Cargando…

Levetiracetam versus fosphenytoin as a second-line treatment after diazepam for adult convulsive status epilepticus: a multicentre non-inferiority randomised control trial

OBJECTIVE: Status epilepticus (SE) is an emergency condition for which rapid and secured cessation is crucial. Although fosphenytoin (FPHT) is recommended as a second-line treatment, levetiracetam (LEV) reportedly has similar efficacy, but higher safety. Therefore, we herein compared LEV with FPHT i...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Nakamura, Kensuke, Marushima, Aiki, Takahashi, Yuji, Mochizuki, Masaki, Kimura, Akio, Fukuda, Yu, Asami, Masahiro, Nakamoto, Hidetoshi, Egawa, Satoshi, Kaneko, Junya, Unemoto, Kyoko, Kondo, Yutaka, Yonekawa, Chikara, Uchida, Masatoshi, Hoshiyama, Eisei, Yamada, Takeshi, Maruo, Kazushi, Ishikawa, Eiichi, Matsumaru, Yuji, Inoue, Yoshiaki
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: BMJ Publishing Group 2023
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9763167/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36207063
http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/jnnp-2022-329485
_version_ 1784852995391881216
author Nakamura, Kensuke
Marushima, Aiki
Takahashi, Yuji
Mochizuki, Masaki
Kimura, Akio
Fukuda, Yu
Asami, Masahiro
Nakamoto, Hidetoshi
Egawa, Satoshi
Kaneko, Junya
Unemoto, Kyoko
Kondo, Yutaka
Yonekawa, Chikara
Uchida, Masatoshi
Hoshiyama, Eisei
Yamada, Takeshi
Maruo, Kazushi
Ishikawa, Eiichi
Matsumaru, Yuji
Inoue, Yoshiaki
author_facet Nakamura, Kensuke
Marushima, Aiki
Takahashi, Yuji
Mochizuki, Masaki
Kimura, Akio
Fukuda, Yu
Asami, Masahiro
Nakamoto, Hidetoshi
Egawa, Satoshi
Kaneko, Junya
Unemoto, Kyoko
Kondo, Yutaka
Yonekawa, Chikara
Uchida, Masatoshi
Hoshiyama, Eisei
Yamada, Takeshi
Maruo, Kazushi
Ishikawa, Eiichi
Matsumaru, Yuji
Inoue, Yoshiaki
author_sort Nakamura, Kensuke
collection PubMed
description OBJECTIVE: Status epilepticus (SE) is an emergency condition for which rapid and secured cessation is crucial. Although fosphenytoin (FPHT) is recommended as a second-line treatment, levetiracetam (LEV) reportedly has similar efficacy, but higher safety. Therefore, we herein compared LEV with FPHT in adult SE. METHODS: We initiated a multicentre randomised control trial in emergency departments with adult patients with convulsive SE. Diazepam was initially administered, followed intravenously by FPHT at 22.5 mg/kg or LEV at 1000–3000 mg. The primary outcome was assigned as the seizure cessation rate within 30 min of the administration of the study drug. RESULTS: A total of 176 adult patients with SE were enrolled (82 FPHT and 94 LEV), and 3 were excluded from the full analysis set. Seizure cessation rates within 30 min were 83.8% (67/80) in the FPHT group and 89.2% (83/93) in the LEV group. The difference in these rates was 5.5% (95% CI −4.7 to 15.7, p=0.29). The non-inferiority of LEV to FPHT was confirmed with p<0.001 by the Farrington-Manning test. No significant differences were observed in the seizure recurrence rate or intubation rate within 24 hours. Serious adverse events developed in three patients in the FPHT group and none in the LEV group (p=0.061). CONCLUSION: The efficacy of LEV was similar to that of FPHT for adult SE following the administration of diazepam. LEV may be recommended as a second-line treatment for SE along with phenytoin/FPHT. TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER: jRCTs031190160.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-9763167
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2023
publisher BMJ Publishing Group
