Cargando…

Evaluation of the Clinical Utility of the Bone Metastases Ensemble Trees for Survival Decision Support Platform (BMETS-DSP): A Case-Based Pilot Assessment

The Bone Metastases Ensemble Trees for Survival Decision Support Platform (BMETS-DSP) provides patient-specific survival predictions and evidence-based recommendations to guide multidisciplinary management for symptomatic bone metastases. We assessed the clinical utility of the BMETS-DSP through a p...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Alcorn, Sara R., LaVigne, Anna W., Elledge, Christen R., Fiksel, Jacob, Hu, Chen, Kleinberg, Lawrence, Levin, Adam, Smith, Thomas, Cheng, Zhi, Kim, Kibem, Rao, Avani D., Sloan, Lindsey, Page, Brandi, Stinson, Susan F., Voong, K. Ranh, McNutt, Todd R., Bowers, Michael R., DeWeese, Theodore L., Zeger, Scott, Wright, Jean L.
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Wolters Kluwer Health 2022
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9848564/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36306499
http://dx.doi.org/10.1200/CCI.22.00082
_version_ 1784871739803566080
author Alcorn, Sara R.
LaVigne, Anna W.
Elledge, Christen R.
Fiksel, Jacob
Hu, Chen
Kleinberg, Lawrence
Levin, Adam
Smith, Thomas
Cheng, Zhi
Kim, Kibem
Rao, Avani D.
Sloan, Lindsey
Page, Brandi
Stinson, Susan F.
Voong, K. Ranh
McNutt, Todd R.
Bowers, Michael R.
DeWeese, Theodore L.
Zeger, Scott
Wright, Jean L.
author_facet Alcorn, Sara R.
LaVigne, Anna W.
Elledge, Christen R.
Fiksel, Jacob
Hu, Chen
Kleinberg, Lawrence
Levin, Adam
Smith, Thomas
Cheng, Zhi
Kim, Kibem
Rao, Avani D.
Sloan, Lindsey
Page, Brandi
Stinson, Susan F.
Voong, K. Ranh
McNutt, Todd R.
Bowers, Michael R.
DeWeese, Theodore L.
Zeger, Scott
Wright, Jean L.
author_sort Alcorn, Sara R.
collection PubMed
description The Bone Metastases Ensemble Trees for Survival Decision Support Platform (BMETS-DSP) provides patient-specific survival predictions and evidence-based recommendations to guide multidisciplinary management for symptomatic bone metastases. We assessed the clinical utility of the BMETS-DSP through a pilot prepost design in a simulated clinical environment. METHODS: Ten Radiation Oncology physicians reviewed 55 patient cases at two time points: without and then with the use of BMETS-DSP. Assessment included 12-month survival estimate, confidence in and likelihood of sharing estimates with patients, and recommendations for open surgery, systemic therapy, hospice referral, and radiotherapy (RT) regimen. Paired statistics compared pre- versus post-DSP outcomes. Reported statistical significance is P < .05. RESULTS: Pre- versus post-DSP, overestimation of true minus estimated survival time was significantly reduced (mean difference –2.1 [standard deviation 4.1] v –1 month [standard deviation 3.5]). Prediction accuracy was significantly improved at cut points of < 3 (72 v 79%), ≤ 6 (64 v 71%), and ≥ 12 months (70 v 81%). Median ratings of confidence in and likelihood of sharing prognosis significantly increased. Significantly greater concordance was seen in matching use of 1-fraction RT with the true survival < 3 months (70 v 76%) and < 10-fraction RT with the true survival < 12 months (55 v 62%) and appropriate use of open surgery (47% v 53%), without significant changes in selection of hospice referral or systemic therapy. CONCLUSION: This pilot study demonstrates that BMETS-DSP significantly improved physician survival estimation accuracy, prognostic confidence, likelihood of sharing prognosis, and use of prognosis-appropriate RT regimens in the care of symptomatic bone metastases, supporting future multi-institutional validation of the platform.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-9848564
