The Bacteriophage–Phage-Inducible Chromosomal Island Arms Race Designs an Interkingdom Inhibitor of dUTPases

Stl, the master repressor of the Staphylococcus aureus pathogenicity islands (SaPIs), targets phage-encoded proteins to derepress and synchronize the SaPI and the helper phage life cycles. To activate their cycle, some SaPI Stls target both phage dimeric and phage trimeric dUTPases (Duts) as antirepressors, which are structurally unrelated proteins that perform identical functions for the phage. This intimate link between the SaPI’s repressor and the phage inducer has imposed an evolutionary optimization of Stl that allows the interaction with Duts from unrelated organisms. In this work, we structurally characterize this sophisticated mechanism of specialization by solving the structure of the prototypical SaPIbov1 Stl in complex with a prokaryotic and a eukaryotic trimeric Dut. The heterocomplexes with Mycobacterium tuberculosis and Homo sapiens Duts show the molecular strategy of Stl to target trimeric Duts from different kingdoms. Our structural results confirm the participation of the five catalytic motifs of trimeric Duts in Stl binding, including the C-terminal flexible motif V that increases the affinity by embracing Stl. In silico and in vitro analyses with a monomeric Dut support the capacity of Stl to recognize this third family of Duts, confirming this protein as a universal Dut inhibitor in the different kingdoms of life. IMPORTANCE Stl, the Staphylococcus aureus pathogenicity island (SaPI) master repressor, targets phage-encoded proteins to derepress and synchronize the SaPI and the helper phage life cycles. This fascinating phage-SaPI arms race is exemplified by the Stl from SaPIbov1 which targets phage dimeric and trimeric dUTPases (Duts), structurally unrelated proteins with identical functions in the phages. By solving the structure of the Stl in complex with a prokaryotic (M. tuberculosis) and a eukaryotic (human) trimeric Dut, we showed that Stl has developed a sophisticated substrate mimicry strategy to target trimeric Duts. Since all these Duts present identical catalytic mechanisms, Stl is able to interact with Duts from different kingdoms. In addition, in silico modeling with monomeric Dut supports the capacity of Stl to recognize this third family of Duts, confirming this protein as a universal Dut inhibitor.