Cargando…
Efficacy of Bromhexine versus Standard of Care in Reducing Viral Load in Patients with Mild-to-Moderate COVID-19 Disease Attended in Primary Care: A Randomized Open-Label Trial
A 28-day randomized open-label multicenter study was conducted to assess the efficacy of bromhexine plus standard of care (SOC) (n = 98) vs. SOC alone (n = 93) in 191 outpatients with mild-to-moderate COVID-19 in the primary health care setting. Bromhexine three daily doses of 10 mL (48 mg/day) were...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
MDPI
2022
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9821213/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36614943 http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/jcm12010142 |
_version_ | 1784865643729780736 |
---|---|
author | Vila Méndez, María Luz Antón Sanz, Carmen Cárdenas García, Alicia del Rocío Bravo Malo, Amparo Torres Martínez, Francisco Javier Martín Moros, José María Real Torrijos, María Vendrell Covisa, José Francisco Javier Guzmán Sierra, Olga Molina Barcena, Verónica Viejo Pinero, Nuria Fernández Díaz, Carlos Arroyo Burguillo, Purificación Blanco Gallego, Ana María Guirao Sánchez, Carmen Montilla Bernabé, Aránzazu Villanueva Morán, María del Pilar Juárez Antón, Salvador Fernández Rodríguez, Ángela Somoza Calvo, María Ángeles Cerrada, Ernesto Cerrada Pérez Mañas, Gemma Sánchez Calso, Antonio Vallejo Somohano, Frida Cauqui Díaz, Carmen Viñas Fernández, Gloria Molina París, Jesús González Godoy, Marina Lumbreras García, Gonzalo Rosado Martín, Javier Rodríguez Hernández, Aida López Antúñez, Sara Vázquez Perfecto, Gabriel Marcello Andrés, María Concepción Puente García, Nieves Marina Gil, Carmen Martínez, Ana Soler López, Begoña |
author_facet | Vila Méndez, María Luz Antón Sanz, Carmen Cárdenas García, Alicia del Rocío Bravo Malo, Amparo Torres Martínez, Francisco Javier Martín Moros, José María Real Torrijos, María Vendrell Covisa, José Francisco Javier Guzmán Sierra, Olga Molina Barcena, Verónica Viejo Pinero, Nuria Fernández Díaz, Carlos Arroyo Burguillo, Purificación Blanco Gallego, Ana María Guirao Sánchez, Carmen Montilla Bernabé, Aránzazu Villanueva Morán, María del Pilar Juárez Antón, Salvador Fernández Rodríguez, Ángela Somoza Calvo, María Ángeles Cerrada, Ernesto Cerrada Pérez Mañas, Gemma Sánchez Calso, Antonio Vallejo Somohano, Frida Cauqui Díaz, Carmen Viñas Fernández, Gloria Molina París, Jesús González Godoy, Marina Lumbreras García, Gonzalo Rosado Martín, Javier Rodríguez Hernández, Aida López Antúñez, Sara Vázquez Perfecto, Gabriel Marcello Andrés, María Concepción Puente García, Nieves Marina Gil, Carmen Martínez, Ana Soler López, Begoña |
author_sort | Vila Méndez, María Luz |
collection | PubMed |
description | A 28-day randomized open-label multicenter study was conducted to assess the efficacy of bromhexine plus standard of care (SOC) (n = 98) vs. SOC alone (n = 93) in 191 outpatients with mild-to-moderate COVID-19 in the primary health care setting. Bromhexine three daily doses of 10 mL (48 mg/day) were administered for seven days. The primary efficacy endpoint was the reduction of viral load estimated as the cycle thresholds (Ct) to detect ORF1ab, N Protein, and S Protein genes by RT-qPCR in saliva samples on day 4 as compared with baseline. Ct values of the three genes increased from baseline throughout days 4 to 14 (p < 0.001) but significant differences between the study groups were not found. Differences in the percentages of patients with low, medium, and high viral loads at 4, 7, and 14 days were not found either. In summary, treatment with bromhexine plus SCO was associated with a viral load reduction of ORF1ab, N Protein, and S Protein genes at day 4, which was not significantly different than similar viral load reductions observed with SOC alone. The present findings do not seem to favor the use of bromhexine as an antiviral in patients with COVID-19. |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-9821213 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2022 |
