HER2-Low Status Is Not Accurate in Breast Cancer Core Needle Biopsy Samples: An Analysis of 5610 Consecutive Patients

SIMPLE SUMMARY: Novel anti-HER2 antibody–drug conjugates showed convincing efficacy in HER2-Low breast cancer patients. We aimed to investigate the accuracy of core needle biopsy (CNB) in diagnosing HER2-Low status. We found a low concordance rate of HER2-Low status between CNB and surgical excision specimen (SES) samples in early-stage HER2-Negative patients. In tumors identified as HER2-0 by CNB, 50.3% expressed HER2 at any level at SES samples. Our research confirmed the necessity of retesting HER2-Low status in SES samples to guide precise anti-HER2 ADCs therapy. ABSTRACT: Background: HER2-Low status is found in approximately half of breast cancer patients and shows potential benefits from novel antibody–drug conjugates (ADCs). Data on the accuracy of HER2-Low status between core needle biopsy (CNB) and surgical excision specimen (SES) samples are lacking. We aimed to investigate the accuracy of HER2-Low status diagnosis between CNB and SES samples. Methods: Consecutive early-stage breast cancer patients who underwent surgery from January 2009 to March 2022 with paired CNB and SES samples were retrospectively reviewed. HER2-Low was defined as IHC 1+ or IHC2+ and FISH-negative. Concordance rates were analyzed by the Kappa test. Further clinicopathological characteristics were compared among different HER2 status and their changes. Results: A total of 5610 patients were included, of whom 3209 (57.2%) and 3320 (59.2%) had HER2-Low status in CNB and SES samples, respectively. The concordance rate of HER2 status in the whole population was 82.37% (Kappa = 0.684, p < 0.001), and was 76.87% in the HER2-Negative patients (Kappa = 0.372, p < 0.001). Among 1066 HER2-0 cases by CNB, 530 patients were classified as HER2-Low tumors. On the contrary, in 3209 patients with HER2-Low tumor by CNB, 387 were scored as HER2-0 on the SES samples. ER-negative or Ki67 high expression tumor by CNB had a high concordance rate of HER2-Low status. Conclusions: A relatively low concordance rate was found when evaluating HER2-Low status between CNB and SES samples in HER2-Negative breast cancer patients, indicating the necessity of retesting HER2 low status at surgery, which may guide further therapy in the era of anti-HER2 ADCs.