Cargando…

Computational pathology in 2030: a Delphi study forecasting the role of AI in pathology within the next decade

BACKGROUND: Artificial intelligence (AI) is rapidly fuelling a fundamental transformation in the practice of pathology. However, clinical integration remains challenging, with no AI algorithms to date in routine adoption within typical anatomic pathology (AP) laboratories. This survey gathered curre...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Berbís, M. Alvaro, McClintock, David S., Bychkov, Andrey, Van der Laak, Jeroen, Pantanowitz, Liron, Lennerz, Jochen K., Cheng, Jerome Y., Delahunt, Brett, Egevad, Lars, Eloy, Catarina, Farris, Alton B., Fraggetta, Filippo, García del Moral, Raimundo, Hartman, Douglas J., Herrmann, Markus D., Hollemans, Eva, Iczkowski, Kenneth A., Karsan, Aly, Kriegsmann, Mark, Salama, Mohamed E., Sinard, John H., Tuthill, J. Mark, Williams, Bethany, Casado-Sánchez, César, Sánchez-Turrión, Víctor, Luna, Antonio, Aneiros-Fernández, José, Shen, Jeanne
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Elsevier 2023
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9823157/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36603288
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ebiom.2022.104427
_version_ 1784866093513310208
author Berbís, M. Alvaro
McClintock, David S.
Bychkov, Andrey
Van der Laak, Jeroen
Pantanowitz, Liron
Lennerz, Jochen K.
Cheng, Jerome Y.
Delahunt, Brett
Egevad, Lars
Eloy, Catarina
Farris, Alton B.
Fraggetta, Filippo
García del Moral, Raimundo
Hartman, Douglas J.
Herrmann, Markus D.
Hollemans, Eva
Iczkowski, Kenneth A.
Karsan, Aly
Kriegsmann, Mark
Salama, Mohamed E.
Sinard, John H.
Tuthill, J. Mark
Williams, Bethany
Casado-Sánchez, César
Sánchez-Turrión, Víctor
Luna, Antonio
Aneiros-Fernández, José
Shen, Jeanne
author_facet Berbís, M. Alvaro
McClintock, David S.
Bychkov, Andrey
Van der Laak, Jeroen
Pantanowitz, Liron
Lennerz, Jochen K.
Cheng, Jerome Y.
Delahunt, Brett
Egevad, Lars
Eloy, Catarina
Farris, Alton B.
Fraggetta, Filippo
García del Moral, Raimundo
Hartman, Douglas J.
Herrmann, Markus D.
Hollemans, Eva
Iczkowski, Kenneth A.
Karsan, Aly
Kriegsmann, Mark
Salama, Mohamed E.
Sinard, John H.
Tuthill, J. Mark
Williams, Bethany
Casado-Sánchez, César
Sánchez-Turrión, Víctor
Luna, Antonio
Aneiros-Fernández, José
Shen, Jeanne
author_sort Berbís, M. Alvaro
collection PubMed
description BACKGROUND: Artificial intelligence (AI) is rapidly fuelling a fundamental transformation in the practice of pathology. However, clinical integration remains challenging, with no AI algorithms to date in routine adoption within typical anatomic pathology (AP) laboratories. This survey gathered current expert perspectives and expectations regarding the role of AI in AP from those with first-hand computational pathology and AI experience. METHODS: Perspectives were solicited using the Delphi method from 24 subject matter experts between December 2020 and February 2021 regarding the anticipated role of AI in pathology by the year 2030. The study consisted of three consecutive rounds: 1) an open-ended, free response questionnaire generating a list of survey items; 2) a Likert-scale survey scored by experts and analysed for consensus; and 3) a repeat survey of items not reaching consensus to obtain further expert consensus. FINDINGS: Consensus opinions were reached on 141 of 180 survey items (78.3%). Experts agreed that AI would be routinely and impactfully used within AP laboratory and pathologist clinical workflows by 2030. High consensus was reached on 100 items across nine categories encompassing the impact of AI on (1) pathology key performance indicators (KPIs) and (2) the pathology workforce and specific tasks performed by (3) pathologists and (4) AP lab technicians, as well as (5) specific AI applications and their likelihood of routine use by 2030, (6) AI's role in integrated diagnostics, (7) pathology tasks likely to be fully automated using AI, and (8) regulatory/legal and (9) ethical aspects of AI integration in pathology. INTERPRETATION: This systematic consensus study details the expected short-to-mid-term impact of AI on pathology practice. These findings provide timely and relevant information regarding future care delivery in pathology and raise key practical, ethical, and legal challenges that must be addressed prior to AI's successful clinical implementation. FUNDING: No specific funding was provided for this study.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-9823157
