoma as Causes of Increased Mortality: A Scoping Review Rizvi, Zehra Kunder, Viktor Stewart, Hanna Torres, Paola Moon, Sana Lingappa, Nimisha Kazaleh, Mallory Mallireddigari, Varshini Perez, Julian John, Nigel Sedani, Anika Jacobs, Robin J Cureus Dermatology Minorities, particularly non-White minorities, often encounter implicit biases from healthcare professionals that may impact their standard of care and quality of life. The study of dermatology has long been based on Whites, unintentionally affecting the treatment of non-White patients. Melanoma, although mostly curable, can become fatal in those presenting with advanced stages at diagnosis. Despite being rare in racial minorities, melanoma is associated with a worse prognosis among them compared to White populations. In light of this, the objective of this study was to determine the role of education in preventing biases and improving the diagnosis and treatment of melanoma in minority groups to improve patient outcomes. This study was designed as a scoping review to gather evidence on the impact of implicit bias and lack of education on the treatment of melanoma in people of color. Following Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines, we searched for peer-reviewed studies involving melanoma, education, and treatment bias in people of color on the databases PubMed, Medline EBSCO, CINAHL, and Cochrane. The data were extracted pertaining to the following main aspects: (1) risk factors, (2) surveys of current knowledge, and 3) educational interventions. This scoping review identified socioeconomic factors, bias, and lack of education in minority populations as causes of increased mortality rates in melanoma. Moreover, because preventative dermatology is largely based on White skin types, incorporating darker skin tones into education will help dispel implicit bias. Additionally, there is evidence to indicate that current patient knowledge and understanding of skin cancer is inaccurate among many and can be significantly improved through educational interventions, such as brochures and videos. Further educational interventions may be beneficial to increase understanding of melanoma in populations of color to address health disparities in dermatological care. Cureus 2022-11-19 /pmc/articles/PMC9762426/ /pubmed/36545166 http://dx.doi.org/10.7759/cureus.31669 Text en Copyright © 2022, Rizvi et al. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
spellingShingle Dermatology
Rizvi, Zehra
Kunder, Viktor
Stewart, Hanna
Torres, Paola
Moon, Sana
Lingappa, Nimisha
Kazaleh, Mallory
Mallireddigari, Varshini
Perez, Julian
John, Nigel
Sedani, Anika
Jacobs, Robin J
The Bias of Physicians and Lack of Education in Patients of Color With Melanoma as Causes of Increased Mortality: A Scoping Review
title The Bias of Physicians and Lack of Education in Patients of Color With Melanoma as Causes of Increased Mortality: A Scoping Review
title_full The Bias of Physicians and Lack of Education in Patients of Color With Melanoma as Causes of Increased Mortality: A Scoping Review
title_fullStr The Bias of Physicians and Lack of Education in Patients of Color With Melanoma as Causes of Increased Mortality: A Scoping Review
title_full_unstemmed The Bias of Physicians and Lack of Education in Patients of Color With Melanoma as Causes of Increased Mortality: A Scoping Review
title_short The Bias of Physicians and Lack of Education in Patients of Color With Melanoma as Causes of Increased Mortality: A Scoping Review
title_sort bias of physicians and lack of education in patients of color with melanoma as causes of increased mortality: a scoping review
topic Dermatology
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9762426/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36545166
http://dx.doi.org/10.7759/cureus.31669
work_keys_str_mv AT rizvizehra thebiasofphysiciansandlackofeducationinpatientsofcolorwithmelanomaascausesofincreasedmortalityascopingreview
AT kunderviktor thebiasofphysiciansandlackofeducationinpatientsofcolorwithmelanomaascausesofincreasedmortalityascopingreview
AT stewarthanna thebiasofphysiciansandlackofeducationinpatientsofcolorwithmelanomaascausesofincreasedmortalityascopingreview
AT torrespaola thebiasofphysiciansandlackofeducationinpatientsofcolorwithmelanomaascausesofincreasedmortalityascopingreview
AT moonsana thebiasofphysiciansandlackofeducationinpatientsofcolorwithmelanomaascausesofincreasedmortalityascopingreview
AT lingappanimisha thebiasofphysiciansandlackofeducationinpatientsofcolorwithmelanomaascausesofincreasedmortalityascopingreview
AT kazalehmallory thebiasofphysiciansandlackofeducationinpatientsofcolorwithmelanomaascausesofincreasedmortalityascopingreview
AT mallireddigarivarshini thebiasofphysiciansandlackofeducationinpatientsofcolorwithmelanomaascausesofincreasedmortalityascopingreview
AT perezjulian thebiasofphysiciansandlackofeducationinpatientsofcolorwithmelanomaascausesofincreasedmortalityascopingreview
AT johnnigel thebiasofphysiciansandlackofeducationinpatientsofcolorwithmelanomaascausesofincreasedmortalityascopingreview
AT sedanianika thebiasofphysiciansandlackofeducationinpatientsofcolorwithmelanomaascausesofincreasedmortalityascopingreview
AT jacobsrobinj thebiasofphysiciansandlackofeducationinpatientsofcolorwithmelanomaascausesofincreasedmortalityascopingreview
AT rizvizehra biasofphysiciansandlackofeducationinpatientsofcolorwithmelanomaascausesofincreasedmortalityascopingreview
AT kunderviktor biasofphysiciansandlackofeducationinpatientsofcolorwithmelanomaascausesofincreasedmortalityascopingreview
AT stewarthanna biasofphysiciansandlackofeducationinpatientsofcolorwithmelanomaascausesofincreasedmortalityascopingreview
AT torrespaola biasofphysiciansandlackofeducationinpatientsofcolorwithmelanomaascausesofincreasedmortalityascopingreview
AT moonsana biasofphysiciansandlackofeducationinpatientsofcolorwithmelanomaascausesofincreasedmortalityascopingreview
AT lingappanimisha biasofphysiciansandlackofeducationinpatientsofcolorwithmelanomaascausesofincreasedmortalityascopingreview
AT kazalehmallory biasofphysiciansandlackofeducationinpatientsofcolorwithmelanomaascausesofincreasedmortalityascopingreview
AT mallireddigarivarshini biasofphysiciansandlackofeducationinpatientsofcolorwithmelanomaascausesofincreasedmortalityascopingreview
AT perezjulian biasofphysiciansandlackofeducationinpatientsofcolorwithmelanomaascausesofincreasedmortalityascopingreview
AT johnnigel biasofphysiciansandlackofeducationinpatientsofcolorwithmelanomaascausesofincreasedmortalityascopingreview
AT sedanianika biasofphysiciansandlackofeducationinpatientsofcolorwithmelanomaascausesofincreasedmortalityascopingreview
AT jacobsrobinj biasofphysiciansandlackofeducationinpatientsofcolorwithmelanomaascausesofincreasedmortalityascopingreview