Cargando…

Garden Scraps: Agonistic Interactions between Hedgehogs and Sympatric Mammals in Urban Gardens

SIMPLE SUMMARY: Hedgehogs are one of several mammals that occur in urban areas in the United Kingdom and are fed by people. Food provided by people may help wild animals but may also attract animals together that could compete, injure, or predate each other. To understand the impact of food on urban...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Scott, Dawn Millicent, Fowler, Robert, Sanglas, Ariadna, Tolhurst, Bryony Anne
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: MDPI 2023
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9951724/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36830377
http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/ani13040590
_version_ 1784893452488540160
author Scott, Dawn Millicent
Fowler, Robert
Sanglas, Ariadna
Tolhurst, Bryony Anne
author_facet Scott, Dawn Millicent
Fowler, Robert
Sanglas, Ariadna
Tolhurst, Bryony Anne
author_sort Scott, Dawn Millicent
collection PubMed
description SIMPLE SUMMARY: Hedgehogs are one of several mammals that occur in urban areas in the United Kingdom and are fed by people. Food provided by people may help wild animals but may also attract animals together that could compete, injure, or predate each other. To understand the impact of food on urban animals we need to investigate how they interact when food is available. In this study, we assessed the type of interaction between hedgehogs, foxes, badgers, and cats using videos submitted by the public. We analyzed interactions between pairs of species to determine interaction type, hierarchical relationships, and the effect of food. We found that agonistic interactions (aggression and/or submission between animals) were more common than neutral interactions, and that between-species interactions showed greater ‘agonism’ than those within the same species. Of interactions within a species, those between hedgehogs were the most agonistic (54.9%) and between badgers the least (6.7%). The species interacting affected the level of agonism, with cats and foxes showing the highest level when together (76.7%). Badgers also outcompeted cats where there were contests over food, but cats were equally as successful as foxes, which were more successful than hedgehogs. However, hedgehogs dominated access to food over cats. We discuss the need to understand interactions between urban animals and the effects of providing food, to inform practice and ensure any potential risks are minimized. ABSTRACT: Hedgehogs occur within an urban mammal guild in the United Kingdom. This guild commonly utilizes anthropogenic food provision, which is potentially beneficial to wild animal populations, but may also bring competitors and predators into proximity, raising the question of how these species interact in urban gardens. In this study, we determined interactions between hedgehogs, foxes, badgers, and domestic cats using videos submitted via citizen science. We analyzed interactions within and between species to determine interaction type, hierarchical relationships, and effect of supplementary food presence/amount. We found that overall agonistic interactions between individuals occurred more frequently (55.4%) than neutral interactions (44.6%) and that interspecific interactions showed greater agonism (55.4%) than intraspecific ones (36%). Within intraspecific interactions, those between hedgehogs were the most agonistic (54.9%) and between badgers the least (6.7%). Species composition of the interaction affected agonism, with interactions between cats and foxes showing the highest level (76.7%). In terms of overall “wins”, where access to garden resources was gained, badgers dominated cats, which were dominant or equal to foxes, which dominated hedgehogs. However, hedgehogs exhibited a greater overall proportion of wins (39.3%) relative to cats. Our findings are important in the context of the documented impact of patchy resources on urban wildlife behavior, and we show that provision of anthropogenic food can potentially result in unintended consequences. We recommend actions to reduce proximity of guild competitors in space and time to limit negative effects.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-9951724
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2023
publisher MDPI
