Cargando…

Response of Terrestrial Net Primary Production to Quadrupled CO(2) Forcing: A Comparison between the CAS-ESM2 and CMIP6 Models

SIMPLE SUMMARY: Terrestrial ecosystems, a key part of the Earth system, can absorb about 31% of CO(2) emissions generated by human activities, which slows increasing atmospheric CO(2) concentrations and global climate warming. The ways in which terrestrial net primary production responds to elevated...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Zhu, Jiawen, Zeng, Xiaodong, Gao, Xiaofei, Zhang, He
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: MDPI 2022
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9774443/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36552203
http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/biology11121693
_version_ 1784855409285136384
author Zhu, Jiawen
Zeng, Xiaodong
Gao, Xiaofei
Zhang, He
author_facet Zhu, Jiawen
Zeng, Xiaodong
Gao, Xiaofei
Zhang, He
author_sort Zhu, Jiawen
collection PubMed
description SIMPLE SUMMARY: Terrestrial ecosystems, a key part of the Earth system, can absorb about 31% of CO(2) emissions generated by human activities, which slows increasing atmospheric CO(2) concentrations and global climate warming. The ways in which terrestrial net primary production responds to elevated CO(2) and associated climate change is a key topic of climate sciences. This study estimated the responses of net primary production to quadrupled CO(2) using 23 Earth system models, and analyzed the underlying causes of uncertainties among the models. The results showed that all of the models projected positive responses of net primary production, with an averaged magnitude of 44.78 PgC year(−1) and an uncertainty of ±20.93 PgC year(−1). The uncertainty came from many sources, and this study emphasizes the role of different projections in CO(2)-induced climatic anomalies and different climate sensitivities. These results provide a reliable estimation of global net primary production response to quadrupled CO(2), and point out that more understanding and improvements are needed for Earth system models to represent both physical climatic processes and the terrestrial carbon cycle. ABSTRACT: Terrestrial net primary production (NPP) is a key carbon flux that changes with rising atmospheric CO(2) and CO(2)-induced climate change. Earth system models are commonly used to investigate these NPP changes because of their fundamentally trustworthy ability to simulate physical climate systems and terrestrial biogeochemical processes. However, many uncertainties remain in projecting NPP responses, due to their complex processes and divergent model characteristics. This study estimated NPP responses to elevated CO(2) and CO(2)-induced climate change using the Chinese Academy of Sciences Earth System Model version 2 (CAS-ESM2), as well as 22 CMIP6 models. Based on CMIP6 pre-industrial and abruptly quadrupled CO(2) experiments, the analysis focused on a comparison of the CAS-ESM2 with the multi-model ensemble (MME), and on a detection of underlying causes of their differences. We found that all of the models showed an overall enhancement in NPP, and that CAS-ESM2 projected a slightly weaker NPP enhancement than MME. This weaker NPP enhancement was the net result of much weaker NPP enhancement over the tropics, and a little stronger NPP enhancement over northern high latitudes. We further report that these differences in NPP responses between the CAS-ESM2 and MME resulted from their different behaviors in simulating NPP trends with modeling time, and are attributed to their different projections of CO(2)-induced climatic anomalies and different climate sensitivities. These results are favorable for understanding and further improving the performance of the CAS-ESM2 in projecting the terrestrial carbon cycle, and point towards a need for greater understanding and improvements for both physical climatic processes and the terrestrial carbon cycle.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-9774443
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2022
publisher MDPI
