Probing Beyond the Pain Scale: A Rare Case of Cutibacterium Acnes Septic Arthritis

Patients with sickle cell disease frequently present to the hospital for pain control secondary to vaso-occlusive crises (VOCs). Diagnostic challenges exist for healthcare providers in distinguishing joint pain secondary to a VOC from an intraarticular infection at initial presentation due to the lack of established clinical markers exclusive to one or the other. We present a 35-year-old female with sickle cell disease and avascular necrosis of bilateral hips and the right shoulder with several previous admissions for VOC pain control complaining of a "different" kind of pain in her shoulder. Treated initially for pain control, our patient was found to be suffering from culture-positive septic arthritis of the shoulder with Cutibacterium acnes, a rare source of de novo intraarticular infection. This case highlights the importance of incorporating patients’ subjective descriptions of illness into differential diagnosis considerations, notably for those caring for patients with sickle cell disease. This case also establishes C. acnes as a rare organism responsible for de novo septic arthritis in the setting of sickle cell disease.