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2022
publisher Wolters Kluwer Health
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-98485642023-01-19 Evaluation of the Clinical Utility of the Bone Metastases Ensemble Trees for Survival Decision Support Platform (BMETS-DSP): A Case-Based Pilot Assessment Alcorn, Sara R. LaVigne, Anna W. Elledge, Christen R. Fiksel, Jacob Hu, Chen Kleinberg, Lawrence Levin, Adam Smith, Thomas Cheng, Zhi Kim, Kibem Rao, Avani D. Sloan, Lindsey Page, Brandi Stinson, Susan F. Voong, K. Ranh McNutt, Todd R. Bowers, Michael R. DeWeese, Theodore L. Zeger, Scott Wright, Jean L. JCO Clin Cancer Inform ORIGINAL REPORTS The Bone Metastases Ensemble Trees for Survival Decision Support Platform (BMETS-DSP) provides patient-specific survival predictions and evidence-based recommendations to guide multidisciplinary management for symptomatic bone metastases. We assessed the clinical utility of the BMETS-DSP through a pilot prepost design in a simulated clinical environment. METHODS: Ten Radiation Oncology physicians reviewed 55 patient cases at two time points: without and then with the use of BMETS-DSP. Assessment included 12-month survival estimate, confidence in and likelihood of sharing estimates with patients, and recommendations for open surgery, systemic therapy, hospice referral, and radiotherapy (RT) regimen. Paired statistics compared pre- versus post-DSP outcomes. Reported statistical significance is P < .05. RESULTS: Pre- versus post-DSP, overestimation of true minus estimated survival time was significantly reduced (mean difference –2.1 [standard deviation 4.1] v –1 month [standard deviation 3.5]). Prediction accuracy was significantly improved at cut points of < 3 (72 v 79%), ≤ 6 (64 v 71%), and ≥ 12 months (70 v 81%). Median ratings of confidence in and likelihood of sharing prognosis significantly increased. Significantly greater concordance was seen in matching use of 1-fraction RT with the true survival < 3 months (70 v 76%) and < 10-fraction RT with the true survival < 12 months (55 v 62%) and appropriate use of open surgery (47% v 53%), without significant changes in selection of hospice referral or systemic therapy. CONCLUSION: This pilot study demonstrates that BMETS-DSP significantly improved physician survival estimation accuracy, prognostic confidence, likelihood of sharing prognosis, and use of prognosis-appropriate RT regimens in the care of symptomatic bone metastases, supporting future multi-institutional validation of the platform. Wolters Kluwer Health 2022-10-28 /pmc/articles/PMC9848564/ /pubmed/36306499 http://dx.doi.org/10.1200/CCI.22.00082 Text en © 2022 by American Society of Clinical Oncology https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/Licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
spellingShingle ORIGINAL REPORTS
Alcorn, Sara R.
LaVigne, Anna W.
Elledge, Christen R.
Fiksel, Jacob
Hu, Chen
Kleinberg, Lawrence
Levin, Adam
Smith, Thomas
Cheng, Zhi
Kim, Kibem
Rao, Avani D.
Sloan, Lindsey
Page, Brandi
Stinson, Susan F.
Voong, K. Ranh
McNutt, Todd R.
Bowers, Michael R.
DeWeese, Theodore L.
Zeger, Scott
Wright, Jean L.