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2023
publisher Elsevier
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-98231572023-01-08 Computational pathology in 2030: a Delphi study forecasting the role of AI in pathology within the next decade Berbís, M. Alvaro McClintock, David S. Bychkov, Andrey Van der Laak, Jeroen Pantanowitz, Liron Lennerz, Jochen K. Cheng, Jerome Y. Delahunt, Brett Egevad, Lars Eloy, Catarina Farris, Alton B. Fraggetta, Filippo García del Moral, Raimundo Hartman, Douglas J. Herrmann, Markus D. Hollemans, Eva Iczkowski, Kenneth A. Karsan, Aly Kriegsmann, Mark Salama, Mohamed E. Sinard, John H. Tuthill, J. Mark Williams, Bethany Casado-Sánchez, César Sánchez-Turrión, Víctor Luna, Antonio Aneiros-Fernández, José Shen, Jeanne eBioMedicine Articles BACKGROUND: Artificial intelligence (AI) is rapidly fuelling a fundamental transformation in the practice of pathology. However, clinical integration remains challenging, with no AI algorithms to date in routine adoption within typical anatomic pathology (AP) laboratories. This survey gathered current expert perspectives and expectations regarding the role of AI in AP from those with first-hand computational pathology and AI experience. METHODS: Perspectives were solicited using the Delphi method from 24 subject matter experts between December 2020 and February 2021 regarding the anticipated role of AI in pathology by the year 2030. The study consisted of three consecutive rounds: 1) an open-ended, free response questionnaire generating a list of survey items; 2) a Likert-scale survey scored by experts and analysed for consensus; and 3) a repeat survey of items not reaching consensus to obtain further expert consensus. FINDINGS: Consensus opinions were reached on 141 of 180 survey items (78.3%). Experts agreed that AI would be routinely and impactfully used within AP laboratory and pathologist clinical workflows by 2030. High consensus was reached on 100 items across nine categories encompassing the impact of AI on (1) pathology key performance indicators (KPIs) and (2) the pathology workforce and specific tasks performed by (3) pathologists and (4) AP lab technicians, as well as (5) specific AI applications and their likelihood of routine use by 2030, (6) AI's role in integrated diagnostics, (7) pathology tasks likely to be fully automated using AI, and (8) regulatory/legal and (9) ethical aspects of AI integration in pathology. INTERPRETATION: This systematic consensus study details the expected short-to-mid-term impact of AI on pathology practice. These findings provide timely and relevant information regarding future care delivery in pathology and raise key practical, ethical, and legal challenges that must be addressed prior to AI's successful clinical implementation. FUNDING: No specific funding was provided for this study. Elsevier 2023-01-04 /pmc/articles/PMC9823157/ /pubmed/36603288 http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ebiom.2022.104427 Text en © 2022 The Author(s) https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an open access article under the CC BY license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
spellingShingle Articles
Berbís, M. Alvaro
McClintock, David S.
Bychkov, Andrey
Van der Laak, Jeroen
Pantanowitz, Liron
Lennerz, Jochen K.
Cheng, Jerome Y.
Delahunt, Brett
Egevad, Lars
Eloy, Catarina
Farris, Alton B.
Fraggetta, Filippo
García del Moral, Raimundo
Hartman, Douglas J.
Herrmann, Markus D.
Hollemans, Eva
Iczkowski, Kenneth A.
Karsan, Aly
Kriegsmann, Mark
Salama, Mohamed E.
Sinard, John H.