publisher | MDPI |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-98212132023-01-07 Efficacy of Bromhexine versus Standard of Care in Reducing Viral Load in Patients with Mild-to-Moderate COVID-19 Disease Attended in Primary Care: A Randomized Open-Label Trial Vila Méndez, María Luz Antón Sanz, Carmen Cárdenas García, Alicia del Rocío Bravo Malo, Amparo Torres Martínez, Francisco Javier Martín Moros, José María Real Torrijos, María Vendrell Covisa, José Francisco Javier Guzmán Sierra, Olga Molina Barcena, Verónica Viejo Pinero, Nuria Fernández Díaz, Carlos Arroyo Burguillo, Purificación Blanco Gallego, Ana María Guirao Sánchez, Carmen Montilla Bernabé, Aránzazu Villanueva Morán, María del Pilar Juárez Antón, Salvador Fernández Rodríguez, Ángela Somoza Calvo, María Ángeles Cerrada, Ernesto Cerrada Pérez Mañas, Gemma Sánchez Calso, Antonio Vallejo Somohano, Frida Cauqui Díaz, Carmen Viñas Fernández, Gloria Molina París, Jesús González Godoy, Marina Lumbreras García, Gonzalo Rosado Martín, Javier Rodríguez Hernández, Aida López Antúñez, Sara Vázquez Perfecto, Gabriel Marcello Andrés, María Concepción Puente García, Nieves Marina Gil, Carmen Martínez, Ana Soler López, Begoña J Clin Med Article A 28-day randomized open-label multicenter study was conducted to assess the efficacy of bromhexine plus standard of care (SOC) (n = 98) vs. SOC alone (n = 93) in 191 outpatients with mild-to-moderate COVID-19 in the primary health care setting. Bromhexine three daily doses of 10 mL (48 mg/day) were administered for seven days. The primary efficacy endpoint was the reduction of viral load estimated as the cycle thresholds (Ct) to detect ORF1ab, N Protein, and S Protein genes by RT-qPCR in saliva samples on day 4 as compared with baseline. Ct values of the three genes increased from baseline throughout days 4 to 14 (p < 0.001) but significant differences between the study groups were not found. Differences in the percentages of patients with low, medium, and high viral loads at 4, 7, and 14 days were not found either. In summary, treatment with bromhexine plus SCO was associated with a viral load reduction of ORF1ab, N Protein, and S Protein genes at day 4, which was not significantly different than similar viral load reductions observed with SOC alone. The present findings do not seem to favor the use of bromhexine as an antiviral in patients with COVID-19. MDPI 2022-12-24 /pmc/articles/PMC9821213/ /pubmed/36614943 http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/jcm12010142 Text en © 2022 by the authors. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). |
spellingShingle | Article Vila Méndez, María Luz Antón Sanz, Carmen Cárdenas García, Alicia del Rocío Bravo Malo, Amparo Torres Martínez, Francisco Javier Martín Moros, José María Real Torrijos, María Vendrell Covisa, José Francisco Javier Guzmán Sierra, Olga Molina Barcena, Verónica Viejo Pinero, Nuria Fernández Díaz, Carlos Arroyo Burguillo, Purificación Blanco Gallego, Ana María Guirao Sánchez, Carmen Montilla Bernabé, Aránzazu Villanueva Morán, María del Pilar Juárez Antón, Salvador Fernández Rodríguez, Ángela Somoza Calvo, María Ángeles Cerrada, Ernesto Cerrada Pérez Mañas, Gemma Sánchez Calso, Antonio Vallejo Somohano, Frida Cauqui Díaz, Carmen Viñas Fernández, Gloria Molina París, Jesús González Godoy, Marina Lumbreras García, Gonzalo Rosado Martín, Javier Rodríguez Hernández, Aida López Antúñez, Sara Vázquez Perfecto, Gabriel Marcello Andrés, María Concepción Puente García, Nieves Marina Gil, Carmen Martínez, Ana Soler López, Begoña Efficacy of Bromhexine versus Standard of Care in Reducing Viral Load in Patients with Mild-to-Moderate COVID-19 Disease Attended in Primary Care: A Randomized Open-Label Trial |