Evaluation of the Clinical Utility of the Bone Metastases Ensemble Trees for Survival Decision Support Platform (BMETS-DSP): A Case-Based Pilot Assessment
title Evaluation of the Clinical Utility of the Bone Metastases Ensemble Trees for Survival Decision Support Platform (BMETS-DSP): A Case-Based Pilot Assessment
title_full Evaluation of the Clinical Utility of the Bone Metastases Ensemble Trees for Survival Decision Support Platform (BMETS-DSP): A Case-Based Pilot Assessment
title_fullStr Evaluation of the Clinical Utility of the Bone Metastases Ensemble Trees for Survival Decision Support Platform (BMETS-DSP): A Case-Based Pilot Assessment
title_full_unstemmed Evaluation of the Clinical Utility of the Bone Metastases Ensemble Trees for Survival Decision Support Platform (BMETS-DSP): A Case-Based Pilot Assessment
title_short Evaluation of the Clinical Utility of the Bone Metastases Ensemble Trees for Survival Decision Support Platform (BMETS-DSP): A Case-Based Pilot Assessment
title_sort evaluation of the clinical utility of the bone metastases ensemble trees for survival decision support platform (bmets-dsp): a case-based pilot assessment
topic ORIGINAL REPORTS
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9848564/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36306499
http://dx.doi.org/10.1200/CCI.22.00082
work_keys_str_mv AT alcornsarar evaluationoftheclinicalutilityofthebonemetastasesensembletreesforsurvivaldecisionsupportplatformbmetsdspacasebasedpilotassessment
AT lavigneannaw evaluationoftheclinicalutilityofthebonemetastasesensembletreesforsurvivaldecisionsupportplatformbmetsdspacasebasedpilotassessment
AT elledgechristenr evaluationoftheclinicalutilityofthebonemetastasesensembletreesforsurvivaldecisionsupportplatformbmetsdspacasebasedpilotassessment
AT fikseljacob evaluationoftheclinicalutilityofthebonemetastasesensembletreesforsurvivaldecisionsupportplatformbmetsdspacasebasedpilotassessment
AT huchen evaluationoftheclinicalutilityofthebonemetastasesensembletreesforsurvivaldecisionsupportplatformbmetsdspacasebasedpilotassessment
AT kleinberglawrence evaluationoftheclinicalutilityofthebonemetastasesensembletreesforsurvivaldecisionsupportplatformbmetsdspacasebasedpilotassessment
AT levinadam evaluationoftheclinicalutilityofthebonemetastasesensembletreesforsurvivaldecisionsupportplatformbmetsdspacasebasedpilotassessment
AT smiththomas evaluationoftheclinicalutilityofthebonemetastasesensembletreesforsurvivaldecisionsupportplatformbmetsdspacasebasedpilotassessment
AT chengzhi evaluationoftheclinicalutilityofthebonemetastasesensembletreesforsurvivaldecisionsupportplatformbmetsdspacasebasedpilotassessment
AT kimkibem evaluationoftheclinicalutilityofthebonemetastasesensembletreesforsurvivaldecisionsupportplatformbmetsdspacasebasedpilotassessment
AT raoavanid evaluationoftheclinicalutilityofthebonemetastasesensembletreesforsurvivaldecisionsupportplatformbmetsdspacasebasedpilotassessment
AT sloanlindsey evaluationoftheclinicalutilityofthebonemetastasesensembletreesforsurvivaldecisionsupportplatformbmetsdspacasebasedpilotassessment
AT pagebrandi evaluationoftheclinicalutilityofthebonemetastasesensembletreesforsurvivaldecisionsupportplatformbmetsdspacasebasedpilotassessment
AT stinsonsusanf evaluationoftheclinicalutilityofthebonemetastasesensembletreesforsurvivaldecisionsupportplatformbmetsdspacasebasedpilotassessment
AT voongkranh evaluationoftheclinicalutilityofthebonemetastasesensembletreesforsurvivaldecisionsupportplatformbmetsdspacasebasedpilotassessment
AT mcnutttoddr evaluationoftheclinicalutilityofthebonemetastasesensembletreesforsurvivaldecisionsupportplatformbmetsdspacasebasedpilotassessment
AT bowersmichaelr evaluationoftheclinicalutilityofthebonemetastasesensembletreesforsurvivaldecisionsupportplatformbmetsdspacasebasedpilotassessment
AT deweesetheodorel evaluationoftheclinicalutilityofthebonemetastasesensembletreesforsurvivaldecisionsupportplatformbmetsdspacasebasedpilotassessment
AT zegerscott evaluationoftheclinicalutilityofthebonemetastasesensembletreesforsurvivaldecisionsupportplatformbmetsdspacasebasedpilotassessment
AT wrightjeanl evaluationoftheclinicalutilityofthebonemetastasesensembletreesforsurvivaldecisionsupportplatformbmetsdspacasebasedpilotassessment