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-97631672022-12-21 Levetiracetam versus fosphenytoin as a second-line treatment after diazepam for adult convulsive status epilepticus: a multicentre non-inferiority randomised control trial Nakamura, Kensuke Marushima, Aiki Takahashi, Yuji Mochizuki, Masaki Kimura, Akio Fukuda, Yu Asami, Masahiro Nakamoto, Hidetoshi Egawa, Satoshi Kaneko, Junya Unemoto, Kyoko Kondo, Yutaka Yonekawa, Chikara Uchida, Masatoshi Hoshiyama, Eisei Yamada, Takeshi Maruo, Kazushi Ishikawa, Eiichi Matsumaru, Yuji Inoue, Yoshiaki J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry Epilepsy OBJECTIVE: Status epilepticus (SE) is an emergency condition for which rapid and secured cessation is crucial. Although fosphenytoin (FPHT) is recommended as a second-line treatment, levetiracetam (LEV) reportedly has similar efficacy, but higher safety. Therefore, we herein compared LEV with FPHT in adult SE. METHODS: We initiated a multicentre randomised control trial in emergency departments with adult patients with convulsive SE. Diazepam was initially administered, followed intravenously by FPHT at 22.5 mg/kg or LEV at 1000–3000 mg. The primary outcome was assigned as the seizure cessation rate within 30 min of the administration of the study drug. RESULTS: A total of 176 adult patients with SE were enrolled (82 FPHT and 94 LEV), and 3 were excluded from the full analysis set. Seizure cessation rates within 30 min were 83.8% (67/80) in the FPHT group and 89.2% (83/93) in the LEV group. The difference in these rates was 5.5% (95% CI −4.7 to 15.7, p=0.29). The non-inferiority of LEV to FPHT was confirmed with p<0.001 by the Farrington-Manning test. No significant differences were observed in the seizure recurrence rate or intubation rate within 24 hours. Serious adverse events developed in three patients in the FPHT group and none in the LEV group (p=0.061). CONCLUSION: The efficacy of LEV was similar to that of FPHT for adult SE following the administration of diazepam. LEV may be recommended as a second-line treatment for SE along with phenytoin/FPHT. TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER: jRCTs031190160. BMJ Publishing Group 2023-01 2022-10-07 /pmc/articles/PMC9763167/ /pubmed/36207063 http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/jnnp-2022-329485 Text en © Author(s) (or their employer(s)) 2023. Re-use permitted under CC BY. Published by BMJ. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an open access article distributed in accordance with the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 Unported (CC BY 4.0) license, which permits others to copy, redistribute, remix, transform and build upon this work for any purpose, provided the original work is properly cited, a link to the licence is given, and indication of whether changes were made. See: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
spellingShingle Epilepsy
Nakamura, Kensuke
Marushima, Aiki
Takahashi, Yuji
Mochizuki, Masaki
Kimura, Akio
Fukuda, Yu
Asami, Masahiro
Nakamoto, Hidetoshi
Egawa, Satoshi
Kaneko, Junya
Unemoto, Kyoko
Kondo, Yutaka
Yonekawa, Chikara
Uchida, Masatoshi
Hoshiyama, Eisei
Yamada, Takeshi
Maruo, Kazushi
Ishikawa, Eiichi
Matsumaru, Yuji
Inoue, Yoshiaki
Levetiracetam versus fosphenytoin as a second-line treatment after diazepam for adult convulsive status epilepticus: a multicentre non-inferiority randomised control trial
title Levetiracetam versus fosphenytoin as a second-line treatment after diazepam for adult convulsive status epilepticus: a multicentre non-inferiority randomised control trial
title_full Levetiracetam versus fosphenytoin as a second-line treatment after diazepam for adult convulsive status epilepticus: a multicentre non-inferiority randomised control trial
title_fullStr Levetiracetam versus fosphenytoin as a second-line treatment after diazepam for adult convulsive status epilepticus: a multicentre non-inferiority randomised control trial
title_full_unstemmed Levetiracetam versus fosphenytoin as a second-line treatment after diazepam for adult convulsive status epilepticus: a multicentre non-inferiority randomised control trial
title_short Levetiracetam versus fosphenytoin as a second-line treatment after diazepam for adult convulsive status epilepticus: a multicentre non-inferiority randomised control trial