title | Efficacy of Bromhexine versus Standard of Care in Reducing Viral Load in Patients with Mild-to-Moderate COVID-19 Disease Attended in Primary Care: A Randomized Open-Label Trial |
title_full | Efficacy of Bromhexine versus Standard of Care in Reducing Viral Load in Patients with Mild-to-Moderate COVID-19 Disease Attended in Primary Care: A Randomized Open-Label Trial |
title_fullStr | Efficacy of Bromhexine versus Standard of Care in Reducing Viral Load in Patients with Mild-to-Moderate COVID-19 Disease Attended in Primary Care: A Randomized Open-Label Trial |
title_full_unstemmed | Efficacy of Bromhexine versus Standard of Care in Reducing Viral Load in Patients with Mild-to-Moderate COVID-19 Disease Attended in Primary Care: A Randomized Open-Label Trial |
title_short | Efficacy of Bromhexine versus Standard of Care in Reducing Viral Load in Patients with Mild-to-Moderate COVID-19 Disease Attended in Primary Care: A Randomized Open-Label Trial |
title_sort | efficacy of bromhexine versus standard of care in reducing viral load in patients with mild-to-moderate covid-19 disease attended in primary care: a randomized open-label trial |
topic | Article |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9821213/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36614943 http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/jcm12010142 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT vilamendezmarialuz efficacyofbromhexineversusstandardofcareinreducingviralloadinpatientswithmildtomoderatecovid19diseaseattendedinprimarycarearandomizedopenlabeltrial AT antonsanzcarmen efficacyofbromhexineversusstandardofcareinreducingviralloadinpatientswithmildtomoderatecovid19diseaseattendedinprimarycarearandomizedopenlabeltrial AT cardenasgarciaaliciadelrocio efficacyofbromhexineversusstandardofcareinreducingviralloadinpatientswithmildtomoderatecovid19diseaseattendedinprimarycarearandomizedopenlabeltrial AT bravomaloamparo efficacyofbromhexineversusstandardofcareinreducingviralloadinpatientswithmildtomoderatecovid19diseaseattendedinprimarycarearandomizedopenlabeltrial AT torresmartinezfranciscojavier efficacyofbromhexineversusstandardofcareinreducingviralloadinpatientswithmildtomoderatecovid19diseaseattendedinprimarycarearandomizedopenlabeltrial AT martinmorosjosemaria efficacyofbromhexineversusstandardofcareinreducingviralloadinpatientswithmildtomoderatecovid19diseaseattendedinprimarycarearandomizedopenlabeltrial AT realtorrijosmaria efficacyofbromhexineversusstandardofcareinreducingviralloadinpatientswithmildtomoderatecovid19diseaseattendedinprimarycarearandomizedopenlabeltrial AT vendrellcovisajosefranciscojavier efficacyofbromhexineversusstandardofcareinreducingviralloadinpatientswithmildtomoderatecovid19diseaseattendedinprimarycarearandomizedopenlabeltrial AT guzmansierraolga efficacyofbromhexineversusstandardofcareinreducingviralloadinpatientswithmildtomoderatecovid19diseaseattendedinprimarycarearandomizedopenlabeltrial AT molinabarcenaveronica efficacyofbromhexineversusstandardofcareinreducingviralloadinpatientswithmildtomoderatecovid19diseaseattendedinprimarycarearandomizedopenlabeltrial AT viejopineronuria efficacyofbromhexineversusstandardofcareinreducingviralloadinpatientswithmildtomoderatecovid19diseaseattendedinprimarycarearandomizedopenlabeltrial AT fernandezdiazcarlos efficacyofbromhexineversusstandardofcareinreducingviralloadinpatientswithmildtomoderatecovid19diseaseattendedinprimarycarearandomizedopenlabeltrial AT arroyoburguillopurificacion efficacyofbromhexineversusstandardofcareinreducingviralloadinpatientswithmildtomoderatecovid19diseaseattendedinprimarycarearandomizedopenlabeltrial AT blancogallegoanamaria efficacyofbromhexineversusstandardofcareinreducingviralloadinpatientswithmildtomoderatecovid19diseaseattendedinprimarycarearandomizedopenlabeltrial AT guiraosanchezcarmen efficacyofbromhexineversusstandardofcareinreducingviralloadinpatientswithmildtomoderatecovid19diseaseattendedinprimarycarearandomizedopenlabeltrial AT