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-99517242023-02-25 Garden Scraps: Agonistic Interactions between Hedgehogs and Sympatric Mammals in Urban Gardens Scott, Dawn Millicent Fowler, Robert Sanglas, Ariadna Tolhurst, Bryony Anne Animals (Basel) Article SIMPLE SUMMARY: Hedgehogs are one of several mammals that occur in urban areas in the United Kingdom and are fed by people. Food provided by people may help wild animals but may also attract animals together that could compete, injure, or predate each other. To understand the impact of food on urban animals we need to investigate how they interact when food is available. In this study, we assessed the type of interaction between hedgehogs, foxes, badgers, and cats using videos submitted by the public. We analyzed interactions between pairs of species to determine interaction type, hierarchical relationships, and the effect of food. We found that agonistic interactions (aggression and/or submission between animals) were more common than neutral interactions, and that between-species interactions showed greater ‘agonism’ than those within the same species. Of interactions within a species, those between hedgehogs were the most agonistic (54.9%) and between badgers the least (6.7%). The species interacting affected the level of agonism, with cats and foxes showing the highest level when together (76.7%). Badgers also outcompeted cats where there were contests over food, but cats were equally as successful as foxes, which were more successful than hedgehogs. However, hedgehogs dominated access to food over cats. We discuss the need to understand interactions between urban animals and the effects of providing food, to inform practice and ensure any potential risks are minimized. ABSTRACT: Hedgehogs occur within an urban mammal guild in the United Kingdom. This guild commonly utilizes anthropogenic food provision, which is potentially beneficial to wild animal populations, but may also bring competitors and predators into proximity, raising the question of how these species interact in urban gardens. In this study, we determined interactions between hedgehogs, foxes, badgers, and domestic cats using videos submitted via citizen science. We analyzed interactions within and between species to determine interaction type, hierarchical relationships, and effect of supplementary food presence/amount. We found that overall agonistic interactions between individuals occurred more frequently (55.4%) than neutral interactions (44.6%) and that interspecific interactions showed greater agonism (55.4%) than intraspecific ones (36%). Within intraspecific interactions, those between hedgehogs were the most agonistic (54.9%) and between badgers the least (6.7%). Species composition of the interaction affected agonism, with interactions between cats and foxes showing the highest level (76.7%). In terms of overall “wins”, where access to garden resources was gained, badgers dominated cats, which were dominant or equal to foxes, which dominated hedgehogs. However, hedgehogs exhibited a greater overall proportion of wins (39.3%) relative to cats. Our findings are important in the context of the documented impact of patchy resources on urban wildlife behavior, and we show that provision of anthropogenic food can potentially result in unintended consequences. We recommend actions to reduce proximity of guild competitors in space and time to limit negative effects. MDPI 2023-02-08 /pmc/articles/PMC9951724/ /pubmed/36830377 http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/ani13040590 Text en © 2023 by the authors. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
spellingShingle Article
Scott, Dawn Millicent
Fowler, Robert
Sanglas, Ariadna
Tolhurst, Bryony Anne
Garden Scraps: Agonistic Interactions between Hedgehogs and Sympatric Mammals in Urban Gardens
title Garden Scraps: Agonistic Interactions between Hedgehogs and Sympatric Mammals in Urban Gardens
title_full Garden Scraps: Agonistic Interactions between Hedgehogs and Sympatric Mammals in Urban Gardens
title_fullStr Garden Scraps: Agonistic Interactions between Hedgehogs and Sympatric Mammals in Urban Gardens
title_full_unstemmed Garden Scraps: Agonistic Interactions between Hedgehogs and Sympatric Mammals in Urban Gardens
title_short Garden Scraps: Agonistic Interactions between Hedgehogs and Sympatric Mammals in Urban Gardens
title_sort garden scraps: agonistic interactions between hedgehogs and sympatric mammals in urban gardens
topic Article
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9951724/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36830377
http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/ani13040590
work_keys_str_mv AT scottdawnmillicent gardenscrapsagonisticinteractionsbetweenhedgehogsandsympatricmammalsinurbangardens
AT fowlerrobert gardenscrapsagonisticinteractionsbetweenhedgehogsandsympatricmammalsinurbangardens
AT sanglasariadna gardenscrapsagonisticinteractionsbetweenhedgehogsandsympatricmammalsinurbangardens
AT tolhurstbryonyanne gardenscrapsagonisticinteractionsbetweenhedgehogsandsympatricmammalsinurbangardens