title_sort levetiracetam versus fosphenytoin as a second-line treatment after diazepam for adult convulsive status epilepticus: a multicentre non-inferiority randomised control trial
topic Epilepsy
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9763167/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36207063
http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/jnnp-2022-329485
work_keys_str_mv AT nakamurakensuke levetiracetamversusfosphenytoinasasecondlinetreatmentafterdiazepamforadultconvulsivestatusepilepticusamulticentrenoninferiorityrandomisedcontroltrial
AT marushimaaiki levetiracetamversusfosphenytoinasasecondlinetreatmentafterdiazepamforadultconvulsivestatusepilepticusamulticentrenoninferiorityrandomisedcontroltrial
AT takahashiyuji levetiracetamversusfosphenytoinasasecondlinetreatmentafterdiazepamforadultconvulsivestatusepilepticusamulticentrenoninferiorityrandomisedcontroltrial
AT mochizukimasaki levetiracetamversusfosphenytoinasasecondlinetreatmentafterdiazepamforadultconvulsivestatusepilepticusamulticentrenoninferiorityrandomisedcontroltrial
AT kimuraakio levetiracetamversusfosphenytoinasasecondlinetreatmentafterdiazepamforadultconvulsivestatusepilepticusamulticentrenoninferiorityrandomisedcontroltrial
AT fukudayu levetiracetamversusfosphenytoinasasecondlinetreatmentafterdiazepamforadultconvulsivestatusepilepticusamulticentrenoninferiorityrandomisedcontroltrial
AT asamimasahiro levetiracetamversusfosphenytoinasasecondlinetreatmentafterdiazepamforadultconvulsivestatusepilepticusamulticentrenoninferiorityrandomisedcontroltrial
AT nakamotohidetoshi levetiracetamversusfosphenytoinasasecondlinetreatmentafterdiazepamforadultconvulsivestatusepilepticusamulticentrenoninferiorityrandomisedcontroltrial
AT egawasatoshi levetiracetamversusfosphenytoinasasecondlinetreatmentafterdiazepamforadultconvulsivestatusepilepticusamulticentrenoninferiorityrandomisedcontroltrial
AT kanekojunya levetiracetamversusfosphenytoinasasecondlinetreatmentafterdiazepamforadultconvulsivestatusepilepticusamulticentrenoninferiorityrandomisedcontroltrial
AT unemotokyoko levetiracetamversusfosphenytoinasasecondlinetreatmentafterdiazepamforadultconvulsivestatusepilepticusamulticentrenoninferiorityrandomisedcontroltrial
AT kondoyutaka levetiracetamversusfosphenytoinasasecondlinetreatmentafterdiazepamforadultconvulsivestatusepilepticusamulticentrenoninferiorityrandomisedcontroltrial
AT yonekawachikara levetiracetamversusfosphenytoinasasecondlinetreatmentafterdiazepamforadultconvulsivestatusepilepticusamulticentrenoninferiorityrandomisedcontroltrial
AT uchidamasatoshi levetiracetamversusfosphenytoinasasecondlinetreatmentafterdiazepamforadultconvulsivestatusepilepticusamulticentrenoninferiorityrandomisedcontroltrial
AT hoshiyamaeisei levetiracetamversusfosphenytoinasasecondlinetreatmentafterdiazepamforadultconvulsivestatusepilepticusamulticentrenoninferiorityrandomisedcontroltrial
AT yamadatakeshi levetiracetamversusfosphenytoinasasecondlinetreatmentafterdiazepamforadultconvulsivestatusepilepticusamulticentrenoninferiorityrandomisedcontroltrial
AT maruokazushi levetiracetamversusfosphenytoinasasecondlinetreatmentafterdiazepamforadultconvulsivestatusepilepticusamulticentrenoninferiorityrandomisedcontroltrial
AT ishikawaeiichi levetiracetamversusfosphenytoinasasecondlinetreatmentafterdiazepamforadultconvulsivestatusepilepticusamulticentrenoninferiorityrandomisedcontroltrial
AT matsumaruyuji levetiracetamversusfosphenytoinasasecondlinetreatmentafterdiazepamforadultconvulsivestatusepilepticusamulticentrenoninferiorityrandomisedcontroltrial
AT inoueyoshiaki levetiracetamversusfosphenytoinasasecondlinetreatmentafterdiazepamforadultconvulsivestatusepilepticusamulticentrenoninferiorityrandomisedcontroltrial
AT levetiracetamversusfosphenytoinasasecondlinetreatmentafterdiazepamforadultconvulsivestatusepilepticusamulticentrenoninferiorityrandomisedcontroltrial