montillabernabearanzazu efficacyofbromhexineversusstandardofcareinreducingviralloadinpatientswithmildtomoderatecovid19diseaseattendedinprimarycarearandomizedopenlabeltrial AT villanuevamoranmariadelpilar efficacyofbromhexineversusstandardofcareinreducingviralloadinpatientswithmildtomoderatecovid19diseaseattendedinprimarycarearandomizedopenlabeltrial AT juarezantonsalvador efficacyofbromhexineversusstandardofcareinreducingviralloadinpatientswithmildtomoderatecovid19diseaseattendedinprimarycarearandomizedopenlabeltrial AT fernandezrodriguezangela efficacyofbromhexineversusstandardofcareinreducingviralloadinpatientswithmildtomoderatecovid19diseaseattendedinprimarycarearandomizedopenlabeltrial AT somozacalvomariaangeles efficacyofbromhexineversusstandardofcareinreducingviralloadinpatientswithmildtomoderatecovid19diseaseattendedinprimarycarearandomizedopenlabeltrial AT cerradaernestocerrada efficacyofbromhexineversusstandardofcareinreducingviralloadinpatientswithmildtomoderatecovid19diseaseattendedinprimarycarearandomizedopenlabeltrial AT perezmanasgemma efficacyofbromhexineversusstandardofcareinreducingviralloadinpatientswithmildtomoderatecovid19diseaseattendedinprimarycarearandomizedopenlabeltrial AT sanchezcalsoantonio efficacyofbromhexineversusstandardofcareinreducingviralloadinpatientswithmildtomoderatecovid19diseaseattendedinprimarycarearandomizedopenlabeltrial AT vallejosomohanofrida efficacyofbromhexineversusstandardofcareinreducingviralloadinpatientswithmildtomoderatecovid19diseaseattendedinprimarycarearandomizedopenlabeltrial AT cauquidiazcarmen efficacyofbromhexineversusstandardofcareinreducingviralloadinpatientswithmildtomoderatecovid19diseaseattendedinprimarycarearandomizedopenlabeltrial AT vinasfernandezgloria efficacyofbromhexineversusstandardofcareinreducingviralloadinpatientswithmildtomoderatecovid19diseaseattendedinprimarycarearandomizedopenlabeltrial AT molinaparisjesus efficacyofbromhexineversusstandardofcareinreducingviralloadinpatientswithmildtomoderatecovid19diseaseattendedinprimarycarearandomizedopenlabeltrial AT gonzalezgodoymarina efficacyofbromhexineversusstandardofcareinreducingviralloadinpatientswithmildtomoderatecovid19diseaseattendedinprimarycarearandomizedopenlabeltrial AT lumbrerasgarciagonzalo efficacyofbromhexineversusstandardofcareinreducingviralloadinpatientswithmildtomoderatecovid19diseaseattendedinprimarycarearandomizedopenlabeltrial AT rosadomartinjavier efficacyofbromhexineversusstandardofcareinreducingviralloadinpatientswithmildtomoderatecovid19diseaseattendedinprimarycarearandomizedopenlabeltrial AT rodriguezhernandezaida efficacyofbromhexineversusstandardofcareinreducingviralloadinpatientswithmildtomoderatecovid19diseaseattendedinprimarycarearandomizedopenlabeltrial AT lopezantunezsara efficacyofbromhexineversusstandardofcareinreducingviralloadinpatientswithmildtomoderatecovid19diseaseattendedinprimarycarearandomizedopenlabeltrial AT vazquezperfectogabriel efficacyofbromhexineversusstandardofcareinreducingviralloadinpatientswithmildtomoderatecovid19diseaseattendedinprimarycarearandomizedopenlabeltrial AT marcelloandresmariaconcepcion efficacyofbromhexineversusstandardofcareinreducingviralloadinpatientswithmildtomoderatecovid19diseaseattendedinprimarycarearandomizedopenlabeltrial AT puentegarcianievesmarina efficacyofbromhexineversusstandardofcareinreducingviralloadinpatientswithmildtomoderatecovid19diseaseattendedinprimarycarearandomizedopenlabeltrial AT gilcarmen efficacyofbromhexineversusstandardofcareinreducingviralloadinpatientswithmildtomoderatecovid19diseaseattendedinprimarycarearandomizedopenlabeltrial AT martinezana efficacyofbromhexineversusstandardofcareinreducingviralloadinpatientswithmildtomoderatecovid19diseaseattendedinprimarycarearandomizedopenlabeltrial AT solerlopezbegona efficacyofbromhexineversusstandardofcareinreducingviralloadinpatientswithmildtomoderatecovid19diseaseattendedinprimarycarearandomizedopenlabeltrial |