Quantifying Trade-Offs in the Choice of Ribosomal Barcoding Markers for Fungal Amplicon Sequencing: a Case Study on the Grapevine Trunk Mycobiome

The evolution of sequencing technology and multiplexing has rapidly expanded our ability to characterize fungal diversity in the environment. However, obtaining an unbiased assessment of the fungal community using ribosomal markers remains challenging. Longer amplicons were shown to improve taxonomic resolution and resolve ambiguities by reducing the risk of spurious operational taxonomic units. We examined the implications of barcoding strategies by amplifying and sequencing two ribosomal DNA fragments. We analyzed the performance of the full internal transcribed spacer (ITS) and a longer fragment including also a part of the 28S ribosomal subunit replicated on 60 grapevine trunk core samples. Grapevine trunks harbor highly diverse fungal communities with implications for disease development. Using identical handling, amplification, and sequencing procedures, we obtained higher sequencing depths for the shorter ITS amplicon. Despite the more limited access to polymorphism, the overall diversity in amplified sequence variants was higher for the shorter ITS amplicon. We detected no meaningful bias in the phylogenetic composition due to the amplicon choice across analyzed samples. Despite the increased resolution of the longer ITS-28S amplicon, the higher and more consistent yields of the shorter amplicons produced a clearer resolution of the fungal community of grapevine stem samples. Our study highlights that the choice of ribosomal amplicons should be carefully evaluated and adjusted according to specific goals. IMPORTANCE Surveying fungal communities is key to our understanding of ecological functions of diverse habitats. Fungal communities can inform about the resilience of agricultural ecosystems, risks to human health, and impacts of pathogens. Community compositions are typically analyzed using ribosomal DNA sequences. Due to technical limitations, most fungal community surveys were based on amplifying a short but highly variable fragment. Advances in sequencing technology enabled the use of longer fragments that can address some limitations of species identification. In this study, we examined the implications of choosing either a short or long ribosomal sequence fragment by replicating the analyses on 60 grapevine wood core samples. Using highly accurate long-read sequencing, we found that the shorter fragment produced substantially higher yields. The shorter fragment also revealed more sequence and species diversity. Our study highlights that the choice of ribosomal amplicons should be carefully evaluated and adjusted according to specific goals.