Does the Degree of Mutualism between Epichloë Fungi and Botanophila Flies Depend upon the Reproductive Mode of the Fungi?

Epichloë (Ascomycota: Clavicipitaceae) fungi can form an intriguing interaction with Botanophila flies. The fungi live within above-ground shoots of grasses. Some species (type I) only reproduce sexually by forming stromata on all host culms (choke disease). Stromata produce haploid spores (spermatia) that fertilize stromata of opposite mating type to form dikaryotic cells. A second category of Epichloë species (type II) produces stromata on only some of the host culms; culms without choke produce flowers and seeds. These Epichloë can reproduce asexually by invading host seed, as well as sexually. Female Botanophila flies visit stromata for feeding and oviposition. Spermatia pass through the gut of Botanophila intact and viable. Flies can cross-fertilize the fungus during defecation after egg laying. Hence, we described the interaction as a mutualism similar to pollination. Yet, subsequent work by others and ourselves showed that visitation by Botanophila flies was not necessary for cross fertilization of Epichloë. We believe these contradictory results can be reconciled from an evolutionary perspective, if one takes into account the reproductive mode of the fungus. We explore a novel hypothesis to reconcile this contradiction, its predictions and discuss ways in which to test them.