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-97744432022-12-23 Response of Terrestrial Net Primary Production to Quadrupled CO(2) Forcing: A Comparison between the CAS-ESM2 and CMIP6 Models Zhu, Jiawen Zeng, Xiaodong Gao, Xiaofei Zhang, He Biology (Basel) Article SIMPLE SUMMARY: Terrestrial ecosystems, a key part of the Earth system, can absorb about 31% of CO(2) emissions generated by human activities, which slows increasing atmospheric CO(2) concentrations and global climate warming. The ways in which terrestrial net primary production responds to elevated CO(2) and associated climate change is a key topic of climate sciences. This study estimated the responses of net primary production to quadrupled CO(2) using 23 Earth system models, and analyzed the underlying causes of uncertainties among the models. The results showed that all of the models projected positive responses of net primary production, with an averaged magnitude of 44.78 PgC year(−1) and an uncertainty of ±20.93 PgC year(−1). The uncertainty came from many sources, and this study emphasizes the role of different projections in CO(2)-induced climatic anomalies and different climate sensitivities. These results provide a reliable estimation of global net primary production response to quadrupled CO(2), and point out that more understanding and improvements are needed for Earth system models to represent both physical climatic processes and the terrestrial carbon cycle. ABSTRACT: Terrestrial net primary production (NPP) is a key carbon flux that changes with rising atmospheric CO(2) and CO(2)-induced climate change. Earth system models are commonly used to investigate these NPP changes because of their fundamentally trustworthy ability to simulate physical climate systems and terrestrial biogeochemical processes. However, many uncertainties remain in projecting NPP responses, due to their complex processes and divergent model characteristics. This study estimated NPP responses to elevated CO(2) and CO(2)-induced climate change using the Chinese Academy of Sciences Earth System Model version 2 (CAS-ESM2), as well as 22 CMIP6 models. Based on CMIP6 pre-industrial and abruptly quadrupled CO(2) experiments, the analysis focused on a comparison of the CAS-ESM2 with the multi-model ensemble (MME), and on a detection of underlying causes of their differences. We found that all of the models showed an overall enhancement in NPP, and that CAS-ESM2 projected a slightly weaker NPP enhancement than MME. This weaker NPP enhancement was the net result of much weaker NPP enhancement over the tropics, and a little stronger NPP enhancement over northern high latitudes. We further report that these differences in NPP responses between the CAS-ESM2 and MME resulted from their different behaviors in simulating NPP trends with modeling time, and are attributed to their different projections of CO(2)-induced climatic anomalies and different climate sensitivities. These results are favorable for understanding and further improving the performance of the CAS-ESM2 in projecting the terrestrial carbon cycle, and point towards a need for greater understanding and improvements for both physical climatic processes and the terrestrial carbon cycle. MDPI 2022-11-24 /pmc/articles/PMC9774443/ /pubmed/36552203 http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/biology11121693 Text en © 2022 by the authors. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
spellingShingle Article
Zhu, Jiawen
Zeng, Xiaodong
Gao, Xiaofei
Zhang, He
Response of Terrestrial Net Primary Production to Quadrupled CO(2) Forcing: A Comparison between the CAS-ESM2 and CMIP6 Models
title Response of Terrestrial Net Primary Production to Quadrupled CO(2) Forcing: A Comparison between the CAS-ESM2 and CMIP6 Models
title_full Response of Terrestrial Net Primary Production to Quadrupled CO(2) Forcing: A Comparison between the CAS-ESM2 and CMIP6 Models
title_fullStr Response of Terrestrial Net Primary Production to Quadrupled CO(2) Forcing: A Comparison between the CAS-ESM2 and CMIP6 Models
title_full_unstemmed Response of Terrestrial Net Primary Production to Quadrupled CO(2) Forcing: A Comparison between the CAS-ESM2 and CMIP6 Models
title_short Response of Terrestrial Net Primary Production to Quadrupled CO(2) Forcing: A Comparison between the CAS-ESM2 and CMIP6 Models
title_sort response of terrestrial net primary production to quadrupled co(2) forcing: a comparison between the cas-esm2 and cmip6 models
topic Article
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9774443/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36552203
http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/biology11121693
work_keys_str_mv AT zhujiawen responseofterrestrialnetprimaryproductiontoquadrupledco2forcingacomparisonbetweenthecasesm2andcmip6models
AT zengxiaodong responseofterrestrialnetprimaryproductiontoquadrupledco2forcingacomparisonbetweenthecasesm2andcmip6models
AT gaoxiaofei responseofterrestrialnetprimaryproductiontoquadrupledco2forcingacomparisonbetweenthecasesm2andcmip6models
AT zhanghe responseofterrestrialnetprimaryproductiontoquadrupledco2forcingacomparisonbetweenthecasesm2andcmip6models