Cargando…
Measuring adherence to inhaled control medication in patients with asthma: Comparison among an asthma app, patient self‐report and physician assessment
BACKGROUND: Previous studies have demonstrated the feasibility of using an asthma app to support medication management and adherence but failed to compare with other measures currently used in clinical practice. However, in a clinical setting, any additional adherence measurement must be evaluated i...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
John Wiley and Sons Inc.
2023
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9930432/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36825517 http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/clt2.12210 |
_version_ | 1784889047584342016 |
---|---|
author | Cachim, Afonso Pereira, Ana Margarida Almeida, Rute Amaral, Rita Alves‐Correia, Magna Vieira‐Marques, Pedro Chaves‐Loureiro, Claudia Ribeiro, Carmelita Cardia, Francisca Gomes, Joana Vidal, Carmen Silva, Eurico Rocha, Sara Rocha, Diana Marques, Maria Luís Páscoa, Rosália Morais, Daniela Cruz, Ana Margarida Santalha, Marta Simões, José Augusto da Silva, Sofia Silva, Diana Gerardo, Rita Todo Bom, Filipa Morete, Ana Vieira, Inês Vieira, Pedro Monteiro, Rosário Raimundo, Maria Rosário Monteiro, Luís Neves, Ângela Santos, Carlos Penas, Ana Margarida Regadas, Rita Marques, José Varanda Rosendo, Inês Aguiar, Margarida Abreu Fernandes, Sara Cardoso, Carlos Seiça Pimenta, Filipa Meireles, Patrícia Gonçalves, Mariana Fonseca, João Almeida Jácome, Cristina |
author_facet | Cachim, Afonso Pereira, Ana Margarida Almeida, Rute Amaral, Rita Alves‐Correia, Magna Vieira‐Marques, Pedro Chaves‐Loureiro, Claudia Ribeiro, Carmelita Cardia, Francisca Gomes, Joana Vidal, Carmen Silva, Eurico Rocha, Sara Rocha, Diana Marques, Maria Luís Páscoa, Rosália Morais, Daniela Cruz, Ana Margarida Santalha, Marta Simões, José Augusto da Silva, Sofia Silva, Diana Gerardo, Rita Todo Bom, Filipa Morete, Ana Vieira, Inês Vieira, Pedro Monteiro, Rosário Raimundo, Maria Rosário Monteiro, Luís Neves, Ângela Santos, Carlos Penas, Ana Margarida Regadas, Rita Marques, José Varanda Rosendo, Inês Aguiar, Margarida Abreu Fernandes, Sara Cardoso, Carlos Seiça Pimenta, Filipa Meireles, Patrícia Gonçalves, Mariana Fonseca, João Almeida Jácome, Cristina |
author_sort | Cachim, Afonso |
collection | PubMed |
description | BACKGROUND: Previous studies have demonstrated the feasibility of using an asthma app to support medication management and adherence but failed to compare with other measures currently used in clinical practice. However, in a clinical setting, any additional adherence measurement must be evaluated in the context of both the patient and physician perspectives so that it can also help improve the process of shared decision making. Thus, we aimed to compare different measures of adherence to asthma control inhalers in clinical practice, namely through an app, patient self‐report and physician assessment. METHODS: This study is a secondary analysis of three prospective multicentre observational studies with patients (≥13 years old) with persistent asthma recruited from 61 primary and secondary care centres in Portugal. Patients were invited to use the InspirerMundi app and register their inhaled medication. Adherence was measured by the app as the number of doses taken divided by the number of doses scheduled each day and two time points were considered for analysis: 1‐week and 1‐month. At baseline, patients and physicians independently assessed adherence to asthma control inhalers during the previous week using a Visual Analogue Scale (VAS 0–100). RESULTS: A total of 193 patients (72% female; median [P25–P75] age 28 [19–41] years old) were included in the analysis. Adherence measured by the app was lower (1 week: 31 [0–71]%; 1 month: 18 [0–48]%) than patient self‐report (80 [60–95]) and physician assessment (82 [51–94]) (p < 0.001). A negligible non‐significant correlation was found between the app and subjective measurements (ρ 0.118–0.156, p > 0.05). There was a moderate correlation between patient self‐report and physician assessment (ρ = 0.596, p < 0.001). CONCLUSIONS: Adherence measured by the app was lower than that reported by the patient or the physician. This was expected as objective measurements are commonly lower than subjective evaluations, which tend to overestimate adherence. Nevertheless, the low adherence measured by the app may also be influenced by the use of the app itself and this needs to be considered in future studies. |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-9930432 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2023 |
