Effect of pre-fragmentation on efficacy and safety for phacoemulsification in femtosecond laser-assisted cataract surgery: a non-randomized clinical trial

BACKGROUND: Ultrasound energy during phacoemulsification results in the endothelial cell loss of cornea. Crystallin lens fragmentation with softening before phacoemulsification can be used with femtosecond laser-assisted cataract surgery (FLACS) device. METHODS: This non-randomized clinical trial included patients who underwent cataract surgery and not had corneal opacity. Patients who were not possible to apply the interface on the ocular surface, were excluded. Each subject was allowed to decide the surgical method by himself/herself. Cataract surgery was performed with FLACS (groups I and II) or conventional surgical technique (group III). The FLACS group was further subdivided into two groups according to whether a lens softening procedure was performed (group I) or not (group II). The nuclear density of cataract was objectively classified by Pentacam nuclear staging (PNS), preoperatively. Surgical parameters including total phacoemulsification time (TPT), cumulative dissipated energy (CDE), and the balanced salt solution (BSS) volume consumed, were measured during the surgery. Postoperative visual outcomes were evaluated at three months after the surgery, and corneal endothelial cell count (ECC) loss were calculated based on ECC measured before the surgery and two months after the surgery. RESULTS: Eighty-nine eyes from 89 patients were enrolled. Fifty-three were treated using FLACS (groups I; quadrant pattern with softening of pre-fragmentation, n=31 and II; sextant pattern without softening of pre-fragmentation, n=22) and 36 (group III) with the conventional manual technique. The FLACS groups (groups I and II) had statistically significant lower TPT (P<0.001), CDE (P<0.001), and BSS volumes (P<0.001) used in the nucleus removal step compared to group III. Furthermore, ECC loss in groups I (4.59%±2.57%) and II (6.10%±3.30%) were also statistically lower compared to group III (13.49%±10.55%, P<0.001). From subgroup analysis with the PNS 2, group I showed lower pre-fragmentation time, lower CDE, lower BSS volume used during nucleus removal, and lower ECC loss compared to group II (all P<0.001). CONCLUSIONS: Pre-fragmentation using FLACS may reduce intraoperative ultrasound energy and intraocular manipulations compared to conventional cataract surgery.