Lessons learned from the first 15 years of penile transplantation and updates to the Baltimore Criteria

Since 2006, five penis transplants have been performed worldwide. Mixed outcomes have been reported, and two of the five penile transplants have required explantation. However, the long-term outcomes have been encouraging when compliance is implemented, whether standard induction and triple therapy maintenance, or single therapy maintenance. Follow-up monitoring of transplant recipients has enabled a synthesis of technical considerations for surgical success and has shown stable leukocyte counts and renal function after a donor bone-marrow-based immunomodulatory regimen followed by tacrolimus monotherapy as long as 3 years post-transplant, as well as continuous nerve regeneration of penile allografts 3 years post-transplant. Areas of uncertainty include the ethics of donor–recipient colour mismatch, surveillance for sexually transmitted infections and how to optimize patient compliance. Questions also remain with respect to the long-term immunological sequelae of penile tissue, functional outcomes, psychosocial implications and patient selection. Patient counselling should be modified to mention the possibility of long-term improvement in nerve regeneration and sufficient renal function with single-therapy maintenance, and to build a longitudinal dialogue and partnership between the patient and the multidisciplinary care team regarding the risks of sexually transmitted infection instead of surveillance.