publisher | John Wiley and Sons Inc. |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-99304322023-02-16 Measuring adherence to inhaled control medication in patients with asthma: Comparison among an asthma app, patient self‐report and physician assessment Cachim, Afonso Pereira, Ana Margarida Almeida, Rute Amaral, Rita Alves‐Correia, Magna Vieira‐Marques, Pedro Chaves‐Loureiro, Claudia Ribeiro, Carmelita Cardia, Francisca Gomes, Joana Vidal, Carmen Silva, Eurico Rocha, Sara Rocha, Diana Marques, Maria Luís Páscoa, Rosália Morais, Daniela Cruz, Ana Margarida Santalha, Marta Simões, José Augusto da Silva, Sofia Silva, Diana Gerardo, Rita Todo Bom, Filipa Morete, Ana Vieira, Inês Vieira, Pedro Monteiro, Rosário Raimundo, Maria Rosário Monteiro, Luís Neves, Ângela Santos, Carlos Penas, Ana Margarida Regadas, Rita Marques, José Varanda Rosendo, Inês Aguiar, Margarida Abreu Fernandes, Sara Cardoso, Carlos Seiça Pimenta, Filipa Meireles, Patrícia Gonçalves, Mariana Fonseca, João Almeida Jácome, Cristina Clin Transl Allergy Original Article BACKGROUND: Previous studies have demonstrated the feasibility of using an asthma app to support medication management and adherence but failed to compare with other measures currently used in clinical practice. However, in a clinical setting, any additional adherence measurement must be evaluated in the context of both the patient and physician perspectives so that it can also help improve the process of shared decision making. Thus, we aimed to compare different measures of adherence to asthma control inhalers in clinical practice, namely through an app, patient self‐report and physician assessment. METHODS: This study is a secondary analysis of three prospective multicentre observational studies with patients (≥13 years old) with persistent asthma recruited from 61 primary and secondary care centres in Portugal. Patients were invited to use the InspirerMundi app and register their inhaled medication. Adherence was measured by the app as the number of doses taken divided by the number of doses scheduled each day and two time points were considered for analysis: 1‐week and 1‐month. At baseline, patients and physicians independently assessed adherence to asthma control inhalers during the previous week using a Visual Analogue Scale (VAS 0–100). RESULTS: A total of 193 patients (72% female; median [P25–P75] age 28 [19–41] years old) were included in the analysis. Adherence measured by the app was lower (1 week: 31 [0–71]%; 1 month: 18 [0–48]%) than patient self‐report (80 [60–95]) and physician assessment (82 [51–94]) (p < 0.001). A negligible non‐significant correlation was found between the app and subjective measurements (ρ 0.118–0.156, p > 0.05). There was a moderate correlation between patient self‐report and physician assessment (ρ = 0.596, p < 0.001). CONCLUSIONS: Adherence measured by the app was lower than that reported by the patient or the physician. This was expected as objective measurements are commonly lower than subjective evaluations, which tend to overestimate adherence. Nevertheless, the low adherence measured by the app may also be influenced by the use of the app itself and this needs to be considered in future studies. John Wiley and Sons Inc. 2023-02-15 /pmc/articles/PMC9930432/ /pubmed/36825517 http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/clt2.12210 Text en © 2022 The Authors. Clinical and Translational Allergy published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd on behalf of European Academy of Allergy and Clinical Immunology. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an open access article under the terms of the http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) License, which permits use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. |