Tuthill, J. Mark
Williams, Bethany
Casado-Sánchez, César
Sánchez-Turrión, Víctor
Luna, Antonio
Aneiros-Fernández, José
Shen, Jeanne
Computational pathology in 2030: a Delphi study forecasting the role of AI in pathology within the next decade
title Computational pathology in 2030: a Delphi study forecasting the role of AI in pathology within the next decade
title_full Computational pathology in 2030: a Delphi study forecasting the role of AI in pathology within the next decade
title_fullStr Computational pathology in 2030: a Delphi study forecasting the role of AI in pathology within the next decade
title_full_unstemmed Computational pathology in 2030: a Delphi study forecasting the role of AI in pathology within the next decade
title_short Computational pathology in 2030: a Delphi study forecasting the role of AI in pathology within the next decade
title_sort computational pathology in 2030: a delphi study forecasting the role of ai in pathology within the next decade
topic Articles
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9823157/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36603288
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ebiom.2022.104427
work_keys_str_mv AT berbismalvaro computationalpathologyin2030adelphistudyforecastingtheroleofaiinpathologywithinthenextdecade
AT mcclintockdavids computationalpathologyin2030adelphistudyforecastingtheroleofaiinpathologywithinthenextdecade
AT bychkovandrey computationalpathologyin2030adelphistudyforecastingtheroleofaiinpathologywithinthenextdecade
AT vanderlaakjeroen computationalpathologyin2030adelphistudyforecastingtheroleofaiinpathologywithinthenextdecade
AT pantanowitzliron computationalpathologyin2030adelphistudyforecastingtheroleofaiinpathologywithinthenextdecade
AT lennerzjochenk computationalpathologyin2030adelphistudyforecastingtheroleofaiinpathologywithinthenextdecade
AT chengjeromey computationalpathologyin2030adelphistudyforecastingtheroleofaiinpathologywithinthenextdecade
AT delahuntbrett computationalpathologyin2030adelphistudyforecastingtheroleofaiinpathologywithinthenextdecade
AT egevadlars computationalpathologyin2030adelphistudyforecastingtheroleofaiinpathologywithinthenextdecade
AT eloycatarina computationalpathologyin2030adelphistudyforecastingtheroleofaiinpathologywithinthenextdecade
AT farrisaltonb computationalpathologyin2030adelphistudyforecastingtheroleofaiinpathologywithinthenextdecade
AT fraggettafilippo computationalpathologyin2030adelphistudyforecastingtheroleofaiinpathologywithinthenextdecade
AT garciadelmoralraimundo computationalpathologyin2030adelphistudyforecastingtheroleofaiinpathologywithinthenextdecade
AT hartmandouglasj computationalpathologyin2030adelphistudyforecastingtheroleofaiinpathologywithinthenextdecade
AT herrmannmarkusd computationalpathologyin2030adelphistudyforecastingtheroleofaiinpathologywithinthenextdecade
AT hollemanseva computationalpathologyin2030adelphistudyforecastingtheroleofaiinpathologywithinthenextdecade
AT iczkowskikennetha computationalpathologyin2030adelphistudyforecastingtheroleofaiinpathologywithinthenextdecade
AT karsanaly computationalpathologyin2030adelphistudyforecastingtheroleofaiinpathologywithinthenextdecade
AT kriegsmannmark computationalpathologyin2030adelphistudyforecastingtheroleofaiinpathologywithinthenextdecade
AT salamamohamede computationalpathologyin2030adelphistudyforecastingtheroleofaiinpathologywithinthenextdecade
AT sinardjohnh computationalpathologyin2030adelphistudyforecastingtheroleofaiinpathologywithinthenextdecade
AT tuthilljmark computationalpathologyin2030adelphistudyforecastingtheroleofaiinpathologywithinthenextdecade
AT williamsbethany computationalpathologyin2030adelphistudyforecastingtheroleofaiinpathologywithinthenextdecade
AT casadosanchezcesar computationalpathologyin2030adelphistudyforecastingtheroleofaiinpathologywithinthenextdecade
AT sanchezturrionvictor computationalpathologyin2030adelphistudyforecastingtheroleofaiinpathologywithinthenextdecade
AT lunaantonio computationalpathologyin2030adelphistudyforecastingtheroleofaiinpathologywithinthenextdecade
AT aneirosfernandezjose computationalpathologyin2030adelphistudyforecastingtheroleofaiinpathologywithinthenextdecade
AT shenjeanne computationalpathologyin2030adelphistudyforecastingtheroleofaiinpathologywithinthenextdecade