Reversed windshield-wiper effect leads to failure of cement-augmented pedicle screw: Biomechanical mechanism analysis by finite element experiment

The failure mode of cement-augmented pedicle screw (CAPS) was different from common pedicle screw. No biomechanical study of this failure mode named as “reversed windshield-wiper effect” was reported. To investigate the mechanisms underlying this failure mode, a series of finite element models of CAPS and PS were modified on L4 osseous model. Nine models were created according to the cement volume at 0.5 mL interval (range: 1–5 mL). Pullout load and cranio-caudal loads were applied on the screws. Stress and instantaneous rotation center (IRC) of the vertebra were observed. Under cranio-caudal load, the stress concentrated on the screw tip and pedicle region. The maximal stress (MS) at the screw tip region was +2.143 MPa higher than pedicle region. With cement volume increasing, the maximal stress (MS) at the screw tip region decreased dramatically, while MS at pedicle region was not obviously affected. As dose increased to 1.5 mL, the MS at pedicle region became higher than screw tip region and the maximal stress difference was observed at 3.5 mL. IRC of the vertebra located at the facet joint region in PS model. While IRC in CAPS models shifted anteriorly closer to the vertebral body with the increasing of cement volume. Under axial pull-out load, the maximal stress (MS) of cancellous bone in CAPS models was 29.53–50.04% lower than that 2.228 MPa in PS model. MS in the screw-bone interface did not change significantly with cement volume increasing. Therefore, the possible mechanism is that anterior shift of IRC and the negative difference value of MS between screw tip and pedicle region due to cement augmentation, leading to the screw rotate around the cement-screw complex as the fulcrum point.