spellingShingle | Original Article Cachim, Afonso Pereira, Ana Margarida Almeida, Rute Amaral, Rita Alves‐Correia, Magna Vieira‐Marques, Pedro Chaves‐Loureiro, Claudia Ribeiro, Carmelita Cardia, Francisca Gomes, Joana Vidal, Carmen Silva, Eurico Rocha, Sara Rocha, Diana Marques, Maria Luís Páscoa, Rosália Morais, Daniela Cruz, Ana Margarida Santalha, Marta Simões, José Augusto da Silva, Sofia Silva, Diana Gerardo, Rita Todo Bom, Filipa Morete, Ana Vieira, Inês Vieira, Pedro Monteiro, Rosário Raimundo, Maria Rosário Monteiro, Luís Neves, Ângela Santos, Carlos Penas, Ana Margarida Regadas, Rita Marques, José Varanda Rosendo, Inês Aguiar, Margarida Abreu Fernandes, Sara Cardoso, Carlos Seiça Pimenta, Filipa Meireles, Patrícia Gonçalves, Mariana Fonseca, João Almeida Jácome, Cristina Measuring adherence to inhaled control medication in patients with asthma: Comparison among an asthma app, patient self‐report and physician assessment |
title | Measuring adherence to inhaled control medication in patients with asthma: Comparison among an asthma app, patient self‐report and physician assessment |
title_full | Measuring adherence to inhaled control medication in patients with asthma: Comparison among an asthma app, patient self‐report and physician assessment |
title_fullStr | Measuring adherence to inhaled control medication in patients with asthma: Comparison among an asthma app, patient self‐report and physician assessment |
title_full_unstemmed | Measuring adherence to inhaled control medication in patients with asthma: Comparison among an asthma app, patient self‐report and physician assessment |
title_short | Measuring adherence to inhaled control medication in patients with asthma: Comparison among an asthma app, patient self‐report and physician assessment |
title_sort | measuring adherence to inhaled control medication in patients with asthma: comparison among an asthma app, patient self‐report and physician assessment |
topic | Original Article |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9930432/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36825517 http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/clt2.12210 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT cachimafonso measuringadherencetoinhaledcontrolmedicationinpatientswithasthmacomparisonamonganasthmaapppatientselfreportandphysicianassessment AT pereiraanamargarida measuringadherencetoinhaledcontrolmedicationinpatientswithasthmacomparisonamonganasthmaapppatientselfreportandphysicianassessment AT almeidarute measuringadherencetoinhaledcontrolmedicationinpatientswithasthmacomparisonamonganasthmaapppatientselfreportandphysicianassessment AT amaralrita measuringadherencetoinhaledcontrolmedicationinpatientswithasthmacomparisonamonganasthmaapppatientselfreportandphysicianassessment AT alvescorreiamagna measuringadherencetoinhaledcontrolmedicationinpatientswithasthmacomparisonamonganasthmaapppatientselfreportandphysicianassessment AT vieiramarquespedro measuringadherencetoinhaledcontrolmedicationinpatientswithasthmacomparisonamonganasthmaapppatientselfreportandphysicianassessment AT chavesloureiroclaudia measuringadherencetoinhaledcontrolmedicationinpatientswithasthmacomparisonamonganasthmaapppatientselfreportandphysicianassessment AT ribeirocarmelita measuringadherencetoinhaledcontrolmedicationinpatientswithasthmacomparisonamonganasthmaapppatientselfreportandphysicianassessment AT cardiafrancisca measuringadherencetoinhaledcontrolmedicationinpatientswithasthmacomparisonamonganasthmaapppatientselfreportandphysicianassessment AT gomesjoana measuringadherencetoinhaledcontrolmedicationinpatientswithasthmacomparisonamonganasthmaapppatientselfreportandphysicianassessment AT vidalcarmen measuringadherencetoinhaledcontrolmedicationinpatientswithasthmacomparisonamonganasthmaapppatientselfreportandphysicianassessment AT silvaeurico measuringadherencetoinhaledcontrolmedicationinpatientswithasthmacomparisonamonganasthmaapppatientselfreportandphysicianassessment AT rochasara measuringadherencetoinhaledcontrolmedicationinpatientswithasthmacomparisonamonganasthmaapppatientselfreportandphysicianassessment AT rochadiana measuringadherencetoinhaledcontrolmedicationinpatientswithasthmacomparisonamonganasthmaapppatientselfreportandphysicianassessment AT marquesmarialuis measuringadherencetoinhaledcontrolmedicationinpatientswithasthmacomparisonamonganasthmaapppatientselfreportandphysicianassessment