Potential Limitations in the Clinical Adoption of 3-GEP Pigmented Lesion Assay for Melanoma Triage by Dermatologists and Advanced Practice Practitioners

Background A pigmented lesion assay (PLA) is used to non-invasively detect the presence of three genes associated with melanoma (LINC00518, PRAME, and TERT) using adhesive patch testing and has the potential to reduce unnecessary biopsies. However, few studies have evaluated the clinical applicability of PLA testing and its potential limitations in real-world practice. We aim to identify possible barriers that inhibit the clinical utility of PLA testing by dermatologists. Methods Retrospective case-control study analyzing the PLA testing by two pigmented-lesion specialists that underwent PLA testing as part of clinical management. Data was collected from April 2021 to April 2022 from an academic tertiary-level center. Results The total cohort consists of 472 lesions. Genetic analysis failure for LINC00518 and PRAME occurred in 12.5% of cases and in 70.9% of cases for TERT. In 38.5% of cases, PLA results were discrepant with histopathology. The additional time associated with PLA use independent from the patient’s visit was 15 min on average. Conclusion The high proportion of non-actionable results and discrepant cases highlights potential barriers to the widespread adoption of PLA testing. The high proportion of genetic analysis failure seen for TERT and limited influence on the proposed risk suggests TERT does not offer significant clinical value.