AT pascoarosalia measuringadherencetoinhaledcontrolmedicationinpatientswithasthmacomparisonamonganasthmaapppatientselfreportandphysicianassessment AT moraisdaniela measuringadherencetoinhaledcontrolmedicationinpatientswithasthmacomparisonamonganasthmaapppatientselfreportandphysicianassessment AT cruzanamargarida measuringadherencetoinhaledcontrolmedicationinpatientswithasthmacomparisonamonganasthmaapppatientselfreportandphysicianassessment AT santalhamarta measuringadherencetoinhaledcontrolmedicationinpatientswithasthmacomparisonamonganasthmaapppatientselfreportandphysicianassessment AT simoesjoseaugusto measuringadherencetoinhaledcontrolmedicationinpatientswithasthmacomparisonamonganasthmaapppatientselfreportandphysicianassessment AT dasilvasofia measuringadherencetoinhaledcontrolmedicationinpatientswithasthmacomparisonamonganasthmaapppatientselfreportandphysicianassessment AT silvadiana measuringadherencetoinhaledcontrolmedicationinpatientswithasthmacomparisonamonganasthmaapppatientselfreportandphysicianassessment AT gerardorita measuringadherencetoinhaledcontrolmedicationinpatientswithasthmacomparisonamonganasthmaapppatientselfreportandphysicianassessment AT todobomfilipa measuringadherencetoinhaledcontrolmedicationinpatientswithasthmacomparisonamonganasthmaapppatientselfreportandphysicianassessment AT moreteana measuringadherencetoinhaledcontrolmedicationinpatientswithasthmacomparisonamonganasthmaapppatientselfreportandphysicianassessment AT vieiraines measuringadherencetoinhaledcontrolmedicationinpatientswithasthmacomparisonamonganasthmaapppatientselfreportandphysicianassessment AT vieirapedro measuringadherencetoinhaledcontrolmedicationinpatientswithasthmacomparisonamonganasthmaapppatientselfreportandphysicianassessment AT monteirorosario measuringadherencetoinhaledcontrolmedicationinpatientswithasthmacomparisonamonganasthmaapppatientselfreportandphysicianassessment AT raimundomariarosario measuringadherencetoinhaledcontrolmedicationinpatientswithasthmacomparisonamonganasthmaapppatientselfreportandphysicianassessment AT monteiroluis measuringadherencetoinhaledcontrolmedicationinpatientswithasthmacomparisonamonganasthmaapppatientselfreportandphysicianassessment AT nevesangela measuringadherencetoinhaledcontrolmedicationinpatientswithasthmacomparisonamonganasthmaapppatientselfreportandphysicianassessment AT santoscarlos measuringadherencetoinhaledcontrolmedicationinpatientswithasthmacomparisonamonganasthmaapppatientselfreportandphysicianassessment AT penasanamargarida measuringadherencetoinhaledcontrolmedicationinpatientswithasthmacomparisonamonganasthmaapppatientselfreportandphysicianassessment AT regadasrita measuringadherencetoinhaledcontrolmedicationinpatientswithasthmacomparisonamonganasthmaapppatientselfreportandphysicianassessment AT marquesjosevaranda measuringadherencetoinhaledcontrolmedicationinpatientswithasthmacomparisonamonganasthmaapppatientselfreportandphysicianassessment AT rosendoines measuringadherencetoinhaledcontrolmedicationinpatientswithasthmacomparisonamonganasthmaapppatientselfreportandphysicianassessment AT aguiarmargaridaabreu measuringadherencetoinhaledcontrolmedicationinpatientswithasthmacomparisonamonganasthmaapppatientselfreportandphysicianassessment AT fernandessara measuringadherencetoinhaledcontrolmedicationinpatientswithasthmacomparisonamonganasthmaapppatientselfreportandphysicianassessment AT cardosocarlosseica measuringadherencetoinhaledcontrolmedicationinpatientswithasthmacomparisonamonganasthmaapppatientselfreportandphysicianassessment AT pimentafilipa measuringadherencetoinhaledcontrolmedicationinpatientswithasthmacomparisonamonganasthmaapppatientselfreportandphysicianassessment AT meirelespatricia measuringadherencetoinhaledcontrolmedicationinpatientswithasthmacomparisonamonganasthmaapppatientselfreportandphysicianassessment AT goncalvesmariana measuringadherencetoinhaledcontrolmedicationinpatientswithasthmacomparisonamonganasthmaapppatientselfreportandphysicianassessment AT fonsecajoaoalmeida measuringadherencetoinhaledcontrolmedicationinpatientswithasthmacomparisonamonganasthmaapppatientselfreportandphysicianassessment AT jacomecristina measuringadherencetoinhaledcontrolmedicationinpatientswithasthmacomparisonamonganasthmaapppatientselfreportandphysicianassessment |